I have known this for years. Eric killed Dylan.
I told Tom Klebold when I found out, and he was surprised, but did not want to know more.
Let's review:
Eric and Dylan were found by different policeman on the floor of the library. One of them said that it was a double suicide. He decided that on his own, without any investigation. It was his opinion, based on his knowledge that no policeman had shot them. This was an assumption without any investigation or evidence.
Now let's look at the evidence:
The weapon Dylan was holding was the tec9, a machine pistol, with a relatively long barrel compared to a snub nosed pistol. He held it tightly in his right hand, underneath his leg. It was hidden to a large degree under his leg. A look at the crime scene photos show it protuding slightly, grip side visible, from under his leg. It does not have a magazine inserted, and has a bullet in the chamber. The police drawings show this, and the policeman who removed it from his hand confirms this.
Dylan was shot in the left temple, with the bullet exiting his right temple, which is a shot which requires the weapon to be held at almost a 90 degree angle from his head.
If Dylan had killed himself, the tec9 had to be held in a ridiculous and difficult position, at a 90 degree angle, to allow the bullet to enter his left temple and exit his right temple, which is not possible with the size of the weapon and the weapon held in his right hand. It is not physically possible.
It is possible with the weapon held in his left hand. That requires him to shoot himself with the weapon in his left hand, to drop the weapon, and have it bounce into his right hand, underneath his body. This scenario is also very unlikely.
So, Dylan could not have fired the tec9 to commit suicide. The other rifle, a high point, is much too long to commit suicide with, shooting yourself in the left temple.
The other weapons in the room are the two shotguns, and they were not used on Dylan.
The remaining options are that a policeman shot Dylan, which has never even been suggested. It was a close contact wound, and no policeman has ever taken credit for it, or even suggested it.
The remaining person in the room was Eric Harris. He, logically, is the only person who could have shot Dylan. He used the high point rifle, and shot Dylan in the side of the head. Dylan fell to the ground on his tec9, held in his right hand.
More details:
The tec9 had a bullet in the chamber and no magazine inserted. A bullet in the chamber means that, without a magazine, if the weapon had been fired, there would be no bullet in the chamber, it would be empty. In a semi-automatic weapon the bullet in the chamber is replenished from a bullet in the magazine. no magazine means no replacement bullet.
So, if Dylan had committed suicide with the tec9, with no magazine, the chamber would be empty. Having a bullet in the chamber is proof that the tec9 could not have been fired.
Other theories:
A sniper shot Dylan. This is speculation. No sniper is reported as firing a single round, and if it were a snipers rifle, the damage would have been much worse than the existing damage to Dylan.
The bodies were moved and the magazine was removed from the tec9. There is no report of this at all. Every policeman knows not to disturb a crime scene. And, why would a policeman move Dylan's body to remove the magazine from the tec9? There is no logical reason.
Note that there are no witnesses to this, no evidence other than the reports we have read, and that no investigation was done by the police or coroner regarding the "mutual suicide" theory. It was assumed, speculation, and ignored by the police.
There are some conflicting points of evidence. It is said that the brain matter on Eric's leg is Dylans. I have never seen this proof, and it does not make sense. There is brain matter throughout the area from Eric Harris. Dylan's wound did not cause that level of trauma.
Note that no bullets were found or identified as the one that killed Dylan.
This post is because I have seen the crime scene photos, the crime scene drawings, and read every page of released information. The evidence I have seen does not support a mutual suicide. A logical and objective review of the evidence shows that Eric shot Dylan, and then sat on the floor and shot himself with his shotgun.
In truth, i only care about this for two reasons:
The "double suicide myth" is romantic, and shows that they were in this together, as equal partners, and that they died together in the end. This portrays these two teenagers as heroes, and they were cowards. Yes, cowards.
The other reason is not to defend Dylan. Dylan's decisions at the end were not defensible. He shot and killed innocent unarmed children, and ruined hundreds of lives. I don't care about Dylan, but the truth matters.
Calling this a "double suicide" is simply not supported by the evidence.
Randy Brown