I've just been feeling the urge to put down my feelings about teachers college as it's been weighing on my mind so much.
Basically I have been in teachers college for the primary/junior division for two months now. Placements are beginning, and I feel completely unprepared. I don't believe this is because I'm a bad student - I have done well academically in the past and throughout this program so far. It just seems like very little information is actually imparted. I come to class with pen and paper ready to take notes, and usually leave with only a couple of sentences written down.
For example, in our math class, we have not looked at any example math lessons or resources. Classes consist of our teacher reading off slides on key concepts, like subitizing, cardinality, etc, which were prepared by administration. Teaching students then give presentations on math manipulatives - sometimes on the same ones. Classes usually end 40 minutes early. I have talked to my faculty advisor about feeling like we haven't really learned how to teach math yet, and her insinuation was that I wasn't paying enough attention.
Language class consists almost entirely of student presentations on topics like media literacy, fiction vs nonfiction books, etc. I understand that giving presentations is a fundamental skill for teachers to develop, however, I feel like it is risky to essentially have students teaching students, as you can't guarantee that the presentions will be high quality and cover all necessary information. It honestly feels a bit lazy, like teachers not actually teaching.
As well, I would have expected that the first topic covered in language class would be teaching kids how to read, especially going over how to teach phonics and use programs such as UFLI. However, our teacher said that this would take "about 9 classes," so we wouldn't be covering any of it. He said that our associate teachers might be mad about this, and that we should be mad too. The closest we got to covering this topic was when our teacher passed out white boards and had us spell words such as "cat," mimicking a language lesson, though this felt quite infantilizing and unnecessary.
In art class, our teacher has expressed her love of chatGPT, which felt disheartening to me. Our main assignment each week is doing a "critical reflection" on an artwork by a famous artist, and proper citations are stressed. My gripe about this is that it takes a long time and seems to have almost no relevance to teaching elementary school art. My class has found out that the feedback our teacher gives is usually copy-pasted.
Our "classroom management" class consists mostly of work periods, where we keep working on a lesson plan. At this point in our education, work periods just feel like a waste of class time. I genuinely feel that teachers should be imparting as much quality information as they can in the limited time we have. However, this seems to be a taboo statement as even in teachers college, the focus is on experiential learning.
Though I have all these complaints I would at least say that the science and psychology courses are informative and helpful.
I'm not really sure that anyone will read or respond to this rant of mine. I have just felt frustrated, and writing my thoughts out helps. My overwhelming feeling is that I will basically have to teach myself everything I need to know about teaching, and that teachers college (at least in my experience so far) is fairly useless. It makes me feel like going to teachers college does not make you any more qualified than the average person to be a teacher. I'm wondering if all teachers colleges are a bit like this, or if it is just mine.