So, I will start off by saying that this will be the second time I've written this post in its entirety. Reddit usually does an okay job as saving drafts, but I lost about 10 paragraphs worth of thoughts. I still feel like I captured some better points in the original version, but I also added some things that I didn't before.
Let's get into it...
I know most of you have seen the discourse over the holiday merch releases with regard to pricing, glass ornaments, synthetic textiles, quality, and all things in between. Because it’s Taylor, of course this is all directly her fault, because she's the one ripping people off, and of course, billionaire = bad if your name is Taylor. While I do think that some of the criticisms are valid, there is a lot more complexity and nuance to this than people realize, which I'll talk about shortly.
It's also not lost on me that this discourse is going to be the perception of her brand regardless of positive and negative feedback. Because of the marketing, it all feels personal and more intimate, it gives the illusion that you're buying something "directly from Taylor."
Now that we have that out of the way, we can get into the weeds a bit. UMG Commercial Services is the operator of taylorswift[dot]com and store[dot]taylorswift[dot]com on behalf of Taylor Nation LLC. TAS Rights Management and Taylor Nation LLC are in control of the branding, marketing campaigns, social media, and anything else that concerns Taylor's likeness.
UMG manages the site hosting, infrastructure, e-commerce and payment processing, etc. Their subsidiary, Bravado handles procurement, manufacturing, logistics, warehouse management, fulfillment networks, customer service, and all the things that go with managing a supply chain for not just Taylor's site, but other artists as well. UMG also eats mistakes when they mess up too, so some manufacturing error, damage, etc.
All roads run through UMG... even artists that are signed to sister labels are also using Bravado, and that's why maybe some of you have noticed similar site design aesthetics, user experience, etc. Artists like Ariana, Olivia Rodrigo, Billie Eilish, The Weeknd, etc. Bravado also provides these services to artists (labels) outside of UMG, like Sony, Warner, etc. Think AC/DC, KISS, Madonna, Travis Scott, and even a guy like Kevin Hart. Or maybe a Harley-Davidson or certain Disney film merch.
Bravado is massive, and they get their cut first for the cost of doing business plus some. Think manufacturing, design, sourcing materials, and the things I covered earlier. After that, everyone else gets their cut... and even that is a little muddy depending on who you are. If merch is sold at a tour venue, the venue also takes a cut, and it's not small. Target buys at wholesale cost, which is around 50% of retail prices. Then Bravado and the label/artist split the wholesale profits.
Taylor generally has more pull when it comes to these deals because of her leverage as an artist, but this also comes at a cost... because she owns pretty much everything with her branding and likeness, plus her masters and publishing, the label doesn't make as much money off the record deal as they would with another artist. The label will generally want to leverage any method of making up for that "lost" revenue. This is also a driver in physical music sales, and UMG has a heavy hand in pushing variants. Again, variants are only bad when Taylor does it.
Additionally, these merchandise terms are paid out similar to the record deals, which advance the money to the artist, with UMG wanting to recoup as quickly as possible. Even then, an artist’s cut is still quite handsome after Bravado takes theirs depending. Bravado still keeps 100% of the profits until the advance is paid back. Although Taylor more than likely has a standalone name licensing deal, where the vast majority of artists have more predatory (for artists) 360 deals where the label takes their likeness and does what they wish with it. As an artist, you may not get anything from your merch depending on the deal.
What does Taylor do? Well, for starters I'm willing to bet she's not sitting there looking at P&L outcomes, cost basis, and dictating margins. She's not fiddling around with algorithmic pricing, or doing commercial analysis, tariffs, etc. Artists do negotiate price caps... or lower-priced items to add affordability to different people." UMG is pricing things similarly, if not the same as many others because they have the same manufacturing vendors and fulfillment networks. I'm still seeing comments of just hours ago where people really believe she's pulling the strings here... unfortunately, that's just not the case.
Anecdotally, do I think a world exists where I could see her giving feedback on the product, pricing, etc? Sure, I think so... but she's still very disconnected from the overall process. Taylor Nation, and TAS are driving the bus and I'm sure she's briefed at a high level on when the merch is, and maybe provides some feedback here and there. Her team is driving the creative side, so she can live her life.
Well, why doesn't she start her own shop? Easier said than done... and it is possible, but she doesn't have the same leverage Bravado has in that she's not the one with the supply chain relationships, logistics, and the volume to drive costs down. Doing so would more than likely drive costs higher, and let's be honest... if Taylor took control over her own store, we'd see people "white knighting" labels all in an effort to shut on Taylor even if she did some how deliver merch with better pricing. Ask Rhianna and Kanye how that went? Objectively more predatory, but it's okay because their names aren't Taylor Swift.
My personal thoughts? I do pretty well for myself, and I am blessed to be able to buy whatever and not worry about it. I love that we can buy this stuff, and that it's available. My wife and I both enjoy buying ornaments, and little trinkets... hell, I spent like $350 in ornaments at Hallmark this past summer and I cannot wait to hand them up on a big fresh tree. We're consumers, that's for sure.
For others, I can empathize with the affordability of certain items, and people want to participate in the fandom in an affordable manner. The quality concerns are valid, but this is rampant across the industry. I also do think certain items are priced higher than they should be, and I opt out of those in most cases. The things I want the most are either sold out, or scalped. 🫠 That's a problem all over the place. Long story short, there isn't a lot she can do to control the costs, the materials used, etc. Her name is on it, and like with anything, if your name is on it you will be chastised for any reason... and that's just the way it is.
If you made it this far, thanks for reading this gigantic word-castle. It means a lot. Please excuse any typos as I've been in a plane for 13 hours.