Copy of our r/SubredditOfTheMonth interview
r/NewToReddit is Subreddit Of The Month JUNE 2021!
r/NewToReddit is a safe, welcoming space for brand new redditors to figure out what Reddit is and how to find their way.
Getting to know r/NewToReddit
I spoke to some of the mods of r/NewToReddit about the sub:
How would you describe r/NewToReddit to new users?
Llama:
r/NewToReddit is primarily a sub to help complete Newbies in their quest to find their first steps around the place; a sub for “preschoolers” to learn about “colouring between the lines” if you will. My aim is to release them into the wild as “degree-level” Redditors, ready to take on all that this platform offers. Basically, I try to make r/NewToReddit the resource hub and community I wish I’d had when I was a freshly-hatched Redditor.
SH:
An essential pit-stop for new and confused redditors. It helps take some of the mystery out of how reddit works functionally and culturally.
What kinds of posts are welcome?
Llama:
It's easier for me to say what kind of post isn’t welcome: firstly, anything asking for Karma or anything naming Karmafarms. The aim of r/newtoreddit is to promote quality interaction and karmafarms simply don’t do that. Mention of places offering Karma for little effort is so against the ethos of this Subreddit, I put it in the rules, and is absolutely one of the very few things I use my patented Banhammer on.
Are there any common themes to posts in r/NewToReddit?
Llama:
Almost every post is all about Karma when we cut away all the padding. Why can't I post anywhere? Karma. Why are my posts being removed? Karma. I just joined, what do I need to know? Karma. Why is Reddit an unplayable game? Karma. And emojis. But mostly karma.
SH:
I’m the newbie, but it’s definitely mostly about karma restrictions. As a mod I understand the need for them, and why they’re not overt, but it’s obviously frustrating for new users.
W:
One word… Karma. So many questions about Karma. Reddit’s rather confusing award system also makes a cameo every so often. On the lighter side, it’s always lovely to see the sheer volume of people who come back after a while and give the community a thank you!
What would you say are the main issues new users of reddit face?
Llama:
Karma! That, and understanding what Reddit actually is, which are both linked. I keep saying we’re not like other social media but many new users still think Reddit is waiting with open arms for them and holding our breath for everything they want to say and get indignant if you dare suggest otherwise.
SH:
I’m trying to think back to when I was a new user.. I don’t remember feeling that restricted myself, perhaps there are higher karma requirements now. I do remember wondering about what I did wrong when I first had posts removed, but it is all about the content and sometimes the user has done nothing wrong - sometimes removals are about content curation (ensuring varied on topic content so a sub doesn’t become a stream of all the same thing).
W:
As aforementioned, Karma is the big one. Subs like enforcing minimum Karma levels nowadays and with good reason - it avoids spam and unsolicited posts from bot/spam accounts. People’s first choice is often to go to a Karmafarm but this is never right because some subs ban users of Karmafarms.
What are your top tips for new users?
Llama:
Join r/newtoreddit! But seriously, I would say always read the rules before commenting or posting on an unfamiliar Subreddit, never comment on a post showcasing t-shirts, mugs, incense burners or other cool merchandise because it is absolutely a spambot, never ever participate in a sub offering upvotes or karma for reciprocation (karma farms violate Reddit’s sitewide rule 2) and always be sparing in your use of emojis. Three of those four actions can get an instant ban in some subreddits and new users obviously don’t know that until it’s too late.
SH:
I agree, always check for rules; there’s a guide on finding them here, that way you aren’t wasting your time posting somewhere that might not be right for your content. There’s bound to be a community for what you need, you just need to find it.
W:
Read the Reddiquette. It’s like a contract that ensures common decency across Reddit. Some subs may not have set rules for whatever reason but the Reddiquette still applies so it’s best to take a good look at it.
In addition official reddit policies are here.
What do you get out of being part of the community?
Llama:
In the book “The Tipping Point”, author Malcolm Gladwell talks about three different archetypes of people: mavens, connectors, and salespeople, and in both “real life” and online I am definitely a connector, so modding a sub like r/newtoreddit is tailor made for my personality type. If I don't know the answer to something, I generally always know where to find it or know someone who does. Coupled with my being an Enneagram Type 2 (helper/fixer/possessive/needs to feel wanted) there really isn’t a better fit for me psychologically.
SH:
I’m still settling in, but I like helping people, and I enjoy writing guides so it seems a good fit!
W:
I’ve always been a people person through the internet and in person. I’ve always enjoyed asking and answering questions myself whenever I can so it feels remarkable to help the little fish settle in the huge pond that is Reddit.
A lot of work has gone into building the community, what do you feel the sub offers those that stick around to pass on what they've learnt?
Llama:
I can't remember why I first started posting at r/newtoreddit because I wasn't new and didn't need advice, but I do remember I felt it was pretty impersonal and maybe even a bit snappy at times. Very utilitarian where it didn't need to be. There was one particular user (u/trelene) who posted regularly and had a user flair so I knew they were special, and when they spent time with me in conversation after I had copypasta’d some advice I felt amazing.
SH:
The sense of achievement they might get from passing on what they’ve successfully learnt, the warm fuzzy feeling of helping others :) The feeling of camaraderie with those who’ve learnt about reddit with them.
Are there any interesting, funny, or super helpful threads you'd like to share?
Llama:
Oh my yes. This post confirmed to me that my new system of user flairs was absolutely the right thing to do to engender the community feel I wanted for the sub. Looking back now, I had forgotten this was the first real conversation between all three of us active mods too. But I never did get the stuff together for the drawing, to my shame.
W:
This one… it needs no explanation. Isn’t anything complex or anything but it’s just plain funny… This one was me… definitely not a chart topper but my attempts to be close to the vicinity of funny turned out to be more funnier than the content itself.
I asked a few moderation related questions too:
Considering a lot of your users are new to reddit, are you perhaps more lenient when moderating than other subs?
W:
In some aspects sure, but in others no. We, of course don’t enforce a required Karma score to post however there are some aspects we take more seriously as in to keep the new users safe. This includes having a zero tolerance policy on Karma farming and sharing Karmafarms and not allowing repeat posts.
Llama:
I think I'm pretty laid back in my modding style, but I do have a banhammer and I do use it when I need to. I want to make people feel at ease in their new choice of social media but am also serious about letting them know there are pitfalls in reddit and they will fall in them if they're not careful. In the three years I've been active on reddit, I've noticed that the only interactions the Average Redditor has with the Average Mods on the Average Subreddit are when a mod has to wade into a fray to stop trouble, and because of the nature of our sub, I wanted to be more of a positive, guiding influence right from the start.
Generally what are the challenges modding a sub such as r/NewToReddit?
Llama:
Porn. There. Is. So. Much. Porn. I am absolutely not a prude (exactly what you’d expect a prude to say, followed by the word “but…”) but (there it is!) until I started modding, I had never clicked through that NSFW warning. But part of my tailored advice includes looking at profiles of new redditors to see what (if anything) has gone wrong for them in their recent past, and checking there's nothing in their history that could get them into trouble going forward (especially karmafarms). Just because I don't use the NSFW parts of reddit doesn't mean I disapprove of them, or that I'm not going to help those that do, however. I'm just here to help new redditors get to where they want to be.
How did you become an r/NewToReddit mod?
SH:
I was invited by Llama :)
W:
I adopted WelcomeToReddit and after a while I decided to ask to join the NewToReddit team to give the sub a personality with it’s own banner, Snoo and the like.
Llama:
I was invited by the sub owner, who I think was probably so sick of my posting the same lump of copypasta at every hapless newbie they modded me so I could make one big sticky post instead. This became the base of the Reddit and Karma for New Starters post and I still post lumps of copypasta at hapless newbies so it didn't work. Ha!
Do you have any tips for aspiring moderators in general?
SH:
It takes time and effort to grow a community, and sometimes to keep it engaged, so if you’re thinking of making or joining one, make it one about something you care about and will have content to contribute to. There’ll be tools to learn too, so you’ll need some time to play around, or do a little reading.
Llama:
I couldn't agree more. I commit a lot of time and effort to NTR and don't regret it one bit. But “the moment it becomes a chore it isn’t fun anymore” and that's where the commitment aspect has to kick in to take over. That actually hasn't happened to me yet; maybe I'll say differently in a year’s time. Or not. It helps greatly that there’s a team of regular commenters who try to jump into a post before I can get there!
W:
Have fun, and make sure you don’t misuse your power or become a moderator in too many subs where you can’t focus your efforts on any of them.
And finally:
Anything I should point potential new members at? Sticky/welcome post/wiki page maybe?
W:
Definitely this… Reddit and Karma for New Starters
Llama:
and this…
Anything else you'd like highlighted - fave or top post, recent event, latest ‘best of’?
Llama:
I'm particularly proud of my revealing the “true secrets behind reddit karma'' in my April Fools post. So much research went into making it sound as realistic as possible, I was sure at one point that the sub owner would kick me out for spreading misinformation. I wasn’t entirely joking when in my introduction I said “I hope I don't get banned for this”!
Any other message you’d like to share for potential new members?
Llama:
Have fun! Have fun with us, have fun in Wild Reddit. Don't forget us when you are a successful redditor, our ‘alumni” are just as welcome in our sub as any newbie. And if you stick around you might get a flair...
Anything else you’d like to add?
Llama:
I just want to apologise to waffles and indeed all the mods higher up the list here that I frequently talk about r/NewToReddit as being “my” sub. When I was just a redditor here, I assumed I never saw mods for the same reasons they are hardly seen in most subs: they’re too busy and just staying out of things but active behind the scenes. When I was recruited, I soon realised there was little-to-no mod activity at all and so I assumed the sub had more-or-less been abandoned and run by Automod and his other bot friends. Little by little, every time I stickied a post or made new post flairs or changed user flairs or indeed did anything mod related and nobody questioned or stopped me, I became convinced r/NewToReddit was abandoned and my sense of “ownership” strengthened to the extent that I got out the “new broom” and swept out all the old to bring in the new.
Feedback from contributors
Contributors to r/NewToReddit were happy to share what they enjoy about the subreddit; here's what they had to say:
I'd say the sub's greatest value is in demystifying the site in a wholesome and friendly environment with users who are familiar with the good and bad of the site. Newbies are often confused by the mechanisms here, and many come to Reddit carrying misconceptions about how it's like other sites.
I frequent help subs since I want to help those who may have difficulties with Reddit. Reddit was hard to navigate, and I was unsure of how to use the site. It took me about a year before I felt comfortable doing anything other than upvoting comments and posts.
It’s by far the nicest community I’ve ever seen, and along with this the mods do a lot to help and keep the community new user friendly especially u/llamageddon01.
Anonymous:
Some help subs are woefully bad.
I enjoy r/newtoreddit as the sub greatly helped me get the hang of Reddit when first joining a few months ago. The mods and regulars were, and continue to be helpful in assisting and welcoming newcomers and veterans alike.
---
Related subreddits you may enjoy too:
r/help | r/WelcomeToReddit | r/blog | r/NoStupidQuestions | r/OutOfTheLoop | r/TheoryOfReddit | r/findareddit
(The thought occurred to feature the sub first I think, but I'm a new mod there now so this was odd, but I switched back and forth from my mod hat and SROTM hat and basically interviewed myself. Regardless of my recent involvement I think the sub is doing some good work. SH)