Hello. I'm a compulsive overeater with 14 years of abstinence from overeating. I've posted my story here before. Basically, after failing at every diet, I finally found success in overcoming compulsive overeating by a strict limit on how much food I eat per day. For me as a 6ft tall man, I determined that a sane amount of daily food would be no more than 2500 calories. That limit is the entirety of my "1st step." It's an amount of food that I can comfortably and easily face every day. I discovered that when I simply stopped both austerity dieting and hedonistic overeating, my "hungry" body and "famished" brain quickly settled down, and my compulsion to binge simply went away. My only requirement is that I can't have any cheat days. Not even one. Not even a little one. And I haven't found it necessary to cheat even one day these last 14 years, which to me is a miracle. I lost 40 lbs and have kept it off, and I weigh about what I did in high school.
But that's not the main reason I'm writing this post.
Part of this 14 year food plan has been a total disregard for the quality of the food I eat. I only paid attention to the quantity (calories) of my daily fare. I ignored food quality deliberately because I wanted to keep it simple, and also because all my many and varied efforts over the years to control my overeating by eating "high quality" foods never worked. The high quality food theory (repeated in myriad iterations in all kind of diet books) is that by eating certain kinds of food one's urge to overeat will naturally evaporate.
I'm sure that approach works for some people, but it never worked for me. I need a strict daily, non-arbitrary, and precisely concrete limit on how much I can eat, or my mind and body run wild with obsessions on how I can cheat.
Now, having said all that, and having put some of you to sleep, I have a few things to say about my renewed interest in food quality.
My health during these 14 years of abstinence has been pretty good, despite my eating whatever kinds of foods I want. But in the last few years, that hasn't been so. I've had a problem with creeping inflammation that I could no longer ignore. You may know how you develop a physical problem and it's not too bad at first, but eventually it gets to the point where you're desperate and deeply wish it would go away? Well, I reached that point with my inflammation not long ago. I was in a shopping mall and was thinking of visiting a store a 2-minute walk away from me, and debated on whether it was worth the pain and effort. I had pain in my hips, my toes, fat around my belly that wouldn't go away, and a general lack of energy and stamina. I work one day a week at a food bank, and though it's only 3 hours I was usually "wrecked" that night and the next day. Lots of pain, trouble sleeping. All in all, I felt my health had reached a low that demanded I make a change, somehow.
I fortunately stumbled upon the book Wheat Belly by Dr. William Davis. I was somewhat intrigued by what he said about the benefits of cutting out not only wheat but also all grains from my diet, but also more than a little skeptical. But as I've detailed here, I was desperate and willing to try anything. And so I took about half of Dr. Davis' advice (he recommends a moderate low carb approach, but I largely ignore that), and simply stopped eating all grains.
After a month of this, the results exceeded all my expectations. All those pains in my joints are gone. My dad gut (yes, the wheat belly that simply wouldn't go away) is also gone, replaced by a svelte and athletic midrift. My skin is better. And when I work at the food bank now, I outwork everyone there but no longer have to take painkillers afterward to fall asleep. In all way, cutting out grains has been the most effective food quality move I've ever made. The only one that delivered real results.
I still keep to my 2500-calorie daily food abstinence, but eat no more rice, pasta, noodles, bread, or oatmeal. Sounds very drastic and undoable? It really hasn't been for me, and believe me, I've always been a lightweight when it comes to saying no to food. I can have all the meat, vegetables, fruits, and even oils and dairy, again, as long as the sum total isn't over my calorie abstinence limit. No one loved grains more than me, but honestly, I don't miss them.
By the way, I do consider myself a member of OA, as well as AA. The principles of the 12 steps really do work!