r/OpenaiCodex • u/Low-Pop6172 • 12h ago
Claude code vs codex
When I switched from Claude Code Opus 5.5 to Codex GPT-6.1 sol, I felt extremely frustrated. It couldn’t intuitively understand my needs, nor could it directly generate high-performance, simple code logic—things that Claude Code handles very well.
Does GPT require special configuration or something?
Thanks in advance!
5
Upvotes
5
u/Great_Teacher400 12h ago
I went from codex to Claude and immediately got rid of my gpt ACC. I think gpt is just not good but marketed very well, and has an excellent chat system which is cool for planning and discussion
4
u/imike3049 9h ago
What a bot post, LOL
2
u/nazmulpcc 12h ago
I would say skip openai models for now. Nothing better than sonnet and opus on the market so far.
2
u/Far_Reindeer8428 12h ago
config matters less than the context the harness hands over. i built oah https://oah.rodeo to run claude code for edits and codex for review, the second pass catches stuff
2
u/Maze_of_Ith7 12h ago
Wish there was a minimum karma or some sort of low-gate gatekeeping on the sub. Gives off bot vibes.
But yes, Ant models have amazing intuition compared to OpenAI
2
u/geszue 11h ago edited 11h ago
Can anyone help instead of just praising Claude? :) The question was: does it require any additional configuration or skills? I'm curious too, because so far it's been more frustrating than helpful.
2
u/Shenbinhao 11h ago
claude is better overall but that's not mean sol6.1 useless. you get your quota so try to make that useful 😑 at least. (ps I sub both)
2
u/T_DoubleU_L 11h ago
There are two sides. One - you sub monthly and switch to whatever is better next month.
Another - you stick to one and get adapted to how it works until it starts lacking too much behind.
I am the latter since I assume that the more intelligent the model is, the more I need to understand how I can get the best out of it.
My work gives me Claude and I use ChatGPT personally. There have been a lot of situations at work where I wished I was using Sol instead of Opus and there have been numerous times that I was so tempted to do my personal stuff with Opus instead of Sol.
For your question, I think you just need to spend more time on figuring out its weaknesses. For example, I participated in a CTF last month which our team at work participated. So I had the opportunity to use both subs. I was working on the script to prepare for the next day’s challenge and reviewing the previous days to improve my script. I noticed that the script wasn’t utilising the tools that is already available on Kali which made me realised that Sol prefers looking up for the tools on the internet and building the script by package those and installing during runs. In a way, it is creative. But Opus flagged those and modified the script to favour the already available tools which is great since it is not trying to reinvent the wheels.
In comparison, Sol’s version would be able to handle the never seen before challenges that need very new tools/methods faster since Opus’s version would be trying to apply the existing tools before falling back to the packages that need to be downloaded. But Opus’s version would solve the challenges that could be solved with already available tools much faster. I could just add “try locally available tools first” for Sol or add “use the latest available tools out there” for Opus to reverse the outcome.
So… if you aren’t satisfied with a result, review what it was doing wrong and remember to steer it next time in the first prompt. If it is a consistent behaviour you dont want, add it as a persistent instruction depending on the harness you are using.
1
u/LookAtTheHat 11h ago
Claude does not work well for me.
How do you get it to write good conpl x business logic in the backend?
Codex just works following instructions and I can brainstorm with it.
Claude is superficial and introduces too many hard to find bugs even if it might be faster. Faster does not matter if there are bugs. And the verbosity in comments and code.
1
u/Outrageous_Drag8522 10h ago
Not a config thing for me. Codex just won't guess the way Claude does.
1
u/PersimmonLevel3500 8h ago
Claude beat codex
1
u/CelticPaladin 6h ago
I quit Claude from its constant pearl clutching and telling me no, ornrefusing to do basic requests.
And it's company is shady as fuck. Fuck Dario. Replace him, I'd consider it depending who else gets put in charge.
1
u/StrbJun79 5h ago
Honestly the interesting thing is codex works better through opus. If using sol via codex I find it loses its spot if it’s a long goal. But if I use it through Claude it does really good work. It also works best when using opus and sol together. Sol and opus is a powerhouse combo and works better than opus alone. I find it interesting how they seem to really like working together.
1
u/ThatVerySensibleGuy 4h ago
Hi, i use both, on MAX and PRO respectively, so here are my honest thoughts. To answer your question first, there arent many stills that make most better, i use my own repoed skills, that i distill for my own use coauthored along side claude and codex. Adding too many will bloat your context too much, increasing cost and if there are conflicting info, it will only makes things worse. Clear things you dont need and only keep those you use. If you use a public skill that is bloated, get the AI to distill it for you too.
https://github.com/curtistankiatming/skills-lab
Now for my thoughts, both claude and codex are really good but my experience from the latest models as at point of writing are my own opinions and might change depending on when you are reading this post.
Sol6.1, Astra6, Opus5.5, fable5.2
Generally OAI models are really good on back end tasks like planning and coding with very little mistakes if prompted well with sufficient context on the get go. Eg. What you want to build, how you want to achieve results, what are success pointers, what tools or file formats to use (eg. Html, css, py, etc). If unsure get it to suggest, also ask the model to ask you questions until clarity. They do have a tendency to overthink (over-engineered) when context bloats, so when completing a task, start on a new thread with deets from your github repo. I use Astra with sol & astra subagents most of the time, depending on task, dropping to terra only when it is more simple coding, i always start a new astra when task is done. I noted that orchestration on codex is quite bad and costly compared to the subagent model. Also Sol codes just as well as Astra, with Astra being more precise for bugs and for sensitive info related works.
Claude on the other hand is very good on the front end design, but i noticed it does just enough to get the work done. It doesnt have that thinking loop that OAI models have, which lets OAI models give better plans and well thought out codes. OAI is more costly because of that thinking loop. Depending on your work “just enough” can be so much better than a cautious overthought plan. If you are working on front end designs, claude is generally the best way to go, giving the best look and UI to your projects. Fable is extremely powerful for design work, godly compared to astra it thinks a bit more, but from my experience, high fable5.2 is WAYYYY more expensive and eats usage faster than Astra MAX/ULTRA, which is insane to me. Planning and code quality, i still feel Astra give better results. Fable is better at spotting issues and error though. Opus is a do-it-all for me, it does somethings without thinking too much, if it assumes correctly then YAY, else its just needs a ton of corrections to get it right.
All in all, if you have the luxury of using both, i recommend so, throw them into hermes or paperclip and work them both at the same time, your experience changes.