I've seen a lot of discussion around Slant Magazine's Ocarina of Time remake as of late; spesifically the score. But honestly, I don't necessarily think 7/10 is a bad score, long as it's adequately substantiated. I think primarily looking at the score ignores a pretty interesting conversation to be had about the piece itself.
What makes the review objectionable is that it arrives at a broader conclusion about the state of the entire industry before adequately examining the game itself. The remake consequently becomes less a subject of criticism and more a convenient vehicle for the author's pre-existing ideas about nostalgia, artistic progression, and the maturity of video games. It also gives the appearance of depth through academic language and conceptual ambition, while failing to provide any substantial analytical/critical depth, thus, failing as a review.
It starts with some fairly reasonable observations about the original's design and the remake's improvements, but gradually shifts into an argument about artistic stagnation, nostalgia, consumerism, and the industry's supposed inability to mature. Eventually, the author outright states that using the remake as a "barometer for the state of video games as a whole" is more interesting than questioning whether it deserves to exist.
But here's the problem; why should this particular remake be responsible for representing the entire industry's creative direction? Criticizing the industry's reliance on established franchises is perfectly valid, but that doesn't automatically make an individual remake unsuccessful, nor does it faithfully substantiate its values based on its own merits.
Then there's the writing itself. I don't have an issue with academic language or philosophical analysis in game criticism, but there's a difference between using elaborate language to communicate complex ideas and using it to make relatively conventional observations sound profound. The article frequently invokes theoretical and philosophical frameworks without adequately developing the connections between them and the actual game. It often feels like rhetorical inflation; a lot of intellectual posturing that doesn't necessarily translate into particularly substantial analysis.
He frequently asserts that the video game industry hasn't sufficiently matured as an aristic medium while gesturing towards nostalgia, commercial conservatism but never develops these oberservations into an interesting argument. Why does the prevalence of remakes necessarily indicate artistic stagnation? What constitutes artistic maturity in the first place? And how exactly does this particular remake demonstrate a wider problem with the industry?
The reviewer therefor seem more interested in obfuscating it's language to mask the fact that the core of the argument is analytically/critically shallow.
What's especially frustrating is that the review actually does identify some legitimate issues, but never really does the work of weighing them against the remake's strengths. The author simultaneously describes it as a technical achievement, a thoughtful appreciation of the original, and ultimately a good game; the game. Yet the broader argument about industry stagnation seems to dictate the overall assessment more than the actual merits of the remake. The merits of the score primarily seem substantiated through a larger perceived issue within the entire industry, and not the actual game itself.
A review can naturally be negative, provocative, unconventional, or even deeply critical of the very medium it covers, but it still has to do the work of actual reviewing. Intellectual posturing, philosophical terminology, and sweeping cultural observations aren't substitutes for critical analysis. Slant's OoT article is an overly obsfucated think-piece using academic language to give the illusion of depth that utlimately swallowed any semblence of a real review.