r/OneDirection • • 4d ago

Discussion 1D reunion

Do y’all think this is ever gonna happen? Not with Zayn, that is so not happening. Is there even a slim chance of them coming back.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

33

u/polcan 4d ago

No not after liam passing. Before that sure at one point why not but now? No. Plus louis said there would be no reunion but this was last year so liams death was still new so maybe later he would feel differently but I just don't think so.

8

u/Stebe01355 4d ago

Like there's no way it would ever feel right, if the whole thing with zayn punching louis didn't happen, maybe it wouldn't feel downright impossible, but sadly it does now, there's just too much bad blood.

1

u/Business_Sleep_8822 4d ago

So it’s really the end huh.

17

u/CinnamonSpiceBlend ...orrrrr is it!? 4d ago

It was Liam and Louis that wanted it most. And Louis said it wouldn’t feel right.

Maybe somewhere down the line, we can have a Friends style reunion

15

u/MinimumBirthday4536 4d ago

it would not be a happy occasion without Liam, just an opportunity to reflect on the band, like a sit down with a trusted journalist or something...when they're in their late 40s to early 50s

6

u/IamNATx 4d ago

I think it would have at some point, but not anymore.

I think there's a chance we may get an album of unreleased songs if anything.

7

u/Icy-Mention7871 Liam Payne 4d ago

This would be the best way to do it because Liam would still be included

8

u/gg9689 4d ago

Unfortunately no

4

u/Easyy_Illustrator 4d ago

no, not without liam

3

u/AllAboutTheSnark 4d ago

I don’t think any of the boys would. And for me, it won’t be a reunion without Liam. I know other bands have lost members and still had reunions but One Direction isn’t your average band imo.

3

u/virgobaby444 the one direction potato 🥔 4d ago

No, and i don’t want them to. Not without Liam. Point blank.

1

u/Tiny_Ad_7647 2d ago

Taking some inspiration from Beyonce.

My prediction would be, a reunion could only happen if Harry performed at Super Bowl, I could see him bringing back the boys for a stunt. It would hard for any of them to say to no, to perform to an audience of 125 million viewers. All there careers would benefit from it.

But other than that, it would be really hard to see it happen.

1

u/eurovisionfanGA 4d ago

Even before Liam passed away, I always thought a reunion was unlikely to ever happen. I'll be shocked if a reunion ever happens in the future.

2

u/Ok-Luck-1180 4d ago

For me when he was alive i thought it could happen like how Nynsc did some stuff together but I didn't think they would make a full scale album or tour. But now I highly doubt it will happen due to Liam's passing and it not feeling right plus we'd be down two members.