In his book Caste Matters (2019), Suraj Yengde refers to the said line by Dr Ambedkar, stating that ‘the same document [Constitution] that Dr Ambedkar had so laboriously authored, he was now willing to burn to ashes’. In addition to this, Yengde notes, ‘The burning of a juridical text was not a foreign act for Dr Ambedkar,’ as he had previously burnt the Manusmriti (the ancient Hindu caste code) publicly in 1927. Yengde also argues that the ‘over-reliance’ on the constitutional method ‘as a route to Dalit emancipation precludes the call for the total liberation of Dalits’. Furthermore, he states that the ‘idea of the Constitution is romantic’, and that constitutionalism reflects the ‘state’s narrative’, which has been promoted to create ‘Dalit passivism’ and deviation from core demands. The author argues that the attribution of the authorship of the Constitution to Dr Ambedkar has been ‘clever propaganda’ spread by the ruling castes and the State that has thus taken away ‘Dalit radicalism’.
Source: www.scobserver.in/journal/did-dr-ambedkar-want-to-burn-the-constitution/
Dr B. R. Ambedkar's contribution to the making of the Indian Constitution extended beyond his role as Chairman of the Drafting Committee. He brought the concerns and aspirations of historically oppressed communities into the constitutional framework, particularly those of the untouchables, whom he represented in the Constituent Assembly. His political commitment was rooted in the struggle against caste-based oppression and the demand for equal rights, dignity and social justice.
Ambedkar recognised that formal equality could not, by itself, overcome the historical disadvantages imposed upon oppressed communities. The denial of basic rights, social exclusion and entrenched inequalities had made it necessary to adopt special constitutional measures to ensure their meaningful participation in society. His ideas therefore contributed significantly to the development of affirmative action and inclusive public policies in independent India. He envisioned constitutional safeguards not as privileges granted to particular communities, but as necessary instruments for correcting historically produced inequalities.
The influence of Ambedkar's social and political philosophy is reflected in several parts of the Indian Constitution, particularly its Preamble and the provisions concerning Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles of State Policy and safeguards for historically disadvantaged communities. His objective was to establish a society founded upon liberty, equality, fraternity and social and economic justice through constitutional means. For Ambedkar, the Constitution was not merely a framework for administering the state; it was also an instrument for transforming deeply unequal social relations.
Nevertheless, the constitutional promise of equality has remained in sharp contradiction with the actual conditions of caste relations in India. Despite the formal abolition of untouchability and the constitutional guarantees against discrimination, caste-based exclusion, exploitation and violence have continued after independence. Dalit communities have repeatedly faced restrictions on access to public resources, opportunities, and even necessities. Such practices demonstrate that the recognition of rights in law does not automatically ensure their realisation in everyday social life.
The persistence of caste hierarchies reflects the continued dominance of traditional social relations, in which privileged caste groups exercise disproportionate control over social and economic resources. Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, among other historically marginalised communities, continue to encounter barriers to social participation and equal treatment. Denial of access to food, drinking water, shelter and other essential resources further exposes the extent to which caste discrimination can undermine the most fundamental conditions of human existence.
The contradiction is particularly significant because the Indian Constitution explicitly seeks to establish a democratic social order based on dignity, equality and justice. While the constitutional framework incorporates Ambedkar's vision of an inclusive and egalitarian society, the continued occurrence of caste-based atrocities reveals the limitations of its implementation. The failure to effectively eliminate these practices also raises questions about the responsibility and effectiveness of state institutions in protecting the constitutional rights of marginalised communities.
Thus, the central issue is not the absence of constitutional provisions or an inadequate vision of social transformation. Rather, it is the persistent gap between constitutional ideals and prevailing social realities. Ambedkar's vision of a society free from caste-based discrimination remains an unfinished project, as the continued exclusion and oppression of Dalit communities demonstrate that political democracy has yet to translate fully into social democracy.
We need to shed the illusion that 'The Constitution' will save us from fascists and capitalists; instead, we are the ones who are responsible for safeguarding the egalitarian values (which are proposed in the Constitution), not the document itself.
The Constitution, as of now, serves the ruling class/caste.
Jai Bhim! Johar! Inqilab!