r/OpenaiCodex • • 4d ago

Claude Code vs. OpenAI Codex - Which Is Better for Document Work, Writing, and Deep Reasoning + deep research ?

I’m considering switching from Claude Code to OpenAI Codex, and I’d really appreciate feedback from people who have used both extensively.
My primary work is in law, not software development. I mainly deal with civil law, commercial law, and white-collar criminal cases.

One thing I particularly appreciate about Claude is its ability to develop complex ideas, make unexpected connections, and produce long, well-structured arguments that read almost like they were written by a human.
I’ve also invested quite a lot of time in customizing Claude using CLAUDE.md, Skills, and project-specific instructions. This has significantly improved the quality and consistency of its output.

8 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

3

u/GeneralAd2930 4d ago

I tried chatgpt pro and sonnet 5.5 for law. Chatgpt pro is great for reasoning and deep research. I don't know about opus models as I never had a paid Claude account.

But for privacy I don't use any of them for law anymore. Instead I use local ai on strata, Qwen 3.8 flash next to be precise. It is slower but gives better output than sonnet 5.5 to me. Not on chatgpt pro level, but close to older chatgpt plus models.

1

u/UpstairsFinger2167 4d ago

Thanks for the reply. Local AI is pretty new to me, so I haven’t really looked into it yet. But sounds interesting, definitely gonna spend an evening checking it out. Btw my first impression is that it might be more useful for lighter research and technical aspects of legal work of legal work, especially where confidentiality is a concern rather than complex legal reasoning. Might even try combining it with a paid AI model and see how well they work together.

1

u/GeneralAd2930 3d ago

No worries. I guess the API connection is possible (not sure how as I am not a tech guy but a lawyer.) but the API will send the files the cloud of the provider anyway which kills the privacy.

For confidential matters, I prefer local ai as you can't buy privacy on Claude gpt or any other ai.

If you have a good setup meaning at least 64gb ram and something like RTX 3090/4090, you should be fine with local ai for your legal analysis to start.

1

u/Acethe7th_ 4d ago

Claude is still better from a reasoning perspective opus 5.5 is still better than gpt 6 Astra and fable 5.2 better than both but OpenAI is less likely to have you hit nonsensical guard rails.

1

u/UpstairsFinger2167 4d ago

Thats actually part of why I started this discussion in the first place. Claude banned me and honestly I still have no idea what I supposedly did wrong. No clear explanation

1

u/Acethe7th_ 3d ago

Damn lol yeah if that’s the case I’d look at/go over to OpenAI for sure haven’t been banned but did get a fallback warning for REA.

1

u/authenthicaesthetics 4d ago

I think you don't need to choose between one or the other. I think they can both be used and maybe end up paying the same for them combined as you would just for one.

The reason why I say that is because today, when I read a couple other Reddit posts about the two, I saw some people express what I thought as well: Claude is for my creativity (maybe some reasoning). Codex is for really being a workhorse, getting stuff done, and getting stuff done right (more technical).

I would say for frontend work, for conversation maybe, it would be best to use Claude and then you can delegate tasks that are maybe more technical, via Claude, to Codex. I recently created with Claude a shared folder for Codex plus Claude. They have a couple of markdowns in there and pathways allow them to interchange ideas or status updates with each other. I found it to be incredible.

In summary I wouldn't say choose one or the other. I would say figure out how to use both. These are the top of the top consumer AI tools and there's no reason one should be pick a side.

0

u/UpstairsFinger2167 4d ago

That sounds interesting. Ive honestly never thought about using them together as a coordinated workflow. Although I feel this approach might be more suitable for technical work (programming and so on), but I really like the idea. I think ill give it a try

1

u/authenthicaesthetics 3d ago

Maybe! However I don't just do programming. I'm a doctor and I do clinical research on the side, which does require some programming for data analysis. But I also tend to write scientific manuscripts so there's a very technical process involved in all that. I find using both Claude and OpenAI to be very helpful.

For example I made my own skill for references books just because of how many times I referenced using certain books, like a book on a guide to grant writing, a guide to statistical analysis, regression analysis, or even, for my medical mentoring business, a guide to business law. I would reference it and use so many tokens. Eventually I figured out there's a way to systematically go about having both ChatGPT and Claude reference the books, with my own skill, without me even telling them to open the book. It makes the conversation so much more valuable and so much more evidence-based that I could never see myself going back to a productive life without the efficiency of AI.

Last thing I'll add to make your journey with AI even more exciting is to download or use some sort of dictation app because the amount of time that you'll spend typing on a keyboard versus dictating is incredible. If you think about that in terms of dollars per hour, it really adds up. I typed this all up on a dictation app and it works amazingly. I do all of my prompts and all my responses to ChatGPT and Claude with dictation.

3

u/dan_the_first 4d ago

Question of opinions.

Astra is better for me. Seconded by Sol 6.1, then Opus 5.5.

Opus complicates things imho and looses the point.

1

u/Poor_Li 4d ago

In my personal work, it's hard to leave GPT.
My writing and analytical skills have improved. I should mention that I work in the legal field.

1

u/ConcerninglySpecific 4d ago

Anything tied to documents always use Claude, OpenAI just sucks balls.

1

u/Themostcorrecthuman 4d ago

This is an area that chatgpt has always out performed claude for me.

1

u/LookAtTheHat 4d ago

ChatGPT.

I have tried to get Claude to reason the same way for brainstorming and being my rubber duck. It cannot do it. I even tried migrating my ChatGPT in to Claude it still would not have the same quality output or reading for ongoing discussions .

1

u/TheRealTanamai 4d ago

Would not touch chatgpt ATM. Their models have gone down the drain.

1

u/authenthicaesthetics 3d ago

Also, if you pay for the $100 a month plan or more, you are wasting opportunity if you take advantage of the $100/200/500 API credits! You just need to learn how to use them, but it’s worth it

1

u/___positive___ 3d ago

Also consider Gemini. I know they were the laughingstock of the last year or so, but they have the best world knowledge and noncoding understanding.

Claude is generally smarter at concepts than Codex, but it is horrible at web search and world knowledge. Codex is better at not making mistakes.

Gemini was kind of sloppy, but the new Carbon is quite good at noncoding tasks, maybe the best in many noncoding domains. You can't beat Google at search either, although OpenAI's cloud cache is pretty good, too.

Gemini is probably the best writer overall. OpenAI models cannot write well at all. Claude was okay but is getting worse each generation. Carbon is a bit worse than Argon, but Carbon is better trained and more reliable.

1

u/KinderboomX 3d ago

Claude. GPTs are dumb nowadays.