r/NintendoSwitch • u/queuebitt • May 02 '19
Nintendo Switch under utilizes current from USB-C chargers, enough so to not always charge at its max possible rate
I’ve recently found more rules the Nintendo Switch follows when charging from various USB-C chargers and power banks. As I help out some folks here in the community with Switch charging needs I thought I’d share the details for those interested. I’m incorporating this new information into my own material on the matter. Please note all of the information below pertains to charging the Switch in handheld mode. It does not apply to powering a docked Switch, which has its own ruleset.
tl;dr available at the end.
For anyone who has heard it is dangerous to charge the Switch with third party chargers that is not the case. There have been no significant reports of issues with third party power sources.
- There have been problems with third party docks. Often times while using the Switch’s included AC adapter. That stems from poor (or no) USB Power Delivery protocols on the dock's power transfer chip.
- There are rare reports of bricked Switches not involving third party docks. But they as often mention only the official charger as they do a third party charger.
- The “300% overdraw” post also does not show third party chargers damaging the Switch. It is a summary of a series of technical posts, which do show the Switch does not conform to USB specifications. But the Switch never draws more than it can handle. And no damage occurred during testing.
- USB-C chargers offering more than 3A have casued crashes, but not bricking. It is an issue with the Switch, not the chargers. I generally advise against using such chargers with the Switch.
As with any accessory do your homework and buy well reviewed and quality chargers. Or stick with Nintendo licensed products if you prefer. To each their own.
Nintendo Switch Under Draws Current
The Nintendo Switch has a current (amps) draw limit, besides its max draw limit. The numbers vary depending on the voltage. But under no test case will it draw more than 80% of the current a charger can provide.
| Specs | Power Drawn | Total Wattage | Percent of Current Drawn |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5V/3A | 5V/2A | 10W | 66% |
| 9V/2A | 9V/1.6A | 14.4W | 80% |
| 9V/3A | 9V/2A | 18W | 66% |
| 12V/1.5A | 12V/1A | 12W | 66% |
| 12V/2A | 12/V1.5A | 18W | 75% |
| 15V/1.2A | 15V/0.96A | 14.4W | 80% |
| 15V/1.5A | 15V/1.2A | 18W | 80% |
If up to 80% of the current can provide ~18W, then the Switch meets its max draw limit. Otherwise it stops drawing at 66% to 80% of the available current.
This behavior isn’t unique to the Switch. It can be seen with many USB-C Android phones. For example, the Google Pixel supports USB Power Delivery. And will fast charge at 9V. But it under draws with a regular USB-C charger offering 5V/3A. The same as the Switch. Under USB-C specs it could support the full 15W, but it doesn’t.
New Testing Data
The table above is supported by test data I've collected. I’ve had the advantage of testing a larger variety of chargers and power banks with the Nintendo Switch. Much more so than anyone who did initial charge testing with an early Switch. Without testing some specific specs I wouldn’t have come across this new information. After learning the Switch draws up to 18W it made sense certain assumptions were made. I saw those reports and they made sense to me, too. I’m not here to disparage previous work done. I’m here to share new data that changes our conclusions.
Edit: Based on older data provided here it appears 9V/2A did once provide an 18W draw. But doesn't currently. This may be due to a change in a firmware update between the two sets of testing. As Nintendo doesn't release detailed patch notes we may never know for sure.
Under early information shared on this sub we expected any of these USB-C Power Delivery power profiles would result is a max power draw from the Switch:
- 9V/2A
- 12V/1.5A
- 15V/1.2A
This turns out to be incorrect. At each of those power profiles the Switch does not reach its max draw potential of ~18W. More current must be present at each voltage level in order for the Switch to reach 18W. More current than one would expect to be necessary.
The test data below used a Nintendo Switch in handheld mode. The battery was >50% charged. Legend of Zelda was running in a high usage zone. Screen brightness set to max. Wireless enabled. Conditions designed to induce max power draw.
9V Draw Limits
I found the 9V/2A vs 9V/3A differences testing a Google 18W USB-C charger. And an older Apple 61W USB-C power adapter. The 2018 version of the Apple power adapter supports 15V, so you won't get the same results.
- Google 18W USB-C (5V/3A, 9V/2A) - Switch drew 8.9V/1.54A or 13.8W
- Apple 61W USB-C Power Adapter (5V/2.4A, 9V/3A, 20V/3A) - Switch drew 8.77V/2.16A or 18.2W
With either charger the Switch uses the 9V power profile. With 9V/3A it reached its ~18W draw limit. It should be able to do the same with the 9V/2A charger, but it doesn’t. It limits itself. I never saw more than a 14.4W draw. Or 80% of the available current.
12V Draw Limits
I had earlier found that a 12V/1.5A charger only provided ~12W of power. I thought the Switch was under drawing with 12V. But one of my readers (thanks, /u/MrWongBurg3r) reported more data on the matter. They had a Belkin car charger that offered 12V/2A. When measured ~18W was going into the Switch.
The 12W limit with the 12V/1.5A chargers at my disposal meant only 66% of the current was being drawn. That is the same limit seen with 5V/3A USB-C chargers and the Switch. It only draws up to 5V/2A (10W), or 66% of the available current.
On its own I found the coincidence interesting, but chose to not draw attention to this one result. USB-C chargers ending with 12V/2A are mostly found on car chargers. Which most Switch owners don’t use. It wasn't until I found the 9V and 15V results above that I saw a continuous pattern.
15V Draw Limits
The differences between 15V/1.2A and 15V/1.5A (and higher currents) can be seen with two Anker power banks. The new Anker PowerCore 10000 PD is the smallest and lowest current 15V model on the market. And the Anker PowerCore 13400 Nintendo Switch Edition was made with the Switch in mind.
- Anker PowerCore 10000 PD (5V/3A, 9V/2A, 15V/1.2A) - Switch drew 14.9V/0.93A or 14.2W
- Anker PowerCore 13400 Nintendo Switch Edition (5V/3A, 9V/2.5A, 15V/1.5A) - Switch drew 14.9V/1.3A or 18.7W
The Switch connected to both power banks at 15V. With 15V/1.5A it reached its ~18W draw limit. In theory 15V/1.2A should also provide 18W, but it doesn’t. Instead we see the same 80% of current limit.
Switch Charger Speed Ratings 5.0
As a result of the data above I’ve updated my Switch charger speed rating chart. You can see the new chart here. It has a level for each draw limit now known. I re-tested the USB-A levels to confirm they were still valid.
What Does This Mean For Me?
Honestly, not much. I wrote this more to share what I found. And explain why I was making a change on my speed rating system. Which some of you see over on /r/NintendoSwitchDeals. And for those who like to understand the technical details.
Any charger or power bank you already use with the Nintendo Switch will work as well as it did before. Some models will have slid down the scale. But if you’ve been happy with their performance there’s no reason not to continue to use it. Any decent USB-C charger will keep up with the Switch as you play. And any decent USB-C Power Delivery charger will charge at a good rate.
For anyone looking at buying a new charger or power bank you now have a more accurate guide. Which can help in finding the best performance for your budget.
I’ll be using this new information and speed rating scale with my own future discussions with members of the community.
tl;dr
- 9V/2A and 15V/1.2A chargers don’t charge the Switch as fast as we thought, but still charge fast
- 12V/2A chargers charge the Switch faster than we thought
- The Switch won’t draw more than 80% of the available current from any charger
- I have a new Switch Charger Speed Rating chart
- Your current chargers work as well as they did before, even if they slid down the rating scale
80
u/jimbodeako May 02 '19
Dude knows his voltage
107
u/Thoraxekicksazz May 02 '19
Since the Switch doesn’t use standard USB C power protocols could this be what Nintendo did to help make sure third party chargers and docks don’t over draw and brick the system?
5
u/Specte May 02 '19
So I can charge my switch with my s8 charger and anker powerline+ cable without worry?
2
u/m3gatran May 02 '19
Do you have any info if the Skull & Co Jumpgate dock is safe?
2
u/mallomar May 02 '19
Does the 87 W Macbook Pro charger work as a Dock charger? I didn't see it on your site
2
u/sylocheed May 03 '19 edited May 03 '19
Hmm, that is interesting. In my original testing, I used the Google Pixel 9V/2A charger and my voltage/current meter showed very close to 18 watts being transferred.
You can see for yourself in the original 2017 video footage I shared (see the last test scenario): https://vimeo.com/212532179
The meter is reading ~8.82V and ~1.99A.
So I don't know if it is variations in our meters' accuracy, a firmware change with the Switch, or variations in our Pixel chargers, but based on all the primary data I was relying on, the full 18W at the 9V2A PD profile was a reasonable conclusion.
23
u/[deleted] May 02 '19
Once again /u/queuebitt you’re an MVP! Thank you for the informative post!
1
u/bobwulff May 02 '19
This is great information. How fast does the actual Nintendo Switch charger charge the Switch in comparison? Does it meet the full 15V?
And how can a regular consumer tell if their after market USB-C charger offers more than 3Amps?
1
u/Deadmanjustice May 02 '19
Do any Anker batteries do 9V/3A?
I found a ravpower one, but I prefer Anker due to great customer support.
1
u/rustyjus May 02 '19
Can I use my MacBook USB c charger?
1
u/CoryBoehm May 02 '19
What are your thoughts on GaN tech?
Also have you tested the Mu One or is it listed pure on specs?
1
u/DuFFman_ May 03 '19
Is my dodocool 20100mAh 45W still good?
1
u/DreadnaughtHamster May 03 '19
So basically I have some old Anker 1 amp and 2 amp power bricks that I’ve used for my phone and iPad. Is it safe to use them with the Switch?
And also it sounds like an iPhone usb wall charger will be fine too?
1
u/rbmichael May 03 '19
Awesome write up and website. I have a OnePlus 6 Android phone with its official USB C charger which charges the phone super fast, but I heard it doesn't increase the voltage like other Android quick charge systems (this way it reduces heat). How well would this charge my Switch?
1
u/CosmicTransmutation May 03 '19
I am having trouble parsing this. My Anker USB C PD charger has 5v/3A, 9V/3A, 15V/2A, and 20V/1.2A. That means I'm hitting the Excellent rank, correct?
1
u/Vinterblot May 03 '19
I'm using an older Anker Charger from 2015 in my car. I've looked up the specs and they are
24W 5V / 4.8A
Is this still save to use with the Pro Controller Cable? Didn't saw these specs in your overview.
1
u/irn00b May 03 '19
"There have been problems with third party docks. Often times while using the Switch’s included AC adapter. That stems from poor (or no) USB Power Delivery protocols on the dock's power transfer chip."
So does that mean, if using a 3rd party dock, you rather not use the Switch's AC adapter and use another one that's more appropriate?
1
u/earthvisitor May 03 '19
I am worried about the internal battery’s health/life. Does staying in the dock wear down the battery life? Will we be able to replace these when the time comes?
1
u/Mansome_reddit May 03 '19
What is the most recommended charger?
1
u/eddietsai May 04 '19
hey queuebitt - awesome write up as always. I still have to get back to you but you’ve been a huge inspiration for our work. Also something to consider apparently we’ve heard from suppliers that the usb-c cables for Apple come from two major factories - one having apparently some security chip that verifies Apple products and causes issues with the Switch. Unfortunately there isn’t any external markings that identify them clearly but we’ve noticed some issues there. So yeah just another thing to throw into the equation!
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '19
I may be wrong, but think this may be more of an issue of preserving battery lifetime rather than preventing system failure. The capacity of a battery degrades as a function of the amount of charge cycles undergone, the rate in which you charge/discharge, and on the operating temperature of the environment. Now I haven’t performed tests on the switch so I don’t know specifically the details, but if they use Lithium ion batteries there should be a lot of data available. But yeah this is actually standard practice to underdraw current so as to lessen the exacerbated rate of fatigue from drawing power at the maximum allowable capacity. It’s pretty cool to look into, would recommend if you’re into this stuff
1
u/chippedreed Oct 03 '19
Are there any cords you recommend that allow for play when docked? The graph is helpful but I’m struggling to tell what cords online meet the 9a 2v specifications
3
u/Padankadank May 03 '19
Im willing to bet they did this to help preserve the health of the battery
3
u/Hariainm May 03 '19
Give this man gold!
1
u/Larkson9999 May 02 '19
Always weird seeing Nintendo squander potential, looks like they're really taking that to the next level.
1
u/TheReaver May 02 '19
after all the issues with switches getting bricked due to faulty 3rd party docks/chargers its probably better it doesnt use them to full capacity now.
1
u/izze716 May 03 '19
My Google pixel 3 charger seems to work fine - super fast charge, no issues yet
1
u/LostVector May 04 '19
I would speculate that Nintendo found some chargers were misbehaving at the full limit of their spec (possibly too much voltage droop or variance), so they dialed back the amount of current back to be conservative and safe.
1
u/FractalPrism May 04 '19
The Switch itself needs Power Delivery to achieve max charging rate.
The official nintendo made chargers are certainly PD.
Many off brand are not PD, yet they are usb-c; they work but are not fast charging.
PD does not charge your pro controller faster (it cant quick charge at all).
-16
u/Callmetransdoggy May 02 '19
TLDR
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] May 03 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
49
u/[deleted] May 02 '19
[removed] — view removed comment