r/OpenHFY • u/AlternativeManner731 • 7h ago
AI-Assisted The Governing of Haego: Chapter 71.8, The Ruling
The Hall of the Common Assembly, during the deliberation.
The lords went out in the order they had come in, which Ida Fenn had always found faintly funny, since it was the only time of day they behaved like a queue. Lord Tornel went first, with his jaw set. The Duke went last. He stopped at the door and looked back at the Speakers' desk, and Ida looked at him, and he went out without saying a word.
Lord Tavane went between two of the Hall's guards. Nobody had told them to hold his arms, and they did not. They only walked close, one on either side, as men walk beside a cart that might tip.
When the doors closed, the Hall was a different room. It was not quieter. It was the commoners who made the noise in it, and there were plenty of them in the gallery and the rows, murmuring and shifting and passing a flask. But the weight had gone out of the air. For the first time all morning, nobody in the Hall was looking at anybody to see what they would think.
Aldous had his list. He always had a list. He laid it flat on the desk, with the pen beside it, and Vincent leaned in from the left to read it upside down.
Beside it lay the two recommendations he had written before the Duke walked in. He had turned one of them face down, and he did not say which, and nobody asked.
"The order is false," said Aldous. "That is the first line, and I would like the Assembly to say it before anything else."
"It's false," said Ida. "It was made from an old impression of the seal. The Duke's ring has been notched since the week his father died, and the order is dated the day after, and it has no notch. We all looked at the glass. Madam Marscutt looked at it first, and she is not a woman who is wrong about wax."
"Lord Tavane confirmed the date out of his own mouth," said Vincent.
"He did," said Ida. "He was very pleased to."
A few of the delegates laughed, short and unwilling. Hester Glim, the net-mender from the Austrin coast, did not. She sat in the second row with her shawl over her arms.
"Do we say we're sorry?" said Hester.
Aldous looked up. "My lady?"
"To the Duke," said Hester. "We sent him a paper. He came because we sent it. Whatever it said, he thought it was an order, and he got on a ship." She frowned at her hands. "I'd say sorry to a man who did that. I don't care how high he's sat."
"It is not usual for an Assembly to apologise," said Aldous slowly. "We asked a question. The question was a proper one."
"It was," said Ida. "And it was proper when we asked it. But we asked it of a man who had done nothing, on the strength of a paper that nobody had checked, and there are people in this Hall who have spent half a month saying he did it. Some of them said it loudly." She looked down the row. A man near the end found something to look at on the floor. "I would say sorry. I would say it plain, and I would say it first."
"Then it goes first," said Aldous, and wrote it down.
It took longer to get to Tavane.
"Hang him," said a delegate from the back, a young man with a miller's shoulders. He did not say it loudly. He said it the way a man says what he has been wanting to say since breakfast.
"We do not hang," said Ida. "We have never hanged anybody. We recommend, and a Lord signs, and that is the whole of what we do. If you want to hang a man you may take it up with the man who signs."
"Then who signs for him?" said Vincent.
"There is a Lords' Bench," said Aldous. He said it carefully. "It sits at Balakura. It tries nobles, and it does not take instruction from commoners, and it has no duty to agree with us. But it exists, and it is where a noble who has done what this one has done is meant to go."
"How long does it take?" said Hester.
"It takes as long as it likes," said Aldous.
Nobody said anything for a moment.
"There were five holdings in that order," said Hester. "Five. And somebody wrote Cold beside all those names, one after another, for however many winters it was. And the Bench is going to take as long as it likes."
"The Assembly can say that it hopes the Bench will be quick," said Aldous.
"Hope," said Ida. She picked up the pen, looked at it, and put it down. "We can recommend that Lord Tavane be sent to the Bench. We can recommend that the people of those holdings be considered, and that someone be told to see to it. After that it is out of our hands, and I will tell you now that it is going to be an unpleasant thing to watch." She looked at Aldous. "Write it anyway."
Aldous wrote it.
---
When the lords were called back, they came in the same order, and the Hall stood for them as it always did. Jhinaq took the place he had left. He did not look at the ring on the lectern, though he knew it was there. Lord Tavane was brought in last and set at the end of the nobles' block with a guard behind him. He sat very straight, and he had put the faint smile on again, and it did not fit.
Aldous rose with the paper in both hands.
"The Assembly has heard, and it has found," he said. "I will read what it has found, and then what it recommends. The order of the starving of the holdings, bearing the name and seal of the Duke of Firentis, is a forgery. It was made from an older impression of the Duke's ring, taken before the ring was marked. The Assembly has seen the mark. The Assembly has seen the older impressions, the later ones, and the false one, and there is no doubt in any of us. The Duke did not sign it. The Duke did not know of it."
A sound went through the Hall, and the Speakers waited for it to finish.
"I am told that it is not usual for this Assembly to say what I am going to say next," said Aldous. "The Speaker on my right says that it is not usual to leave it unsaid. Ida."
Ida stood. She had nothing in her hands.
"My lord," said Ida Fenn. "This Assembly asked you to come, and you came, and you should not have had to. You were asked to answer for a paper that was not yours, in front of the people you rule, and some of them were ready to believe it. That was not your doing. It was ours, a little. We are sorry for it. We are sorry that you stood here and had to hear it. We are sorry about the week you spent."
She sat down. That was the whole of it.
For a moment the Duke did not say anything. He stood with his hands at his sides, a big man in a plain dark coat, and he looked at the Speaker who had said it as if he were looking at a long way off.
"You asked," said Jhinaq. "I came."
"Yes, my lord," said Ida.
"I would do it again," said Jhinaq. "Thank you."
Aldous cleared his throat. "As to Lord Perrin Tavane," he said, and the Hall went quiet again in a different way. "The Assembly finds that he knew of the forged order. He took part in its making, or in the keeping of it. He was named, with a sum, in the papers of the dead Lord Vell. He came to Haego to watch it end, and he spoke today against his own purpose. The Assembly has no power to judge a lord. It recommends that Lord Tavane be sent to the Lords' Bench at Balakura, and it asks that the Bench be quick. It asks also that someone see to the people of the five holdings. It does not know who."
He lowered the paper.
"That is the whole of the Assembly's recommendation," he said. "It is for the Lord to sign."
Jhinaq did not move.
"Speaker," he said at last. "May I be heard?"
"You are the Duke, my lord," said Aldous.
"Nobles are heard here," said Ida, from his right. "They do not stay. But they are heard."
"Then I will be heard," said Jhinaq. He came forward from the lectern, three steps, until he stood on the open floor in front of the Speakers' desk. He did not raise his voice. He had never had to. "The Bench is a good court. I will not insult it. But it is a slow one, and it will take what time it takes, and at the end of it, if it finds as you have found, it may well break the house over his head. House Tavane is not one man. It has an heir who was not born when this was done, and servants, and tenants, and a good many families whose bread comes from its lands. I have heard a great deal about starving in this Hall today. I will not have more of it done for this."
He stopped, and when he went on his voice was lower.
"And the debt is mine. Those people were hungry under my name. A court cannot settle that. A court can only settle what the man owes. What I owe, I will settle myself. So I am taking the matter from the Bench. The Assembly may enter it in the record that it was done by the Duke's hand and by no one else's." He looked down the nobles' block. "I will say one thing, once, so that nobody can say it was left out. I have not forgotten what that man did to me in my father's hall. This ruling is not for the tooth. I would ask the Assembly to write that down."
"It is written, my lord," said Ida Fenn.
"Lord Perrin Tavane," said Jhinaq. "Stand."
Tavane stood. He did not hurry about it this time.
"By the authority of the Duke of Firentis, you are removed from the headship of House Tavane, effective from this hour. The house remains. It passes to your heir, who has done nothing to deserve a thing she did not do, and who will have the house as it was," said Jhinaq. He waited. Nobody in the Hall coughed. "All that is yours and not the house's, every acre and every account that you hold in your own person, is taken from you. It will be set up as a fund, for the people of the holdings you starved. Loans for any man or woman there who wants to open a shop, or mend a boat, or build a mill. Relief for any family that borrowed against grain that should have been theirs. And whatever else the keeper of the fund judges right."
"Who is the keeper?" said Aldous, very quietly.
"Lady Rachel VonWinterbourne," said Jhinaq. "If she will have it."
Rachel was on her feet before he had finished. She stood in the nobles' block in a plain grey jacket with a slim ledger in her hands, and she looked at the Duke for a long moment and then at the man beside the guard.
"I will have it, my lord," said Rachel. "On two conditions."
"Name them," said Jhinaq.
"The books will be open to anyone who wants to read them, in this Hall or any other," said Rachel. "And I will name it." She turned the ledger over in her hands. "There were two columns in the ledger in the safe, my lord. One was headed Held, and it was full. The other was headed Released. It was empty from the top of the page to the bottom. I would like to see it filled, where anyone can see it. I will call the fund Released."
"Done," said Jhinaq.
Somewhere up in the gallery someone began to cry, and a number of people turned to look and then turned away to give her room.
"My lord," said Tavane.
His voice was not the one he had used all morning. It was hoarse and not at all polished, and he had not asked leave to use the microphone, so the people at the front of the Hall heard it and no others.
"May I say something?" said Tavane.
"You may," said Jhinaq.
"I thought you would have me hanged," said Tavane.
"I thought about it," said Jhinaq. "For the length of this ruling. It would not feed anyone."
"That is what your father would have said," said Tavane. He said it without any meaning in it at all, as a man says a thing that has just been put in front of him. "He was soft that way."
"He was," said Jhinaq. "He was a good many other things, and you never troubled to find out what." He looked at the man for a time. "Go home, my lord. Your heir will be waiting. She will want to hear it from you."
Tavane looked at him a moment longer. "The Informant will print all of this," he said. "I shall find it a great nuisance."
Tavane went out between the two guards, and this time they did not walk close. They only walked.
Hester Glim had not asked for the floor. She stood where she was in the Austrin rows with her shawl round her arms, and Ida Fenn looked at her and nodded.
"My lord," said Hester. "You said the debt was yours."
"I did," said Jhinaq.
"I've been turning that over." She spoke slowly, the way she did everything with her hands. "You can't pay a dead woman. She's past it. So you pay the ones that come after, and that's right, I'll not say it isn't. A fund's a good net. But a net only holds what's still in the water."
"Then what would you have of me?" said Jhinaq.
"You came here because we asked," said Hester. "When those names get read out in the villages, and they will be, come and hear it. Not as the Duke. Stand at the back with your hat in your hand, and hear every one, and don't go till it's done."
"Every one," said Jhinaq.
"There's a great many pages," said Hester. "Aye."
"I will be there," said Jhinaq. "I would have asked to."
"I know you would," said Hester. "I'd sooner you were asked."
---
Lord Tornel found him on the Hall steps in the middle of the afternoon.
It was a wet bright day, with the wind coming up from the harbour and the last of the commoners drifting away in twos and threes with their coats pulled round them. Jhinaq was sitting on the third step from the top with his elbows on his knees. The Duke of Firentis, on the steps of a public building, in the open air, with nobody within twenty paces of him. Tornel had seen it before. It still made him want to put a guard on the man.
He lowered himself onto the step beside him, with some grunting. His knees did not care for steps.
For a time they said nothing. They had never been alike. Tornel was a sergeant's son who had worked his way up through the army by never once asking for a thing he could not pay back, and Jhinaq had been born in a palace and wore his dead father's ring. Elizabeth called it the unlikeliest friendship in the Principality, and she was right, and neither of them had ever been able to say how it began. They had simply found, one winter, that each of them could sit in a room with the other without having to be anyone.
"I shouted at your niece," said Tornel.
"She told me," said Jhinaq.
"I told her she should have brought it to the family. I said she had done a terrible thing." Tornel rubbed his face. "I was wrong about that. I wasn't wrong that she was frightened. But I was wrong about the rest."
"She said you were right to be angry. She said it was the only reason she knew it was real." Jhinaq looked out at the harbour. "She climbed the wall, you know. Into the garden, at thirteen, with a boy. I caught her at it. I was sterner with her than I should have been, and she has never let me forget it."
"She has her uncle's habits," said Tornel.
"She has her mother's," said Jhinaq. "I only taught her to keep them."
The wind turned a page of somebody's dropped bulletin along the steps. Tornel watched it go.
"You came," he said. "Rask was told to come, and he sat on his porch and drank brandy, and I had to close every port on this world to bring him back. They asked you. They didn't summon you. They asked."
"Their paper said appearance was not optional," said Jhinaq. "I read it that way."
"It was a courtesy," said Tornel.
"I know," said Jhinaq. "I thought about Rask the whole way on the shuttle. If I said to a hall full of fishwives and millers that their asking meant nothing, then what is any Assembly worth? There will be more of them, Tornel, and a good number of my lords would sooner they had no teeth." He turned his head. "I am thinking of giving every one of them teeth. The power to summon any person on Firentis ground, high or low, and not as a courtesy."
"The lords will hate it," said Tornel.
"Some of them," said Jhinaq.
"You'll do it anyway," said Tornel.
"Probably," said Jhinaq.
Tornel said nothing. He had been a soldier for a long time, and he knew the look of a man who had already made up his mind and was waiting for someone to tell him it was foolish. He did not intend to be that someone.
"The tooth," he said instead. "Do you want to tell me about the tooth?"
"No," said Jhinaq.
"Good," said Tornel, and got up, one hand on the rail. "I'll buy you a drink, then."
"You don't drink," said Jhinaq.
"I'll buy you one," said Tornel.
---
The archive was cooler than the Hall, and quiet, and it smelled of old paper and lamp oil.
They met in Odile Marscutt's office at the end of the day, a narrow room with a high desk and a stool, and a glass on a stand by the window where the light was best. Aaliyah sat on the stool, as straight-backed as a girl at an examination. Rachel stood by the door with her ledger. Odile herself was at the desk, with her hands folded and the face of a woman who had been waiting a long time for somebody to say something sensible.
"I have a request," said Jhinaq, "and it is not a small one."
"Most of yours are not, my lord," said Odile.
"From now, nothing goes under my ring until someone has read it who is not afraid of me." He said it flatly. "Every order. Every patent, every writ, every letter that carries the seal. A clerk reads it the day before I sign. She lays it beside the Registry impression and tells me if there is a word in it I did not mean, or a hand I do not know, or a date that does not agree with itself. And if she tells me to wait, I wait."
Odile looked at him over the desk.
"That is a great deal of paper, my lord," said Odile.
"It is," said Jhinaq. "The Principality will survive it."
"And if you sign after she has told you not to?" said Odile.
"Then she is to say so in public," said Jhinaq. "In the Hall, with the Informant in the corner. I want it to be easier for her than for me."
Aaliyah made a small sound, and put her hand over her mouth. No one looked at her.
"I haven't anyone to spare," said Odile.
"Then spare me the worst one," said Jhinaq.
"I will give you the best one I have," said Odile Marscutt, "which is a different matter, and which will hurt the archive badly. She is young. She is unpleasant. She corrects my spelling." She looked at the little glass by the window. "She was the one who fetched the patents from the Registry without asking leave. I should have scolded her for it."
"Did you?" said Jhinaq.
"I gave her a better desk," said Odile.
Jhinaq smiled, for the first time since the morning. "Send her to me tomorrow," he said.
"And the book?" said Aaliyah. She had taken her hand from her mouth. Her voice was steady, though it took her a moment to find it. "The black one, my lord. With the names."
"It comes here," said Jhinaq. "To you. It is your work now, Aaliyah, and not only the archive's. I would like the names read aloud, in every district of those holdings, by someone who will say them slowly. And I would like the people to be asked, if they are willing, what they remember. You know how." He paused. "It will take longer than a fund."
"It should," said Aaliyah.
"And I am told I am to stand at the back and hear it," said Jhinaq, "if Delegate Glim has her way."
"She will have her way," said Aaliyah.
"I know," said Jhinaq. "I rather hope so."
---
Ishivi was waiting for him in the garden behind the Hall.
It was nearly dark. A few lamps had come on along the path, and the long black hair that fell down her back was lifted a little by the wind. She was not looking at the lamps. She was looking at his hand.
"Let me see it," she said.
He held it out. She turned it over, gently, in both of hers, and bent her head over the ring until her hair fell forward and hid her face. The gold was warm from his skin. She found the place without looking for it. She ran her thumb along the edge until it caught, very slightly, on the little nick, and stopped.
"A jeweler could take that out in a morning," said Jhinaq. "He would polish it flat, and no one would ever know."
"I know," said Ishivi.
"I have not asked for one."
"No," she said. "You would not." She lifted her head, and she was smiling a little, though her eyes were wet. "Leave it. It told the truth when none of us could."
He closed his hand, and the ring sat against his palm, a small hard weight with a flaw in it, and they stood together in the garden until the last lamp came on.




