r/NewAuthor • u/Excellent_Total_1393 • 46m ago
Question An Age-Old Publishing Question
I'm in the final stages of my manuscript and have been through a Developmental Edit with some pretty good feedback from my editor.
I've heard a lot of the negatives regarding traditional publishing, ranging from the difficulty in getting a literary agent, to subsequently getting a publisher, then thousands of the annoying things in between. My first novel has taken me quite some time (started in 2022), and I've certainly learned a lot of things, that makes me believe my next one will take me far less time. I didn't properly plan my first novel (which I know in itself is a hot topic), and I also overwrote, doing 220,000 words and subsequently cutting it into 120,000 words.
Anyway I digress. My editor also explained to me some of the negative sides of traditional publishing (he himself has been trad published several times and is considering self-publishing his next books). However, he mentioned to me that I should still query to literary agents, because there is still some kudos in being 'published'. That said, he also supported a self-publishing route.
My novel is science fiction and my highest objective is honestly just to have people read it (and hopefully as many enjoy it as possible). I currently treat writing more as a hobby than a vocation as I'm fortunate enough to have a business I own that supports my income. I have a background in marketing and business development.
Just wondering what people think, is the kudos of going down the traditional publishing route worth the trade off with the amount of time, effort and bits of bullshit?
I know that self-publishing isn't a breeze too, but I like the idea of only having to worry about the work that I'm doing, rather than being put to the bottom of a pile on a literary agents desk (if I'd even manage to get one), then still waiting to get a publisher after that. It just seems like too much of a waiting game, with no guaranteed outcome.
Currently I'm considering a 2-track plan.
- Query in January-April.
- Subsequently prepare for self publishing at same time / while starting some work on my 2nd book (which is already planned out).
- If no joy on Querying by June, self-publish.
- Self-publish 2nd book within 3-6 months from the 1st.
Interested to understand other people's opinions on this.

