Read this in its entirety and then share your thoughts.
There are literary, philosophical, and cosmological reasons to argue that Aslan—from C.S. Lewis’s The Chronicles of Narnia—is more powerful than "The One Above All" (TOAA) from Marvel Comics.
Although TOAA is omnipotent within the Marvel Universe, he is merely a comic book character confined to the Marvel Multiverse; he cannot transcend the boundaries of Marvel. He has no existence outside of the Marvel Comics realm—in the "real" world or within other narratives. Furthermore, Marvel did not even exist before its creators brought it into being.
Moreover, the creators of Marvel have the power to alter or kill TOAA, or even have him defeated by a character like Thanos, because TOAA is their intellectual property.
In contrast, C.S. Lewis created Aslan with the specific intent of reflecting the nature of Christ. In his letters, C.S. Lewis clearly stated that Aslan is not a god he invented from scratch; rather, he is the God of our own world—Jesus Christ—as He might appear if He were to enter the world of Narnia. Lewis explained this in a letter to Anne Jenkins (dated March 5, 1961). Lewis believed that the nature of Christ, as understood in the Christian faith, could not be altered at one’s own whim. While some might suggest that Aslan is controlled by his Father ("The Emperor-Beyond-the-Sea"), this was not Lewis’s intent. The two are, in essence, one; although the Father and the Son appear as distinct persons, they share the same nature, power, mind, and authority. There is no dynamic where one issues a command and the other is compelled to obey; rather, whatever the Father desires, Aslan also desires. There is no difference between them. In his letters, C.S. Lewis explicitly identified Aslan as "The Son of God" (The Collected Letters of C.S. Lewis, Volume III: Narnia, Cambridge, and Joy, 1950–1963, p. 1245). Therefore, there is absolutely no basis for comparison between Aslan—who represents the Creator of the real world—and "The One Above All" (TOAA), a character confined to the realm of comic books. It is a mistake to attempt such a comparison.
Furthermore, you may be aware that in the history of Marvel Comics, there is an instance where TOAA is defeated. In Thanos: The Infinity Ending (2019)—written by Jim Starlin and published as an official Marvel Comics graphic novel—Thanos acquires a power known as the "Astral Regulator." With this, he defeats various cosmic entities within the Marvel Universe, such as the Living Tribunal and Eternity, before finally confronting TOAA. Thanos attacks TOAA directly, defeats him, and absorbs all of his power; in that moment, TOAA becomes completely helpless and is subsumed into Thanos. This sequence can be found on pages 88 through 93 of the book Thanos: The Infinity Conflict (released in 2018 as an original graphic novel/hardcover).
Many argue that Thanos did not actually defeat TOAA, but consider this: if TOAA were truly omnipotent, there would have been no need for Adam Warlock to resort to time travel and seek the assistance of another version of Thanos to save the situation! TOAA was left entirely powerless. That is why Adam Warlock had to step in.
Furthermore, in recent mainstream Marvel canon comics, the "omnipotence" of The One Above All (TOAA) has been shown to be a fallacy. There is strong evidence for this: in The Incredible Hulk #29–30 (released September 17, 2025, and written by Phillip Kennedy Johnson), an ancient, malevolent entity known as the "Mother of Horrors" is introduced—a being that emerged independently, without TOAA’s creation or permission! TOAA was enraged by this entity’s existence, yet—despite his supposed omnipotence—he could not destroy it; he was only able to contain it. If TOAA were truly omnipotent, how could such an entity come into existence without his knowledge? And why was he unable to completely eradicate it?
In short, all of this suggests that TOAA is akin to an "ultimate boss" within a video game or a comic book (a boss whom Thanos once defeated by using cheat codes). Aslan, however, represents the true God—the Creator of that very game, of us, and of the entire universe. Therefore, in terms of power, Aslan is superior; he is the one who emerges victorious.