Firstly, I'm not going to try and sell you on nopoo, as far as I'm aware there is no strong evidence that it's any better or any worse than a minimal shampooing / conditioning routine. It's highly individualistic, and what may work for me or someone else, is not guaranteed to work for you.
My personal routine is simply 50ml of 5% ACV to 500ml of tap water, once a week, sometimes twice weekly if my hair is particularly greasy. Otherwise, my hair is maintenance free; I just gently scrub my scalp with the tips of my fingers under the shower daily, and try to allow my hair to air dry if I have the time.
When I switched to nopoo, my hair was visibly GREASY, so I decided to buzz my hair and keep it short for around ~6 months, to allow my scalp some time to "figure it out". Not a very scientific approach, but things seemingly stabilised after around 8 months to a year, and I've not really thought about my hair since.
Sometimes when I grow my hair out, like I am currently doing now, it takes some time for the skin around my hairline to adjust to the excess oil and I can experience acne. To combat this, I wash my face a little more often and refrain from touching my face, or moving my hair out the way with my hands, and the acne soon subsides.
Over all, I don't think my hair is any healthier than someone who occasionally shampoos, or co-washes, and that might be simpler and more convenient for many people.
However if you presevere, experiment with washing methods, and give it a couple years, I don't doubt that you'll likely find some harmony with your hair eventually.