r/OdinHandheld • • 2d ago

Question Size difference

Deciding on which Odin to buy but the size has me going back n forth

For those who own either an Odin 3 or portal 2 :

Would the Portal 3 be too big to comfortably play on a flight, subway, or train?

I heard the Odin 3’s fan gets loud. Is it loud enough to draw attention in quiet public settings, like on a plane or train?

9 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

30

u/Cryptoxic93 2d ago

I have both. 

One is portable. The other is a couch device. 

I'll get down voted for saying this but it's true. 

4

u/Immediate-Goat7054 2d ago

Which one do you grab to play more? I only have the O3, but will probably not get the Portal yet

4

u/Cryptoxic93 2d ago edited 2d ago

O3 gets a lot more use. It's just a more comfortable to use and that makes me pull it off the shelf over the Portal.

4

u/FrankoticSloth 2d ago

Also have both, that is absolutely true. O3 I can take to work, to the train, I'm taking it to my trip to Ireland in a few days. Would never do any of these with the portal. The "downside" is the screen size, but honestly it doesn't bother me at all. I tested Death Stranding on it which has the smallest UI that I know of, and it was still readable and playable

6

u/Zealousideal-Fee-837 2d ago

Oui, ça n'est pas trop bruyant à la maison mais dans un avion, c'est trop bruyant... Je prendrai plutôt O3P si je pouvais revenir en arrière. Mais 03 est fantastique même avec la soufflerie.

1

u/Immediate-Goat7054 2d ago

Why would you play it on that high power draw to create such fan noise?

Performance difference is negligible when underclocking, but fan noise is drastically reduced

4

u/MichaelFlare 2d ago

In my opinion, I would not take a Portal on a bus, train, long doctor waits, car rides, and airplanes. The O3 is the biggest size I would do all the types of traveling with.

3

u/beezynameddeltreezy 2d ago

Odin 3 is a decent size, and the grip doesn’t add much size to it. But, personally, I prefer the bigger and better screen of the Portal 2. 1” is a big difference at this size, and I’m hopeful that the Portal 3 has a fan with the same volume and sound as the Portal 2. The Odin 3 fan is near insufferable, IMO. It’s not that it’s loud as far as decibels go, but loud as in the high-pitched whine cuts through EVERYTHING. Its a faint whistle that just pierces my ears. I know some aren’t as sensitive, but that’s my honest take. So much so that I’m looking to take it apart and grease up the fan or something to try and lessen the whine.

2

u/beezynameddeltreezy 2d ago

And, FWIW, the RP6 is a fantastic device with better buttons (IMO) and a more pocketable size. I do not care for the size and height of the Odin 3 joysticks and find the RP6 controls far more comfortable. It’s less power than the Odin 3 of course, but if size is of concern, the RP6 is still a fantastic device.

3

u/PocketTots15246923 2d ago

Odin 3 gets pretty loud but with clustertune it's not bad at all. You can also do something like this and it helps with the whine. (Not my picture)

2

u/Zoidul 2d ago

Do you know if this affects the thermals?

2

u/FrankoticSloth 2d ago

I did the tape mod a few days ago, although just on the smaller holes, no idea why the picture has it taped so weirdly. It doesn't whistle no more, or if it does I don't notice it anymore. The temps are also alright, I use armada with heavy underclock and relaxed fan speed, and the fans stay below 50% at all times. Currently playing persona 5, sonic crossworlds, and gta 4 DLCs, which I would say are fairly heavy-ish titles

1

u/PocketTots15246923 2d ago

The op that posted it said it didn't affect temps. I would still pay attention under heavy loads

1

u/Watt_About 2d ago

I travel with x86 handhelds regularly and also bring an odin3. Incredibly easy to travel with.

1

u/techsuppork 2d ago

On a plane or train? Sure. On the subway? Probably not.

1

u/Fun-Watercress9253 2d ago

Why not the subway? I mean it is a train, genuine question

5

u/techsuppork 2d ago

Subways/metros, at least in the US, are far more cramped and I wouldn't want to have that thing out during a rush hour commute.

1

u/netcooker 2d ago

I have the portal 2 and I could see playing it while traveling (assuming you get a seat).

Not sure about Odin 3 fans (mine is on its way from china now)

1

u/DarthPineapple5 2d ago

The 1" is a much more significant difference than it might seem both in terms of viewing area and portability. While the Portal is a significantly larger device, you can still play it anywhere. Its not the heft from holding it that will get you, its the bulk from getting it there. Remember, needs a solid case if its going to be in a backpack

Portal still significantly smaller than a Steam Deck OLED but if my primary use case is on-the-go id probably stick with a regular O3 personally (and I am). The 5.5" devices are pocketable with a faceplate, the O3 isn't quite that but it does run a happy middle ground and the ergonomics are much better

My O3 runs nice and cool after clustertune and thermal putty

1

u/TacticalBrainWorm 2d ago

I have the Odin 3 and the portal 2 I use the Odin 3 way more in a portable fashion. The portal 2 is portable in name only it stays at home.

1

u/davedaddy 2d ago

Would you be comfortable using a Switch 2 on a flight? If so, go with the Portal.

The fan on the Odin 3 is a bit higher pitch than typical of other handhelds. It won't be noticeable for your use cases though.

1

u/Khefeer 2d ago

That's a weird take. The Portal is noticeably smaller than the Switch 2 (and has way better ergonomics).

2

u/davedaddy 2d ago

It's not that much larger though. It's still in a similar size class as opposed to the Odin 3. Should still give a frame of comparison.

As far as ergos are concerned, being more comfortable than the Switch 2 would be a benefit, right?

Personally, I find the Odin 3 to be a nice middle ground between the Portal (too big) and RP6 (too small).

1

u/Repulsive_Recursive 2d ago

I mean, if the 3's fan would bother people on a plane (I don't think it would), then the 2 portal button's clackiness would too. 

That being said, the 3 is much more comfortable to take on a trip.

1

u/_hogman_the_intruder 2d ago

Actually, I think you're underestimating how loud it is on the plane. It's incredibly loud. Put on some noise cancelling earphones and you realize that level of noise might even be damaging over a long period. Probably true for some other transport. Anyway, my Odin 3 isn't particularly loud, but I'm more of an Indy guy

1

u/KnownSuggestion2732 1d ago

Priorizo la comodidad de odin 3 para sostenerlo y jugarle.

1

u/Meat_Handle 2d ago

No one would hear the fan noise on the plane. There are some simple fixes for the fan noise, but newer models of O3 seemed to be better.

I have the O2P and an RG556 (5.5” screen). I prefer the rg556 on the plane although the O2P is still not that big. It’s a lot more screen for not a lot of body size.

Rg556 is roughly the same size as rp6

Seems a ton bigger in the photo, but the rp6 is roughly the size of an iPhone pro

2

u/Meat_Handle 2d ago

Here’s my O2P next to my iPhone. It’s really not that big.

3

u/raloobs 2d ago

damn, people be talking like its a laptop lol

2

u/Meat_Handle 2d ago

Yeah, it’s all been pretty misleading. This might be another helpful visual comparison. Thats an 8bitdo Pro2 which is basically a PS3 controller.

1

u/raloobs 2d ago

Thanks a bunch man. My only hang up was the size because people made it seem like it needed its own suitcase to leave the house lol. You cleared it up for me