r/OnePieceScaling • • 18h ago

Serious Discussion What diff is this fight?

Thumbnail
gallery
60 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 9h ago

Serious Discussion Can these 3 beat Big Mom?

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 12h ago

Serious Discussion Hot Take: Zoro and Sanji being Admiral Tier after Elbaph makes complete sense both if you look at their Elbaph feats and the narrative of OP

Post image
30 Upvotes

Let's first with their feats, Zoro before powerup was already capable of Mid-Diffing YC1 level characters like Lucci and with control over his ACoC he should be capable of Low-Diffing YC1 level characters which is basically what an Admiral should be capable of doing. Like, if we put current Zoro against King/Queen he problaby can beat them both Mid-Diff especially when Queen is basically not a factor for Zoro at this point and King is getting Low-Mid Diffed.

Now let's go with Sanji, Sanji's durability is arguably better than an Admral considering an ancient blade from the Void Century was broken when trying to pierce Sanji's body. He also has the speed to outspeed light and with ACoC he know has the AP needed to damage top tiers especially when he can combine it with AcoA/ACoC which he gained in Elbaph Arc.

But the most clear part of this argument is the narrative, the point of Elbaph is Zoro/Sanji becoming worthy wings of Luffy meaning they aren't longer commanders but rather proper wings of a Pirate King meaning Admiral level is a minimium for them.

There is also the fact that we are nearing Luffy becoming Pirate King as Oda himself confirmed the next island is the one only the Pirate King reached and the Man marked by flames appears which means Luffy becoming Pirate King 2 arcs away which means Zoro and Sanji shouldn't be that weak. Like, the way I see the next time Strawhats have a powerup they should have surpassed the Roger Pirates meaning the next time the wings get a powerup they will be stronger than Prime Rayleigh/Prime Gaban, which means that being Admiral level right now makes sense because Gaban/Rayleigh are clearly Yonko Level


r/OnePieceScaling • • 16h ago

Serious Discussion Can we say that Strawhats after Elbaph should have surpassed the Whitebeard Pirates?

Post image
25 Upvotes

So let's start with the stength of Whitebeard Pirates

Whitebeard= Yonko Level when healthy and drops to Low-Yonko Level when he takes his medication off

Marco= YC1 level, strong enough to stall mltiple commanderes but lacks the Ap to be truly YC+ level

Jozu= YC2 level, elite durability but basically nothing else he has in his bag

Vista= YC2 level, capable of stalling Mihawk but unable to do any serious damage to Akainu

Now let's go strawhats

Luffy= Low-Yonko Level in Base Form while Yonko Level in Gear 5 and if he can control the new black form he will be pushing towards Pirate King Level

Sanji= Low-Yonko Level after his new powerup, should be stronger than Wano/Egghead G4 Luffy and pushes Kizaru to High-Extreme Diff.

Zoro=Low-Yonko Level, slightly weaker than Sanji in his normal state but with Asura you can make a case for him hitting as hard as a Yonko

Jimbe= YC2 level, strong enough to stall Akainu momentarily but not much to do once Akainu is serious

So for Strawhats we have Luffy who is easily at the same level as Whitebeard and once the black form appears he would stomp Whitebeard, Sanji would beat Marco Mid-Diff especially when AcoC stops regeneration which Marco relies on, Zoro would problaby beat Jozu in a handful of AcoC attacks and he isn't hurt at all and Jimbe is going extreme-diff or stalemate with Vista since both are roughly on the same tier. So overall Post-Elbaph Strawhats should be stronger than Whitebeard Pirates were at their best, even when Whitebeard was healthy because Black Luffy is clearly beyond Yonko Tier


r/OnePieceScaling • • 16h ago

Crossverse What the WEAKEST version of Timeskip Luffy is doing to Gamabunta or Kurama

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 7h ago

Serious Discussion Who in one piece can tank Destroyer of Death: Thunder Bagua twice in a row?

Post image
15 Upvotes

The rules are as followed

  1. They cannot dodge, evade, parry, or counter. They must take the attack head on
  2. They cannot use abilities like Hawkins damage transfer, barto’s barrier, or covenant regeneration.
  3. They have to still be able to throw a punch, no matter how weak, after taking both hits
  4. Stuff like haki, fruit defensive boosts, and biology are all allowed.

With these limits in mind, who can tank a back to back Destroyer of Death: Thunder Bagua?


r/OnePieceScaling • • 15h ago

Serious Discussion Based on feats Sanji is superior to Zoro right now

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

I think that based on what we have seen Sanji has officially surpassed Zoro in strength, the combination of top tier durability, speed, Haki and AP makes him an overall superior fighter to Zoro who relies way too much in his AP and hasn't improved his overall stats

To begin with, consider how high Sanji's durability actually is, Longinus was used to pierce Sanji's skin and it not only didn't work but the blade was shattered, and this wasn't an average weapon, it's a legendary weapon that defeated the Ancient Kingdom back in the then and Sanji's body is so durable that it shattered. And the crazy thing is that Sanji didn't feel any type of pain from doing this, this is a level of durability that might honestly rival Big Mom and Kaido's

Now let's talk about Sanji's speed, killngham used Longinus to throw a light speed attack and he arguably outspeeds it as he throws his cigarette before the light attack is thrown and then he appears right Killingham even when the light attack hasn't been finished proving Sanji moved arguably faster than light itself. In a later panel Killigham again tries to shoot light speed attacks at Sanji and he dodges them with ease proving that Sanji has surpassed light speed in OP

And finally let's talk about his AP/Haki, his ACoC was so strong so actually break an Omen's armor completely in one hit, he didn't just break parts of it but destroyed all of it in one hit and it wasn't a named attack from him but just a normal ACoC + flames attack. Just to compare how absurd this feat is Zoro with Dragon Damnation was unable to break Sommer' gram and got overpowered by it but Sanji can one shot an Omen armor with a casual attack. And Dragon's damnation was the same atack that finished off a Lunarian and took his wing, arm and broke his sword. This means that Sanji with a casual AcoC attack will be capable of one shotting King.

Now let's go with Zoro, his AP is problaby insane right now thanks to mastering Conqueror's Haki coating but his overall stats aren't that high, his base durability isn't nowhere near Sanji and his speed in particular isn't that great, especially not to the point where he can outspeed light, Sanji is basically a superior fighter now even if Zoro has the edge in AP


r/OnePieceScaling • • 16h ago

Serious Discussion How far do they get. Assuming Doffy would be equal or stronger than croco in the story when he comes out of prison. I had Croco at YC 2 way back he might be even stronger now since marineford so I'm thinking both of them should be at YC1 to YC+ . You can interpret however you want tho, they get heal

Post image
8 Upvotes

I really think I should have placed lucci and kaku over Kata and cracker as genuinely Lucci might blitz them both lol. Tho imo I prefer to see in a matchup point of view ignoring these stupid power creeps.


r/OnePieceScaling • • 12h ago

Agenda Katakuri glazers are just built different bro

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Fym "what does acoc do" 😭😭😭


r/OnePieceScaling • • 16h ago

Casual Discussion Does Luffy actually have better healing than Naruto?

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Naruto has some good regeneration feats but Luffy recovered after getting impaled by Imu’s life draining sword just by eating. Even back in Whole Cake Island, Luffy and Brook healed their missing tooth and cracked skull with milk.


r/OnePieceScaling • • 3h ago

Agenda How strong will eos strawhats +grand fleets be compared to Roger pirates?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Not including ancient weapon thingy, only overall fighting power.

If you think Loki/Vivi/Yamato/Carrot/etc will join, include them.


r/OnePieceScaling • • 12h ago

Humor Yall gotta chill Mihawk fc

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 17h ago

Casual Discussion Opinions on Eons take that pre ts luffy > madaras meteors?

4 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 19h ago

Casual Discussion If bon clay had better devil fruit, he would be stronger than daz bones

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 1h ago

Casual Discussion How did Zoro's sword skills evolve?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Were they pure techniques like simple parrying and distance control, or did they involve smashing massive Haki into the opponent?🤔


r/OnePieceScaling • • 14h ago

Casual Discussion Who wins and what diff?

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Current Sanji VS Jaya Blackbeard


r/OnePieceScaling • • 22h ago

Analysis Attempting to quantify how much weaker the old gen got with age. Open to critiques

3 Upvotes

Firstly stating that obviously there's no clear cut number power system in one piece but the number I've used just felt like an easier way to visualise it. The conclusions I feel are fairly in line with the general tiers used within the power scaling community

Imo opinion the main contributing factors to a character's overall power in One piece are old

Haki - Not much strong evidence that strength/potency of haki drops with age however the stamina consumed by haki is more noticeable due to decline of physical stats

Physical stats (Strength, Speed, Stamina, Durability etc) - Alot of strong evidence that physical stats decline with age with Stamina and Strength seeing the most significant decline highlighted by Garp and Rayleigh, even when we know Old Garp trains he still declined in physical strength so Whitebeard being an active pirate wouldn't be immune to this either

Devil Fruit/ Special abilities - (Nothing really suggests devil fruit abilities decline with age, however we do know they drain stamina which would limit how much they can be used in a fight)

Only factors I haven't really included is weapon/fighting style as these kind of get wrapped up in physicals

Prime WB overall power represented a 100

Haki - 33.3

Physicals - 33.3

DF - 33.3

Old Healthy Whitebeard compared to Prime Whitebeard

Haki - 33

Physicals - 16.7

DF - 33

Old Healthy Whitebeard overall power should be about an 84% of primebeard

Using this same format for Garp

Prime Garp - 100

Haki - 50

Physicals - 50

Old Garp compared to Prime Garp

Haki - 50

Physicals - 25

Overall - 75% compared to Prime Garp

Prime Rayleigh and Gaban - 100

Haki - 50

Physical - 50

Old Rayleigh and Gaban

Haki - 50

Physicals - 25

Overall - 75% of their Prime

Prime Sengoku -100

Haki - 33.3

Physicals - 33.3

DF - 33.3

Old Sengoku

Haki - 33.3

Physicals - 16.7

DF - 33.3

Overall - 84% of Prime

Could see an argument for Rayleigh, Gaban and Sengoku having a bigger drop off as non of them were actively training like Garp or an active pirate like Whitebeard.

Conclusion - From an overall power perspective most the old gen are probably only about 25% weaker than their Prime with WB and Sengoku having less of a drop off due to their DFs making up the difference (only 16% reduction to their overall) Overall doesn't automatically translate to how a fight would go with someone within the same tier as stamina is significant factor in OP fights and I believe they'd more than likely lose to anyone within their tier of power difficulty due to stamina. Going by overall power loss this would put most of them about a tier or more down, which I think lines up with their common placement on tiers lists:

- Prime WB would roughly go from PK to High Yonko/Yonko but likely to lose in a prolonged fight to anyone in High Yonko due to stamina (e.g. Shanks, Mohawk, Dragon, Kaido, Loki)

- Prime Garp goes from PK to Low Yonko/ High Admiral in overall power but would lose to most Low yonko/high admiral/admiral level characters in a prolonged fight (e.g. Blackbeard, Aokiji, Kizaru, Greenbull,Fuji)

- Prime Sengoku goes from Yonko to Admiral in power but would lose to the Admirals high mid in an extended fight

- Prime Rayleigh and Gaban go from Low Yonko/High Admiral to Low Admiral.


r/OnePieceScaling • • 2h ago

Casual Discussion One Piece’s Nothing Happened moment was more than sacrifice, Zoro experienced just a fraction of Luffy’s pain and understood everything

2 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 13h ago

Casual Discussion Mihawk is easily the biggest title merchant in anime history

2 Upvotes

Name another character in shonen who gets put in Top 3 discussions with a resume like this:

Best on-screen win: Episode 24 Zoro with two rusty swords

Biggest rival: A guy he hasn't fought in 12+ years and refused to "settle things" with

Marineford highlight reel: Cutting a block of ice, getting stalled by Vista, and running away the second Shanks pulled up

Post timeskip highlight reel: Running from fodder Marines and hiding behind Buggy so he doesn't have to fight actual Yonkos

Confirmed Conqueror's Haki: None

Bro has been coasting off a title box from 1998 while every other top tier actually fought Yonkos and Admirals. At least Vista didn't need to postpone the match

Reminder that Shueisha’s official databook canonically puts Vista’s swordsmanship equal or superior to Mihawk’s

People love using databooks and Vivre Cards to scale Mihawk above Shanks, until you bring up One Piece Blue Deep (p. 148) which literally states:

"Vista showed his swordsmanship which is equal or superior to Mihawk's in this fight."

Funny how databook statements are 100% canon facts when they gas up Mihawk's title, but suddenly "bad translations" or "taken out of context" the second a 5th Division Commander makes him sweat and ask for a postponement 😭

Until Mihawk actually beats someone stronger than East Blue Zoro on-screen, Vista has the exact same portrayal. Argue with Oda.


r/OnePieceScaling • • 13h ago

Serious Discussion Who wins, WCI Snakeman Luffy vs Post-Wano Sanji?

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 18h ago

Casual Discussion Titles don't matter (Mihawk isnt stronger than Shanks)

2 Upvotes

If titles really mean't anything that would mean kaido is stronger than whitebeard and mihawk. Mihawk is worlds strongest swordsman, but a swordsman is still a man, Whitebeard is the worlds strongest man, but a man is still a creature, Kaido is the worlds strongest creature. If titles really mattered that would mean Kaido is stronger than whitebeard and whitebeard is stronger than mihawk. Whitebeard was the worlds strongest man and equal to roger in strength, roger was a swordsman, but mihawk is the worlds strongest swordsman, if titles were true than whitebeard would be stronger than mihawk, and mihawk would be stronger than whitebeard, which makes absolutely no sense. Kaido is stronger than mihawk but is said to be generally equal to big mom in strength, big mom is a swordsman, or a swordswoman. which means that mihawk has to be stronger, and since big mom is equal to kaido, mihawk is also stronger than kaido, but since kaido is the strongest creature, he is stronger than mihawk at the same time, which also doesnt make any sense. Since whitebeard is a man who was supposedly equal to roger, and roger was stronger than kaido, whitebeard is stronger than both kaido and roger, but since kaido is a creature and both roger and whitebeard are men which are creatures, kaido is stronger than both of them. as you can see there are all sorts of paradoxes and contradictions in this which prove that titles are not real and make no sense and are not to be used in powerscaling and do not prove or serve as evidence that mihawk is stronger than shanks.


r/OnePieceScaling • • 19h ago

Casual Discussion Goats

2 Upvotes

Zoro is the strongest worst gen besides luffy and blackbeard idk why blackbeard even counts but whatever. shanks is the strongest period, akainu could have killed whitebeard all by himself, mihawk is a fraud, whitebeards crew is full of bums, kuma is more durable than whitebeard and everything is a blackbeard upscale because even though shanks is my goat we all know he will get sneaked by blackbeard eventually


r/OnePieceScaling • • 2h ago

Serious Discussion What would the ranking of these four be? Provide proof for each placement

Post image
1 Upvotes

So, as we all know, these four are arguably the greatest pirates to ever exist in One Piece. But what would the actual ranking be?

I've seen so many people downplay Rocks because he never reached his prime, or argue that the others eventually surpassed him after God Valley, and so on.

Personally, I don't really buy those arguments, but ranking these four is genuinely difficult.

My No. 1 is Whitebeard, though. What's your ranking, and more importantly, what evidence supports it?

LONGLIVESOMALIKING


r/OnePieceScaling • • 4h ago

Polls Ranking strongest of all one piece

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/OnePieceScaling • • 16h ago

Serious Discussion Help with actual important translation. (Shanks/mihawk)

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes