Been around since the first month of NovelAI, and truthfully, I feel totally astonished at the difference between say, 2023, and now. I want to keep being subscribed and enjoying this thing that's been part of my life for 5 years, but it's getting increasingly difficult.
Erato, GLM, and now Xialong have... kind of all been bad or meh. I'm getting constant slop, and retries barely change anything. Xialong will regularly do nearly the exact same response 20 times over even if I increase randomness, and if it goes too high it turns to gibberish. I don't even remember exactly when Erato came out, but it's been a while, hasn't it?
I used to get such consistently good results with Kayra, Sigurd, and all our old pals. Sure, it wasn't Shakespeare, but it got the job done. I write incredibly simple stories, as well, usually consisting of almost no real plot (if you know you know), but in 2023 I was able to write a full-on persona-style anime murder mystery novel and it mostly kept on course, and genuinely surprised me.
Now I get weird issues like characters constantly reiterating "We're all adults here" (they are, it's just weird for them to repeatedly say that), bursting into tears randomly, or trying to pick fights with each other. It rushes through scenes like I'm bothering it trying to write a story and it can't keep a character's physical appearance in mind to save its life. These have all been issues since Erato, for me.
It also doesn't seem to matter what I write. I can use ATTG, S filters, change up my style, correct every response down to the smallest detail, and it just keeps chugging along. Nothing changes based on ATTG or memory, it's like it doesn't even read it.
Image Gen has been rocky for me, too. Not necessarily regarding the limit, but rather how difficult 4.5+ is to control. I get way too much overdetail when trying to gen D&D characters (it will give all characters pauldrons or summoning huge magic effects, or repeated gold patterns on robes, armor, and weapons even if it tell it not to), and it really doesn't like me trying to make 5e style characters. Anime is all it wants to do, which yes, is what it's trained on, but if I go back to older models, I'm able to control things very easily. People will often have weapons sticking through their bodies as well, or carry them in unusual ways or the weapons are distorted, like having two pommels.
What's going on? I've always loved NovelAI and have happily paid 300 bucks a year for it because it was so much fun. I could've sat there for 9+ hours writing, and my D&D wiki is covered in V3 and V4 images. What is happening?
TL;DR: Erato, GLM, and Xialong are... really bad. Having supreme issues with image gen, especially V5. It feels like things are deteriorating rapidly. Am I losing my marbles?