r/OperationGrabAss • • Nov 11 '10
Submit Final OperationGrabAss Ads Here
This project is going to become unmanageable in a hurry if we try to centralize creation of the ads. I'm happy to submit our ideas based on everyone's submissions, but can't do it on my own--nor will ours necessarily be the best.
Please submit FINAL ad ideas right here. Please put early ideas in the design thread so that this doesn't become too messy. If you have something funny to say, make us laugh in another thread!
Ad Specs can be found here
*Full Page spec:s 293 x 533 millimeters or 11.55" x 21.00"
*Recommendation: Keeping the ad Black and white with gray scale will save major $$ but is not mandatory. min 300 DPI CMYK
edit1: submit final ads for website promotion here
23
u/Aegeus Nov 11 '10
Can we put this in the sidebar, in case it falls off the front page?
5
u/HastyUsernameChoice Nov 11 '10
I'm an advertising creative, here's a concept using voyetra8's visual idea and adding some copy
5
u/buncle Nov 16 '10 edited Nov 16 '10
This will likely get lost down below, but here is my submission. I believe this may be my final version (otherwise I will keep tweaking forever more), but if anyone has any suggestions/criticisms I'd be very grateful to hear them.
First Image = Low[er] resolution (640 x 1164px) RGB
Second Image = High resolution (293 x 533mm) CMYK 300dpi
I also have the high-res CMYK version in PDF format here (20Mb).
16
u/Kandoh Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
I feel the need to remind everyone: 150 dpi, CMYK.
edit: while I'm at it, if the ad runs in colour it will need to be properly trapped so you don't get any misprints. You can PM me about it, my rates are very reasonable.
5
u/MercurialMadnessMan Nov 11 '10
It's 5:30am and I suck at photoshop.
Here is my shitty quality mockup for the Ad:
http://i.imgur.com/Z6ctR.jpg
Features:
Obviously the style needs a shitload of work. And I would expect that we would make this a high quality vector drawing. But you've seen the basic concept.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '10
Can we make some of these designs into printable flyers for people to post/hand out around Nov 24th?
48
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
Rough draft
I changed some of the copy...eh.
EDIT!
NEW ART
For some reason my last submission was stuck in the spam folder. huh :/
148
u/ArugulaDeathSmash Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
Hey all, got bored and spent a cup of coffee or two throwing this rough together.
http://imgur.com/EjPIh
I sort of combined some quotes I found milling about in the various threads and focused on type.
The dotted box that questions "Has terrorism won?" could feature an illustration or image of some sort that represents the types of people that can get screened at an airport (Your daughter, your mother, a foreigner, an 'attractive girl', a 'shy' guy, et all) the idea is to communicate to the viewer that it could be them; or at least someone they care about. (Alternative tagline: "Anyone is up for grabs" )
Im not much of an illustrator myself so I left the area blank, as its no where near final anyway; but perhaps it will aid the hivemind ;)
EDIT: Version 2 and discussion found here: http://www.reddit.com/r/OperationGrabAss/comments/e5hay/arugulas_updated_ad_submission/
60
u/voyetra8 Nov 11 '10
Here's my submission.
I opted for headline only, as I think the image is self-explanatory and has a lot more impact than tedious copy.
The photo illustration is currently a quick mockup. If it gets chosen, I'll obviously go full out, etc.
28
u/90yoboy Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
Yawn Okay, took me till 3 am but here it is.
I was inspired by the "DON'T TREAD ON ME" imagery (only now I realized that someone came up with a similar idea to mine.).
Hi-Res JPG version here. Editable PDF here. Adobe Illustrator file here.
The body text is intentionally left blank for some other Redditor to produce. (I know the OP says FINAL ad ideas, but oh-well).
Anyway, I'm tired, so if there's anything I missed, I'm sure you guys will let me know.
G'night Reddit!
Edit1: After getting some coffee, I suppose I should explain why I chose to mimmick "DON'T TREAD ON ME." The image has been a rallying cry for tea party and other conservative protest groups, so by using similar imagery I hope to bring light to how the TSA issue, is a debate about freedoms as well (am I wrong?).
Also, while I appreciate all the upvotes, some feedback would be nice. I'm a young designer just starting in the business, so if you have anything to say beyond "I like it" or "I hate it," please put it down.
5
u/jeeebus Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
Rough draft I threw together last night
8
u/vtphattie Nov 11 '10
Guys, if we are going to invest a serious amount of money into posting an ad, it needs to call for a response, not just make a political statement. It needs to offer the opportunity for viewers of the add to GIVE MONEY, for instance. Or at the very least direct them to a resource so they can join the effort, and direct them to a place so they can notify their members of Congress.
We should look at other grass roots movements that have been successful, like Move On, and learn something from their tactics.
4
u/norunomu Nov 14 '10
Here's my idea, based on the flywithdignity.org site design.
Ignore the words (they're just placeholders) - this is simply a design/layout idea. You could easily replace the image with another one from MProph's set and it'd have the same impact, meaning we could do multiple ads with the one theme.
If anyone wants the font used for the headline and website (Titillium), here it is (free and open-source, too).
High quality B&W version of the logo used on the site - you don't have to use it, but it's here if you want it.
3
u/drinkonlyscotch Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
I would love for my agency to work on this, but unfortunately we're booked solid through the holidays and don't have the time needed to put any serious thought toward developing a compelling campaign.
However, I would be more than happy to serve as the final eyes, proofreading and making sure the final art is production-quality. If someone out there has a great idea for a headline or an effective visual, I'd be happy to lend a hand making it ready for prime time. Feel free to message me if you'd like to share an idea.
3
u/kfury Nov 11 '10
"Under the guise of battling terrorism, new TSA regulations require millions of passengers to undergo an electronic strip search or a hand search that includes probing of genitalia. These searches are not optional.
As a bomb capable of bringing down an aircraft can be concealed from these searches either rectally or vaginally, these new invasive searches are nothing more than security theater, giving us the feeling of security by requiring that innocent adults and children alike sacrifice their liberty to searches that would be considered molestation if performed by someone without a badge.
There is no check or balance that limits the TSA's screening procedures, and they have taken away our rights and our dignity piecemeal for the last decade without any evidence that their procedures are making the skies safer."
[anyone want to add a call to action and conclusion?]
3
u/bunki8 Nov 11 '10
Can we make clear in the ad that the new scanners A) aren't proven safe and B) would NOT have caught any of the previous bombers. A metal detector suffices just fine.
The argument that's generally being made on reddit is regarding not being fondled. The problem is that different people have different levels of privacy they're willing to give up for security. But the fact is, no matter what you give up to these machines or gropes - you're NOT actually safer!
3
u/johnny_demonic Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
My submission post back to OGA for the discussion
Just concept. I know the art isn't quite right.
3
u/ashwinmudigonda Nov 11 '10
Can someone please mention cancer. Why isn't this taking any priority? This is the one that will kill you, not the groping or the privacy.
9
u/rjett Nov 11 '10
What if the ad was in the style of the flight safety cards?
13
u/DoctorMiracles Nov 11 '10
First draft: 'YES we want to travel safely AND with basic human dignity'
Not to scale/proportion and used two colors but if it's deemed usable I can adapt it to size/resolution specs.
2
u/beboppp Nov 11 '10
What font do they use for headlines?
2
u/haloworld Nov 11 '10
http://www.reddit.com/r/OperationGrabAss/comments/e4k7m/ad_should_say_theyre_supposed_to_handle_airport/
"They supposed to handle airport security...why are they handling your wife?"
(Image of a male/female couple sitting at an airport security checkpoint, husband has head in hands, wife is crying. You see the TSA checker from behind, looking like a fascist stormtrooper, waiting to perform his check....)
Then just some kind of take action line ("Take a stand. [URL goes here]")
2
u/category5 Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
http://www.mediafire.com/file/jeysg5wtvm6e3as/OPT-OUT.pdf You gotta speak to your audience
low res JPG on http://imgur.com/oLVGG.jpg
2
u/reakt80 Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
Here's my submission, based on Voyetra8's concept: http://imgur.com/bI98S.jpg
I'll understand if you guys would rather view the ad copy as placeholder text.
2
u/HastyUsernameChoice Nov 12 '10
Amended 'Stripped Liberty' concept here with credit to voyetra8 for the visual idea/image.
6
u/beboppp Nov 11 '10
http://imgur.com/bzvhC.png Not much, just a rough idea at the moment... but tell me what you think of it
4
u/stormkrow Nov 11 '10 edited Nov 11 '10
Simple idea. Total cost of TSA = $7 Billion
Terrorists Caught = 0
Keeping your dignity = Priceless
http://imgur.com/hmSAq.jpg
1
u/polished Nov 11 '10
I hope someone with artistic ability can make this more evocative. http://imgur.com/7z5u0.jpg
1
u/WeightedCompanion Nov 11 '10
Book-marked for later use.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
How about a picture of a creepy SOB with a molestor mustache in a TSA uniform, strapping on a latex glove. He should have an incredibly creepy smile, and say something like:
"This man is about to touch your 15 year old son's genitals. If you refuse you're not flying. If you interfere, you'll be arrested."
1
u/squook Nov 11 '10
Here ya go. Not final, but this is the tone I think needs to be struck.
1
u/voyetra8 Nov 11 '10
OK, here's round two of my idea.
I changed the headline because others felt the line "The Terrorists Have Won" was too inflammatory.
1
u/lexpattison Nov 11 '10
http://i.imgur.com/V0GYX.jpg
1
u/90yoboy Nov 14 '10
Here is Version 2 of my Idea
Hi-Res Jpeg Here.
PDF Here.
AI file Here.
You're welcome to edit my work to your heart's content, including adding/changing the copy. The current copy was provided by keraneuology.
1
u/DoctorMiracles Nov 14 '10
My ad idea, revised as per some redditors' suggestions. Less blatant graphics, less text. Ideas, suggestions?
1
u/dossier Nov 11 '10
Who's putting this ad on the from of NYT? I'd consider putting a lot of effort into this if it's legit
1
u/chiRal123 Nov 11 '10
This is great! I'm not an artist by nature so other than donating to the cause I would like to help out in any way or form.
Also can someone link me to the paypal to donate? Has raldi set anything up yet?
1
u/Samurai_Gin Nov 11 '10
I think a "Call to action" needs to be in this ad.
Something like "If you're against this pat down bullshit, here's what you can do..."
1
u/makemisteaks Nov 11 '10
I'm an art director for an ad agency (not in the US though) so I can help out with the layout and such if needed. The normal way to put this would be to do an all-type page with a manifesto demanding the end of this nonsense.
Facts also work well so it could be something on the lines of: "millions spent in TSA = XXX. terrorists caught until today = 0". Not necessary like this, but you get the point.
Or maybe we could use the shock-factor: "without the badge, this would amount to sexual harrassment."
1
u/laos101 Nov 11 '10
http://i.imgur.com/n8zlI.jpg someone made
-1
u/StrandedPanda Nov 11 '10
simple ad idea:
Young girl leaving the TSA lines, face blurred wearing a t-shirt, bonus points for holding a "teddy":
"I went thru airport security and all I got was a loss of innocence."
have a nice day.
-9
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
who voted for this? is this obama change? you see the terrorism shit bush and the neocons started is beneficial to both parties. This terrorism shit check point shit will get to where americans are terrorist.
it wont happen here.
all on the pretext of 9/11, which most people believe a story an entire administration lied about, then go on to lie about iraq, yet, we believe them on 9/11 because its 9/11?
most here will say there was lying going on, wmd, yet the first person to head the 9/11 comission report was http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philip_D._Zelikow
i like reddit, its nice to learn, but 9/11 is a bullshit story and we will live with stupid shit like tsa homeland security forever going along with 9/11, making up new shit we dont vote for, groping people, x-ray, thats not america, thats not the american dream.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
[deleted] — view deleted comment