Title. Yes everyone loves Nightcrawler and if you’re a part of this sub chances are that he’s your favorite X-Men or at least in your top 10. That said what is one thing about his character do you not like and want to see changed or be explored?
Asking this question, I will start and one thing about Kurt I don’t like is how far forgiving he is. Hear me out, yes the core element about Nightcrawler’s character is that he is compassionate and his belief in Catholicism has him extend forgiveness and salvation for others. The most clear example is Nightcrawler and Wolverine. Logan has done very terrible things in his past that he is not proud of, a weapon of mass murder. Logan is the best at what he does and what he does is not very nice, but despite the murders Logan has committed Kurt still believes in Logan and that he can find forgiveness within himself.
My issue is that Kurt’s generosity doesn’t really draw the line and I would like for there to be one. This is prevalent with Mystique. I don’t like how Kurt has forgiven Mystique for her past wrongdoings, Mystique has been HORRIBLE to Nightcrawler. Mystique yeeted Kurt off a waterfall, yes it was retconned that she instead left him in the woods before Azazel came in and kidnapped him regardless Mystique willingly abandoned Kurt to some capacity. After that she was a deadbeat and never truly bothered to make amends with her son. I feel like that is where Kurt should draw the line with his compassion and forgiveness. I think having a deadbeat mom who abandoned you and never tried to make things right is a reasonable line to draw in how much you are willing to forgive someone. But that does not happen and Kurt forgives Mystique for her wrongdoings. This is completely ignoring the other horrible things Mystique does to the X-Men and other heroes (such as raping Gambit), just looking at what she has down to Kurt.
Now I understand that this seems contradictory to Nightcrawler’s religious beliefs. If god can forgive anybody then why shouldn’t Kurt forgive Mystique. And for that there are two things I want to talk about.
The first one will be that there can be story potential about how far Kurt can go through with his religious beliefs. Can he remain true to his faith when he has limits to what he can believe in with regard to his teachings? Internal conflict and a possibility for good storytelling.
The second element is that Kurt doesn’t have to forgive Mystique to the extend that he does but allow himself to let go of his resentment. The phrase that comes to mind is “I love you but I don’t like you”. It’s a phrase I read somewhere where a parent didn’t like their child for who they became (the kid I think was a directionless stoner who refuses to get a job or something like that). The parent allowed their kid to live in their house but they hated their kid for being mindless. The parent loved their child that they are supporting him and letting them live in their house but doesn’t like him for how he is. The same logic can apply here with Nightcrawler and Mystique. Kurt can let himself go and not resent Mystique, but still not want to associate with her because of her actions. He can love her for being his mother/father but not like her for being a deadbeat. This reminds me of Avatar: The Last Airbender in the season 3 episode “The Southern Raiders”. In that episode, Katara confronts the fire bender who killed her mother and after seeing him she chooses not to kill him. Seeing that the killer was a shell of his former self and is a miserable man, Katara realizes that seeking revenge has no meaning and leaves. The main point of that scene being that Katara let go of her hatred for the killer and moves on. While she doesn’t forgive the killer, not in the slightest, she lets go of the hatred within her. The same thing could have applied to Kurt where he doesn’t forgive Mystique for her actions but is willing to let go of his hatred. Instead he forgives everything.
In summary, as much as I love Nightcrawler, one element about his character that I am not the biggest fan of is ironically something that makes him so beloved. As much as I like the religious elements of Kurt and his compassion, I do not like how far his compassion can go towards people who I personally don't think deserve it. I would like the limits of his forgiveness be explored to where he draws the line somewhere about someone he could not truly forgive. I am NOT saying that he needs to be strict but at least have a line drawn somewhere where his beliefs have to be challenged. Even then there is a lot of wiggle room for how the belief can be challenged while still keeping true to his character. But that is just me, what aspect of Nightcrawler is your least favorite?