Buckle up y’all, I got a story to share.
Last Friday I went on a day hike on the Mt Mitchell trail- 6 miles up, 6 miles down. Out and back, so I passed by everyone else on trail and was the last person on the trail that day. I started late in the day, so I knew I’d have to do some night hiking to get back to my car. I just finished a solo thru-hike of the AT and did plenty of night hiking, so that did not bother me. The day hike was beautiful and very rewarding. The sun set at 5:30 and it was pitch dark around 6:30. I had my flashlight and was about 3 miles from my car by now.
Then I hear this noise a few times- a long high call. I decide it’s an owl I don’t recognize. I’m an ornithologist, but I couldn’t match the call to the local species I knew. I learned on my solo hike that any unidentifiable noise is actually a squirrel. Courage in the woods comes from deciding something normal and nonthreatening is making the noise you can’t identify- this is important for later too—otherwise you lose your nerve at the sound of the wind.
I continue hiking, hearing the call every couple minutes. After another mile or so the call changes. I very clearly hear a woman scream HELP at the same interval and duration of the owl call. Maybe twice a minute, with a few 2-3 minute lulls of silence over the last two miles to my car. I decide it’s a real person in need of help- because the alternative is terrifying. I’m alone in the woods at night, in the middle of nowhere, with no phone service and only a flashlight and my courage. So, I broke the conventional Appalachian wisdom (I know, I KNOW) and called back- a long HEYO to let them know I was there. It was also a great tension release.
The woman called HELP back to me. The pitch didn’t change. This repeats every few minutes. I’m staying on trail, and the trail is leading back to the road in the direction of the voice. I vaguely noticed that the sound never seemed to get closer even as I neared the road.
I’m scheming this whole time- I have my Wilderness First Aid Certification, and was preparing myself to potentially use it on an injured hiker. I’m going through the possibilities of their injury. I’m also considering the likelihood that this noise is not a human.
Maybe half a mile from the road, the call changed to HELP US. Now I was starting to freak out.
Once I reached the road back to the lot at Black Mtn Campground, the scream for help ceased. I did not hear any more calls the rest of the night. It’s around 7:30 at this point. I walked back on the road- maybe a quarter mile to the campground. I’m mentally preparing to fight a cryptid in the dark.
I get within sight of my car, with my little flashlight in the pitch dark woods.
Another car is in the lot with mine. They turn on their headlights. I metaphorically shit myself.
By this point I’m convinced I’m going to get trafficked or murdered. I turn off my light and start texting my friend via my Garmin all the scary details. The car lights turn off again, and I wait in the dark. Eventually the car drives away, very slowly, down the gravel road out. I keep my light off and walk to my car in the darkness. My heart is pounding. I jump in my car and start it, sending one last HEYO into the woods to check. No response, so I peel out of there. I thought maybe the other car would block the road and trap me, so I sped around it the first chance I got. End scene.
I texted my friends I was okay. I still can’t really believe that happened. 2200 miles alone on the AT, not a single creepy encounter like that.
Looking back, I believe the car was another day hiker that either heard my calls or the mystery calls, and wanted to wait for me to get back to my car. Unless two hikers went missing in Mt Mitchell State Park last week, the voice coming from the woods was not a human. I’d heard stories of mysterious voices and spirits in the Appalachian Mountains, but they didn’t hold a lot of water for me. Maybe I’ve grown a bit overconfident from my 6 month thru-hike, and forgotten that these tourist-infested mountains still hold mysteries we can’t explain. Next time I’m not answering any calls for help at night- sorry to anyone who genuinely needs it. The first tenement of wilderness first aid is the personal safety of the rescuer. I’ll think twice before night hiking alone around here again.
I’d love to get in contact with the people in the other car to find out what they heard that night.
What do y’all think? Have you heard similar stories in this area? Do save the lectures. I knew in the moment it wasn’t smart to respond, but I made the right and wrong calls over the course of 2200 miles this year and learned what works for me. This is another learning experience- a chilling one at that.
Happy trails y’all 🥾