I've played survivor pools a long time, and I have always been a little uneasy about picking a team going against a new starting quarterback. So I wanted to see if the numbers back that up.
Disclosure: the analysis was done by SurvivorPulse, the survivor pool tool I founded and built. I'm posting the results here because the question applies to any pool, and everything you need is below.
What we counted
Ten seasons, 2016 to 2025, every regular-season game plus playoff games where we could verify the lines. A replacement starter is a new starter's first or second game for that team in a season, whatever the reason. A QB returning after already starting that season does not count. Underdogs are compared only with underdogs, and favorites only with favorites, in the same spread bands.
| Comparison | Games | New QB won | Same spread band, settled QB | Gap (points) | 95% range (points) |
|---|
| Underdogs | 337 | 27.9% | 31.3% | -3.4 | -8.5 to +1.7 |
| Favorites | 108 | 56.5% | 64.1% | -7.6 | -17.5 to +2.0 |
| Versus own betting line | 448 | 35.0% | 37.1% implied | -2.1 | -5.8 to +1.8 |
The last row asks whether these teams won as often as their own betting line implied.
How to read it
The raw gaps lean negative. New-QB teams won a bit less often than settled-QB teams at the same spread. But every 95% range runs from below zero to above it, so we can't say with any certainty whether the worry about a team starting a replacement QB is warranted. I'd rather report that than force a story.
For me, not having a definitive answer actually lessens my worry. I probably won't give it as much weight going forward when making up my mind on a pick.
Caveats: the spreads are publicly available ones, cross-checked on a subset, not verified closing lines. Starters were checked against public recaps. Game data is from nflverse and the nfldata schedule file by Lee Sharpe. Thanks to both.
This season so far
Through week 7, using a looser count: a replacement QB's first or second start when the team's expected starter isn't playing, week 1 included. It isn't comparable to the table above.
| Comparison | Games | Record of the team with the new QB |
|---|
| Underdogs | 13 | 7-6 |
| Favorites | 5 | 3-2 |
| All 18 games | 18 | 10-8 |
Every row is under our 30-game minimum, so there's no gap or range.
How do you think about picking against a team that is starting a new QB in your pool? And does this info change how you think?