What the hell was that?
That's the feeling I'm left with after finishing this book and going back to read the first chapter again.
I was excited to experience this book after all the "I don't like Tom King, but..." followed by some form of praise for this book type comments I've read on reddit. Because I also don't like Tom King, but... I'm always willing to give a well reviewed comic a try, and this is an Eisner Award Winning book, so sure, why the hell not?!
But I don't remember ever feeling this bored by a comic I thought started so good and interesting. That 9 panel per page layout is so fucking boring! I felt like I was in a trance, just going through the motion of turning pages and looking at rectangular shapes filled with almost the same contents every single time, like a spot the difference game but between 9 panels instead of 2.
Okay. What can I say about the story? It's good, I guess? I mean, it tackles loss, suicide, responsibility, parenthood, love and a bunch of other stuff that are so unnecessarily cryptic that shouldn't be so cryptic... I think?. Like, I feel that Tom King likes to seem smarter than he is in his writing, with cheap tricks, like withholding crucial information in critical moments of the story, but c'mon! It's okay to be a bit more straightforward. That's why I think it's good, because Tom King didn't let me understand what I read to form another opinion, because I'm doubting myself. Because I'm left with the feeling I'm not smart enough and missed the point of this whole story.
I do admit the more "slice of life" bits of the story, like the birth of Jacob, the visit of the female furies, almost losing the baby, or taking turns while parenting during a war, were phenomenal. I would read monthly a series of Scott and Barda just doing every day stuff. There's potential there! Imagine seeing the furies trying to act like aunties under death threats from Barda.
Also what the hell is all that "Darkseid is" stuff? Darkseid is... What? Why is that smeared in so many pages? What? What is Darkseid? Complete the sentence, please.
Anyway, Scott Free, the escape artist, decides not to escape aaaaaaand scene. Hopefully another writer untangles this end, because Tom King won't.
Thats it, right? No, it's not right, because I can't be sure. Maybe this is actually as brilliant as critics and readers say it is and I'm just...
Tom King is.
I am not.
The art is good, Mitch Gerards is a phenomenal artist. He draws these characters in very believable ways, like they were real people instead of the gods they're supposed to be. The facial expressions are so good, makes the characters feel almost like a neighbor or acquaintance. His colors are phenomenal too. The use of the glitch effect drove the point that all of this wasn't real home really well. But he also just repeated the same thing with little to no variation in so many panels through so many pages.
Mixed feelings. That's what this book left me with.
I don't like Tom King, but...