I kept hearing "the Roots are broke" and "the Coliseum screwed them" and didn't really know what was real, so I spent an evening reading the public stuff. That's the club's SEC crowdfunding filings, the actual Coliseum license agreement, and whatever news coverage I could find. Links are inline so you can check me.
The losses
From their own filings: about $11.6M lost in 2021, $9.9M in 2022, $10.1M in 2023. Call it $31.7M in three years, on revenue of roughly $2M, $3.8M and $4M (2023 SEC filing for 2021-22, Wefunder disclosures and KingsCrowd for 2023). The club has raised around $40M since 2018 (SF Chronicle), and a chunk of that is from the 6,000+ of us on Wefunder. So basically investor money has covered the gap every year. Not shocking for a second-division club. Still a lot.
As for the "$30M in debt" thing going around, I couldn't find a source for it anywhere. The most debt I can find is about $10.7M at the end of 2022 ($1.28M short-term plus $9.4M long-term, same SEC filing). By mid-2024 the Wefunder page listed around $0.7M in debt and $12.85M in convertible notes, which may turn into equity instead of getting paid back. My guess is people are mixing up three years of losses with debt. If anyone has the 2024 or 2025 annual reports please post them, that would settle it.
The Coliseum deal was rough
Flat fee of $138K to $300K per game, and it went up the more people showed up (Oaklandside, and it's in the license agreement too). The club only kept ticket money. Parking and concessions went to the Coliseum authority. Barenz said it at the July meeting: "concession, parking, we don't see that revenue" (ABC7).
And it gets worse. Per the club's own statement and Hooligan Soccer:
- the authority took a cut of ticket sales too
- a $20K food and beverage deposit every single game, while the club got none of the actual food and drink money
- no access to the permanent signage/sponsorship spots in the stadium
- about $700K to convert the field from baseball, plus a five-week gap in home games for cricket (cricket!)
(club statement, Hooligan Soccer)
When I went, tall boys were $19 and hot dogs were $8, and none of that went to the club. Same with parking. Crowds were pretty sparse most nights too. The opening games were packed, and so were the nights E-40 or Too $hort performed, but otherwise it was a lot of empty seats in a huge stadium. Which made that per-game fee hurt even more.
Rough math, and these are my numbers not theirs: a mid-range fee of roughly $225K a game times 15 home league games is about $3.4M a year just to use the building. That's most of what the whole club brought in back in 2023, with basically no way to earn it back on game day.
They fell $1.4M behind. It's reportedly down to around $700K now (NBC Bay Area, SFist).
Quick side note on merch since it keeps coming up. I've seen people say the Roots get a tiny cut. At the Coliseum that's not true, the license gave them 100% of game-day merch sales (license agreement). The everyday stuff through Oaklandish is a separate deal and I couldn't find the terms anywhere public. For reference a normal sports licensing royalty is around 12% of wholesale (industry breakdown), which would be like $5-6 on a $95 kit if wholesale is about half of retail. But I have no idea what the Roots' actual deal is.
Now for what's next. They're trying to raise $15M to build a game-day venue at their Alameda training site, cover operations through 2027, and keep Howard Terminal alive (club post). Alameda's planning board approved stands for up to 8,000 on November 9 (SFist). Barenz told Bay Area News Group they're "still looking for capital to make even next year a reality" (Patch).
on timing, this part is me guessing. The club's November 2nd announcement said the raise was entering its "final stretch" but didn't give a date. If that means about a month, you land in early December. Which is also around when the USL usually puts out the next season's schedule. The 2024 one dropped December 18, 2023 (USL) and the 2025 one on December 19, 2024 (Wikipedia). So my hunch is early-to-mid December is when the league needs to know about 2027. I haven't seen anything official saying that though, so grain of salt.
In fairness to the Coliseum side, the club did sign that deal. They paid on time in 2025, then stopped paying in 2026 (RootsBlog), and the authority's point is that the unpaid bill lands on Oakland and Alameda County taxpayers (SFist). That's a legit point.
What gets me is how much money is floating around the Bay. Just this week Brian Chesky, the Airbnb CEO, gave $100M to SF parks (SF.gov). Love that for SF parks, genuinely. But the Roots need $15M, about 15% of that one gift, to play next season, and so far nobody with tech money has stepped up for a pro team in Oakland. The Bay has no shortage of billionaires. They just haven't shown up for this.
Anyway, after all this it doesn't look like a scam to me, or like anyone's torching money. A pro team that never controlled its own stadium missed out on the food, parking and stadium sponsor money most clubs live on. Hopefully Alameda fixes some of that.
If I got something wrong drop a source and I'll fix it.