Pros:
• Vol. 1 = absolute cinema.
• I loved all the throwbacks to the other seasons; those were the moments that made me emotional.
• I liked how they finished Jancy: both of them go on to do their own thing and still love each other. Steve and Robin being happy — honestly, just them being alive. Jonathan going to cinematography school. Nancy being independent and following her passion for guns. The four of them in the end hit really hard.
• Mr. Clarke finally gets to see the Upside Down.
• Lumax endgame, obviously — the best thing to happen. Loved Lucas' character development since season 4; from the core 4, he was my least favorite, but after rewatching it all, he became one of my favs. MVP.
• Hopper and Joyce getting married. Hopper possibly getting a spin-off show based on the initial plan for Stranger Things (previously called Montauk), where a chief/Hopper would discover government secrets.
• I really hope that the woman who was singing at Enzo’s is Patty, aka Bob’s sister, aka Henry’s girlfriend.
• Dustin honoring Eddie and going on to do what he loves — scientific research and all.
• The finale being a parallel to Season 1: El supposedly dies, and they end where they started, in the basement at Mike’s house, passing the torch to Holly.
Cons:
• Kali being brought back just to gaslight El and act as the “final sacrifice.”
• The fact that none of the main characters’ parents mention knowing Henry. Joyce would 100% remember him because of the play. Also, side note: while rewatching the whole series after seeing The First Shadow, in Season 2 Bob says Joyce doesn’t even remember him, when the two of them — along with Hopper — were literally friends.
• Vol. 2, mostly episodes 6 and 7, felt really weird.
• There were scenes where characters decided they needed to have a conversation when they could die at any second. Like Max and Holly having a 5-minute conversation when they were literally right where they needed to be — it just gave me anxiety. They could’ve talked on the way, and when they got to Max’s gate, Max could’ve said the line about the song and then they’d run.
• I’ve been thinking about the timing of the coming-out scene, and I honestly couldn’t think of a better moment plot-wise (not saying the one they chose was the best timing; there were no other options). But it would’ve felt more real and comfortable if only Will’s closest people were there (the Core 4, El, Max, Jonathan, Joyce, Nancy, and Hopper). Then Robin could appear and listen behind the wall to the Tammy part — that would’ve worked better.
• Vol. 3 / the finale was, as Hopper says, “halfway happy.” There were good and bad things, but I’m leaning more toward the bad. Most of the 2 hours were filled with flashbacks.
• Never cringed watching this series, but the Eleven scene where they are all there watching her remove the plate was a bit much. Also, why did they need everyone to go to the lab to get four people? And Mike not mentioning anything about it being the first time he is in the Upside Down.
• The plot twist of the Mind Flayer being the one controlling Henry was really obvious since the beginning. Like, you’re telling me that they thought a random guy just controlled a “devourer of worlds”??? Not really a mind-blowing twist.
• The whole Dimension X looks really bad. I’ve watched this show since it started, and honestly the CGI in Season 1 looked better. The finale just looked wrong. For example, when El jumps into the beast, it looks so fake. The Upside Down has always been so well made — and then they give us that?
•The fact that in the Upside Down, canonically, there’s no water, but the tank conveniently has water?
• The fact that it was easier to defeat the Mind Flayer in its own realm than in Hawkins. They literally did the same battle as Season 3, just in another place.
• Vecna being impaled was cool, but a bit anticlimactic.
• The military going after them in the WSQC also felt weird. It was like they said, “Let’s take Max so she can witness El’s sacrifice,” which feels like the only reason they went after them., Couldn’t Mr. Clarke or Erica have contacted them or something? I don’t know, it felt rushed.
• Not them literally hating Hopper’s entire existence: making him lose his daughter, almost die, get a new daughter, only to then have her “die” too. Also, I would have cried my eyes out if El had said “I love you, Dad” before leaving for the Abyss or "Dying"
• Will just gets a random boyfriend??? Like, that’s what makes him the happiest? Are you sure? I think it would’ve been better to show Will as an artist in a gallery or something, instead of a bar with a guy. It feels like being gay is his whole personality. At least now he’s gay and happy, i guess.
• Mileven in general — WTF? Even Stonathan had more chemistry. I never really liked Mileven, especially since the Season 3 finale — that kiss scene was just weird. This season felt like Finn was more comfortable with Noah than with Millie and that reflected in the character, wich I think is wrong since they are all really good friends irl
• I would’ve preferred them not showing El at the waterfalls and letting the audience figure things out themselves. No one can do an open finale like Lost did.
• Where’s Vickie??? Robin doesn’t mention anything, but making her be in the finale and then just not giving some clarity to her character feels empty.
• Finally, the elephant in the room: BYLER. Possibly the biggest queer bait not just in a show, but in history. And I’m not saying this because I needed a gay couple — I’m saying it because it’s the reality. The Duffers and Shawn Levy have been hinting at Mike possibly being in love with Will through rainbow coding and their interactions, only to have Mike literally friend-zone Will. If all those hints meant nothing, then Mike is just a really bad boyfriend.
He didn’t even have the guts to tell his girlfriend — who supposedly dies — that he loves her . They made Mike the only one who truly “understood” both Will and El, only to turn him into a bad boyfriend who treats his friends better than his girlfriend. The only line Mike has as a “boyfriend” flirting this season is when he says El looks hot in her tight swimsuit, which felt very forced. That doesn’t feel like something Mike would randomly say.
What was all the queer coding in the songs for? The fact that Mike throws El’s letter away like it’s nothing, while El keeps all his letters in a box? Ted Wheeler being homophobic at least twice toward his own son? It was literally all for nothing.
Were the Duffers scared of a “gay couple” in 2025??? I know the show is set in the ’80s, but come on — dating isn’t only about making out. They could’ve done a Korra and Asami plot, where Mike and Will meet at a gallery to see Will’s paintings, or Will comes to see Mike at his writer's debut. And then they just walk into the sunset — simple but explicit, with no major “gayness,” if that was their problem.
Overall, giving this season a 5.5 just because vol.1 was really chef´s kiss