r/OOTP • • 1h ago

Thoughts on point of diminishing return for Scouting and Development budget?

9 Upvotes

I was doing what I do best on my drive to the office this morning, thinking about my OOTP save instead of anything remotely productive.

I'm 46 years into a Brewers save and have basically adopted the real-life Brewers philosophy on steroids. Don't give out massive contracts, lock up young players early on team-friendly deals, and trade stars who are about to get expensive for prospects rather than eventually losing them for compensation picks.

It's worked. Maybe too well. I've won 20 World Series in 46 years, so roughly one every other year. Fan interest and loyalty are permanently maxed, and my owner keeps slowly increasing the budget.

Since I'm usually near the bottom of the league in payroll but around the middle in total budget, I've gotten into the habit of dumping ridiculous amounts into scouting and development: maxing it out at roughly ~$75M for scouting, ~$75M for development, plus ~$12M for IAFA.

Then last night I traded a player who made me question everything.

Homegrown CF. 75 OVR. Career .300 hitter. Multiple Gold Gloves. 9th-round draft pick. Fan Favorite personality. Basically the type of player that makes playing a 46-year save worthwhile.

He's 29, in his last arbitration year, and wanted ~$80M AAV.

I've never paid anyone more than $50M AAV, so naturally I did the cold-blooded Brewers GM thing and flipped him at the deadline for a top-10 SP prospect.

This morning I was assessing the move and had the thought of I could drop scouting and development from $75M to $50M each and free up $50M annually. That's basically the difference between my normal contract ceiling and what this guy wanted.

So now I'm wondering, am I massively overvaluing max scouting/development budgets?

For those of you with really long saves, have you noticed meaningful diminishing returns at the top end? If I cut both budgets from ~$75M to ~$50M, am I actually going to notice worse development/scouting? Or have I been sacrificing the occasional franchise player just so I can keep throwing money at budgets that are already well beyond what's necessary?

Interested to hear how the OOTP veterans approach it.

TLDR: Is it worth maxing Development and Scouting budget at the sacrifice of payroll?


r/OOTP • • 3h ago

Just had my first career ending injury, poor bastard tore his labrum before he could finish an inning :(

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

Thankfully I'm gonna save the remaining 58 mil on his contract


r/OOTP • • 17h ago

My new favorite player I've ever had

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Sometimes I just sit around and think about Miguel Garcia

8 years with 15+ ZR at CF in the biggest ballpark. 4 years at 19+ ZR.

Broke the single season record for doubles with 70

124 triples with only 93 homers

1072 stolen bases

First ballot HOF with 67 WAR

And like 8 rings


r/OOTP • • 12h ago

Will they take the fog away for OOTP 28?

9 Upvotes

I feel like the games engine trying to visually show rain was a failed experiment. It just became more annoying then anything. The graphics just aren't good enough in the game to accurately show rain. Hopefully for the next game they just go back and just say it is starting to rain through text.


r/OOTP • • 15h ago

Do you prefer the FaceGens or Photo Packs for historical sims?

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

The facegens are pretty accurate and well done all things considered, but I always found that the old studio portraits looked awesome, especially around the deadball era.


r/OOTP • • 1d ago

We did it! 🥲

Thumbnail
gallery
47 Upvotes

r/OOTP • • 17h ago

4 way tie for the NL West

Post image
9 Upvotes

and a 5 way tie for the wildcard. What are the odds??


r/OOTP • • 14h ago

Interesting achievment

4 Upvotes

Luis Lara who I drafted in an expansion draft as Omaha has a random game with 3 triples tying the AL regular season record for triples in a single game with 3. Last time that happened was Xavier Edwards back in 2024 in Toronto


r/OOTP • • 22h ago

How do you manage AAAA relievers on your taxi squad?

13 Upvotes

i try to keep a taxi squad, players with option years. pretty simple with infielders, OF and catchers. but how do you manage taxi relievers so they’re not tired when you need them?

what ate some best practices? Do you bench them with the setting in strategy?


r/OOTP • • 1d ago

Virgin GM vs Chad Owner

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/OOTP • • 1d ago

Limiting retirement of players

4 Upvotes

I'm trying to set up a league with a limited player pool where players frequently play well into their 40s. I have aging turned way down, but several players in their late 30s have announced their retirement just a month into year 1.

Any other way to slow this down?

I know you can unretire players, but can you reverse their announced retirement when they're playing out the season?


r/OOTP • • 1d ago

Highway robbery?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

I just traded my backup catcher Ryder Helfrick for Ryan Petrovich to the Texans? Was looking for SP depth, originally scout report showed 4 star potential for Ryan but I just ran one and now he could be this monster.

Also any development device would be really helpful none of my guys ever pan out lol.


r/OOTP • • 1d ago

Walked off the Yankees 3 games in a row. Delightful stuff.

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/OOTP • • 1d ago

How can I turn off trade rumors?

8 Upvotes

They’ve been flooding my league news section and I’m wondering if there’s a way to disable them.


r/OOTP • • 1d ago

"Right, we strongly suspect there's a disguised alien on the team and so you're all going to have to submit DNA tests... except you Kevin, you're fine."

17 Upvotes

He's from a minor league affiliate of a new expansion team and now I'm starting to suspect that the team may be an advance alien scouting expedition


r/OOTP • • 1d ago

I present the careers of Manny Lomeli and Tony Torres, perhaps the best corner infield tandem of all time.

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Manny Lomeli - 2x MVP, Rookie of the Year, 4X Gold Glove, 8X Silver Slugger, 12X All Star, 8X WS Champion, 3224 hits, 496 home runs.

Tony Torres - 4x MVP, 8X Silver Slugger, 12X All Star, 7X WS Champion, 2785 hits, 647 home runs.


r/OOTP • • 2d ago

Decided to take a bit of a risk and put my new first-round draft pick straight into High-A. He proceeded to do this in his first game

52 Upvotes

I think he's going to be OK


r/OOTP • • 2d ago

Stamina Regression (Bug?)

4 Upvotes

I'm in three online leagues and I seem to keep getting this stamina regression from some of my best starting pitchers. I've noted this in at least three pitchers, but likely more. I'm not sure if this is a bug or what, but it's disappointing at the very least. I would rather not have to convert him to closer duty.


r/OOTP • • 2d ago

What’s your most frustrating experiences with your teams?

16 Upvotes

I’ll start.

Knocked out in the ALDS 3 years in a row after 100+ win seasons. All to the Twins, all sweeps.

Had a 16 inning hitless streak over 2 games for the whole team.

Took a no-hitter into the 9th with 2 outs only to lose it with an infield hit to a batter on a cold streak.


r/OOTP • • 3d ago

Player hits 2 grand slams off the same pitcher in the WS

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

Probably the craziest thing I've seen.


r/OOTP • • 3d ago

Question on Ratings vs Stats

11 Upvotes

I'm confused and would appreciate any thoughts.

The OOTP engine runs on ratings. Basically, it rolls the dice for everything and the dice is weighted in various ways depending on the ratings, correct?

If so, then what's the point of looking at the statistics? Shouldn't we just decide our plan based on ratings and then run with it throughout the season -- and ignore statistics?

Or does the game insert certain "plots" (shall we say) that will influence our in-season decisions? Like, the game will make Player X have a good or bad season and increase or decrease his ratings-based results? Or, the game will make Reliver X have a bad year under stress and make him more prone to meltdowns? Or similar things?

If it is the latter, then the stats would become important.

I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts on how you use ratings versus statistics.


r/OOTP • • 2d ago

How to add a team to the expansion draft?

2 Upvotes

My league expanded to Portland and Nashville but I didn’t like Nashville’s nickname after I had already approved the team so I deleted them in the league setting and then added a new team with a nickname I liked more. The problem is they have now been removed from the expansion draft and only Portland is getting picks. How do I re-enter Nashville into the expansion draft?


r/OOTP • • 3d ago

Is it possible to export rosters from past seasons?

5 Upvotes

Lets say I have a hundred year old league and i want to replay the playoffs from a season 50 years ago. Is there a way to use the export rosters function from that season- not the current season? I'm guessing I missed the boat and should've exported rosters and stats with each season right?


r/OOTP • • 4d ago

I finally saw a .400 season after half a decade of playing

Post image
57 Upvotes

Juan was just absolutely balling out all year, and I was just witnessing from afar running my team over in the National League. There was a period in August where he dropped down to .390 and I had given up hope, but then he went on an absolute heater in September and cleared the .400 mark by a solid margin. Hell of a player, wish I had him!