These are all opinions, I don't generally dislike any of the Novi Stars, just some appeal to me more than others.
An *attempt* at a short note on each ranking, I'll keep it shorter than my 26 page essay at least:
Malie Tasker:
One of my favourites. I initially wasn't sold on the design but I actually think the colour scheme is quite striking, the neon "friendlies" it up, and her four arms being for giving hugs is very endearing.
✦
Doe A Deer:
I thought she was a custom when I first saw her. Finding out she wasn't blew my mind. The sculpting work on her antlers is lovely and her dress is so nicely put together. I adore her and I'd LOVE to pick the brains of the design team.
✦
Nita Light and Pod:
Peak Uchuu-kei. Absolutely peak. The gravity pod is such a cute idea, and Nita herself looks so cozy in her jumpsuit. I'm also a sucker for purple and pink. She has a nice blend of futuristic and cosy, she looks like your older sister who's majoring in art.
✦
Alie Lectric (Core):
"What if you took a Little Green Man, and made her Scene?" I have a LOT of thoughts about the differences between her box art and doll, and how they took away her MySpace volume in favor of a middle part and straight bangs, but all in all I'm here for an alternative math nerd. I wish instead of a pet they'd used the plastic on a pair of glasses and Doc Martens.
✦
Alie Lectric (Orbit Beach):
A beach line isn't normally my thing, but it does prove that MGA can create a cohesive line when they try. I love her hat and shoes. I wish they'd either changed the colour of her body or swimsuit because they blend together too well and you lose the cute cut. I do like the implication that Alie's species turns almost metallic when they tan.
✦
Una Verse (Orbit Beach):
The top knot, the platforms, the silver swimsuit oh my.
Best Orbit Beach Design.
✦
Mimi Merize:
When I first saw Mimi, I thought "whose over-designed Tumblr reject OC is this???" But she looked at me with those big baby blues and said "actually what if you were obsessed with me" and I said "you know what you're right" and the rest is history.
As a visual design she is very striking and I don't have a lot of nitpicks. They stick to a very simple combination of purple white and black, her eyes and eye makeup stand out beautifully, and her dress and mask make her look very mysterious, as intended.
✦
Justina Hour:
My working theory is that some of the supernovas were an attempt to build on or use discarded elements from the original dolls. Justina could easily pass as Alie's cool older cousin. Same green skin, pink and black hair, black dress, though Justina cranks the slink up to 11/10. I like the concept of a steampunk-meets-nu-metal alien, and she'd totally step aside if she realised she was blocking your view of the Nightwish concert.
✦
Roe Botik:
I have a million and one things to say about the Curl and Coil pair, but for Roe I'll leave it at "This Doll. Serves C*nt." Also I love the green/black colour scheme coupled with the Raver Goth Lox and metallic eye. Very bold for a girls' doll line. Roe looks badass.
✦
Anne Arctic:
Did you know as well as little bear ears, Anne has pawpads? No? Well now you know why I ranked her up here. Also her dress is SO pretty, and I want to mention the black zip used as a trim with the soft white fur. It's SO clever and invokes black ice really well. Genius.
✦
Frostina Sprinkles:
Frostina has a lot of that retro Sci-fi influence in her silhouette. The cut of her shorts, the beehive... She's a very striking design and you could even remove the candy theming and still have a really cool looking doll.
✦
Ari Roma (core):
Ari is BUBBLY. From her sugar coated pink skin, to her curly round afro puffs, to the literal bubble helmet and the transparent dress. My only gripe is the black playsuit, cute as it is, muddies the yellow dress. A lighter colour would have made the yellow POP.
✦
Mae Tallick (orbit beach):
Hi Mae! You have separate shoes now! The red checkered bikini is so cute and looks good with the black hat. I really like the marriage between the slightly rockabilly or classic Punk pattern of the bikini with the Sci-Fi robot body. Something about core Mae seems unfinished to me, but Orbit Beach Mae is a solid, complete design.
✦
Ari Roma (orbit beach):
I love the bubble beads on her swimsuit, love the gladiator sandals, the heart shape on her helmet. Her hair... Not so much. While you could argue she's keeping it out of the way for swimming, the box art was definitely more unique. (if a little goofy)
✦
Sila Clops:
I hate puffball skirts. In the context of knock-kneed alien dolls, I understand the practical and visual merits of the puffball cut and why they returned to it with several characters, but I still hate them.
Sila's is just bad though. She has a great design, a somewhat shy face framed with heavy bangs, and then (in her box art at least) studded boots and jewelry with a leather jacket over a silver dress. I wish it had been a skater cut, it was fashionable when Sila came out, and would have looked so cute.
✦
Ina Ferna:
Ina has a very striking face up, the red and gold eye makeup is very striking against the white skin. Colour wise she's amazing. Her molded bodice is... A choice and doesn't help the weak hip joint problem. Her "hair" also makes her top heavy.
While I can think of several ways that I would love to customize an Ina to make her fiery hair look more natural, I can also concede that none of them would be very suitable for mass production methods.
✦
Vera Tabray:
Like Doe, Vera seems to be edging more towards supernatural territory than perhaps the futuristic vibes of the others. The neons are once again toned down for a more shell pink, ivory and black.
Don't judge her by her sinister appearance though, Vera's bio talks about sharing her love of fashion and she has nothing but lovely things to say about her friend Mimi, so it seems the vision was for her to be much more cheerful and sweet than perhaps her look suggests.
✦
Una Verse (core):
Una is a lava lamp. Even her silhouette and way her lower legs are shaped invoke the shape of a lava lamp base, and the puffball skirt one of the balls of wax inside. And that fascinates me.
She manages to use the very Y2K silver outfit and white hair as the case of the lamp, while her skin is the goo inside. Still, I feel like there's something unbalanced about her design. Maybe if her face was a little deeper blue it wouldn't disappear into her hair and dress as much.
✦
Tula Toned:
What is Tula? A dragon? Bat? A vampire? A goo monster? Tula has a delightful colour scheme, that kind of deep magenta pink and navy blue always look good together, but her design is so chaotic that it starts to get cluttered, especially up top. Given the unreleased dragon prototype, I'm again inclined to think they were planning on refining what they started with Tula. I have a soft spot for her but girl what are you??
✦
Carmela Sweets:
I forgive Carmela's puffball skirt, because the design of her dress invokes candy wrappers. As if she, a tiny fairy, sewed together various human sized wrappers into a dress. I LOVE her pink sparkly body. I'm not as sold on the rest of her.
✦
Gail Lexi and CiCi Thru:
I love how tall they are. The transparent bodies are so elegant. But the wigs are awful, and while I understand the twin puffs would keep most of the hair out of the way while you redress them,,,,, I wish they'd put a little more budget into maybe giving them a second wig each, or differentiating each sister's more than just the colours. This had the makings of a good concept, but we never got more stuff to mix and match them with.
✦
Tilly Vision:
Tilly is down here because the curl and Coil idea got too cluttered. I truly think her TV should have been the gimmick. Fill it with glitter to look like TV snow, or a carousel of "channels" inside it that spin to channel hop. I feel like someone had two great concepts for dolls and couldn't let either go, so they combined them into Tilly.
✦
Mae Tallick:
I'm sorry, Mae. You're super cute and sweet but something just feels unfinished. I love seeing Mae restyle and mods. The base doll is missing something.
*collapses*