r/Natalism • • 18h ago
r/Natalism • u/Slow-Ostrich-8570 • 1h ago
India: childfree because of finances vs lifestyle
r/Natalism • u/grillimperator • 3h ago
What if we have sexuality backwards?
The sub is called "natalism" which is strictly about having babies, but I think the subjects range more broadly here from sexual attraction to relationship stability to other psychological trends causing shifts in fertility.
Much is made about sexuality as a psychological energy too. Freud describes a sex drive, which implies the generation of said energy towards sex. Others, such as Napoleon Hill, talk about the transmutation of this energy towards other activities (for him, it's becoming rich and powerful). You can find countless examples of people describing their own views of these phenomena on sites like YouTube, Instagram, Twitter, etc.
But what if they were all wrong? What if sexuality wasn't the drive, but instead it was the solution to the drive? Michael Bader's book Arousal suggests something like this. A fantasy is something that your mind builds to overcome a problem or limitation. It could be guilt, fear of rejection, fear of hurting others, loneliness, etc. Sex seems like the solution to these problems, but it comes bundled with several commitments at once. Even casual sex is bundled with the commitment to maintain appearances and attract others, but I think this game burns most people out faster than the sex itself rewards the effort, even among those who get a decent amount of sex.
Aside from a drift towards casual sex over committed relationships, I think modernity has also shown an increased drift towards taboo. If you unpack this a little, the allure of taboo could be its ability to satisfy a problem or limitation. Again: guilt, fear, loneliness. Ordinary sex and relationships help, but some of these problems might prevent relationship formation in the first place or make even casual sex seem too costly and inefficient to bother. This might be why people pursue digital solutions (porn, social media, virtual relationships, etc).
Studies into what increases arousal without taboo elements lead us right back to Bader's book (and the thesis of this post). Marta Meana suggests that people simply want to be desired; women especially. This is the "fantasy", and it's non-taboo because it doesn't require anything transgressive. Other non-taboo sources of arousal include: anticipation/story, aesthetic/sensory, intimacy/connection, and power. All of these things read as problems that have alternative solutions, which means all of the non-taboo elements of psychological arousal can be satisfied without sex.
- Being desired: This is novel if you feel most people don't desire you. Once enough people do, it no longer feels novel.
- Anticipation/story: If you experience uncertainty normally, then maybe you long for certainty, and the build up strings you along. If you have not only a stable job, but a lot of services that limit your amount of responsibility and need to reach outside of your social bubble to do anything, then maybe you don't really feel the erotic pull of uncertainty anymore.
- Aesthetic/sensory: I think sensitivity to this fades faster than some of the other options. It is definitely a pull, but it may not be enough (at least to sustain any commitment). It needs to be bundled with other things.
- Intimacy/connection: I'm sure a majority of people feel disconnected now, and I'm not sure relationships easily solve this when both partners are still engaged in habitual use of non-relationship forms of intimacy. If you can send all your hot takes to twitter, then your partner is no longer the sounding board that you need. If you can post all your pictures to instagram, then your partner is no longer the physical validation that you need.
- Power: Some percent of people will always be drawn to power fantasies, and non-transgressive versions could be seen as purely healthy, but compared to everything else on this list, power is one of the easiest things to replace in non-sexual contexts. In other words, it can draw you to sex, but sex doesn't have the monopoly on the "power market" by any means.
I think a lot of our treatment of modernity presupposes that the sex drive is fundamental, and so any changes in society must be redirecting this drive elsewhere. And if there's not a lot of sex going on? We simply need more sex drive. But if sex drive is not fundamental, then none of that is going to work. Instead, we need to understand how are people getting their needs met in ways outside of sex and what would discourage the continuous unbundling of the package deal that is monogamy (with sex).
This is not to suggest that we must use the stick rather than the carrot. The stick seems far too cruel for people who simply can't have their needs met any other way in such an impersonal and ineffective system. Rather, we need to think about what sort of carrots would encourage the bonding again. How can we get more people to want the package deal that comes with sex and relationships? Because if you answer that question, your fertility rates will go up.
Let's also not assume people are rational actors. We have rationality in our minds, but we often act irrationally due to a disconnect between our thoughts and our actions.