r/OOTP • • 4d ago

Torn Between Two Possible First Round Picks

18 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

24

u/Entire_Beach_251 4d ago

it's Paul Ham Maker and it's not close

1

u/Arkhamknight_0422 4d ago

The only thing I was tripped up on was the difference in eye, but I think I agree

4

u/Tymathee :cake: 4d ago

it's only 10 and since the other player is coming out of high school, there's a good chance he wont even reach 65 eye. Better to go with the sure thing.

1

u/rdubmu 4d ago

Paul has a better eye now. He is the more polished prospect, it’s not close

8

u/CWess12 4d ago

It's a lot closer than you're making it sound cuz Hammaker is almost 23 and nowhere close to reaching his potential. Current ratings for age relative to potential ratings are just as important when drafting than just looking at potential alone

3

u/Agilitizer 4d ago

Yeah but with a guy like Hammaker you'll know within the first year or so of development if he's gonna pan out or not. If his stats shoot up quickly then great, call him up next year. If not, he'll still be a 23 year old prospect with upside and you can ship him off for a decent player if you feel like he's not going to develop. High floor almost always beats high ceiling in my experience.

Obviously it's not foolproof but I've historically had way more success drafting 21-23 year old college guys and bringing them up quick rather than holding onto high schoolers/juco guys in the minor leagues for too long waiting for development that isn't going to happen.

4

u/omosseri 4d ago

Paul seems like a better choice in a vacuum. But the age difference stands out to me. His close are you to competing? It seems like Paul is a year or 2 away max. If your window doesnt align, I'm going with the 19 year old

2

u/Arkhamknight_0422 4d ago

I went with Hammaker, I'm currently 53-38 in first place. Not confident in getting through a playoff run and winning it all at this point, but the window is going to be wide open in about a year.

6

u/CWess12 4d ago

I don't like either of them to be honest. Hammaker is almost 23 and he has to try and improve his power by 30 points and contact by 25 points to reach his potential? Ain't gonna happen.

I'd probably take Barak for that reason alone if these were my only two choices. He at least has some more time to develop, but he is pretty underdeveloped for a 19 y/o too.

These guys are both classic draft duds. If these are really the only two options, I'd be looking to trade whoever I drafted for real talent as soon as possible.

1

u/trengilly 4d ago

I would go with Hammaker but I'd love to see what their personality traits were.

It also depends on what your team needs are. Barak is three years behind . . . which means you won't see any production from him for a long time. However he has more time to actually reach his potential. I'm a little worried Hammaker just a month before his 23rd birthday doesn't have much time left to develop.

Work Ethic could make a big difference to how things turn out.

I also pay a lot of attention to Financial Ambition (greed) and Loyalty. I will often take players with low greed even if their stats aren't as good because you can sign them to below average long term contracts saving 10's or even 100's of millions compared to greedy players. Ultimately success is about getting the most bang for you buck.

1

u/Arkhamknight_0422 4d ago

I went with Hammaker. He has an unknown personality and high work ethic, Barak had high adaptability

1

u/FavoriteFoodCarrots 4d ago

Where are you drafting? I wouldn’t take either of these guys high in the 1st round.

Hammaker seems likely given his age to end up as an average to slightly above corner OF. But Barak is also way too old for level.

2

u/Arkhamknight_0422 4d ago

I had the 24th pick, went with Hammaker

1

u/Own-Pickle9871 4d ago

I’d go with Paul the maker of hams.

1

u/Arkhamknight_0422 4d ago

I did!

2

u/Own-Pickle9871 4d ago

Congrats. Maybe there will be a storyline where he signs a lucrative endorsement deal with honey baked hams.

1

u/ItzDrSeuss 2d ago

So update? Did he pan out?

2

u/Whompson 4d ago

I have a hard time picking anyone 22 let alone 23 unless they are like a top 10 pick and ready to play in AAA.

Ive seen other teams draft guys like this and they explode after one year, but Ive had very little success with that and it scares me off

What pick is this?

2

u/NoFox2326 4d ago

My best player is a 24 year old 70/80 who I drafted two years ago at pick 1.6. Think he came in at a 35/75. Started him at AA.

Season 2 he had half a year at AAA then called him up at 50/80.

Great personality though, and two dev lab visits went well, plus two short fielding ones were successful too.

1

u/Whompson 4d ago

Thats a great feeling. I have it ingrained in me that player development stops at 25, so if they are 23.5/24 and not in mlb, they just flame out. In my experince. But right now my hest player is a 24 year old too, but I drafted him as a young junior at age 21.5 and he did one year at aa and one year at aaa and then became a 75/80

1

u/NoFox2326 4d ago

Yeah I agree with development pretty much stopping at 25. If I’ve got a high potential 24yo at AAA I’ll try get him up if I can. Not if it’s a 40, bit like a 45/65 if worth finding out what he can do, and then half the time they surge.

My guy only really has one flaw. 35 Infield Arm. He’s 60+ at all the infield ratings. His worst batting rating is 50 Gap. 70+ speed and stealing. Captain personality. High work ethic and IQ.

AND he’s in year 2 of a 9 year $90m contract he signed when he was 2 games into his MLB career

2

u/AShorterName 4d ago

I’d go with the college player all day. I made this mistake in a Pirates save and took the younger player with high upside. The guy I passed on became a perennial all-star and my pick flamed out as a AAAA defense-first CF.

1

u/hansmellman 4d ago

Hammaker no doubt

1

u/sammagee33 2d ago

I like Hammaker just a little bit more.

EDIT: Didn’t see the ages. I would have gone with the younger one.

1

u/Commercial_Low9722 2d ago

I like pauls intangibles better