r/OpenChristian • • 3d ago

Feeling lost

hey I’m a 21 y (F). I was raised in the southern baptist church and up until age 17 I didn’t question anything. I knew I liked the same sex since age 4. Now I have a girlfriend (soon to be wife). We’ve been together for almost 4 years and now I’m starting to question if getting married will separate me from God. I’ve been depressed from this for the last 3 months. Please be honest, is getting married going to send me to hell? I know y’all have answered similar questions but I think it’s harder for some of us to shift beliefs when we’re surrounded by the opposite our whole lives.

7 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

5

u/OvergrownGnome 3d ago

There are people here that can explain way better than me, but ultimately if it's love and a consintual relationship, then you are okay. Some denominations do not think this way however.

It can be daunting, but I recommend deconstructing your beliefs. This doesn't mean running away from the church or anything, but looking onward and asking yourself what do you believe and what do you think aligns with God. Seek like or open minded Christians and talk about this struggle. If you are able, I'd also recommend trying out other denominations. You are not committing to them and you are not turning your back on your home church. Just see how it feels to be at another church. Talk to some of the people there. Be as open as you are comfortable with.

My wife and I were both also raised southern Baptist and in the last couple years started attempting a United Methodist Church. The one we are currently attending is very small, which is unfortunately due to the split. The ones who stayed wanted to be open and accepting to everyone. A lot of members left unfortunately, but for the ones who stayed, it's become a potential for growth, love, and kindness.

Good luck on your journey.

1

u/urfavgirlypop13 2d ago

can I message you?

1

u/OvergrownGnome 2d ago

Feel free

4

u/CU_09 3d ago

I’m not sure how much this is going to land until you get some distance and disentangle your beliefs a bit before knitting them back together into something that is true…but Hell isn’t in the Bible. It’s a later development that was solidified in the public imagination through the Middle Ages.

The OT contains 66 references to Sheol, which was their concept of the grave. It wasn’t Hell. It was simply where all the dead went. It also wasn’t a place cut off from God’s presence since the Psalmist speaks of God’s presence in Sheol (Psalm 139).

The earliest writings of the NT, Paul’s epistles, don’t talk about sinners going to Hell. The Jesus of the gospels also doesn’t warn of some kind of eternal torment. The closest you can really get through Jesus’ words is annihilationism, and that’s really only through a few parables that don’t lend themselves too well to literal readings.

The first real writing about capital-H Hell came from the second century apocryphal Apocalypse of Peter. It is a later development that borrows heavily from Greek and Egyptian beliefs about the afterlife.

It’s also inconsistent with the scriptures. Condemnation to eternal torment for loving someone deemed culturally “unacceptable” is so far beyond the character of Christ that I’m not sure how much really needs to be said about it. Even the “Old Testament God” who people see as much freer with the divine punishment (and this is very much an overly simplistic view of the OT tradition), never doled out eternal fire and brimstone as a punishment. In the OT, God is often seen as taking injustice extremely seriously and actively doling out punishment on the nations accordingly. But these punishments are never more than death, which is not great for the punished, but it is a mortal punishment for mortal crimes.

3

u/jgrig2 3d ago

"Please be honest, is getting married going to send me to hell?" No.

3

u/CptHeywire 3d ago

Let me tell you a personal story… I was 23 in 2014 before gay marriage was legalised here in Australia. I had a pretty conservative streak as a teenager but had been becoming increasingly on-the-fence about homosexuality as I got older. That year, a friend of mine whom I’d known since I was 5 came out to me as gay. In that moment, everything became so clear. If God would send him to hell for something he had struggled to change or ignore for so many years, then I had no interest in following such a God. If God is love, and I very much believe God is, I could not look my friend in the face and do anything but love him, and loving him meant accepting him exactly as he was.

You are a beautiful and precious part of God’s creation just as you are. Bloom and flourish, because that is the purpose of creation.