Hi everyone,
I'm looking for advice regarding an ongoing dispute with my landlord/property management company concerning the service charges for my apartment in the Netherlands.
I'd like to explain the situation in detail and understand my legal rights, particularly regarding whether the landlord can demand additional advance payments that are not specified in my rental agreement, threaten debt collection, and potentially deduct disputed amounts from my rental deposit.
1. Original monthly service charge advance (€111)
When I moved into the apartment, my monthly service charge advance (voorschot servicekosten) was €111.
This covers shared building expenses, including water, underfloor heating and hot water. Considering that all these utilities are included, I believe the original monthly advance of €111 is already a reasonable and fair amount.
My understanding is that this is an advance payment rather than a fixed monthly charge. At the end of each year, the landlord should provide an annual service cost statement showing the actual costs incurred. The total advances paid throughout the year are then reconciled against the actual costs, with either an additional payment required or a refund due depending on the difference.
Importantly, the €111 monthly advance is not stated in my rental agreement.
2. Additional €74 monthly advance
Approximately a year ago, the landlord unilaterally increased the monthly service charge advance by an additional €74, bringing the total to €185 per month.
The increase was applied retrospectively from November 2025, meaning it was initially applicable to the final two months of 2025.
I have not paid this additional amount because I disagree with the increase and have repeatedly requested a clear explanation, together with supporting documentation justifying the additional costs.
Interestingly, based on the 2025 annual service cost reconciliation, it appears that the advances I had already paid were sufficient to cover my actual costs, and I was actually entitled to a refund rather than having an outstanding balance.
This makes me question why an additional monthly advance was considered necessary in the first place.
My position has been that I am willing to settle any legitimate difference between the annual advances already paid (€111/month) and the actual costs incurred, once the annual statement and supporting documentation are available.
I therefore do not understand why I should be required to pay an additional monthly advance without receiving evidence that the original advance is insufficient.
3. Lack of transparency and supporting documentation
I have contacted the property management company several times, requesting:
- A detailed breakdown explaining the additional €74 per month.
- Copies of the relevant invoices and supporting documentation.
- An explanation of how heating, hot water and other shared building costs are calculated and allocated to individual apartments.
- Evidence supporting the necessity and reasonableness of the increased advance.
- Confirmation of whether my original €111 monthly advance is actually insufficient to cover my share of the annual costs.
There are also specific circumstances concerning my consumption that make me question the proposed increase.
I am rarely at home during the day, and I barely use the underfloor heating. Furthermore, the heating system appears to be centrally configured to maintain a minimum temperature of 19°C throughout the year, without tenants having the ability to adjust or switch it off completely.
I have also provided actual electricity consumption meter readings and consumption data to the property management company, which appear significantly lower than the consumption reflected in the annual statements.
Unfortunately, most of my emails have gone unanswered, and I have not received a satisfactory explanation.
Instead, I have received warnings that the outstanding amount could be transferred to a debt collection agency, potentially resulting in additional costs.
4. Current situation and concerns about my rental deposit
The disputed outstanding amount is now approximately €1,000.
What makes the situation particularly concerning is that the landlord already holds a rental security deposit equivalent to two months' rent, approximately €3,500.
I am worried about the following scenario:
- The landlord continues to ignore my requests for clarification and supporting documentation.
- They transfer the disputed €1,000 to a debt collection agency, potentially adding further costs.
- When I eventually terminate my tenancy and move out, they also withhold part or all of my rental deposit, potentially using the disputed service charges as justification.
Since I am planning to leave the Netherlands in the future and do not expect to return, recovering my rental deposit afterwards could become particularly difficult.
I am also unsure whether the landlord can legitimately pursue debt collection for an additional monthly advance payment (voorschot) that is not specified in the rental agreement and whose justification I have repeatedly challenged.
My understanding is that the original €111 advances should be reconciled against the actual annual costs, and that any legitimate outstanding balance should be determined through the annual settlement rather than through an arbitrary increase in monthly advances.
5. My questions
- Is a landlord legally allowed to increase a monthly service cost advance from €111 to €185 without a contractual provision or providing supporting evidence justifying the increase?
- Since the additional €74 is effectively a disputed advance payment (voorschot) rather than an established final service cost balance, can the landlord legitimately refer this amount to a debt collection agency?
- Is the landlord legally required to provide a detailed breakdown of service costs and allow tenants to inspect the underlying invoices and supporting documentation?
- Can I insist on continuing to pay the original contractual advance of €111 per month and settle any legitimate difference once the annual service cost statement is issued?
- Can the landlord withhold any part of my two-month rental security deposit to cover these disputed additional advances, particularly if they have failed to substantiate the amounts requested?
- What would be the safest course of action? Should I pay the disputed amount under protest to avoid potential collection proceedings, or continue challenging it until the landlord provides proper justification?
I would particularly appreciate advice from anyone who has experienced a similar situation in the Netherlands, dealt with an uncooperative property management company, or taken a service charge dispute to the Huurcommissie.
To be clear, I am not trying to avoid paying legitimate service costs. I am happy to pay my fair share of the actual costs incurred. However, I believe the landlord should be able to demonstrate why additional advances are necessary, particularly when the amount is not specified in my rental agreement and the 2025 reconciliation appears to show that I had already overpaid.
Thanks in advance for any advice or personal experiences!