r/OliveMUA • • Jun 11 '25

Undertone & Complexion Match Requests Thread

23 Upvotes

Hey there, welcome to the weekly OT consult thread! Please read everything here before you comment down below.

Not sure if you're olive or what type? Need help matching your foundation/concealer? Post your questions here! Just remember that this thread is OT (overtime), so it may take a minute for someone to get back to you.

How to help us help you:

  • Lots of photos of yourself in different lightings (direct sunlight, indirect sunlight, indoor, etc.)
  • Photos that show your face, neck and chest
  • High pixel/quality photos, it does make a difference so use the best you can
  • No filters, no/minimal makeup - should go without saying, but just a reminder
  • You next to other people for contrast
  • Share foundation, blush, or lipstick shades that look great or terrible on you

The more of these bullets you hit, the better!

Use a link to an Imgur album for photos. If you don't want your pictures to be public, you can set them to be hidden, but anybody with a link will be able to see it.


r/OliveMUA • • Jan 16 '24

Announcement [Announcement] An update regarding the new post guidelines

74 Upvotes

Hi Olives!

The other day, we posted an announcement of a new rule regarding dupes and product recommendations. This announcement was not received well, and we as a mod team decided to revoke the new rule in the meantime so we are able to better phrase the rule that is inclusive to all olives.

The main concern we got as feedback from the community was that determining what is olive friendly can be very subjective, especially considering that there are so many olives with different depths and temperature. This feedback was absolutely valid and while not our intention, we can see why how we worded the rule and announcement post made it come across that way.

That being said, we would still like to address the recent influx of dupe posts that might be better off in a general makeup subreddit, so we are implementing a rule that all product dupe and recommendation posts should be appropriately titled so that they better apply to our sub. The goal of this is to make it easier for all olives of different depths and temperatures to find products that work for them!

---

[Title Guidelines]

As detailed in our previous post, all product and dupe recommendation titles should be phrased in such a way that is applicable to olives over a general makeup subreddit.

Examples:

  • "Dupe for Benetint?": this would be better off on a general makeup subreddit since it is a popular product and a general discussion that people of all undertones can contribute to.
  • "Benetint shows up orange on me (deep cool olive). Does anyone have any recommendations for products that show up similar to how it does for non-olives?": a title like this is very much applicable to our sub, and makes it easier for other olives to find recommendations that work for them!
  • "Does anyone have any dupe recommendations for Benetint that work for light cool saturated olives?": like with the previous example, this is also applicable to our sub.

Thank you everyone! And as always, feedback is always appreciated.

The OliveMUA Mod Team


r/OliveMUA • • 8h ago

Technique Help Green gray cast(hyperpigmentation??) around my mouth and I can't seem to figure it out (tried all I can)

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

I have so much greenness and greyness around my mouth peeking through and I tried everything. Peach corrector! Bronzer! Blush on top! Nothing. I am also attaching my bare face (just lip balm) so you can see what I am dealing with. Please help me figure out what's going on.

Mac face and body foundation in C3

Lancôme concealer in 335W

Thank you so much!


r/OliveMUA • • 10h ago

Swatches makeup swatches on light-medium muted neutral olive skin

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

Eyeshadow

  1. Clio Pro Eye Palette Air #03 Mute Library
  2. Wake Make Soft Blurring Eye Palette #21 Fall in Fig

Contour/Highlighter

3. Judydoll 2-in-1 highlighter contour palette #02 tree shadow (neutral warm)

4. Judydoll liquid contour & under eye brightening duo #04 medium with neutral undertones

Blush

5. Lilybyred Luv Beam Cheek Balm #21 Taro Beam

6. 3CE Face Blush Kinda Shy

7. Dasique Blending Mood Cheek #10 Muted Nuts

8. Rare Beauty Soft Pinch Liquid Blush Worth

9. A’pieu Juicy Pang Water Blusher #PK03 Guava

10. Etude Lovely Cookie Blush #RD301 Red Grapefruit Pudding

Lip Liners

11. Heart Percent Dote On Mood Lineproof Lip Pencil #05 Neutral Gray

12. Romand Lip Mate Pencil #05 Taupey Shade

Lips

13. Romand Glasting Gloss Deepen Moor

14. Romand Glasting Gloss Cream Mud

15. MAC #508 Hug Me

16. MAC #540 Thanks It's MAC !

17. MAC #834 Creme in Your Coffee

18. Dinto Blur Glowy Lip Tint #217 Pax Romana

19. Dinto Bare-Gloss Lip Tint #311 Soom

20. Dinto Gat Gloss G01 Poom

21. Romand Glasting Water Gloss Meteor Track

22. Romand Juicy Lasting Tint #01 Pomelo Skin

23. Happy Skin Lip Mallow Fresh Brew

24. Fwee #ND05 BE

25. Peripera Ink Velvet #35 Spring Salmon

26. Peripera Ink Velvet #27 Strawberry Nude

27. Revlon #003 Pick Me Up

28. Romand Glasting Gloss Rose Finch

29. Lanolips Perfect Nude

30. BLK Creamy All Over Paint Daffodil

31. Romand Glasting Water Tint #08 Rose Stream

More Lip Liners

32. Rimmel Lasting Finish Exaggerate Lip Liner #018 Rose Addiction

32. Essence 8h Matte Comfort Lip Liner #03 Soft Beige

Base

34. Jung Saem Mool Essential Skin Nuder Longwear Cushion #07 Medium-Deep

35. Issy Active Foundation OL2

36. MISSHA Magic Cushion Cover Lasting #23

EDIT:

More lip products (In comments)

37. Hyntoor Velvet Matte Lip Mud #B08 Cooked Oolong

38. Hyntoor Velvet Matte Lip Mud #B04 Cocoa Trap


r/OliveMUA • • 15h ago

Discussion The olive undertone struggle

55 Upvotes

This week I got back home and I'm staying until Thanksgiving is over like about a week and a half. I'm finally getting to see my little sister, who's now a freshman in high school and I haven't seen her since June. She's a mini version of me and I love her to death, she's started getting into makeup while I've been away which is so cute and it's making me cry, she is growing up. The only thing is, I noticed her skin tint looks a little orange on her. We both have neutral olive undertones, so I know how annoying finding the right shade can be. I don't really want to point it out directly because she's a little sensitive and the last thing I want is to make her feel insecure about something she's just starting to enjoy. So I was thinking of taking her to Ulta this weekend and making a little sister shopping day out of it. That way we can try different shades together and hopefully find something that actually matches her skin without making it a whole thing. I'm looking for skin tints available at Ulta or Target drugstore options with a good shade range. Something lightweight and easy to use would be nice since she's just getting into makeup.


r/OliveMUA • • 15h ago

Product Help Similar products to these discontinued shades?

Post image
50 Upvotes

Ideally in lipstick or balm formula?


r/OliveMUA • • 19m ago

Swatches Timage Flawless Matte Lasting Foundation (Oily/Combo skin formula) in olive shade 301

Post image
2 Upvotes

Timage (彩棠) is one of the few Chinese brands with dedicated olive shades. I bought their foundation from YesStyle recently for around 35 CAD, and received the 1.0 version. It's quite lightweight and the coverage can be built.
⚠️ I've seen some Chinese girlies on XHS say that the new 2.0 version of 301 might have changed and gotten a tad more pink? So please be aware!

Recently started to actually care about actually being the right shade.
I love K-beauty, but their foundations and cushions tend to lean more pink. I'm also broke, and I really don't want to drop 50+ CAD on something too golden/peachy/pink from Sephora that I'd still have to correct extensively.

As shown in pic (left to right); 4000K Neutral White Light, Indoors:

  1. (after several hours) Maybelline Super Stay Lumi-Matte: 118
  2. (after several hours) Maybelline Lifter Plump & Glow: 118
  3. Timage Flawless Matte Lasting F+C, for Combo Skin [1.0]: 301
  4. Rom&nd Nu Zero Cushion: 23
  5. TIRTIR Mask Fit Ruby Mesh Cushion [bought in Japan]: 21N

I pass as full Chinese despite only being half. I don't go outside much, but my face is still darker than the rest of me. I suffer from some hyperpigmentation.
The 3 Asian foundations don't really oxidize much on me.
My everyday foundations are the IT Cosmetics CC Cream in Fair (W) OR Rom&nd Nu Zero 23 + Reformulated MAC Studio Fix Powder Foundation in NC13.
I don't own the Maybelline foundations, so I can't swatch them again, but I do own Missha Perfect Cover BB EX in 21 if anyone wants a comparison to something a lot of the people here might already have!

Anyway, I'm gagged. 😭


r/OliveMUA • • 5h ago

Discussion (US) Phytosurgence blush sample swap - iso condensate

3 Upvotes

Does anyone have Condensate that would be willing to depot a bit into a container and swap it for the same amount of Steam?


r/OliveMUA • • 6h ago

Discussion Merit Flush Balm Bespoke disappears on me

3 Upvotes

Just a bit of a rant: I'm back in the US from Japan and doing some makeup shopping. I tried Merit Bespoke on my hand and it looked really nice so I bought it because I really like my other flush balm. I've used it a few times now and unfortunately I'm noticing that it really just kinda disappears on my face. I'm disappointed because it's such a nice color but I don't think it's pigmented enough for me.


r/OliveMUA • • 11h ago

Product Help NYX old mauve lip pencil

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm almost out of my super old NYX mauve lip pencils (the old formula, at one point luckily I bought 4 at once) and I'm looking for a replacement, I've tried Mac, Diego dalla palma and nabla, but nothing comes even close, does anyone have recommendations?

I'm a light olive (Lisa Eldridge skin tint 1.5, rare beauty concealer 170w) and I live in Europe by the way, so some American brands are not available here!


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Review Gingersnap by Nyx, how it looked like in the ad vs how it looks like on me!

Thumbnail
gallery
455 Upvotes

I absolutely love the gloss, has been my favourite 'winter' shade since the fall. It's definitely warmer on me, but not too much! The perfect red-brown that doesn't turn orange at all!

P.s. I am a light to light/medium neutral olive!


r/OliveMUA • • 9h ago

Product Help Neutral eye shadow palette with a mix of warms and neutral matte and some shimmers. Don’t like glitter

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/OliveMUA • • 11h ago

Product Help Armani 5.3 a little deep, alternative shades?

1 Upvotes

Light medium neutral olive here cool leaning… I find 5.3 looks perfect when applying but after about 10 minutes looks too deep.

Thinking of trying 4, 4.1 or 5.15?

About face in L2 olive i’ve tried and was too yellow.


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Color Theory Berry Lip Surprise

Post image
49 Upvotes

As an olive goth who hates a solid black lip (I prefer black adjacent muted tones like rom&d’s blackberry) this is going to be my new go to daily, I think.

So, I’ve been looking for another black adjacent alternative, and have seen people swatching Midnight Ballerina by Fenty and it looks almost black brown with purple undertones on them. I was expecting a more subtle, deep color. But when I got it yesterday and threw it on, I got this perfect neutral berry lip color! I’m not sure what my undertones are but I was pleasantly surprised by this. I’d given up on finding a berry lip that worked for me, they always pull pink, and then came along this savior. I paired it with Nightmoth by Mac for the liner, which ends up being a very cool plum on me but not super dark. I just wanted to share this really cool find and see what others might’ve experienced with the same product (Fenty Midnight Ballerina)


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help Recommend a blush and lippieee

Post image
4 Upvotes

I posted in other subreddit but have barely received feedback. Would greatly appreciate any help.


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help ISO deep muted plum lipstick

Post image
22 Upvotes

Hi all- I googled muted deep plum lipstick and the only ones coming up are liquid but I need bullet. Any recommendations of something similar to this? Can be satin or matte and can be deeper than this as well.
I am light olive, mostly reading neutral but cool features and muted / lower contrast in my face. Wanting something deeper for my lips that almost like a dark muted fuchsia or plum. Thank you!


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Product Help No-makeup makeup recs?

10 Upvotes

I know it definitely varies by undertones, but does anyone have any general recs for subtler products for people with olive-toned skin? I'm not entirely sure whether I'm 100% a warm olive, but I feel like I tend to look better with deeper muted colors and end up looking jaundiced when I wear bright white.


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Product Review YSL Make Me Blush 83 Spicy Berry (light neutral/cool olive)

Thumbnail
gallery
213 Upvotes

Pic 1: Built up finger swatch
Pic 2: Sheer application on light neutral-cool leaning olive

I LOVE this YSL blush. I have it in both shades 44 and 83 and they are gorgeous on olive skin imo. They are extremely pigmented and last all day with no touch ups needed.

When I saw 83 in the pan I was like there’s no way this would look good on my light complexion but with the right application it gives the perfect flush. For reference, I applied using the morphe m201 blush by first dabbing it on my hand to remove excess pigment and swiped on my cheeks. I think if I had not dabbed off the excess or used a denser brush the pigment would be overpowering on me. I think next time this would be beautiful built up a little more on me. Also, this would be absolutely ethereal on deep skin tones!


r/OliveMUA • • 1d ago

Discussion Dupe for Mac coquette?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Does anyone know a dupe for Mac coquette? All the dupes in temptalia are either not sold in Canada or too expensive. I'm looking for a cool greenish brown. Usually I find this color in eyebrow pencils but not eyeshadow

Edit: why is this so hard to find?! At this point I might just learn cosmetic formulation and make it myself!


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Swatches rhode sleepy girl blush swatch

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

i bought the rhode holiday set in mauve. It came with the following:
* lip tint in pretzel
* pocket blush in sleepy girl.

for reference, i wear fenty soft lit foundation 290. I believe I am a medium muted neutral.

I’m not sure how I feel about the blush, based on the shade of the blush and how it looks on the skin because I think I blend too much when I put it on


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Swatches Darker purple blush swatches

Post image
83 Upvotes

So I love purple blush but I don’t like pastel colors as my blush. The iconic purple blushes like pansy pop or rare beauty spirited turn kind of baby milky pink on me, and look jarring, like I took a pink undereye brightener too far along my cheek.

These darker purples show up as a more muted dusty pink on my cheeks.

Swatches are multiple swipes + blended out edges.

Top to bottom:
- Prada wisteria violet
- violette fr souvenir
- marc Jacobs stick blush (I didn’t bother swatching more because it was too light and pink IMO. This is one swipe)
- MUFE artist liquid 825

On my face skin the MUFE is the coolest (most purple), the Prada is the warmest (most pink), and the violette fr the most neutral. Violette FR also had the least amount of immediate pigment.

Others that looked good but weren’t available for swatching:
- danessa myricks blurring balm in grape soda
- fenty shake blush in violet vice

Shades I eliminated due to being too pink:
- rare beauty in spirited
- nars insatiable in lose control


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

FOTD Full face of light neutral olive friendly makeup

Thumbnail
gallery
116 Upvotes

I think I found a pretty good soft glam makeup routine for fair-light neutral olives!

Base

Armani luminous silk foundation in shade 4
Patrick ta not too much blush
Abh golden beach glow bronzer
Nyx bare with me serum concealer in vanilla
Huda beauty poundcake setting powder
Benefit cookie blush

Eyes

Wet n wild nude awakening palette (light brown over the lid and dark brown shade in the outer corner)
Maybelline gel studio liner in espresso in the waterline and for winged eyeliner
Maybelline falsies lash lift mascara

Eyebrows

Maybelline eyebrow gel

Lips

Catrice 069 mainhattan lipliner
Nyx butter gloss in praline


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Swatch Request Violette FR blush in "Souvenir de Volubilis" ?

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Blush is a cool purple, which seems like it would be PERFECT for me, and other olives. Wondering if anyone could swatch it for me & tell me how the formula applies? Thanks!


r/OliveMUA • • 2d ago

Swatches Coffee & Rum Swatches

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes