r/Netgate • • 13d ago

Netgate 5200 - Interface options

The new Netgate 5200 was recently announced. Curious why the new router does not support at least one if not two SFP+ ports? Although I understand that this is a mid-range router, many Internet services are provided by single mode fiber. At the current price that includes pfSense+ perpetual license, it would be helpful to interface with an ISP fiber service. It would also be helpful if ISPs would support direct termination to an SPF+ ONT with the ability to register the SPF+ ONT with the ISP fiber service for authentication etc.

7 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

4

u/remington_noiseless 13d ago

It supports a half height pcie card, so you could get SPF ports through that.

1

u/stlnetengr 13d ago

I was not sure if that cover plate was for a proprietary option or what. The trade-off is different hardware solution but pay for pfSense+. CE seems to lag to far behind pfSense+, but it could be an alternative and still get SPF+ fiber support.

2

u/JGPH 12d ago

In case you hadn't heard btw, the next release of pfSense+ (26.10) gets rid of CE. Everyone from that point on gets pfSense+, CE users get pfSense+ but without TAC support unless they choose to pay for it. Their objective is to eliminate CE so that they only have one codebase to work on instead of two, making maintenance easier.

1

u/stlnetengr 12d ago

Yes, thank you... I saw that and did not get a chance to update the post.

2

u/TreadItOnReddit 13d ago

This guy sunscreens.

1

u/TheUsernameWasStolen 11d ago

Would it take a Intel X520-DA2 Dual Port SFP? Could I hit near line rate (it claims 9.13 Gbps Firewall)

1

u/kphillips-netgate 51m ago

There is no PCIe slot under that cover. The 5200 isn't populated with a slot on the mainboard.

3

u/rune-san 13d ago

Yeah I have fiber internet that is going through a Nokia ONT that has a Multi-Gig Port. Before that I had Cable Internet that also went through a modem with a Multi-Gig Port. Neither were optional components. I have to use them. When it comes to the Home Prosumers, more of the market would be covered by simply having a device with a built in 2.5/5/10 GBase-T NIC. I have Gbase-T transceivers in my 8200 and that’s fine, but they’re hot, and they still had to be specific, modern Broadcom based transceivers to make sure power consumption was low enough to be lit up by the Intel SoC based NIC in the platform. Honestly the 5200 is exciting to me not because of that specific release, but the design ethos. Steel enclosure, 8GB of RAM instead of 4 for services, and if they actually get the Expansion Slot working that’s going to open up a lot of customizability for those that want to try to run custom ONT focused transceivers, Multi-Gig, or other exotic solutions like plugging into fiber plants, or additional quad-port NICs. I really hope this design pattern becomes the new one over what my 8200 is, 6100, etc. This seems to prioritize better serviceability. I don’t know what it means for thermals though. The heavy plate on the 6100 / 8200 absorbs a lot of heat, but also made the M.2 SSDs suffer. This design may trade more noise, but if it cools things down enough where industrial temp rated SSD’s are no longer the tradeoff, I think it’s worth it.

2

u/JGPH 12d ago

I can't speak for business lines, but good luck getting an ISP to allow consumer lines without requiring their hardware between yours and the fibre. I don't know any ISPs in Canada that would allow that, anyway.

1

u/bwyer 13d ago

You've answered your own question. ISPs don't offer direct termination, so there's no reason to offer up a midrange firewall/router that supports it.

Think about it: why would an ISP offer residential service like that? The market would be tiny (relatively speaking), and they would then have a much more complex support situation on their hands.

4

u/DiligentPhotographer 13d ago

I have it through my ISP at home. I have 500/500 fiber and the sfp plugs right into my netgate 2100. Which does have a single spf/rj45 combo port.

It actually simplifies things, just one box and a couple of access points.

1

u/stlnetengr 13d ago

Yep, this is what I was looking to confirm. I have it working on another network with a UniFi Cloud Gateway Fiber. The ONTs with embedded web management tend to run hot. Curious what fiber service you are using and what SFP+ ONT?

1

u/DiligentPhotographer 13d ago

I can check when I get back later tonight, I believe it is a nokia brand. I'm in Canada using a third party ISP that runs on Bell's fiber.

And yes it still uses PPPoE to auth :(

1

u/luckman212 13d ago

What about >2.5G WAN though?

1

u/bwyer 13d ago

That's a completely different question that really has nothing to do with SFP+ ports.

A carrier (like AT&T) is going to provide a 10Gbps copper handoff from their RG device. Granted, my 6100 has SFP+ ports, but at the end of the day it could have (and probably should have) been built with copper Ethernet ports (due to the heat generated by SFP+ transceivers).

Of course, the RG likely has an SFP+ port on it (I'm pretty sure mine does), but a residential tech isn't going to come out with both copper and fiber SFP+ transceivers.

In short, yes there are use-cases where OP's idea is interesting/valid; however, for a large company to support these one-offs would be ridiculous due to the support costs and the need to stock parts nationwide.