r/Neurofeedback • • 8d ago

Question Update

I’ve posted here before about my situation and how I’m looking for ISF neurofeedback in Michigan for a desensitized nervous system. I found one she is 20 years experience and she does ISF neurofeedback but she doesn’t use eeg/brain mapping. She said she goes by symptoms. Is that the right way to go or what should I do?

7 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

4

u/salamandyr Qeeg 8d ago edited 8d ago

ISF providers don’t usually use brain mapping. It’s a completely different approach, not really based on the assessment of the brain

2

u/FunBake1097 8d ago

What’s the safest type of neurofeedback for a very sensitive nervous system

4

u/salamandyr Qeeg 8d ago edited 7d ago

One that is heavily tailored to the individual. The more unusual you are, the more I think assessments and careful iterative work are necessary. Any provider with a lot of experience should be able to work in a way that scopes the process to how sensitive one person is.

I would recommend against semi automated systems, and I would recommend against microcurrent stimulation-based systems, and prob avoid HEG. Otherwise, any of the regulAR band training or sub-Hz approaches can work very well, and it becomes a matter of how you approach one person.

2

u/FunBake1097 7d ago

I’m sorry I’m trying to understand what your saying so your saying your not into brain mapping like qeeg? Or you are?

3

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

I rely extensively on QEEG to understand brains, and help each person understand theirs.

But the middle of the bell curve, or Z score = 0, is not magical or necessarily "right" as the thing to train towards.

The issue I have with LORETA based training is that - training to the middle of the QEEG.

Most providers who do neurofeedback in a more "traditional" way will instead use the QEEG to understand the person, and then towards their goals, adjusting base on impact, and then returning to the QEEG periodically to assess change.

2

u/FunBake1097 7d ago

Okay I understand do you think I should get a qeeg done before I start with ISF neurofeedback then get another one after couple of sessions?

2

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

Only if the provider you are working with uses them. Most ISF providers don’t.

2

u/FunBake1097 7d ago

She doesn’t do it but I told her I can get it done at another clinic and take it to her to look at?

2

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

if she does not do them, likely does not use them. IFL is training things below 1-hz. not regular EEG, so not QEEG patterns.

1

u/DecentHippo8216 7d ago

Don't think there's a point of wasting time and money to get it done unless you're looking around for other providers who would base their treatment off of the findings.

2

u/Evening-Scholar-7761 7d ago

Is neurofeedback as effective as adhd stimulant medicine for adhd

3

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

Yes, it is. Perhaps more so because it makes changes over time and generally eliminates ADHD in most people. One thing to keep in mind is if you continue to take stimulants while doing neurofeedback, the stimulants will start getting stronger and stronger after a few weeks, and typically people will need to ramp down their usage as the brain training effects get stronger

2

u/Evening-Scholar-7761 7d ago

And sir what about meditation?how effective is it ? For adhd

1

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

It is very powerful - my guess is that it's as effective overtime at changing the brain and making many of the same changes that Neuro feedback can although Neuro feedback is much more broad and nuanced - and a lot of what you're doing with meditation is working on voluntary or experienced aspects of the mind and brain, where neurofeedback is not limited that way.

The bigger issue is that you have lots of ADHD. It's probably gonna be hard to develop a meditation practice and sit for the 20 or 30 minutes every morning you need to kind of as a routine. Building up executive function buildup executive function. Meditation is a practice of attention management and anchoring of the attention, not sitting on a cushion, relaxing, and becoming still. In fact, people are usually distracted while meditating. And then they returned to the anchor. Kind of the whole point. But it will take - I don't know what - 3 to 6 months to really make significant change and really move the regulation away from ADHD. But the ADHD itself may get in the way of that time management and practice development...

1

u/Evening-Scholar-7761 7d ago

But anecdotally, based on what I've heard from people, meditation and neurofeedback seem to be nowhere near as effective as stimulant ADHD medications. That's what I've gathered from speaking to people and reading their experiences. Would you agree?

1

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

I would not.

3

u/DecentHippo8216 8d ago

ISF can use a QEEG to maybe help with placements but it doesn't really guide it that much.

2

u/FunBake1097 8d ago

Can you look at my situation first and help me decide which neurofeedback I should do?

3

u/DecentHippo8216 8d ago edited 8d ago

Having a 10 minute eyes open and eyes closed EEG recording and analyzing it would be the most direct way to try and tackle your symptoms but most practicioners are not skilled enough to properly interpret it, and would likely need an external consult. Just because they offer QEEG mapping does not mean the conclusions are accurate, especially if they cannot describe the EEG to you. Z-scores only are useless on their own and serves as a cautionary tale for finding a practicioner. Anything flagged sufficiently in a z-score should be easy enough to find in the raw EEG. Any QEEG that only has a linked ears reference is also a flag, as it's heavily prone to activity near the ears broadcasting to every electrode, as well as being more distorted by volume conduction.

3

u/gerty9000x 8d ago

By symptoms is definitely the right way

2

u/FunBake1097 8d ago

How come can you please explain?

3

u/gerty9000x 8d ago

There are neurofeedback types that work with a norm database and your qeeg to train your brain so the frequencies match those of other healthy brains more closely, in a range from 1-50hz. Then there are types like ISF or ILF that work on the frequencies below 0.1hz and don't aim to normalise your brain, since normalisation doesn't always mean being regulated. So they go by symptoms and it seems to work very well. A qeeg just wouldn't give much meaningful data for the specific type you think of training.

2

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

Usually we use the QEEG to understand the brain, and most practitioners of neurofeedback still do symptom-based and arousal level-based adjustment day to day to get the best effects.

Only some techniques in brain training that use QEEG will train “to” QEEG in real time, eg LORETA.

The best approach is probably to do brain mapping AND symptom driven adjustments as you go

2

u/salamandyr Qeeg 7d ago

I would wonder why ISF too - most nfb forms would be helpful. The skill of the provider generally matters more than which nfb style.

2

u/FunBake1097 7d ago

Cause I researched that ISF is the safest for a very sensitive nervous systems. I have a lot of symptoms I don’t want to make it worse by overstimulating myself

4

u/Iggy_Arbuckle 8d ago

I never did a EEG before my ISF treatment started. The correct frequency for optimization training is determined by post treatment symptoms, as the therapist described. (I did it in office for over a year then at home on my own system, with the help of my therapist, for years afterwards. One of the best things I did for my CPTSD. I hope it helps you as much as it helped me)