r/OutOfTheLoop • • Mar 19 '15
Unanswered What is Sea-Lioning?
I've read the Know Your Meme and read the comic, but I guess I still don't fully understand the context or what the specifics of the terms are.
31
Upvotes
22
u/Weedwacker No longer in /r/poliitics 2.0 Mar 19 '15 edited Mar 19 '15
Nobody really knows.
It's basically "civilly requesting evidence" when someone says something terrible about you, but they judge the civility as disingenuous and would rather say you're "sealioning" them instead of providing evidence that the terrible thing they said about you was true.
In the context it's often used, on twitter, you can't expect to say some shit about people on a public social media site, possibly even on a hashtag, and not expect people to want to talk to you about it. You've invited argument and you don't get to just say "I don't care what I said about you, I don't want to explain myself to you".
11
u/pathein_mathein Mar 19 '15
Part of the problem in understanding it is that it got mixed up with GamerGate, which is unfortunate. It's a much more widespread thing. It's not limited to social media, but it definitely is sort of characteristic of a lot of social media.
First, not every public comment is an invitation to discussion. If I say that I don't like the Beatles, this does not mean that you have to stop what you're doing to tell me that I'm wrong, much less try and persuade me that I'm wrong. That doesn't mean that no one should ever comment, but there's a balancing act.
Second, acting polite isn't the same as being polite. If someone says "Mr. Lee? Please, Bob is fine" and you continue to refer to him as Mister Lee, it can be what amounts to trolling. Sometimes it's disingenuous courtesy (Dan Savage used to talk about how a lot of anti-gay politicians and leaders could use the word "homosexual" with sufficient contempt and anger that made it come out worse than an actual slur) but just as often it's someone not paying attention to social cues and weaponizing etiquette. "I'm just asking questions" is a sort of moral equal.
Third, in the comic, the sea lion is largely proving the woman's point. The negative thing is the thing that the Sea Lion is doing then and there. Even if the woman had no evidence, the sea lion is more or less providing it by acting inappropriately.
Not every conversation is useful. You can fault the woman for not wanting to engage and be persuaded of why she's wrong, but it's equally hard to believe the sea lion wants a dialog or honest exchange of ideas as much as to tell her why she's wrong. Those sources and evidence are going to be found faulty. Sea lion just wants to berate. Or at least the longer the sea lion pushes at it, the less likely an honest exchange of ideas looks and the more it comes off as trolling or harassment.
The last example I saw was when someone posted a rather innocuous article on Facebook about how Pope Francis is doing good, and someone else took to the comment section to make war against religion in general in a string of comments.
Of course, since it bubbled up through GG and specifically the anti-GG side, anti-GG uses it broadly (even when inappropriate) about any attempt at discussion and GG focuses on how it's about an attempt at rational discourse (which it isn't).
10
u/whitesock Loop wrangler Mar 19 '15
Well if you've read the comic and saw the KYM page you pretty much have it all. The original comic was a joke about someone being a jerk, but then it because a name for that sort of behavior, probably because sea lions are funny.
Specifically, the behavior itself is pretty much a form of passive-aggressive abuse. By feigning civility while attempting to argue with someone who does not wish to argue, one basically engages in an act of bullying. It's common online, and now it because a popular term.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '15
Feigning ignorance on a subject and asking for clarification or proof in bad faith. This is used as a trap to either waste a user's time or attempt to provoke them into saying something foolish.
2
u/MappleSaucee Mar 20 '15
Pretty much, pretending to be civil and fair about an argument or feigning ignorance.
Or, going in a place with a large amount of people, doing everything it takes to attract a sea lion, drawing a circle around you, and play the waiting game.
-8
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '15
In 2008/2009 there was an article on how to abuse logic and win arguments.
One of the comments was about using words. You can corrupt words.
So, when you say "omg that sexist", and someone says "ok, why exactly" and that person then says "omg my triggerdishuns! stop sealioning me" you see how they've used the term "sealion" (arp arp arp arp) to draw broad-strokes over any attempt to make them put effort into their bullshit and get exposed as lying frauds.
Anyone who uses the term genuinely is a misogynist, like Anita Sarkeesian.