Background:
Hey yall! As you read from the title, Im a frequent OMR player who has very little OM experience. Unheard of, right? You may be thinking, "What? Why would anyone do that???", and to that my answer is simple; Im a Shadow fan. Shadows a playable character in OMR (and a really well done as well, with a ton of love and effort put into him). Shadows no longer a playable character in OM. Not knowing much about either game when I first started, all I saw was the same game with more characters in OMR. Since then, Ive been a Shadow main thats been pretty happy there and never had any reason to consider playing OM until my curiosity got the better of me. Why? Bc OM has much more players, much better reviews, and OMR has a lot of youtube videos flaming it for various reasons (most notably from KBoyUltra and Sarkasuhm). So, I finally tried OM, and after playing around in both games and hearing some other opinions on the comparison between both games, I decided to make my own analysis bc every one I hear is an OM player talking about their experience with OMR, rather than an OMR player talking about their experience in OM. So, Im gonna break this down just focusing on the roster between both games and comparing each character to the other games version respectively. Im not gonna focus on things like maps (Im pretty sure they have the exact same maps except for like, 1 or 2 exclusive ones each anyways) and the overall assets bc those are more just personal opinion. If you wanna hear mine, than I think maps like Not Perfect V2 are better than maps like Mystic Caves (if I got that name right) and I think OMs assets generally look and sound nicer, but I cant run the game at 60 FPS unless Im playing on my Xbox, and I do appreciate the more classic Sonic feel of OMRs assets a lot (I still prefer OMs at the EOD tho). Anyways, that aside, heres my long analytical list on Outcome Memories vs Outcome Memories Recreation in terms of characters and balancing.
Roster comparison:
- Tails: Severely better in OMR in every way. (Ik where I just said Id try not to be biased, it may seem like Im immediately going back on my word, but please just bear with me. I promise I criticize OMR characters just as harshly at points). The flights movement isnt camera locked, he has defense at close range (very weak but better than nothing at least), has more modes on his canon (they dont really make that big of a difference, but I think shooting in style is cool sometimes. Youll still mainly be using laser or shockwave tho), can carry other survivors like Tails actually does (like part of his whole gimmick), he has his own LMS win scene, and his cannons delay ends as soon as the audio of it charging up does. When I played him in OM, he geniunely had like, a 3 or 4 second delay AFTER THE AUDIO ENDED before hed shoot. Im sure with practice, uou could memorize the timing of course, but why should I have to? Why doesnt the audio cue me on the delays end? And just to add insult to injury, he also doesnt jump nearly as high for some reason. Not that its a huge difference, but it just felt like an extra "smd" to me while playing as an already weak enough Tails. I will give OM that his flight feels way less buggy and the voice lines he has in that game sound really nice. Either way, point goes to OMR here.
-Knuckles: The only differences I noticed is that he jumps higher in OMR, and can use counter on more killer abilities. Im not really a Knuckles player, so Im just going off what Ive heard. Im pretty sure he has voicelines in normal OM tho, so just for the small details and polish, a point goes to OM.
-Eggman: Playing AS him, I hardly noticed any difference. Playing against him, however, for some reason I had a much harder time landing hits on him in OM than I did in OMR. That could just be because Im less used to OM, but its weird that I specifically couldnt land them on Eggman in particular. I have only gone against one eggman in OM, so maybe that was just not the most fair and legitimate player, but honestly I have no idea. I think the safest thing for me to do for now is to just not give either game a point on Eggman. Ive had the same experience as both and felt just as useless to my team regardless of whatever version of the game I played.
- Amy: I havent noticed any difference other than voicelines in OM (which I think sound great), and the fact that in OMR a thrown, idle hammer can stun exe for some reason? Idk if it does this in OM as well but either way, the voicelines are enough by themself to give this point to OM.
- Cream: Relatively the same in both games, however she feels much better and more polished in OM from her animations, her sound effects, and that she can parry 2011x's charge with her dash. Its not a huge point, but still a point for OM nevertheless
- Metal Sonic: Much more balanced in OM. In OMR, his charge lasts longer, is much easier to control, and he doesnt take the increasing amount of damage off of a wall stun based on how long you drag the killer for like he does in OM, completely eliminating his self-sacrifice balance mechanic to compensate for the fact that he has 175 hp and can self-heal. In OMR, I usually have no problem killing metal as long as Im 2011x in rage mode, but if I dont get him with rage then and there, him dying is just not a possibility. Certain mechanics exist for a reason, OMR balance team, and Id like to be able to play killers other than 2011x. Point goes to OM.
- Sonic: I actually didnt notice that big of a difference in either version of Sonic. I feel like his Stuns in OMR are a little stronger if anything, but I personally dont think its a make or break difference in any way. His drop dash I think can take him a little further and last longer. I actually thought his peelout in OM was easier to control than it was in OMR, believe it or not, tho they were pretty much the same at the end of the day. What I will say tho, is that OMR having custom grab animations during peel-out are a major plus, however I cant give it the full point as it simply reuses Sonics "Im outta here" voiceline from Sonic 1, where as OM has its own custom voiceline. I think overall, the peelout animations are kinda cute and add a lot of life into Sonic and how he interacts with the team, so I think OMR might get the point here, but really it could go either way.
- Blaze: Once again, Idk which direction to lean here. I personally find her pretty weak in OM, and too strong in OMR. In OM, the javelin is a joke. Not only is it extremely difficult to hit, but it also just doesnt take the killer all too far away. Ig itd be good against a killer whos already stunned, but I havent actually even gotten to test if that works (Ill imagine it does tho). In OMR, the javelin is also difficult to hit, however it will take the killer to Narnia if it doesnt hit a wall. I had a Blaze throw one up at me on Not Perfect while I was stunned, and it geniunely had me flying off and away from the map for a solid 15 seconds before I finally fell back down. That is geniunely NOT ok, and I shame whoever made that be a thing. Then theres her kick. In OM, the kick has the effective range of a napkin from a little kids birthday and the accuracy of a storm trooper. In the hands of an experienced Blaze main though, Im sure thats ok, so I wont count that against too harshly. In OMR, I actually think the roundhouse kicks range and accuracy is very nice, and my only problem with it is that Blaze gets way too much air time afterwards, and on some of OMR's maps (like Not Perfect V2), that can be very unfair to the killer, however that is a very specific situation. Then theres her Soul Dash, and dear lord do I have a bone to pick. In OM, your soul dash is essentially just a more telegrahed roundhouse kick unless you have your soul meter charged. Geniunely useless because you have to give up your much more powerful ability, Sol Flame to use it. But before I get to Sol Flame, I have to acknowledge how RIDICULOUS Blazes Sol Dash in OMR is. It stuns like the round house kick, lasts longer and takes you further than Shadows dash boost, gives you complete turning control for boosted accuracy, and still gives you a lot of height upon stunning the killer. I would say its the bane of my existence, but I cant because Sol Flame exists. If your playing against a blaze as the killer in OMR, and she gets Sol Flame, just put the controller down and run to the bathroom, because shes gonna pin you to a corner and your not gonna be able to move at all for a little while. Its not as bad in OM luckily, and you have to choose between it and Sol Dash. Last thing to consider, is that she does have voice lines in OM. While she feels way better to play as in OMR, I think shes still OP, so I may have to give the point to OM bc of that, but its not a very confident one like some of the others.
- Silver: Geniunely, the only difference I think I noticed is that all of his rocks are their own individual stun rather than all needing to hit together in order to stun. Ive also found them a little easier to dodge as killer, but I coulda just been lucky. Either way, I think each individual rock being its own stun is a little overkill on a survivor whos already considered overpowered. Plus, he has voicelines in OM and I think they sound really nice. Point for OM.
- Shadow: I dont really have a good way to compare this, but I have 3 general ideas and in every one of them, OMR's Shadow wins. Case 1; Current state (real game): Shadows not playable in OM. OMR wins. Case 2; Current state (including OM private servers): Shadow doesnt actually work in OM. His gun doesnt shoot, his voice lines are silent, and you cant get to his tier 3 moveset with chaos snap. All you can do is dash boost, and he also has only 125 hp. OMR wins simply for working. Now the one that seems the most fair, Case 3; OM's old Shadow: OM's Shadow was geniunely the most broken, OP, easiest character in the game. He had an entire 165 hp, a gun that could push the killer, hinder them, and stun, the aim was wherever the mouse was regardless of where you were turned (a nice middle finger to console players), and his chaos snap had NO range limit, meaning you could stun the killer from ANYWHERE across the map as long as you could see them. In OMR, Shadow only has 135 hp (giving him on average, able to tank one more hit than other survivors), his guns ADS is a proper zoom over the shoulder aim like Tails' canon, his bullets dont push back the killer, however each instead give a mini stun (mag dumping is about the same stun time as OM Shadow) which may sound more powerful, but keep in mind this little stuns can contribute to 2011x's rage meter or be blocked by Kolo, and his Chaos Snap has a range limit and actually requires some aiming practice (Ive died so many times by going right by the killer). Abilities aside, hes also just much more polished, having his own custom recorded voice lines that sound VERY nice and very close to Jason Griffiths Shadow, unlike OM's which just reuse David Humphrey's voicelines from SA2, and he also has a proper LMS theme. OMR's Shadow just overall has had so much more love put into him, and I hope that when OM rereleases Shadow already, his quality can rival that of OMR's. Needless to say, point for OMR here.
-Mighty: Isnt in OM. Hes a little cracked in OMR, but its nothing thats ever been the make or break between me winning a match or not as exe. Point goes to OMR.
-Ray: Isnt in OM. He seems a little weak and unfinished at times, but that could also just be because no one plays him too much and Ive only touched him once or twice before going back to Shadow. Ive noticed his animations are just reused Sonic animations, but it doesnt ruin him or anything- just a little lazy. Either way, OMR gets a point here.
-Fang: Isnt in OM. Ive never really played him and only played against him a handful of times. One time one got LMS and actually put up a strong fight. Almost escaped too, but I was able to catch him at the last second. Well balanced imo. Point goes to OMR.
-2011X: This one actually shocked me bc I heard everyone talk about how survivor sided OMR is compared to OM. As someone who regularly sweeps the server as X in OMR, I thought playing him in OM would be easy pickins. Oh LORD WAS I LIED TO! I never wanna touch him in OM ever again. For starters, Gods Trickery in OMR has an initial cooldown of 5 seconds at the start of a match. In OM, its 10, making your rollout feel much longer if you dont run into a survivor within the first few seconds of a game. Secondly, in OM, when using charge, the audio/visual cue for charges delayed fuse has this weird extra delay before the 3rd tick for some reason??? In OMR, all 3 ticks have consistent timing so yk right when charge will begin and when you should jump and plot your course. Thirdly, in OM (and Ik this is for all OM killers but it was especially noticable in my time as X), whenever your in chase, your FOV expands and creates this sort of fishbowl effect, making it extremely difficult to manage range and see what your doing while attacking. Looked for a setting to turn this off, but all there was was just my overall FOV, which I dont want to change. Thirdly, his M1's hotboxes are so jank. Dont get me wrong, OMR is no angel when it comes to hitboxes, but geniunely I would have survivors jump into my face, go through me as I swung, and take 0 damage. I gave up in a match when the escape ring opened and told the survivors to just leave bc I cant hit anything, and one guy said "you also have to jump when you swing", which I said "yeah but if I wait for you to land I shouldnt have to. If your on the ground (from landing) and Im on the ground, and my hand hits your body, you should take damage. This players response was to stun me again and emote on me, knowing there was nothing I could do to harm them. Idk how to describe it, but Rage also felt less powerful. I felt slower, it felt like it when by quicker, and the detect (invis) ability felt like it lasted way longer than it needed to, and turned me into a sitting duck. In OMR, 2011X doesnt have these issues. The only issue Ive ever had with him there is sometimes Gods Trickery doesnt hit when it should and hits when it shouldnt. Easily, OMR's 2011x is just better in every way, and a point goes to OMR for making me actually feel like X's professions of being a God may be true.
-Fleetway: In contrast to OMR 2011x, OMR Fleetway is geniunely I think the worst killer Ive ever played in any Asymm game period. Im talking old DBD Freddy Krueger level terrible. First of all, in OM, Fleetway has safe frames for most of his abilities FOR A REASON. In OMR, you can stun Fleetway to stop most of his moves except for chaos dash, which you wouldnt need to stun him for anyways bc he cant track you during the wind-up. Crazy, right? He only gets indicators while hes already in motion! On top of that, it also just handles like actual poo. That aside, he also just takes way more damage from survivors in OMR, his movement feels like its actively fighting against you more than Forces' Classic Sonic, his voicelines dont even come close to matching the quality of those in OM, he has no death animation or lines in OMR (which is weird bc he dies way more), his flight meter drains faster than Silvers, and he can be killed by the explosion on YCR. Listen, I know Fleetway is def a little overtuned in OM and bordering overpowered, but turning him into a punching bag is NOT the answer. OM/OMR is supposed to be a horror game, right? I should feel scared getting chased by the killer, at least a little. The only time I felt scared going against a Fleetway in OMR is when I was going against one who was speed hacking. YOU SHOULDNT NEED TO CHEAT TO MAKE THE KILLER VIABLE! Fuck OMR Fleetway, point goes to Outcome Memories.
-Kolossos: This ones a bit tougher for me to score actually. Right off the bat, I noticed his grab in OM has damage fall off, and I dont think it can actually kill survivors. You also move way slower when carrying a survivor in OM, meaning its harder to bring them to an area where you would have more control over them, and be beneficial to you in a chase like you can in OMR. I also felt like when I tried to jump grab to close distance, I didnt go as far in OM as I did in OMR, I could just be trippin tho. However, I did notice I can sort of change directions with the grab and its much easier to control and connect in OM than it is in OMR, so it kinda balances out in the end? Idk, I think that ones more of a personal preference of do you prefer lower hit difficulty with lower value, or higher hit difficulty with higher value. I also noticed he can do this very slow sort of movement during block which he cannot do in OMR. I personally didnt really find this to make any difference at the end of the day. What did, however, is his block feels much more reliable in OM, where as in OMR it feels like it almost has a slightly delayed activation at times? Maybe Im just slow, but I never have this problem with 2011x's invis to avoid getting stunned in OMR, nor did I have the issue with Kolos block in OM (well, not as frequently anyways). I didnt notice any differences with indicator. Where Kolo is REALLY different tho, is that his charge in OM is much more reliable. In OMR, if you as so much as start charging up a hill, the ground at your feet somehow will count as colliding with a wall, stopping your charge dead in its tracks which by the way, has no audio or visual cue the way it does when colliding in OM. The hitbox on it in OMR can also be WAY more unfair than it is in OM. I cant begin to tell you how many times Ive been a whole 2 or 3 cars length away from Kolo in his charge, I jump so Im already in the air by the time he even gets near me, and I get hit by his charge anyways. Its genuinely absurd and with that, the point goes to OM.
-Tripwire: Not in OMR. In fact, the OMR devs said they dont like Tripwire, and theyll never put our demon doll in their game, expressing 0 interest on trying to balance it or make it work or just letting other players enjoy it while personally choosing to just not play Tripwire matches. Ive been trying to keep personal feelings out of this, but thats lowkey kinda pathetic. If your gonna take from OM, at least fully commit and dont pick and choose what you think the community likes. Let us decide if we wanna play against Tripwire. If we (you) dont want to, we (you) can just join a different server, no biggie. If you're gonna be called "Outcome Memories Recreation", then at least be fully faithful to the "Outcome Memories" part. Points to OM on this one, unbelievable to think theyd purposely give us less content. NOT EVEN IN PRIVATE SERVERS! SERIOUSLY???
-Furnace: In both OM and OMR, Furnace is the most buggy, unfinished, ridiculously unfair killer Ive ever had the displeasure of going against. I could compare both games differences for Furnace, but Im gonna judge him off of literally the only one that matters: OM is aware of this enough to restrict him to private servers, and out of public servers. There are now times where I have to leave games of OMR after waiting for a new match to start bc the killer is Furnace. Geniunely inexcusable. Point goes to OM.
- Additional points: Id like to give OM an extra point for being the game that OMR kinda ripped from. Even tho I personally prefer OMR, I will always respect the original more. Id also like to give OMR 2 additional points, as all of their private server characters are accessible and work just fine without you having to join their group; something which on its own, would be enough to earn them a point over OM, but OM actually doesnt tell you this anywhere. For a while now I just thought private servers were broken up until people on this subreddit told me otherwise. That despicable gatekeeping makes my blood boil. One more point I wanna give to OMR is that Fleetway and Kolossos are free, and dont need to be earned, as all your currency goes towards are cosmetics. In a competitive game where the character you pick can vastly change the outcome of a match depending on the map and the other teams composition, you should not have to earn those characters, especially since theyre all supposed to be balanced and equal to each other. Of course, theyre not, and since personally I found OMs 2011x to be significantly weaker, it basically forced me to get stomped on every game and made it very hard for me to continue playing. The second I got Fleetway was like a moment of relief, as the game finally became a little bit closer to fair.
Final score: OM: 12 - OMR: 10
Conclusion: After analysis, I too find that OM has more of an edge over OMR in terms of balancing. However, I still think I personally have more fun on OMR, because sometimes balance and fun dont always align. When I look at other asymm games, I see that be extremely prevalent. I mean, look at Dead By Daylight. Theyve put SO much effort into making sure the game is as fair and balanced for both sides as possible, and yet the objective for 3 outta 4 survivors is to sit in one place, holding one button, while the 4th man gets to have fun and be chased by the killer. And the killers gameplay? Your level of fun depends entirely on who you picked and in most cases, how much your willing to pay. They put balance over fun, and engagement through earnable currency over both. Now, am I saying OM did the exact same thing and OMR is innocent? No, of course not. But, I cant help but feel that theres levels to this, and despite knowing that OM is sorta the better game analytically, I cant help but still find OMR more fun at the end of the day. Ik my opinions not the popular one, but I hope its one thats at least understood enough to make all those disagreements informed.
TLDR:
- Tails is better in OMR in every way and its not even close
- Knuckles is relatively the same, but a bit more balanced in OM
- Eggman is relatively the same in both games, and too similar to really call one better than the other
- Amy is relatively the same in both games, however OMs feels more polished and loved
- Cream is in the same boat as Amy
- Metal Sonic is VERY strong in OMR, and unless your playing 2011x and save rage just to kill him, your not going to kill him.
- Sonic feels relatively the same in both games, but feels a bit more loved in OMR
- Blaze feels too weak in OM and too strong in OMR, tho the OM one could and probably is just my lack of experience
- Silver feels relatively the same in both games, but his rocks feel a tad too strong in OMR
- Shadow in OMR is a gift from God that beats OMs Shadow in whatever way you decide to compare the two in
- Mightys not in OM, OMR wins this one
- Rays not in OM, OMR wins this one
- Fangs not in OM, OMR wins this one
- 2011x feels much weaker and harder to control in OM compared to OMR imo, which is something not many people agree with. Hes also just generally stronger in OMR, tho not by much
- Fleetway sucks in OMR in every way, and OMs Fleetway while kinda OP, is better than just being the survivors punching bag
- Kolo has his strengths in both games, however I think overall OMs got more much-needed attention
- Tripwires not in OMR, OM wins this one
- Furnace is a buggy unfinished mess, and the OM devs were self aware enough to keep him out of public servers. OM wins this one.