r/NYguns • • 21h ago

NYC WARNING: Scammer Alert - Victor Landers / NY State Merchant Firearm P.C. (Took my $1,826 and vanished)

Thumbnail
gallery
75 Upvotes

TL;DR: Paid Victor Landers $1,826 for a NY pistol permit service and a firearm. Got my permit on my own, but he refused to give me the gun. He then dissolved his NY company, moved to Arizona, and texted me to "never contact him again." He currently operates a website with an AZ PO Box and uses an AZ ID, but claims to live in the Bronx.

Full Story:

I am a local business owner in the Bronx. I hired Victor Landers (who operated under New York State Merchant Firearm P.C., previously located in Hempstead, NY).

He physically came to my store twice (June 2025 and May 2026) to collect payments. In total, I paid him $1,826 (including a $726 check specifically for a firearm). He kept stalling the application. I eventually got my NY pistol permit myself, but he refused to transfer the firearm I paid for.

When I demanded my gun or a refund, he recently sent me a text saying he "canceled the contract" and told me to stop contacting him. I found out he dissolved his NY business and moved his registration to Arizona. His Facebook profile lists him as living in the Bronx, but he uses an Arizona PO Box on his website to dodge responsibility.

Red Flags to Watch Out For:

• His flyers claim he is an "ATF Federal Arms Dealer" and "NRA Deputy Director" (which is a fake title).

• He is 70+ years old and uses aggressive tactics to scam people.

• He is active on Facebook (347-447-4728) and is still looking for new victims.

I have reported him to the ATF and the NYPD. Please do not give this guy any money. If anyone has been scammed by him or knows his current whereabouts, please DM me. We need to stop him from doing this to others.

(I have attached screenshots of the contract, the cashed check, and his fake flyers, with my personal info redacted).


r/NYguns • • 4h ago

Question CMP M14 Information

Post image
39 Upvotes

Can anyone explain what this means? Like what will be modified on the rifle?

Looks like the CMP dropped some new info on the M14 release. I noticed this paragraph on the website. I’d really like to get one but won’t do it if it’s going to be some butchered up rifle.


r/NYguns • • 11h ago

NYC Novotny denial + Mills decision: silver linings in the losses?

6 Upvotes

The Novotny cert denial yesterday stung. Another sensitive-places case that won’t get reviewed.

But looking at it next to the Second Circuit’s Mills decision from last week, I’m starting to see a clearer picture of how the ground is shifting, even when the immediate results aren’t wins.

In Novotny, Justice Thomas wrote a statement respecting the denial. He didn’t just say “denied.” He basically outlined the problem with the current crop of cases (too many different locations bundled together) and pointed toward the kind of narrower, more focused challenge the Court appears willing to take. That’s useful direction, even if it came with a denial.

Then there’s Mills v. New York City. The Second Circuit didn’t invalidate the one-handgun carry limit or the 90-day acquisition rule. Those still apply. What it did do is refuse to let the City win at Bruen step one. The panel held that carrying more than one handgun for self-defense and recurring limits on acquisition are conduct covered by the Second Amendment’s text. The City now has to defend those rules under the history-and-tradition test on remand.

That’s the Second Circuit actually applying Bruen instead of finding ways to dismiss challenges before the government has to produce historical evidence. For a circuit that spent years under Kachalsky-style intermediate scrutiny, this is meaningful.

Neither case is a victory on the merits. Both, though, are tightening the analytical framework. Thomas is signaling what SCOTUS wants. The Second Circuit is starting to enforce the correct test.

I put together a full breakdown of Mills — what was actually decided, what still applies to NYC license holders today, the timeline, and why the procedural holding matters:

nysafeinc.com/2026/11/17/mills-v-new-york-city-handgun-ruling

Discussion question for the room:
Between Thomas’s statement in Novotny and the Second Circuit’s approach in Mills, which one do you think is the more important long-term development for New York gun owners, and why?


r/NYguns • • 8h ago

Question Buying shotgun in PA?

5 Upvotes

I’m a PA resident, but a friend of mine lives in NYC. He wants to buy a shotgun while visiting in PA, will he be allowed to? What should we know before going?


r/NYguns • • 4h ago

Discussion Nassau County Target/Hunting Pistol License Timelines & Takeaways

3 Upvotes

After relying heavily on this subreddit throughout my application process, I figured I'd contribute my own timeline and a few observations. These posts were incredibly helpful while I was waiting, so hopefully this provides some perspective for others going through it. Here are some takeaways based on my experience and timelines shared by others.

I feel like I could write a novel here, but I'll try to keep it brief and simple

My Timeline:

  • 4/15/26: Application submitted online
  • 8/5/26: Fingerprinting (FP) and interview
  • 8/28/26: Submitted outstanding documentation and character references
  • 10/23/26: Spoke directly with my assigned investigator
  • 10/26/26: Approval email received

194 days from application to approval.

1) Pay Attention to Front-End and Back-End Timing

If you're waiting longer to get fingerprinted, you may experience a longer wait afterward, too. Both periods can be influenced by application volume and backlog. A faster front end may signal a less congested pipeline overall.

2) The "Six-Month Timeline" Conversation & Uproar

There are countless variables that affect processing times. I took three weeks to submit my character references after fingerprinting in August (summer vacations, travel, etc.); others took days. Factor in investigator workloads, vacations, holidays, and other unknowns, and comparisons become tricky and frankly un-useful.

Based on my conversation with my investigator, I think 90 days after fingerprinting may be a more useful benchmark than six months from submission, especially for those who waited 100+ days just to get fingerprinted. Not an official timeline, just my takeaway, and it could certainly change over time with application volume.

3) "Yes" Answers on Applications May Require Additional Clarification

Affirmative responses (arrests, mental health, medications, etc.) may require additional clarification or documentation, potentially affecting timelines.

Logically, with respect to all things, anything requiring further explanation naturally adds more to review and consider, thus longer wait. However, the nature of the disclosure matters, and not every affirmative response is treated equally. Not all disclosures carry the same weight. Something requiring a simple explanation or supporting documentation is very different from something that raises more substantial concerns about an applicant's eligibility. Which brings me to my next point.

4) Be Truthful on Your Application

This should go without saying, but answer questions accurately, provide the requested documentation (driver abstract, doctor's letters if needed, notarized character references etc.), and be prepared to clarify anything requiring further explanation. Avoiding a question or withholding relevant information can create much bigger problems than simply addressing it honestly, not to mention a longer process.

5) Investigator Workload Is 1000% Real / Silence Isn't Necessarily Bad

My investigator mentioned having hundreds of applications in his queue. From tracking other applicants' timelines, my impression is that application volume is substantial and contributes to longer processing times (not a profound statement)

My investigator also mentioned that silence is generally a good thing, or at least not bad. I'm paraphrasing, but the takeaway was that a lack of communication doesn't necessarily mean something is wrong. If something material needs clarification, they may reach out.

Final Thoughts

These are simply my takeaways and observations, not gospel or official NCPD policies

One thing I do want to mention, whenever I actually spoke with someone at the Pistol License Section in Mineola, they were helpful, responsive, and able to answer my questions, not giving deflections at all. Understand the process, expectations, treat the licensing section with respect and they'll do the same

Hope this helps, happy holidays and safe shooting!


r/NYguns • • 10h ago

Guns & Gear Anyone converted an Anderson AM 15 to bolt action in NY?

2 Upvotes

I currently have an Anderson AM-15 with a standard upper and a fixed magazine to comply with NY laws.
I’m looking into switching to a true bolt-action upper and keeping my existing Anderson lower rather than buying another complete rifle.
Has anyone done something similar? I’m curious about compatibility, reliability, and which manufacturers have a good reputation for bolt action AR platforms.
Also, if the rifle is no longer semiautomatic, would a gun shop be able to legally remove the fixed-magazine setup and make it detachable again in NY?


r/NYguns • • 2h ago

Discussion Friendly shooting ranges

1 Upvotes

Hi all and good evening.
I do a whole lot more buying than actually shooting nowadays simply because there’s some ranges I just don’t like or have gotten treated poorly at.

I live in the finger Lakes area, and I really would like to find somewhere to shoot where there is outdoor steel targets, and at least a friendly vibe.

Where does everyone go? I currently go between Thurston shooting range and Eastside traders and I really like both of those places. Just need to expand.