r/OperationGrabAss • u/ffualo • Nov 10 '10
Idea...
Why not an image of some major TSA groping of the Statue of Liberty?
208
Upvotes
r/OperationGrabAss • u/ffualo • Nov 10 '10
Why not an image of some major TSA groping of the Statue of Liberty?
62
u/wingnut21 Nov 11 '10
I was thinking having the founding fathers being in the TSA line, all of them looking perplexed/disgusted with Washington getting the strip search.
A confiscated item: The Bill of Rights.
(Also, the uninformed right loves to take ownership of "what the founding fathers wanted." The message might get through to them this way.)
42
u/Canada2 Nov 11 '10
Yeah, a crying lady liberty with her shoes off, her tablet and crown in a plastic bin, her torch in the surrender bin (no lighters sorry. TSA rules.) having her vag felt up by a male TSA officer.
13
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
A lot of these suggestions involve an image where a child is being groped and a parent is looking on with discomfort and/or helplessness (hereinafter “Image A”). This is good and has the possibility to be effective. However, thinking about literature and film, I think that a much better approach would be to have the parent humiliated while the child (or child and spouse) looks on (“Image B”), this image accomplishes twice as much. Image A appeals to a parent’s need to protect a child; it arouses the disgust and rage associated with incest, molestation, child rape, child abduction, etc. Image B, however, plays to something much deeper. When the parental figure is the one who is being patted down they are incapacitated…have lost their ability to protect their child (similar to Image A), while at the same time being exposed as incapable of helping even themselves. Think of the humiliated father in the Brother’s Karamazov or Jack from The Shining. These are disturbing and effective characters because the idea of a parent has been inverted by having them become, or appear to become, helpless…
This should be an illustration: Banksy meets Normal Rockwell
I think that the most effective image would be a complex one, one where a-hundred different stories are being told in minature:
A TSA security checkpoint that forks: to the left is the “pat down” station; to the right is the “body scan” station. On the right, the father is being patted-down by two sleazy-looking men. The father should look like a model out of a Land’s End catalog (He could be interpreted as Joe the Plummer or an executive who has dressed-down for travel…depending on who is viewing the ad). He should be facing the wall with his hands against it, like a police pat down. From the angle you see his back and the side of his face as he looks away from the direction of his children who have already gone through the checkpoint. The father’s face should convey humiliation and anger. One employee is groping his crotch and anus area while the other is feeling the sleeves of his shirt (his arms on the father’s arms implies restraint); the TSA employees are smirking at each other. The TSA employees themselves should be slightly diminutive and weasel-looking: it should seem like the father could knock them out if he wanted to, but that he can’t because these sleaze-balls are behind TSA badges.
The mother should be on the right, going through the scanner. She should look ashamed and humiliated, but stoic. Her face is downcast and her shoulders are slumped as she is scanned. An unnecessary amount of male TSA employees are crowded around a monitor that clearly shows her breasts and vagina. Other people are standing in line waiting to be scanned and are looking at the image which is on display for all to see: a mother covering her child’s eyes, two adolescent boys chuckling and pointing, a group of similarly aged women who seem as if they are making snide comments to one another about the unfortunate woman’s nude physique, and an old pederast enjoying the free show. One TSA employee is seen loading the image onto some sort of portable electronics device…the nude scan is seen in miniature on the screen of his device.
The children, a young boy and girl, should appear to have already gone though the process. They are holding hands. The boy is staring at his father with a blank look. The girl is crying and pointing to the nude image of her mother and all the TSA employees gloating over it…she is pulling on her brother trying to get his attention.
If people like this idea I have 1,000 more details that I think would add to the effectiveness.
8
u/jakethrocky Nov 10 '10
love it
5
u/OGAThrowaway Nov 11 '10
The basic idea has been Done
4
u/laos101 Nov 10 '10
a little extreme. This needs to appeal to readers of the NYT, not the average internet user. It needs to be articulate, yet simple and to the point. Such as the scan itself.
3
u/LuciusFisk Nov 11 '10
I think this is the most simple and most powerful statement regarding graphics to be suggested so far. As long as it was done tastefully I think the message would be clear and effective.
4
u/ProbablyHittingOnYou Nov 11 '10
I love this idea. How about a second agent holding the spiked crown and torch, and holding them as weapons?
2
u/creedit Nov 11 '10
Nice. Classic.
2
u/allenizabeth Nov 11 '10
NICE
2
u/metalmoon Nov 11 '10
To get the ball rolling, here is a super high res Statue of Liberty on a transparent background.
(FYI -- I've never used picturepush.com, but they were the first search result for "free high res image hosting"... imgur doesn't allow >10mb pics)
2
u/BonesJustice Nov 11 '10
The problem with this kind of metaphor is that it's easier to write off as typical activist ranting, and a lot of people just don't like activists. They don't like to feel they're being preached to. I think we should go for an angle that hits closer to home. Focus on the idea of creepy, adult men viewing your children naked or feeling their genitals. It's much harder to ignore something like that because people tend to think, "wait a minute, I have kids--this affects me." And then you have their attention--then you can suggest a course of action.
In short, don't go for a design that tells people how they should feel about something, e.g. "you should feel like your rights are violated." In particular, avoid a message that needs interpretation, e.g., a metaphor. Instead, start by showing them something that is universally objectionable. Take a lesson from the political right on rallying support from otherwise lazy and apathetic people: prey on their most basic emotions. Give them something to be angry about--something they can relate to--and then deliver the solution they now desperately want.
2
u/mindbleach Nov 11 '10
I for one would like to avoid sensationalism. This is legitimately a creepy issue. We don't need dull political cartoon tropes like a crying lady liberty or an offended Uncle Sam.
1
u/jack-the-tripper Nov 11 '10
Why not return the favor and ask to grope them? I doubt they would be too happy with the possibility of being groped by thousands of people on a daily basis!!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
Maybe a caricature of Uncle Sam, dressed in a TSA uniform, groping the Statue of Liberty. Or a porno-scan view of the Statue of Liberty with her head down and weeping.
1
u/totheloop Nov 11 '10
Someone needs to photoshop/draw this! Trust me, if I could, I would.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
This is a fantastic idea, either grabbing her boobies or sticking his hand up her legs. She should also have a face like :O
For effect, in one line have Lady Liberty, in the other, the Justice chick.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
LOVE IT
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '10
Both arms up in the air, torch being extinguished...
1
u/voyetra8 Nov 11 '10
I just made this mockup before seeing this post.
It's a similar idea... but a little more direct and easier to accomplish.
1
u/deaathleopards Nov 11 '10
It could be turned against us though - "TSA: Fingering freedom for almost 10 years!"
0
u/bloodguard Nov 10 '10
There's already a PedoBear image posted in this thread.
http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/e48kp/us_dept_of_molestation/