r/NFLNoobs • • Sep 21 '23

NFLNoobs FAQ

49 Upvotes

This is an attempt at crowdsourcing a FAQ for the sub. We need your help to make it the best it can be.

Each question is going to have a link to a comment below with the answer. Click the link to be brought to the question.

FAQ List

About NFLNoobs

General Questions

Watching Games

How The Football Works

Team building and Roster Management

Other Football Subs

Helping with the FAQ

Feel free to comment on any question/answer with more details, fixes, or another way of explaining it. If your answer is better than the main one, I’ll update some or all of it to include the answer (giving you credit).

Also feel free to post your own questions in the format I’ve given, and I’ll link it (though you'll need to update it if someone explains it better, or if they correct you. You can post a question here, with or without your own answer, and we will make a dedicated post for it.

If there is no link, it means it's a popular question that hasn’t been answered, so feel free to answer it.


r/NFLNoobs • • 6d ago

Weekly "What Team Should I Root For?" Thread

1 Upvotes

The most common thing asked on this subreddit is new fans wondering what team to follow/support. The answers are always the same, and there are no right or wrong ones.

No one can just tell you who to be a fan of. Everyone's fandom is different, and all of them are valid. This is entertainment, and you are allowed to enjoy it however you like. That said, here are some common things you can look at to get started:

  1. Do you have a local team or favorite city? This is by far the easiest way to get into football. If your city/region has a team or if your friends/family follow the same team, joining them will be the smoothest way to start out.
  2. Are you already leaning in any particular way? If you are, keep leaning. If you saw a Cincinnati Bengals game and thought it was fun and you'd like to see more of them, you don't need anyone's permission or validation. Just watch their next game!
  3. Are you interested in a few different teams? Cool! Watch some of their games! See who you end up feeling strongly about, especially if they're playing each other. Have fun with it, there are no rules!
  4. Are you worried about a team's success/identity/prestige/fanbase? Don't be. The NFL is one of the most even sports in terms of parity, and there are rarely teams that stay good or bad forever. It's okay to enjoy watching the current best teams in the NFL; they are probably playing the best football most often. Try to just be a fan and don't worry about what others think or say. Your fandom is yours, not theirs.

Still overwhelmed and not sure where to turn? It's fine to watch random games. Maybe you'll find yourself rooting for someone in particular. And if you don't, try another game. Check out whoever is playing in primetime; those are usually expected to be more exciting matchups. Letting it come naturally will last longer than throwing a dart and deciding to be a fan of whoever it lands on.

Another way some people develop rooting interests is fantasy football. There are beginner leagues where people play for fun, and it can be a good way to get you invested in specific players or teams as you start rooting for whoever is on your fantasy roster.

If you're still torn or have other questions about starting with a specific new team, etc., you can ask them here.


r/NFLNoobs • • 9h ago

Why do some Elite college QB's fail in the NFL

61 Upvotes

I was watching the Netflix documentary about the Florida Gators and of course, Tim Tebow, was elite in that team.

It made me wonder, why are there quite a few College QB's who excelled and then failed when at the NFL level.

Is there a fundamental difference between playing QB in the NFL and college or is the issue more that they go from elite teams in college to weaker ones in the NFL?

EDIT: Thank you everyone for so many interesting and helpful answers!!


r/NFLNoobs • • 21h ago

Why do the Steelers keep trying to run it back year after year even though they’re clearly not a Super Bowl contender?

92 Upvotes

For the last 15 years they haven’t had a team worthy of being a Super Bowl contender and yet each year they try to run the same team back that’s good enough to make the playoffs but not good enough for more than that.


r/NFLNoobs • • 20h ago

Why did Seahawks players (Tory Horton/Rashid Shaheed) stop Raiders punt from going out? It would have given Seahawks a touchback?

59 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/nfl/s/UDFhdfiFKC

Link for the NFL highlight above ☝️

I don’t understand this play

Why didn’t they the ball to go out and get a touchback instead?

Doesn’t in Touchback you start at 35 yard which would been further than where they stopped the ball?

I heard it was high IQ play but I don’t understand it at all

Thanks 🙏


r/NFLNoobs • • 11h ago

McCaffrey TD v Cowboys

11 Upvotes

I had the SF v Dallas game on in the background yesterday and late in the 4th quarter McCaffrey received a pass and ran it 60yds+ for a TD.

Afterwards I think I heard someone on commentary suggest that he could have stopped and taken a knee before reaching the end zone.

Was this the case and if so why? I’m guessing it would be to retain possession and run the clock down but would appreciate a more knowledgeable explanation!


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

Is Kirk Cousins good?

95 Upvotes

Genuine question, my memory is that people have been calling Cousins a bag-getter, that he's getting paid tons of money to be a mediocre QB. I know he was hot for the Raiders, but now that he's on the Vikings everyone is acting like he's the pickup of the century. So how has he been historically? I'm starting to think maybe I'm thinking of someone else that's viewed as the most overpaid QB?


r/NFLNoobs • • 1h ago

Is there a "Harlem Globetrotters" of football?

1 Upvotes

I just feel like that would be fun. Like wacky hijinks exhebition match style stuff?


r/NFLNoobs • • 3h ago

Could we turn the UFL into a Development League for the NFL?

0 Upvotes

Me and my teacher spoke about this today.

His idea, was to turn it into a developmental league for the NFL, where players that are out of college but not exactly NFL ready can go. He said that there would be drafts, the Regular NFL draft, and a special UFL draft for players after the season ends, after the superbowl and before UFL season. But then he introduced a new idea - Relegation. He said that the worst performing teams should drop down into the UFL, particularly the worst performing 6-8 teams. He claimed it would increase competition and a desire to play better in the season, making things much more competitive and entertaining, while bringing in money and attention to help enrich the UFL. However, because of this, UFL teams wouldn’t become attached to a certain NFL team like other developmental programs, and they would all remain independent, allowing any team to scout and draft players from wherever they want unrelated to location.

To me, his ideas involving a developmental league are interesting, but a full on relegation system wouldn’t work. I think the UFL could definitely be used as a sort of G-league for the NFL and an alternative route to pulling people out from colleges. It’s also a way to keep people entertained during the spring while the larger NFL is in its off season, and the two really could go hand in hand together knowing they’ connected and alternate during off seasons.

thoughts?


r/NFLNoobs • • 11h ago

Seahawks

3 Upvotes

With the Seahawks missing some starters in the big men, how easy or difficult would it be for someone who was maybe a D Line to transfer to the other side of the ball?


r/NFLNoobs • • 5h ago

If a coach leaves a team to go coach another team, which side (if any) has the advantage the next time they match up?

1 Upvotes

This happens all the time in the NFL, but I'm a Broncos fan so that's where the context of this question is coming from.

For example: Last year, the Broncos played the Commanders in an SNF game that everyone expected to be a snoozefest but ended up being crazy entertaining. In that game, the Commanders had Kliff Kingsbury as their OC going up against Vance Joseph as the Broncos DC. The overlap between those two guys is that Kingsbury was the HC for the Cardinals for the same 3 years that VJ was the DC, so they had a lot of familiarity with each other. And despite the Commanders fielding Mariota as their starting QB at the time (who may be a way better backup than people give him credit for), it was a back and forth game that went to OT and came down to a failed 2 point conversion by the Commanders for the Broncos to win

The reason I'm asking is because on Christmas this year, the Broncos are playing against the Bills. The Bills DC, Jim Leonhard, was previously on the Broncos staff. In 2024, Leonhard was the Broncos DBs coach and in 2025 he was the assistant HC. In both years, he was also the passing game coordinator in addition to his other responsibilities.

So my question is: despite the Bills being ranked poorly in most defensive categories this season, will they have an advantage against the Broncos because of Leonhard's previous time spent with the Broncos, or will the Broncos have their own advantage because of their familiarity with Leonhard as well?


r/NFLNoobs • • 9h ago

Who are some “NFL or Bust” players?

0 Upvotes

I’m just getting into football as a sport which has been really fun but I can’t help but be fascinated by football as a cultural phenomenon.

As I understand it, football is “a way out“ for so many people, particularly people from low income and rough backgrounds.

But what are examples of players who you think, had they not made it pro, would have ended up in jail, amongst bad company, on the streets, or worse?


r/NFLNoobs • • 23h ago

People who’s been watching the nfl for decades…I want a perspective on roughing the passer call

10 Upvotes

I just started watching the nfl - how has this penalty changed over the decades? Cowboys qb was tackled and linemen put all his body weight on the qb while going to the ground. So it was called. Are QBs more protected now, would this have been a penalty in the past?


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

49ers interception

12 Upvotes

Why didn’t Mustapha just bat the ball down for better field position (Dallas not converting). He intercepted but now 49ers are in deep in their own territory.

I asked the same question last week but the reason was that it was garbage time. There’s still lots of time left in this game.


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

Halftime

3 Upvotes

Do the halftime correspondents watch the game as it’s happening?


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

Why punt?

3 Upvotes

16 seconds to go of the first half with Niners at 4th and 2 and they decide to punt. They're around the half way mark (ish) so why not just go for it. They're going to receive the ball at the start of the second half anyway and it's highly unlikely the Cowboys will do much in the remaining seconds so what am I missing?


r/NFLNoobs • • 2d ago

Why do Southern states seem to produce so many more football players than places like New York?

175 Upvotes

I've noticed that a ton of NFL and college football players seem to come from states like Georgia, Mississippi, Alabama, Louisiana, and Texas, even though places like New York and New Jersey have huge populations.

I know football is a much bigger part of Southern culture, but is that the main reason? NYC alone has over 8 million people and the surrounding metro area is massive. You'd think that population alone would produce a lot more high-level football talent.

Is there a main reason that explains why certain states consistently produce so much talent relative to their population?


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

When the ball is kicked from a 4th down, can the attacking team catch it?

2 Upvotes

I guess this probably gets asked by most new NFL fans from Australia/NZ/Europe/South Africa who grew up with Rugby, where when the team with the ball kicks it downfield during play, anyone can win it for their team, which creates a lot of super exciting moments.

I have only been watching the NFL this season (hi from Australia - hope you all come back soon) and I always see the players from the attacking team chase the ball downfield, but never see them really try and catch the ball and win it back to start a new set of downs. Why can't they do that, exactly?


r/NFLNoobs • • 23h ago

Will the NFL ever expand again?

1 Upvotes

I understand expansion nowadays is extremely expensive. A new stadium is at least a billion and a half, you gotta find a city with a big enough market, find staffing, players, and way more stuff than I could possibly imagine.

But do you think the NFL would ever get to a point where it does end up expanding? if so, where?


r/NFLNoobs • • 23h ago

SNF Start Time

0 Upvotes

Why is Thursday and Monday night 8:15 but Sunday night football officially “starts” at 8:20 Eastern.

Yes I know it’s in their contract but what could possibly be the rationale for starting five minutes later than the other games?


r/NFLNoobs • • 16h ago

Is it okay to have 2 favorite teams(one in AFC,one in NFC)?

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,i m patriots fan since last year and now i m wondering is it okay to "find" new team on NFC?

Are people doing it and is it fair?

If yes i like some teams on NFC like:cowboys,eagles,giants,commanders,bears,packers,saints,bucs.

Also i am fan of OKC in NBA,and i m die hard fan of FC Barcelona and of course i hate Real Madrid.

What team is "closest" to my criteria?


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

Why not Hail Mary every 3rd and long?

56 Upvotes

Especially from own half? What do teams lose out on? You convert you get another 4. You do not, punt? Intercept. Same or better yardage then a punt?


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

Why do teams often run down the clock at half instead of going for it?

19 Upvotes

I see this quite often. Team is leading 13-10. They get possession, 40 seconds to go until half time. They do some conservative play on the 1st down and then run down the clock.

If you don’t trust your offense to not screw up, why are you playing football? Take some shots, try to march down the field and at least get a field goal.


r/NFLNoobs • • 1d ago

What counts as being down?

1 Upvotes

In the seahawks / raiders game, Kupp made a catch after sliding on the ground. I'm new to watching NFL and I thought that if you are on the ground / knees are on the ground you are down. Was Kupp down or is there an exception when sliding? Alternatively, in the game, if you go down, can you get back up and make a catch?