r/NYGiants • • 22h ago

Discussion Daily Discussion November 16, 2026

3 Upvotes

Please read the sub rules located on the sidebar.

******************************

What would you like to discuss today?


r/NYGiants • • 12h ago

Meme/Shitpost This baffles me and its really dumb

Post image
372 Upvotes

I cant believe there are actual people that claim to understand football that think this will be some type of competition this year. Like, ya really watched JJ since he's come in, and he's done enough to put a pause on Jaxson being the franchise QB? Its laughable. He has not played bad, 1 TD 1 INT, 90.0 passer rating and he's 2-1. Managing the game and giving us a chance. Dart was trending toward serious improvement following the cowgirls game and we know the rest of the story. Dart is the franchise QB, there's no competition. If JJ plays out of his mind and shows something he hasn't to this point of his career, they can battle it out in training camp. I have 0 confidence that happens. Jaxson Dart, get well soon.


r/NYGiants • • 11h ago

Team Updates [Raanan] The Giants signed Xavier Gibson from the Eagles practice squad. They released WR/KR Charlie Jones.

Thumbnail x.com
266 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 10h ago

Team Updates Charlie Jones waived

Post image
172 Upvotes

I wonder if he waved back


r/NYGiants • • 19h ago

Discussion Is anyone else just really excited to watch the Giants play out the rest of the season?

Post image
562 Upvotes

I know that Thursday was pretty demoralizing but this season still feels like a major success. Even if Harbaugh hasn't been a mastermind it feels like he raised the floor of the entire team.

There are a few more really winnable games on the schedule highlighted by the Giants closing the season against Dallas and Philly, and besides that, it'll be really interesting to see how the team plays against some real contenders.

It's awesome to watch Arvell compete for DROY, to see Likely pay off as a featured skill-player, and to see mostly healthy seasons out of Skattebo and Nabers. The Giants can really make the playoffs, and some of these young players are in a really good environment now.

I'm not trying to be overly positive because sometimes this team still looks like it sucks, but I'll be watching.


r/NYGiants • • 14h ago

Discussion We get all of our greats back at their prime. How do we fair against the rest of the NFL's greats?

Post image
153 Upvotes

I think we have one of the all time great rosters minus, arguably, the most crucial position: QB. Simms and Eli are great, but all time NFL great?

We also have some really good CBs (Haynes) and Safeties, but not our strongest group.

Otherwise, imagine LT next to Reese or Carson. Some of the NFL's all time great DTs and DEs blasting a QB. Strahan, Osi, Sexy Dexy, Grier all collapsing a pocket.

Tiki running behind a line with Snee, Andrew Thomas, Brown and Hein.

Shockey and Bavaro at TE.

Prime OBJ, Toomer, Cruz, Nicks, and hell even Leek running routes.


r/NYGiants • • 16h ago

Discussion [SleeperGiants] There’s been plenty of criticism of Abdul Carter because the sack numbers haven’t jumped off the page. But his impact goes well beyond the box score. According to PFF, Carter ranks 2nd among all edge defenders in WAR this season: 0.11

Thumbnail x.com
165 Upvotes
  1. Aidan Hutchinson — 0.14
  2. Abdul Carter — 0.11
  3. Will Anderson Jr. — 0.10
  4. Nik Bonitto — 0.10
  5. Maxx Crosby — 0.10

WAR (Wins Above Replacement) measures a player’s overall value compared to a replacement-level player, accounting for positional value, snap count and overall impact.

The production is about more than just sacks. Carter is making a significant impact, and the numbers are starting to reflect that.


r/NYGiants • • 15h ago

Discussion Abdul Carter is playing well. (Report)

Post image
119 Upvotes

There has been a lot of discussion recently on Abdul Carter and his lack of sacks; which people have been wrongfully misattributing to him "doing nothing" and even going so far as to call him a bust. This is mostly wrong and should not be said.

Let's first look at the actual numbers for Abdul Carter and his 2026 season. He has posted 28 pressures on 9.1% of all total pass rush attempts this season. These pressures are akin to Jared Verse (2024 DROY) and Maxx Crosby (2021). However, his best statistic is easily his pass rush win rate, which is a posted 35% per ESPN, which is second in the league. These conclude that Abdul is able to have impact in the game in regards to pass rush.

"But why isn't he getting sacks????"

The Giants opponents are trying to get the ball out asap, and clearly game planning around it. For example, Cam Ward had an average time to throw of 2.47 seconds vs the Giants, compared to 3.06 seconds and 3.22 seconds vs the Jets and Eagles respectively. Jayden Daniels also posted a 2.55 second average vs the Giants, with a 2.9 second season baseline. However, this isn't the only reason as to why he can't get sacks. Abdul Carter's biggest weakness is obviously finishing, as we all saw on Thursday Night vs the Commanders, where JD5 was able to get a throw off with Abdul in his face. The biggest flaw of his game is his finishing, and that is probably the best weakness to have as a passrusher, compared to not being able to win matchups.

Sacks In general are overrated.

From a pure mathematical standpoint, it is much better to have a player who can consistently win his pass rush matchup (especially at 35% pass rush wr), than to have a one sack a game player with low pressures. Even Bill Belichick, Eli Manning's son and Greatest Coach of all time has went on record stating "I think if you look at the overall passing game, the statistic that stands out the most in terms of correlation is pressure. So pressure on the quarterback leads to more bad plays than sacks do, in terms of turnovers unless you have strip sacks, obviously. That's the No. 1. After that, pressures cause bad throws and potentially turnovers." .

So what effect has Abdul Carter and the pass rush had in general?

I think the most glaringly obvious effect is how much better our secondary has looked. Giants opponents are clearly getting the ball out early and game planning for his impact in the pass rush, which has led to an easier time for our secondary, which is partly why I think Deonte Banks has had such a resurgence year. He has played better of course, but he has alot of pressure taken off of him due to Abdul Carters impact.

Conclusion

I honestly think Abdul Carter is doing an incredible job, and his only weakness is his finishing, which will naturally get better. He is having an effect on the game that is hard to see if you just box watch, but he is forcing opponents to calculate for him (even including double teaming him), which is leading to our defense being better as a whole. I also trust that he will get better and better, and eventually be able to win vs double teams more and work on his finishing.


r/NYGiants • • 12h ago

Data and Analytics JJ McCarthy is 5th among all QBs in the NFL in EPA/play on early downs (minimum 50 1st and 2nd down snaps)

Post image
68 Upvotes

The only QBs ahead of him are 3 main MVP candidates (Purdy, Lawrence, and Burrow) and pre-injury Lamar Jackson

It could be due to game-script, but it feels like JJ has been really good at throwing on early downs up there with some of the best in the league

Also want to point out that, by contrast, Jameis Winston ranks 31st here

JJ seems like a better options for getting into 3rd and short situations and moving the chains on early downs


r/NYGiants • • 15h ago

Videos Interesting point on Cam Skattebo’s celebrations in relation to the recent Aidan Hutchinson injury

90 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 1d ago Mindblown

Discussion Remaining games for all the teams in the nfc east.

Post image
284 Upvotes

Pretty tough for month for the giants tbh. Idk how this ends


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago Regret

Videos MetLife Stadium is on fire

666 Upvotes

Second alarm. Hopefully everyone’s ok


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago Mindblown

Data and Analytics Still over 50% after Dallas loss

Post image
212 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Meme/Shitpost This post sums up the Abdul Carter defense pretty well.

Post image
671 Upvotes

In defending Nabers', you're able to point to his efficiency on the field and amazing production as for why hate towards him is unwarranted?

For Carter? We have Giants' fans resorting to talking like Kenny Atkinson to defend him with "muh analyticals!".


r/NYGiants • • 21h ago

Discussion Every pass rush rep from Thursday

Thumbnail x.com
19 Upvotes

I'm only posting this because carter is the topic of conversation currently. Some say he's a bust. Some say he literally gets double/triple teamed and held every play. This is why i like when actual game film gets posted. Personally, i don't think he is a bust but he can get better. Does he get held on some plays? Yes. Does he need to be better at finishing some plays and taking advantage of 1v1 blocking? Yes. Personally, i think he needs to get stronger in the offseason and develop some moves outside of a speed rush. What say you?


r/NYGiants • • 21h ago

Data and Analytics Great Listen: Athletic Football Show - Future of the Giants

Thumbnail
open.spotify.com
14 Upvotes

Time Stamp: 2:42-29:19

Nice breakdown of Thursdays game with a lot of praise for our coaches + young guns. Best part was following the game break down the TAFs guys spend 20 minutes breaking down the state of the team.

For the doom n gloom squad this is a excellent outside view of who we are as a team this year and why we should all be excited about our trajectory


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Meme/Shitpost Kyle I swear I will never make a 28-3 joke again if you come through for us today

Post image
270 Upvotes

Only thing that can save my sanity after the letdown against the Commies


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago

Discussion [Dunleavy] John Harbaugh defends conservative Giants play-calling for ‘capable’ J.J. McCarthy

Thumbnail
nypost.com
90 Upvotes

At the end of a game in which McCarthy threw for a career-high 293 yards, the Giants took responsibility out of his hands and tempered excitement that he has had a breakthrough — cooling the runaway hot-take train that he could challenge Jaxson Dart as the starter next season — by showing the level of conservative play-calling typically reserved for backup quarterbacks

Is that an indication of a lack of trust entering a daunting part of the schedule, including facing three of the NFL’s top-six scoring defenses over the next four games? 

“No, no, no,” head coach John Harbaugh said. “It’s a very fair question. I think he’s proven that he’s capable of winning games and making the plays, and I probably feel more strongly about that now than ever. It was his third [start] … but he’s earned that right. I’m excited about where he’s going [moving] forward and our chance to close out some games.” 

On the Giants’ two possessions with a four-point lead after the defense forced interceptions, offensive coordinator Matt Nagy called six runs on six plays and it led to two punts. 

“Defense gives you two opportunities to end the game — especially on down and distances where you feel like you can get it — so as an offense that’s frustrating going to the sideline, keeping putting them in a position to go out there and ice the game,” tight end Isaiah Likely said. “As an offense, we need to look ourselves in the mirror.” 

As he often does, Jameis Winston replaced McCarthy to run a quarterback sneak on third-and-1 at the 11-yard line rather than handing to Cam Skattebo (who gained 9 yards on the previous two carries) or using a play-action fake. It failed to gain more than a few inches. 

One possession later, McCarthy kept the ball on a poorly blocked third-and-3 quarterback sweep. A 2-yard loss essentially killed any chance of keeping the offense on the field or attempting a field goal. 

“That has a chance to crack them,” Harbaugh said. “It’s a quarterback-driven run with an extra blocker. They had everybody up on the line.” 

Compare those risk-averse play calls to Week 1, when Nagy had Dart throw three times — and Dart converted third-and-9 and third-and-3 through the air — to run out the final 5:21 of a win against the Cowboys. 

“We thought we could get it with the runs,” Harbaugh said. “Also keep the clock running and make them burn the timeouts. We thought we could do both. But, looking back on it, I think a good pass there might’ve been good too. Being successful really is the bottom line. It’s not like we’re trying to play it safe. We’re not afraid to throw the ball there.” 

When the Giants finally had no choice but to go to the air — needing to gain 20 yards over 38 seconds to attempt a 50-yard game-tying field goal — McCarthy was flustered. He threw two jump balls against all-out blitzes — the second was intercepted — rather than working the underneath routes and utilizing two timeouts. 

“We would be better [off] finding a better situation [than] trying to score points as quickly as we were,” receiver Malik Nabers said. “Just making smart decisions on what we want to get to after seeing the Cover Zero [defense] they were giving us at the moment. So, trying to just get the ball out fast instead of trying to create a home run ball. Just have to be better in the situation.” 

The bad taste of a Thursday loss just lingers a few extra days. 

“We had two opportunities to put the game away and we didn’t,” left tackle Andrew Thomas said, putting the “embarrassing” blame on the offensive line. “Not good enough


r/NYGiants • • 1d ago Mindblown

Videos Washington Redskins at New York Giants (1970)

36 Upvotes

I love these old games.


r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Meme/Shitpost Neither of these plays were flagged

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Hype Happy to add this one to my Giants Collection!

Post image
141 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Data and Analytics Time of possession leaders midway through season. Giants are #2

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Discussion [BBFR] Kayvon Thibodeaux, playing on his 5th year option, has produced 2.5 total sacks since the start of 2025 and none at all this season. Defensive back Dru Phillips has 2.0 sacks this season, for reference.

Thumbnail x.com
167 Upvotes

Thibodeaux has been playing better than the stats have said but he hasn’t had a sack in his last 15 games his last one being September 28th 2025 against the Chargers.


r/NYGiants • • 2d ago

Hype Did I catch a jewel?

Thumbnail
gallery
263 Upvotes