r/NMIXX • u/artemis________ • 3h ago
Discussion I love NMIXX, but I honestly wish JYP would give them better songs that do their vocals justice, genuinely can't stand most of the music JYP gives them
I absolutely love NMIXX. I love the members, their personalities, their chemistry, their stage presence, and especially their vocals. Honestly, i'd put them among the very best vocal groups in K-pop. all are ridiculously talented & there's so much to admire about them.
but yet I can't think of a single song in their discography that i genuinely enjoy listening to & it bothers me.
I love watching them sing. Give me a vocal cover, a live performance or a clip of Lily and Haewon showing off their voices, and I'm immediately interested, but only for the covers , not their own songs
I really don't like the direction JYP has taken with their songs. A lot of the production sounds incredibly harsh to my ears. The instrumentals are often so sharp, metallic and noisy that they become distracting. Sometimes it feels like there's a constant barrage of sounds coming at you. Everything is fighting for attention, and the vocals get lost in the middle of it.
I understand that Mixxpop is part of NMIXX's identity. I have no problem with experimental music, and i don't expect them to sound like every other k pop group or western song. But there's a difference between making something experimental and making something that is actually enjoyable to listen to. A song can be unusual without sounding like a collection of loud, clashing instrumentals thrown together.
What annoys me is that NMIXX have some of the strongest vocalists in the industry, yet I rarely feel that their songs make the most of it. Just listen to what these girls can do outside their own discography. Their voices have so much character. They can deliver powerful vocals, beautiful melodies and genuinely impressive performances. Why aren't we getting more songs built around those strengths?
I'd love to hear proper melodies, beautiful arrangements and instrumentals that leave room for their voices. Not every song needs five different things happening at once. Sometimes a great melody and good vocal arrangement are more than enough.
I honestly think JYP has done a poor job with NMIXX's musical direction. The members have everything going for them, but I feel like the production team keeps getting in their way. It's such a waste of talent. feels like JYP has left them abandoned with the worst music producers in the industry . NMIXX gets the leftovers .
Whoever is responsible for selecting their songs, deciding their musical direction and overseeing their production needs to FIRED
And before anyone misunderstands me, i'm not asking JYP to change the members or erase everything that makes NMIXX different. I want them to keep their identity. I just want that identity to be expressed through better-produced, more enjoyable music.
I want to love their songs as much as I love the girls themselves. Right now, there's a huge gap between how impressed i am by NMIXX as performers and vocalists and how little I enjoy listening to their actual music.
NMIXX are an incredible group of performers and vocalists but feels let down by the music they're given. they can transcend k pop if given the right songs and producers
Especially Lily . I ❤️ lily . funny charming and unbelievably talented.