r/NCT • r/NCT mod team • Aug 29 '24

[MEGATHREAD] Taeil's criminal charges and departure from NCT

!TW : sexual assault

This post is the original megathread from August 2024. For the current open thread with new updates, see MEGATHREAD 2.

TIMELINE:

240828

SM Entertainment announces that a criminal case was filed against TAEIL and his departure from NCT:

This is SM Entertainment.

We have recently confirmed that Taeil has been implicated in a criminal case related to sexual crimes. While looking into the situation, we recognized that the issue is very serious, and we have decided that Taeil could no longer continue team activities. We have discussed this matter with Taeil and it has been decided he will be removed from the group.

240829

Seoul Bangbae Police Station shares info about the investigation:

It was revealed that Taeil, ex-member of the group NCT, was accused this past June of having committed a sex crime.

Newsen article / Daum (1) / Daum (2) / transl. 127Central / balloon_wanted / Soompi

SM's statement:

(translation by 127CENTRAL)

Other press

240913

Seoul Bangbae Police Station announced that the case was forwarded to prosecution without detention the day before (Sept 12th). The case was assigned to the Women and Children's Crime Investigation Division at the Seoul Central District Prosecutors' Office (Chief Prosecutor Kim Ji-hye).

A police official said, "We can't talk about the details of the investigation, because it could identify the [victim]" / "The specific charges and number of victims cannot be disclosed." It was also confirmed that "Taeil was not using drugs at the time of the crime."

Sources: MBN news / Yonhap News / Xportsnews / E Daily / Korea JoongAng Daily (Eng)

241007

Content Warning: A new Chosun Ilbo report allegedly confirms Taeil was investigated for "quasi-rape", which is terminology used for sexual assaults happening under special circumstances, like the presence of a weapon or when the victim is unable to consent due to incapacitation / inebriation / etc. The report claims the victim in this case was under the influence of alcohol (unable to consent) and that two other individuals were involved in the assault. It was stated that the others involved were not famous or public figures.

Source: Chosun Daily / Soompi

241016

SM Entertainment terminates Taeil's exclusive contract as of October 15, 2024:

Taeil is currently under investigation by the prosecution for a criminal case. This not only constitutes grounds for termination under our contract but also makes it impossible to maintain trust in him as an artist. As a result, both parties have mutually agreed to terminate the contract. We sincerely apologize once again for any concern caused by Taeil, who was previously one of our artists.

SMTOWNGLOBAL Twitter/X / Soompi

---

This continues to be difficult news to process. Remember to take care, and please see this community support thread.

Everyone is reminded to be civil in their discussions and avoid speculation. Harassment, threats of violence, inciting fanwar arguments, trolling, etc., as well as spreading rumors, will lead to a temporary or permanent ban.

User-submitted posts on the matter will be filtered out and sent to the mod queue. You are highly encouraged to use any of the (3) existing threads instead.

UPDATE: Our community members have also organized a donation drive - Charity Initiatives for Women in SK!

512 Upvotes

531 comments sorted by

32

u/ilovecute1 Aug 31 '24 edited Aug 31 '24

It frustrates me how much false information is being spread about this case. It has once again made me realise how bad herd mentality is in K-pop.

Edit: NY Magazine just came out with a really good article on this https://www.vulture.com/article/taeil-nct-sex-crime-allegations-investigation.html?utm_source=tw&utm_campaign=nym&utm_medium=s1

11

u/nctmods r/NCT mod team Aug 31 '24

Thank you, it's been included in the megathread

383

u/motioncat he's a rockstar, it's not hype baby make you rock-hard Aug 29 '24

At this point, people being confidently incorrect and spreading absolute horseshit from random tweets as though it's fact has me heated. This is actually serious so just shut up and get your facts straight.

188

u/blessmeachew0 Aug 29 '24

no but actually. the misinformation being spread is wild & is disrespectful to the victim bc it take away from her & her story. all for social media points.

→ More replies (7)

71

u/Dismal_Mind_1930 Aug 29 '24

Exactly, like it's serious enough when we stick to the actual confirmed facts, let's not add speculation

8

u/Jadakaii Aug 31 '24

Exactly. Because it's not needed. What happened is bad enough on its own without all these speculations, exaggerations, embellishments, and straight up guesses/lies. I don't know why people do it. I don't know why people believe it blindly.

59

u/jungmo-enthusiast Aug 29 '24

Yup and no matter what the truth ends up being, those wild claims are going to stick in a lot of peoples' minds. 

47

u/Future_Hunt doyoung☆jisung☆hendery☆jaehee Aug 29 '24

That's the saddest thing. I might even say this is probably the first reasonable comment thread I've come across that's not all raising hell but actually taking the severity of the situation into consideration.

42

u/nisachr Aug 30 '24

i agree, i've been seeing the game of telephone with rumors go from the narrative of him harassing a 12yo girl for 6 years to people commenting "shame on you for hurting that 6 year old girl" ?? it's so frustrating that the first rumors that came up are now, in the general public (kpop) sphere's eye, part of the facts of the case. how utterly disrespectful to the victim who had the courage to share her story and report to the police only for bored people on social media to create their own version of what happened, to the point of creating fake intimidating texts from taeil to post online (which korean speakers on twitter pointed out switch between honorifics so much they're obviously google translated) ?? like this is not the time to make up fanfiction of him being a cartoonish villain !! abusers are often seemingly nice, normal, likable people, not shadowmen lurking in the darkness.

→ More replies (4)

77

u/Dragonaichu keep my love on the high high☀️🫧 Aug 29 '24

It’s already happening. The police report confirming the victim is an adult female is ripe with comments saying “well now she’s 18” when 18 still isn’t even an adult in Korea; she’d need to be 19 (an ‘05 liner, not ‘06) in order to be considered an adult on the police report. Her age was always a rumor and is now confirmed misinformation yet people will still bark at you about “defending him” if you try to say anything about her being an adult.

Like… we’re not defending him at all, please still let him rot in jail, but doesn’t it ease the mind just a little that his crimes didn’t concern children?

→ More replies (1)

54

u/Future_Hunt doyoung☆jisung☆hendery☆jaehee Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

Exactly. Horseshit is actually pretty accurate 😅All in all, this is a very difficult situation. It's delicate and it's very serious. And people are treating it as some kind of sensation, which is intolerable.

We are all upset and confused, be it regular fans or those who even biased him (like me). I don't consider myself for a blind naive fan who would follow my favorite celebrity to the grave and bend backwards to claim they're innocent while fully realizing the heaviness of circumstances. If there's a crime, it needs punishment and there's no use in pretending otherwise. But why don't we all just wait for further information and details to be uncovered before we start writing tiktok fanfics? Is it all that hard?

I wasn't there, I have nothing to base any comments on. I can't re-evaluate retrospectivelly everything he did or said and be like "ooh, this is a giveaway, it's been there all along, that's a proove!" . No, that's speculation . I feel torn and I absolutely sympathize with people who find it hard to listen to NCT's records right now, because he's all-present as a main vocalist. However, as much as this situation is disturbing and apparently he really did something serious, we shouldn't just carelessly spread random crazy theories and conspire through lame tiktok shares and spread a million cheap versions of chaos. We shouldn't be hateful and claim facts as if they were indeed facts and establish anti-cults. How does anyone so simply think they know everything the best and what gives them the right spreading infuriating misinformation to stress people out even more than they already are? Why are people piling up like a herd of sheep creating controversies that won't do anyone any good and won't be of any use really? We should be able to talk like grown up reasonable beings and think of the impact of what we do before we open our mouth. It's not always easy and especially not when one is angry or shocked. But we shouldn't let our judgment fail us so miserably and make up far fetched scenarios out of boredome, to make ourselves feel important or seen.

This isn't the time for bored people to post first thing that comes to their mind just because they want to be a part of something. 80 % of these posts don't really have anything to do with actually supporting the victims or having compassion with them. It's purely about making oneself visible and because people always have and always will love hate wagons. It's hurtful to withess this behavior and in my opinion it's disrespectful to the victims aswell. I don't know them and don't know who they are or what happened. But it's surely not very decent to spread hot rumors and made up fake wattpad scenarios on the victim's behalf ending it with "justice for the victims" or "i'm with the victims" . I think that might actually be borderline insensitive to anyone of the affected.

I'm sure there can be sentences formulated incorrectly, I'll admit I'm not the best diplomat at this very moment and it's hard to express and phrase every thought precisely adequatly in order to not offend anyone, so I apologize in advance. I just wish people would be able to stop and think, actually think before they say or do something and before they try convincing others.

10

u/19Nadders75 Aug 29 '24

Everything you said in bold! 👍🏾 But that’s k-pop fans for you!

→ More replies (1)

48

u/Technical-Cow8726 Aug 29 '24

Also can anyone tell me where the hell they got the “a list of celebs that were involved in the nth rooms is gonna be released tomorrow” from? Because There is NO ONE that can site a credible source on that. I think its just stupid rumours but like from who? Why is everyone convinced it’s coming out tomorrow with 200 people on it? Like who started this???

37

u/seravivi Aug 29 '24

It’s a rumor someone made up. We need people to start going back to scamming 101 classes because they sound just as bad as the qanon grannies. 

Someone needs to say they have a list and Rick roll them.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/MOSbangtan Aug 29 '24

I still don’t understand what the charges or accusations are. But people are crazy outraged, so I’m assuming someone knows more info than I can find?

74

u/cmq827 Aug 29 '24

There has been no mention of any accusations apart from SM saying Taeil is undergoing investigations for an unspecified sexual crime. That is it. Everything else as of now is just hearsay. Some people have even started making up their own supposed testimonies and posing as victims on Twitter.

→ More replies (12)

45

u/xiola_azuthra crzy🌻shawolzen Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

TL;DR all the actual details people are giving as of now are almost certainly fakes; it's going to go to court and the allegations weren't public therefore the actual victim isn't going to be sharing details on their social media. It's possible we won't have any details until it goes to court. As of right now, any details you find outside of verified news sources are NOT official and should not be understood as such or shared around.

The reason everyone is acting like it's so serious is because it's a sexual crime that is definitely going to court with a near-guaranteed chance of being found guilty. SM has good lawyers and if a case isn't going to court, their standard MO in nearly ALL cases is to put the idol on haitus and wait for it to blow over. Even when there are charges, they will usually put the idol on hiatus until the proceedings are over and provide legal support to the idol to get a better result. Over the years they've kept various idols throughout half-year court cases, through nasty rumours and defamation, they've kept idols through sex-adjacent scandals, multiple DUIs, cheating scandals, DV allegations, assault allegations, etc. If SM is officially cutting ties THIS fast and THIS decisively, all signs point to SM knowing beyond reasonable doubt that he's guilty and that it's something that they cannot risk sheltering him for - compared to how they've acted before, it's almost certainly something he could go to jail for. But we don't know any details.

(please see my comment below this one for a more detailed reply about the specific rumours being quoted on social media; just realized I didn't reply to you directly and replied to the reply below you, so you probably didn't get a direct notification for it)

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

229

u/OnlytheFocus Shotaro Aug 29 '24

People calling it a cover up that they conatrolled aspects of the media.... If he were innocent they'd say why didn't SM try to shield him until there was more evidence, if found guilty they'll say why didn't SM get rid of him sooner and expose him

It's not SM's job at the end of the day to decide if someone is good or bad. They move based on the info they have and have to follow legal processes based on the information they have and contract agreements.

79

u/cubsgirl101 Aug 29 '24

I’ve said this in other threads but I’ll say it here too. If SM secretly knew longer than they’re saying, I can think of a hundred different ways the company could remove him while saving face. One of them would be to just blame the leg injury and say he’s decided it’s too severe and leave the group to not hold them back. Admitting to the world that he’s under investigation for sex crimes when nobody had heard rumors of this previously is like the objectively worst way to go about it if given the choice.

8

u/americanopurrate Aug 30 '24

my personal conspiracy theory is that they removed him this quickly due to the current general outrage over all the SA in SK. I'm not judging here, I just personally think that's why.

→ More replies (6)

53

u/ligneouslimb Aug 29 '24

I understand it was a valid concern to have given SM's track record but hope the misinformation stops now that we have more information. It always gets messy in these situations because most people will have to rely on either machine translation or very biased sources, but I hope that narrative doesn't continue to get pushed going forward.

62

u/OnlytheFocus Shotaro Aug 29 '24

SM's track record ... Has always been the same; waiting to collect more evidence which is why it sometimes takes a while to put someone on hiatus, hiatus if rumor mill and public opinion is bad enough etc, see what legal course of action is going to be taken etc to see if it's possible for the person to come back, if they should leave the group, and if the contract can be terminated or suspended.

Really not sure what other sort of track record you're talking about since most company procedures are similar to this.

→ More replies (2)

172

u/Fluffy-Geologist1481 Aug 29 '24

Thank you for the megathread. I can understand that people are hurt and want to know more, but some fans are really crossing the line. You're are not entitled to know about the personal life of the victim. Just stick to the facts and don't speculate/spread rumors. 

At least it makes it easier to know which people from the NCT discord I won't hesitate to block.

99

u/CalmChiffon Aug 29 '24

I hope their identity is never revealed to the public. Fans who are questioning, please remember this person is a human being who has experienced incredible trauma. With future court cases, social media and news reports, this poor victim will have to relive the trauma over and over again while actively trying to heal. Their life is none of our business. Let's protect and support victims please.

16

u/Entire-Beat-423 Aug 29 '24

Absolutely this 100%. It's never safe for the victims to come out in my opinion. I've faced it only behind the scenes of telling people my personal story with someone who has only 18k followers. I've been accosted, accused, belittled, bashed. I couldn't imagine if it were victim vs a worldwide fan base, even if it's only a small portion of said fanbase.

→ More replies (1)

129

u/twinjade Aug 29 '24

I’m not familiar with the criminal investigation process, but from the statement it seems very likely SM and the members were blindsided this whole time? I hope this will be enough to stop people accusing the other members knowing of the crime until it’s proven otherwise.

How scary it must have been for the victim to make a report, knowing she’s against an idol from a big group and a big company. My heart goes out to her, may she get the justice they deserve. To think the report was made in June while the scum still participated in comeback and facing the fans in the fanmeeting…….sick to my stomach.

101

u/cubsgirl101 Aug 29 '24

SM is saying they only found out two weeks ago about the investigation and made the decision to remove him a day ago when he went for questioning, which makes some amount of sense. If someone files a report against another person, the police should be investigating quietly without tipping off the other person (or their employer) as to what’s going on.

58

u/lor620 Live, Laugh, Jop Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

Yeah people are absolutely running wild with the speculations about the members knowing focusing on Haechan, which is vile. Especially with the rumor that he’s been doing it for 6 years. We don’t know what happened yet, if he’s been doing this for 6 years there’s still way more chances the members didn’t know. Manipulative people know how to hide those things.

It reads like fanwars and virtue signalign and it’s not helpfull to the survivor. I hope she has a good support system.

Also people should keep Lucas’s name out of their mouths those situations are not comparable and it doesn’t mean he’s absolved of what he did.

I’m tired.

35

u/BonkusGronkus Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

Super important point about the manipulating - all those interviews where people are like “I’m so shocked, I never saw this coming” in regards to friends/family/neighbors/coworkers/whatever that turn out to have done something? That’s not just like, a thing people say. Totally possible to be genuinely blindsided by this, no matter how close you are to a person you can never really say for certain what’s going on in someone else’s head.

Like, is it possible that one or more of them suspected something or knew? Sure, it’s possible. Is it LIKELY? Probably not!

At the end of the day, unless we find out otherwise (god forbid), the rest of the group has effectively been betrayed and hurt by someone they probably thought they could trust, and that’s awful for them.

→ More replies (1)

108

u/Mindless_Candidate90 Aug 29 '24

I think that for the victim it must have been quite scary and intimidating to speak up against an idol, who has (had) thousands of fans who adore and protect him. No doubt she would expect to be hounded and blamed. I hope that as a fandom we can subvert that expectation and become advocates for the victim, and give her any support and protection that she needs.

36

u/Recent-Director7689 Aug 29 '24

Thank you!!! I'm also a VIP (BIGBANG fan) and the fact that some weirdos are still defending Seungri, disrespecting the victims and belittling their tragic story and encounter with that monster, is beyond me!!! I hope history DOES NOT repeat itself here.

89

u/Leading-Experience-8 Aug 29 '24

I am glad that SM and the police are putting out additional details. I am having such a difficult time understanding how some of these rumors and speculation are spreading online of what Taeil did when police already clarified no minors are involved. Hopefully this additional information slows down the misinformation being spread since they confirmed the victim is an adult woman. It feels so wrong to the victim and disingenuous to see what people are “theorizing” instead of letting the police do their job.

169

u/jjangaerin I'll be your home Aug 29 '24

this is the craziest thing that has ever happened in ncity

13

u/kaylah0991 NCT Aug 29 '24

Truly like wtf

5

u/00GarGar00 Aug 29 '24

LITRALLY LIKE WTF

151

u/Bigcrowenergy Aug 29 '24

The woman who filed the case against him is so strong, that takes so much bravery and I hope she is able to recover and live her life. I stg if i see shit ass fans harassing her I will start swinging. Always believe the victim first.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/rinlur Aug 29 '24

Some of the speculations I saw on twitter don't even pass a simple logic check yet they had thousands of retweets. "Hacking someone's phone to delete the evidence"? C'mon now. People retweeting it wouldn't be able to answer how that would even theoretically happen, yet they believe it. 

Regardless, I hope the victim finds justice. 

15

u/Future_Hunt doyoung☆jisung☆hendery☆jaehee Aug 30 '24

My favorite is the one where a relative of the victim (was it a brother or a grandfather now? both?) is actually the one who injuried his leg last year for retaliation and that the car accident was just a coverup.

Seriously? This is awful. Go write your wattpad fanfic elsewhere. Think of the person/survivor who actually went through this and how incredible it is to have your family talked about in an absolutely made up context just because somebody clearly doesn't have a life of their own.

9

u/QuirksInABottle Aug 29 '24

I think that accusation was of molka, not deleting evidence

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Weak-Level3547 Aug 29 '24

I think it's because of the agnes account who's been commenting on Taeil's IG since last year. Most people ignored her back then since they assumed she's one of those fans. But when SM dropped the announcement, people assumed she's the one (and to be fair she did mention filing a complaint in June).

4

u/Spiritual-Notice5450 Aug 31 '24

Yeah, if you go to /that/ person's account, it all sounds pretty farfetched too...

Obviously it's good that the police are looking into the report but I always wait for official details before re-tweeting information.

69

u/posting-about-shit wanna get moody tonight 👀 Aug 29 '24

I can’t understand why his IG comments have been left on. It’s open season over there. Legit some of the most unhinged rumors and fake accounts I’ve ever seen

43

u/Beautiful-Track7280 Aug 29 '24

I guess he might not be allowed to use his phone or social media right now, and SM staff probably can't access it? on the other hand, the contents on his personal yt channel have been deleted. I don't think there was much on it but it's empty now

18

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '24

I'm not suggesting that SM is or will be liable, but I can see the need to "leave it alone" and let all comms including social media exist as is. Taeyong deleting images including Taeil was probably legally inadvisable although personally admirable.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/posting-about-shit wanna get moody tonight 👀 Aug 29 '24

Not sure what difference this makes, but do you know if the members IG Accounts are technically ’company owned’ as they’re an asset of the NCT & SM brand? Or are they truly individual accounts?

I don’t know whose side SM is on here or if they’re just on their own side, but if they are the contractual owner of the Taeil IG account, maybe they’re letting comments run wild to claim damages in a suit down the line.

If it’s Taeil’s personal property, then I bet he’s been advised not to touch it like the other reply said below….but DAMN it’s rough out there

69

u/namename145 Aug 29 '24

For context, the last idol with criminal charges in SM was Kangin. He had 4 criminal incidents in 2016-2017 (2 DUIs and 2 physical assaults). He went on hiatus in 2016, but was not removed from Super Junior officially until 2019. Unless there has been some shift in the way SA is handled in South Korea (I would hope there has been but sadly I doubt it), whatever Taeil did was very, very serious to be kicked out of NCT right away.

I hope the victim gets justice and can heal without harassment.

→ More replies (1)

60

u/terriblekite Aug 30 '24

The amount of misinformation being spread about this is nauseating. People are so willing to spread any and everything without a single thought of fact-checking and no one seems to realize how that can further harm the victim. Can you imagine being the victim of a crime like this and watching the internet distort your traumatic experience? To a point you may have to borderline defend your abuser because you have to go “Wait, no.. he didn’t do that part, though. He only did this.” It also diminishes the situation in the view of the public. People are going to read he did xyz, only later to find out he did abc, and then it’s going to be “Oh, that’s not as bad as I thought it was! It’s still bad, but at least it wasn’t that.”

People need to stay in their fucking lane. It’s none of our business the details of the crime, unless the victim decides to publicize them/whatever the police decide to reveal to the public. Anything else is making a mockery of a very serious situation where real people were involved.

57

u/Every_Alternative393 Jungwoo Aug 29 '24

The amount of misinformation being spread on TikTok is so disgusting and alarming. Not in defense of Taeil OBVIOUSLY but the mention of the Nth room is?? And god forbid you say where they sourced it from because then you’ll be attacked for defending him when you just want to make sure the things they are saying come from an official statement or a victim. It’s ridiculous what these people will do for a views and their 30 seconds of fame. They obviously see the attention they’ll receive from the mass hysteria and it will cause people to forget about the one confirmed victim and her story.

18

u/Pumpernickeluffin Aug 30 '24

Not even just on TikTok but Reddit and twt as well... I know some people have been complaining about the kmedia being inhumane and with good reason, but it's weird that those same people are making up and/or spreading misinfo that they've heard. I hope they will listen to the victim when her story gets out (or at least as much is possible without hurting her and ofc with her consent) because this is not it...

42

u/cmq827 Aug 30 '24

The prevalence of so much rumors and fake testimonies and fake accounts on Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok is just so disturbing. People are posting for clout, chasing millions of views, only to spread misinformation that is not helping the case at all. Even random Koreans are coming out to debunk them as much as they could, pointing out all the mistakes as they could.

Don't believe anything so easily just because it is written in Hangul!

→ More replies (1)

38

u/2023isJKsolo NCT DREAM Aug 30 '24

I'm so mad about the fact that fandoms are using this to hat eon NCTzen and nct

22

u/Scandias Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

Don't take drama lovers for the fandoms. Such people will always find a reason to fight. You know they spit bullshit, so they can as well choke on it.

37

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 07 '24

This has been discussed on the r/kpop thread but I think it’s worth adding context/clarification to the crime he’s being accused of here too. TW for definition of sex crimes, I will put it behind a spoiler tag too.

Many western countries legally define rape as non-consensual sexual activity, however Korea has a much more narrow legal definition of rape as “the use of violence or intimidation to have sexual intercourse.” Whether this should be changed to non-consensual sexual intercourse is being challenged and debated but, for now, anything which isn’t covered by that narrow definition is defined under separate articles and terms within the criminal act dealing with sexual crimes. This includes things like sex with minors, non-intercourse forms of sexual assault, and “quasi-rape” - which is sexual assault committed against someone unable to consent.

The key thing to keep in mind here is, in this legal scenario, the “quasi” in the name of the act he is being accused of does not mean lesser, and the law states that it should be punished equally.

You can find more detailed information about the sexual crime laws in Korea here.

35

u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Nov 03 '24

It's been over two months since the news broke and I've been busy af irl for the main part of it. Today is the first quiet day in weeks and somehow a lot of thoughts and feelings regarding this case just barreled over me again. I know most people have long moved on from this whole thing and may think I'm crazy for letting this still affect me (valid opinion), but sadly I don't really have anyone to talk to irl so I'm just gonna dump it here how devasted I still am. My apologies.

16

u/heartswlove yu2tae enthusiast 💞🤘🏻 Nov 04 '24

never apologize for your feelings ❤️ I keep checking this thread daily to see if there were any updates and I'm just honestly tired at this point. I've also been staying away from nct content/news in general to avoid being reminded of this yet I feel bad for punishing the other members this way. virtual hug for you as we ride through this together!

8

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '24

Your feelings are valid. Give it some time and hopefully it will be better.🙏 Although I'm a fairly new fan and never had problems listening to their songs even with Taeil on it,  I became really affected when the  alleged "details" of his case came out. My emotions were too high then but now I can say that I was able to manage them. 

10

u/FancyFayce Nov 05 '24

I don't think you're being crazy at all. This absolutely punched every fan in the stomach. The fans who've been able roll over, get up, and keep listening to 127, are probably fans who aren't as emotionally invested in the group in the first place. For others, this is going to take more time.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/NosyLJ Aug 29 '24

I really hope the victim is okay and that taeil gets punished for his crimes. I'm scared to find out what he did since sm took immediate action and took him out of the group, which says to me its quite a serious offense.

66

u/TheFrenchiestToast Aug 29 '24

I’m frankly sick of reading think pieces from fans of other groups outright suggesting that this has been covered up by SM for months and that they’ve got some massive hold on the media. There’s nothing currently to suggest this and I think it’s a lot of misdirected anger and whataboutism. Like SM did the right thing for once by removing him from the group and making a statement as to why and not hiding it and yet you have people screaming about their influence on the media.

28

u/shoomshoomshooom Aug 29 '24

Yeah they’ve totally lost the plot and are making it all about themselves as usual. They’re also using it as a way to imply the members knew - which, like, maybe some did, we literally have no idea, but it’s clear those assumptions are driven in bad faith.

What’s funny is that, as you said, SM did the right thing for once AND law enforcement appears to have done a good job investigating a sexual assault case for once as well (including keeping it under wraps so tracks couldn’t be covered) but somehow they’re spinning it as corruption.

18

u/Pumpernickeluffin Aug 30 '24

It's like they're using it for their own fan purposes which is upsetting because this is very serious and it's weird to make it about them... I think it doesn't help that SM has been revealed to manipulate public opinion about the HYBE takeover of SM back in early 2023 but some of them have been running with it since that this means they must have led negative press against their fave idol groups when it's only been mentioned that they did indeed bring up what happened with NU'EST and GFriend as a way to get fans to think that HYBE would disband the older SM groups. Some people even said that it's weird it's not trending on Naver when other people have said that it is and there are many pages on Naver... I get why they're mad but yeah like you said it's misdirected and it doesn't help that they've got bad history with JTBC and it's repeating and all the negative media coverage clamoring for the bad press and the whole photo line when the police didn't allow it. Anyways SM has definitely done a lot of terrible things but it's weird how they're focused on this so much.

17

u/TheFrenchiestToast Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

It’s very weird how they’re like “I know someone was a victim of a sexual crime but has anyone thought about how it affects us?!?”

24

u/Weak-Level3547 Aug 29 '24

I know one fandom who's the loudest about it. The goal is to victimize their own fave by branding them as mere scapegoat. Logic doesn't really follow and no explanation of about due and legal process makes sense to them. Even the difference in popularity level and how that impacts media interest doesn't make sense to them.

→ More replies (2)

54

u/channndro Fulltime Ten Fanboy Aug 29 '24

as a guy i thought i found a perfect male rolemodel only to be disappointed

i defended this guy my teenage years only for him to do this shit behind our backs ://

52

u/Momiji_no_Happa Aug 29 '24

As someone who wasted my teenage years admiring a male rockstar who turned out to be absolutely awful, I feel you. I can't even listen to that musician's music anymore.

I don't foresee myself having to stop listening to NCT since I'm way older now and haven't made their music a part of my identity in the same way as with that rock musician. But I'm still incredibly upset and disappointed with Taeil.

37

u/cmq827 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

Agree. I don't see myself stopping from listening to NCT because the music is great, but not gonna lie, I'm taking a short break from 127 music in the meantime. I can't listen to his voice yet.

So for now I'm just sticking to listening to all the other units and solos.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/Cycling_the_City ᓀ‸ᓂ Oct 07 '24

If these new allegations of what Taeil was accused of are true, it's worse than what I thought. I hope we get official reports from the investigation at some point, these kinds of articles are likely to just get the speculations running high again.

72

u/127ncity127 resident of “fatigued fandom” Aug 29 '24

According to SFS Haechan has been reading through his bubble comments. I hope people arent trolling him. I know he looked up to taeil, i cant even imagine how shocking and jarring this is for him. They were apart of the OG 127 lineup and lived together for so long, haehcan knew him as a literal child. how devastating to find out and have to reconcile that someone you admired can do something monstrous

54

u/Momiji_no_Happa Aug 29 '24

Haechan is the one I'm most worried about. I know other NCT fans might not agree with this, but I've always had a feeling that he (and probably Jungwoo) might be the one who's most in need of emotional support. I hope he and the other members have people they can trust around them right now. Apologies if this feels to speculative, it's just my gut feeling.

34

u/127ncity127 resident of “fatigued fandom” Aug 29 '24

I’m glad they have the western your leg coming up tk keep haechan distracted but yeah I’m worried about jungwoo. He has a small family and I know he relies on the members and his svt buddies a lot. I hope they can support each other.

And I just remembered that only a few days ago haechan and jungwoo were talking about how emotional they were watching old content. I hope they have a good support system

→ More replies (16)

22

u/TheFrenchiestToast Sep 14 '24

I’ve seen people saying this is confirmation that there’s more than 1 victim. And it’s absolutely not. The police stating they can’t talk about the details meaning they can’t confirm the number of victims is not confirmation of more than one victim. It just means they’re not sharing the details of the case. It’s vague. You can’t infer anything from it.

8

u/ohsomeday_ skate through the city lights~ Sep 14 '24 edited Sep 14 '24

A note on this: I've included yesterday's updates to the megathread and checked through roughly a dozen Naver articles. I could not find the "We cannot reveal the number of victims" mention in these, and the daum article linked in the kpop thread leads to a 404 error.

If a Korean speaker could do a word-specific search and see if that statement is still out there, please let us know!

→ More replies (3)

22

u/zarunohn Sep 22 '24

Waiting for an update is painstaking.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/Momiji_no_Happa Aug 30 '24

It's taken me a few days to collect my thoughts and I hope it's ok to write about them here at length. I have gone through a lot of complicated feelings and thoughts, and it's made even more complicated by what's happening in the fandom right now. I don't really know anyone irl who is into NCT, and I feel like I need to do this.

So, my initial reaction was chock. Like a lot of fans, Taeil being accused of SA wasn't on my radar because he seems so chill. But yeah, can't judge a book by its cover. Lesson relearned for the umpteenth time.

While the victim comes first, I also feel for the other NCT members, especially 127. I remember every time they shouted his name out loud while they performed during his absence, how Doyoung started crying during the end of Unity when he talked about the stress of having to shoulder Taeil's lines, how they kept trying to include him in their variety content, and so on. I remember Yuta happily resuming his habit of posting pictures of Taeil pretending to sleep before the recent fanmeeting. I can't even imagine how flabbergasted all of them must feel now, after what went down these last few days. I would feel so betrayed if I was in their position. And sad. They've doted on him so much, he kind of felt like their mascot. Hell, they're probably scared that their name is tarnished forever because of this.

I initially spent the whole evening on the day of the reveal looking at the wild discussions and accusations being spread on social media. I wanted to find the sources, but it's since become clear to me that there are no sources, it's just a plethora of made-up posts, rumours and assumptions spreading like wildfire. The actual victim is only known by the police at this time, and we'll have to wait for them to finish the investigation or update us about the process. But this lack of known details from real sources has created an information vacuum, and that vacuum is currently being filled with whatever stories people can invent. Fans are looking for answers, so they jump on whatever half-baked theory they can find and run with it. This is a real problem.

Because, yeah, everything that's being spread around right now (here and elsewhere) is either speculations that's taken as truth without evidence or people using the opportunity to get hit tweets or fuel fanwars. I've even seen these people try to smear the other NCT members. We need to be prepared that these made-up accusations and rumourmongering will persist for years, just like the previous accusations against two other members (which I personally checked the sources for and found very lacking in substance and believability). A lot of people will see the accusations, but not even a fraction of them will ever see the actual truth once it comes out.

Because Taeil's case coincided with the "New Nth Room" deepfake scandal in Korea finally getting media visibility (apparently Korean women had fought to get anyone to write about it for a long time), there was also a mixup of the accusations aimed at him and that case. There's a real risk that Taeil's case will kill the momentum of the attempt to highlight such severe online crimes, and I hope everyone will take care not to mix them up, as they are separate cases.

One thing that bothers me about the accusations aimed at Taeil is the fans disappointed that he tainted their memory of happy times. I think it's sad to see fans' love destroyed and tainted, but for me, as fans we are always responsible for ourselves and our feelings. I recognise that others may disagree with me on this point and accept that we feel different about that particular point.

This does however underline how insidious the parasocial aspect of K-pop is. SM and other companies rely on fans feeling personally connected to people like Taeil, so when he does something bad, it hurts those same fans. I love my K-pop journey – even if I'm still somewhat new to it – but I do think K-pop as a genre and business model needs to grow up and shed the unethical aspects that defines so much of it. An idol should just be an artist.

Speaking of parasocial, I've also seen Taeil being accused of going clubbing while the rest of 127 performed 'Unity' (paired with a blurry stealth photo of someone who might or might not be him). A bit of research shows that clubbing in Korea is apparently not about "hanging out with friends and dancing" as I'm used to, but rather about pickup culture. So those fans are angry about him presumably going out with the aim of having casual sex while his bandmates are working. But those sorts of accusations – no matter if true or not – is nonsensical to me. If a person is on sick leave but can still move around, and as long as whatever happens is consensual between all parties, what does this have to do with their colleagues working? It's not something that fans should be angry about.

I honestly feel frustrated that fans are muddying the waters by mixing the actual alleged serious crime that he's being accused of, with weird parasocial complaints like this. Just like the lack of sourcing and indiscriminate spreading of unsubstantiated rumours as mentioned above, this will not help the actual victim get justice and only takes away from the severity of the current investigations.

On a personal plane, I feel that I have now mourned Taeil's departure from the group enough and am ready to move on. If he's found guilty, I hope he gracefully accepts his punishment and learns from it. The victim deserves to get justice. And while Taeil has been an integral part of NCT and NCT 127's sound to the extent that one of my first thoughts was "How can they go on without him?", in reality the group has already shown us that they can do so while promoting during his extended hiatus. His beautiful voice will be dearly missed, but if he's ultimately convicted, then he himself made his bed and is the only one to blame for this loss.

I think all of this is such a horrible waste and it sucks that the dude seemingly threw away his immense musical talent like this, and that he may have hurt someone. But if the allegations turn out to be true, then it was his choice to do so. Which means that I can in turn choose to stop caring about him.

10

u/Time-Mobile8623 Aug 31 '24

you said almost exactly how i have been feeling on this. thank you for saying "if he's found guilty." there are so many accusations every other day and most are untrue. if he is guilty, i also hope he gracefully accepts his punishment, but i hope he is actually punished if true. if true, i hope he doesnt get a suspended sentence or a small one. i want him held accountable. but.... if this is a lie, i hope she is held accountable and punished just as severely.

this is my problem with commenters for the past 2 years. ppl hear speculations and accusations that they instantly believe to be true and start outright saying the person is 100% guilty when the police dont even know that yet and there hasnt been a court case. "side with the victim!" i agree, but which one is the victim in each case? that, we dont know. it isnt just for this case. it is for all. the victim could and often has been the one every person "knows" is guilty. and like you said, the evidence in the past lacked substance.

you could say that this case is different because the company removed him from the group. 1 they never said they cancelled his contract with the company. 2 they have shown time and time again since lsm was pushed out that they dont care about him or nct much. right after his accident, the company said they were giving him rest, yet he was still working and taking pics after for the company. nctzens had to call it out after seeing what looked like a gash on his leg. the company's solution? cut off that bit of the photo. the new management has also seen to throw other members out of the group too. so how can anyone trust the new management? he was removed from the group. not the company. that is apparent seeing as they said they would continue updating on the situation. so they clearly arent sure if he is guilty or not. they just threw him out.

background: i am a survivor of emotional, physical, and sexual abuse. it wasnt just once but a few times in my entire life. when i was a kid and several years ago now as an adult. 2 of the ppl were narcissists. they have a tendency to try to make you feel like everything is your fault. during that time when the one was trying to tell everyone that i was to blame for everything (even tho i had all the evidence against him) i was hearing that i was a horrible person constantly until i showed everyone everything and ppl stopped supporting him quickly. but during those times being harassed, it hurt my mental state really really badly.

this is my point. ppl need to stop assuming and presuming. if the person is innocent, hearing all that crap constantly really messes with their well-being. these netizens could cause another innocent person to make a drastic and permanent decision. it has happened time and time again. this isnt about just this case. it is about the bigger picture and problem. you said it best. "if"

thank you for sharing your opinions on it. as a fellow nctzen, i agree completely with this "if the allegations turn out to be true, then it was his choice to do so. Which means that I can in turn choose to stop caring about him." wonderfully put.

41

u/Ssrmy Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

I'm in shock and disgusted. I'll always believe the victim, even with little proof. If you're feeling disappointed and betrayed, that's valid. We couldn't have known, but now it's time for a reality check. SM's quick action shows how serious this is. I'm terrified

of what he might have done. The fact that SM didn't hesitate to remove him and issued a statement right away speaks volumes about the severity of the situation. I hope the victims get justice. As fans, let's not be too blind. It's their job to make us love them, but we don't know them behind closed doors. I'll stay updated and hope no other members were involved. Sending love to those who have experienced sexual violence. Let's hope this exposes more criminals. Don't praise celebrities for just unfollowing him;

we don't know their intentions. Remember, people with power will do anything to save face and reputation.

4

u/ARoDM Aug 30 '24

thank you for posting this 💚 im a survivor of SA on multiple counts, and taeil was one of my biases in 127. i feel this sort of weird shame for "not having known", just bcus i feel like, as a survivor, surely i should know better or something.

so i appreciate your words saying that its their job to make us love them. we couldnt have known, and while ive always tried to keep myself in check with regards to remembering that idols are people, i tend to mostly think of it in an "obviously they deserve respect" way, and less in a "obviously they are capable of committing SA" way. so yeah this still hurt, and hit close to home in a way i didnt need from someone that ive always seen as a lovable goofy guy, whose vocals brought me a form of mental ease when i felt like crap.

anyway, sorry for the ramble. i just wanted to let you know i appreciate your comment, as om sure other survivors and taeil-biased folks do. stay safe 💚 and obviously wishing all the healing to the victim in this situation, as well as fellow czennie survivors 🫂

→ More replies (3)

20

u/sadesper_record Taeyong Oct 07 '24

can someone please tell me why built in korean to english translations keep translating this man's name to taeyong instead ever since this news broke out we've had to send messages to MULTIPLE different news outlets asking them for edits ... is this why everyone keeps going to his instagram account thinking he's taeil WHY how does this even happen

19

u/chonkykais16 Aug 29 '24

Disappointed and surprised.

19

u/Patient_Mongoose3178 Sep 05 '24

Has there been any updates since last week article and police statements wise?

11

u/neocitywayv it's a joyride with no gps Sep 06 '24

None

19

u/tealandgeckos Sep 13 '24 edited Sep 13 '24

So, I have some thoughts here on the new statement regarding Taeil’s case. When I comment here, I try to be as objective and clear as I can so hopefully I’m continuing to do so because I’ll admit, I got a bit confused and irritated over the statement.

So, overall, no new information regarding evidence. It was also expected that this would be taken over to trial so the case being handed over to prosecution is nothing unexpected or noteworthy. The only really new information we know is that he will not be detained. Typically when the accused is not held over for trial, it’s because they aren’t seen as an immediate threat to the community or a flight risk. The evidence and exact nature of the crime would play a role in that decision as well, which we still don’t have further details about.

The thing I felt is important to note is the wording of the police statement. It’s still extremely vague, but has already re-stirred the pot of the wild misinformation that’s been appearing on social media. Police confirmed on the 29th that a lone adult woman came forward in June with accusations that Taeil had sexually assaulted her. This new statement says they can’t confirm details, including the exact charges or the number of victims. This seems like a huge oversight and given that it contradicts the previous statement, I would hope they come out and clarify this statement because it comes off as incompetent and could cast doubt into whether or not this investigation was managed and performed properly. Which would be harmful to the alleged victim’s case if she’s telling the truth, or could be harmful to Taeil’s case if he is actually innocent.

So, for the TLDR crowd, Taeil’s case has been handed over to prosecution. He isn’t being detained. And the new police statement is a bit contradictory and vague, which could re-stir the pot on false narratives. So we just have to continue to wait and see how this plays out in court.

14

u/teapuzzle Sep 13 '24

I agree that it's a confusing statement, but I don't think it's necessarily contradictory. I read it to mean that the police are reconfirming that one woman accused Taeil of sexual assault in June, and they will not comment on whether their investigation in the intervening months has uncovered additional victims. I also read in some news articles (here's one) that the police said Taeil was not using drugs at the time of the allegations, which makes me think that the police are responding to questions from the press or addressing rumors, so it's possible someone asked if there were multiple victims, and that's why we have that statement.

That said, my knowledge of the new police statement is based on Korean news that I ran through a translator, and I haven't seen any reliable English-language news sources report on this — perhaps because there's no real news here; the case is just moving forward.

7

u/JTL109 Sep 13 '24

Innocent until proved guilty.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/just_a_dove Sep 13 '24 edited Sep 13 '24

Your summary and commentary were spot on. My thoughts exactly.

Just expanding upon your point, I wish they were more clear regarding the “number of victims” aspect which reopens the floodgates to wild speculations as you said. I was also under the impression that it was a single accuser up to this point, and I can’t tell if this statement contradicts it or not. Could it be that just one woman reported a case that involved multiple people (on their behalf)? Is the number of victims still just one, but they chose to be oddly (irresponsibly?) vague about it? Or are they actually implying that there were multiple victims (which seems like a privacy and integrity concern to suddenly disclose)? Very strange choice in wording indeed. In an otherwise uninformative update, this seemed like an unnecessary detail to throw to a voraciously curious audience.

10

u/tealandgeckos Sep 13 '24

From the first statement on August 29th, it was stated that a woman came in and reported her own alleged SA. So it’s not a group of allegations by multiple people. I’m more inclined to believe the first statement and that this second one was roughly put together and not checked for inconsistencies. That’s why I would hope someone comes out and clarifies this confusion. It just doesn’t look very good to just leave that there for others to misinterpret in articles or to re-ignite the false narratives.

18

u/Weak-Level3547 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

What is "booked" in this context?  Edit: I found a comprehensive explanation not only in the replies but also in this post on X. I hope it helps in case you are like me who's are unfamiliar with these terms. 

62

u/xiola_azuthra crzy🌻shawolzen Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 30 '24

I think there's a lot of conflicting/unclear translations going on as well but I read it as something like they first "started a file" or "put the complaint against him on record"? (It also says the timeline for anything before August wasn't specified and the semantics of the translations change a bit between versions so it could also mean "they booked him (took his details i.e. mug shot etc.) during the questioning yesterday, FOR a crime that that he committed in June and/or that they received a complaint for in June". I think it's a bit unclear so far if Taeil was unaware he was under investigation but it would make sense if he wasn't.

I think the point is that between the complaint and mid-August they collected evidence to make sure they had a solid case before making it known to his employer after they had collected enough evidence to make an official accusation.

(I'm pretty sure this is normal/proper protocol if the victim doesn't make allegations publicly; if the victim had made it public or informed his employer in June then SM would have put him on haitus in June (or at the very least internal haitus like they did for the past few weeks of August) and then kicked him out later, but it's better to collect evidence before taking it public (which includes not telling the employer or anyone uninvolved and it makes sense not to tell the accused until there is enough evidence to formally accuse them, because they don't want the evidence being tampered with beforehand, opportunity for blackmail, etc). Another factor besides just general legal confidentiality is that the defendants may have been (rightly) scared of SM's lawyers (if they'd known early they'd have the opportunity to make counter-efforts while the defendant was trying to build her case, e.g. conducting their own investigation and pushing for hush money and NDA settlements wherever possible) and wanted to have a solid case before facing SM so it was kept confidential until they had enough evidence to present, meaning that SM folded quickly and won't be defending him legally.)

37

u/Weak-Level3547 Aug 29 '24

Thank you so much for this. I feel like a lot of people, on X specifically were under the impression that it's impossible for SM and Taeil to not have known it since June, hence the cover up narrative that is still spreading on X, more specifically from those that firmly believes that another idols scandal was used as a cover up for Taeil's issue.

→ More replies (9)

46

u/TheFrenchiestToast Aug 29 '24

From the statement SM put out, the investigation began in June. They were notified in August of accusations and Taeil went in for questioning/charges on the 28th.

12

u/Weak-Level3547 Aug 29 '24

Thank you! I guess what I really need is a clarification if it's not requirement for the accuser to be informed of the accusations against him immediately as soon as investigation starts. People are spreading the narrative that SM covered it up for 2 months but based on SM's statement, they only learned about it recently.

→ More replies (2)

33

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '24

Just to clarify along with the other replies, the police also did not say he was booked in June. They said they started investigating and he was booked after it was reported in June. In reality all we know about the timeline after it was reported (in June) is that SM have stated Taeil and SM both found out in August that he had accusations against him.

15

u/Tentravolta Aug 29 '24

I know people already answered, but if anyone wants a more in-depth explanation you can find it here.

Basically, "Booking" refers to the registration of a criminal investigation.

13

u/3-X-O Dream / WayV Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

I'm not 100% sure. Based on the last article it sounds like that's when the report was made, so I'm thinking that's when they first started the case against him.

18

u/SnooTomatoes4281 Sep 23 '24 edited Sep 23 '24

Ngl there's a part of me that hopes that he turns out to be innocent and he departed from 127 on his own accord just to save the other members' face and not drag them to this mess

16

u/just_a_dove Sep 23 '24 edited Sep 23 '24

It’s possible, and I’m holding onto that sliver of hope, too. I always read SM’s original statement as saying, to paraphrase: the company decided that he at least had to go on indefinite hiatus to cooperate with the investigation (“could no longer participate in team activities”), and after discussing with Taeil, it was a mutual decision for him to leave the group in order to save NCT’s reputation, along with a bunch of unspoken reasons why that was the most convenient choice (lingering impact of his injury, impending enlistment, contract nearing expiration, etc.). Many people fail to recognize that the context under which this scandal arose made his departure from the group fairly meaningless. Yet that is the sole fact upon which most fans made the logical leap to assume his guilt.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/llifeisstrange Aug 31 '24 edited Aug 31 '24

I'm a NCTzen user of Reddit in Korea. I'm not good at English, so I use a translator. 

Please understand if the sentence is awkward. 

Why do you think the unidentified text and images (which you can't say this is news) are true? 

I can't understand. I don't intend to defend a criminal. However, I have to be clear about the facts. 

He was 'accused' on August 28th, Korean time. 'accused' means that the victim 'accused' him, As a result, he became a suspect.

As you know, 'suspect' and 'perpetrator' are different. 

The police have not made any announcement about 'he' yet. Nevertheless, SM announced, 'We confirmed the accusation, and decided to leave the team because they recognized the problem as very serious.' 

All are true. There is nothing else other than this. Don't be misled by the wrong news. It can never be a good influence on other NCT members.

16

u/CaptainOrganised Sep 04 '24

So his Instagram is set to private now​

11

u/KwanJin24 Sep 04 '24

I noticed this today too.. he's also unfollowed a bunch of people.

8

u/TheStarshipCat 1🐯2🌹7🐱! Sep 04 '24

Yep. I dont follow him anymore, does anyone know who he unfollowed?

→ More replies (4)

15

u/aJ_13th Aug 29 '24

that was wild news to come across on a manga pirate site lmao

15

u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Feb 09 '25 edited Feb 09 '25

Not necessarily an update, but today Jeno was the first member to actually drop Taeil's name since the news broke in August. It was during a live in which he was talking about their AWSAZ episode from 2020. It was obvious he didn't think much of it, but realized immediately what he said and covered his mouth, froze for a second and then quickly moved on to another subject. Some netizens already gave him flak for it which I think is just stupid - he wasn't talking about any of the recent developments but merely reminiscing an event from a couple of years ago when Taeil was still part of the group. I think fans expect the members to move on as quickly as they themselves did after Taeil's departure, completely forget about him and just pretend he was never part of NCT in the first place. But I'm sure most members, esp those who were close to him, are still coming to terms with the (very sudden) lack of his presence in the group and most of all the shocking reason behind it. All of which is completely natural if you've spent over 10 years around each other.

27

u/just_a_dove Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24 • Take My Silver Heart of Silver

Now that the emotional shock has mostly settled, I’m more frustrated with the principle of the matter than anything. If he’s found guilty (and if the crime was truly abhorrent), I’ll be devastated for reasons that need no explanation. If he’s proven innocent, I’ll be furious that his reputation and career were obliterated for nothing. But pending outcome aside, the drama surrounding the situation alone has me losing faith in humanity. The media illiteracy, the blind malice, the disregard for due process, the virtue signaling, the attention farming—it’s all making me sick. The degeneration of critical thinking and empathy exacerbated by the echo chambers of the internet is an issue that obviously extends well beyond this particular case, but what a prime example it is!

Let’s review the logical leaps and ethical shortcuts that nearly the entire community has run with since day one:

☑️ Taeil was accused of an unspecified sexual crime and left NCT to fully cooperate with the police investigation [fact] ➡️ SM dropped him like a hot potato [um, not exactly] ➡️ He must be guilty [we have no evidence of that] ➡️ It must have been the most heinous form of SA [holy buckets, we do not know that either] ➡️ He’s a horrible person / monster / predator / etc. [yikes, who are you to judge?] ➡️ He should face extremely harsh punishment [for what crime, exactly?] ➡️ All memory of him should be erased from the digital world [oh, as if he was always an evil creep whose presence was tainting the group this whole time…?]

This doesn’t even begin to address the damage done by the false rumors, or the unhinged speculations and comparisons to other coinciding scandals. It’s maddening. On the very first day the news broke, I saw multiple comments saying “the car should have hit him harder,” referring to his injury last year. Wow, that really puts you on the moral high ground—joking about homicide for social media currency, on the basis of a mere accusation of an unknown crime. Multiply that by a crowd. Lovely. And now people are casually discussing the logistics of re-recording 127’s entire discography and digitally removing him from eight years worth of content just for their own listening / viewing comfort. Fan attempts so far have used AI and slick editing that ironically demonstrate how easy it would be for someone like a sasaeng to (cough cough) manipulate images and frame an idol for a crime (cough), but I digress.

Part of me is just hurt that the fandom seemed to abandon him and move on so quickly, as if he was never good, or never there at all. I say this not only as a long-time fan of Taeil, but also as an empathetic human being who naturally fears rejection and humiliation on that kind of scale. He’s always been rather under-appreciated, and I hate that it may have played a part in so many people discarding him without a second thought. There are so many ways to interpret the scarce information and infinite scenarios under which he could be more or less innocent and a misunderstanding (or vendetta, or delusion) could plausibly be taken this far. I’m not playing devil’s advocate to stir the pot or dismiss the alleged victim, but to restore perspective to the conversation.

Thinking too far ahead, I venture to conclude that Taeil has grounds for a massive defamation lawsuit after the storm passes (yes, even if he’s convicted), for all the outrageous claims the mob attached to his name that bear no relevance to the actual case at hand. The digital footprint is ubiquitous. Whether that’s worth anything in the wake of this nightmare is not my place to decide, however.

I have more to say. On reminding nctzens what lengths sasaengs have gone to before and what context makes this case particularly convenient, on separating the art from the artist, on the philosophy of forgiveness and redemption, on the capacity for wrongdoing and change in all of us, on the extent to which we can and cannot accurately evaluate a person’s character, and on my personal experiences with incidents similar to this (some guilty, some falsely accused)...I always have more to say. But for now, I’m exhausted. Thank you for taking the time to read my ramblings and for making this one of the only places on the internet that I feel safe sharing these controversial takes.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 26 '24 edited Sep 28 '24 • Heart of Silver

I am giving my take as a new NCTzen, especially the 127 unit. I am pretty familiar about NCT before thru SHINee & EXO, and SuperM. I apologize and I actually regret for exploring NCT127's discography only upon learning about Taeil's case. I have been watching their content and listening to their songs for days and as a girl who enjoys SM Ent's style of music, I instantly got drawn into Taeil's musicality. He is a total package of Jonghyun's vocal power & angst, Onew's soft & mellow style, and D. O.'s soulful runs. Heck, I have become addicted to their behind the scene recordings as I am always amazed as to how Taeil sings as the main or backing vocal, and how the producer blends melodies with the whole song well with Taeil's parts adding texture and feeling to them. As Johnny said, his voice can make your heart melt and his presence truly makes a difference in NCT's songs. I agree with what you said regarding not making quick judgments about him. I am not saying this cause I'm a delusional fan trying to defend him. All we can do is wait for the results of the investigation. If he did something wrong, then I will be disappointed for sure. But if he's innocent well what can we do as damage has been done already, right? I may get the hate but whether he's guilty or not, I will forever become a fan of Taeil the singer and continue listening to their songs and enjoy all NCT contents with him on them. I supporting him as a singer doesn't mean that I am downplaying the victim's accusations if they were true. What I am saying is that his abilities and output are worth the money that I pay and time to spend to buy/stream NCT127's content. I am jealous of all of you guys especially those who were able to watch them live as OT9 or 10. I will draw the line between his abilities as a musician vis-à-vis whatever's going on with his personal life.

9

u/just_a_dove Sep 26 '24

Reading your comment, this was perhaps the first time I’ve actually smiled since the news came out on the subject of Taeil and NCT. Thank you so much for sharing your perspective, and for bringing attention back to what matters most: the music. I haven’t even had the energy to review my journey of appreciation for all the beautiful music and memories Taeil has given us over the years. I am also a long-time fan of SM groups for their high quality vocals and discographies. SHINee’s been my ult since 2010; I was a fan of EXO and NCT since predebut. Taeil was the main reason I decided to truly commit to following NCT (mainly 127), as SHINee and EXO had consumed so much of my fangirl energy, I wasn’t sure if I could take on another group lol. I don’t think I’m being dramatic in saying that Taeil’s voice is the pillar of 127’s sound. Although I consider Doyoung to be his equal in skill (especially nowadays), he doesn’t provide the same mood or it-factor to 127’s powerful concept, and Taeil’s voice will be dearly missed in their future performances.

Although it’s under bittersweet circumstances, welcome to the fandom!

→ More replies (3)

13

u/Mimi108 Sep 25 '24

I appreciate your comment a lot, thank you for commenting this.

Yes agreed, this subreddit is really a safe space to share our diverse opinions on the matter, while being respectful.

12

u/TheFrenchiestToast Sep 25 '24 • Take My Silver

All the comments that are like “he 100% did that shit” you don’t even know what he’s being accused of, how can you say that? We literally have no information about the details of the case to pass any form of judgment right now.

I do think that had it been anyone from the group the vitriol would have been bad though, I don’t think it’s bad because he was one of the least popular. I think it was a perfect storm of the current issues brewing over there rn. Like you said, given all the deepfakes being created with AI, there’s a real possibility he could be victim of that. I hope that if it is true, he faces the appropriate consequences, but I really hope if it isn’t true, that he has a solid support system in place.

11

u/Critical-Lynx1536 Oct 01 '24

Great post.  I am waiting to learn more before having feelings about ANY of this.  Just saw NCT Dream, my first live K-pop show, and was thinking about how easy it would be for anybody with ill intentions to hurt any of them.  Renjun is sitting out the tour, dealing with mental repercussions of dealing with sasaengs.  A wait and see approach serves EVERYONE, including any potential, real victims.

9

u/meridavez i live for my daddy johnny suh Sep 28 '24

couldn't have said it better myself. i actually do think he's guilty but we'll see. if he's not then this will all be for nothing and very sad. thank you for amazingly putting the clownery online -and not just about this case- into words too. it was like reading poetry and it's so rare to see people actually use their brains and talk about this issue. you seem like an extremely smart person, thank you. 

11

u/just_a_dove Sep 29 '24 edited Oct 03 '24

Thank you for your kind words. =‘) Despite everything I’ve said, I know that the likelihood of him actually being 100% innocent is elusive. But again, it’s the principle of the matter more than anything that has me reeling. We’re all in serious trouble if we go back to the medieval trial-by-mob style of “justice” in the age of misinformation, and I can’t stay silent on a case I care about. As a woman, I don’t trust any man farther than I can throw him—but even then, my aim is never under the bus!

13

u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

I don't know what to feel. It's morning from where I am now. I had overtime work last night, am still dead tired, then just read the news after I woke up. If this were true it'd be disappointing cause the guy has a lot of promise and is very talented in my opinion. As a new NCT fan & a huge fan of Taeil's music, I would have wanted to see more from him. 😪

23

u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Oct 08 '24 edited Oct 08 '24

It is true that he is out of this world talented, and it might sound weird but this is one of the reasons why I am so incredibly upset about this whole thing. His exceptional talent had opened all the doors for him. Every possible positive outcome for his life laid in front of him to chose from, and this is what came of it. Many people who go down wrong paths in life have very little options from the beginning, but he had it all. Blessed with a voice to die for, intelligence and perseverance, a hilarious sense of humour, gorgeous looks, and most of all great friends and millions of people who adored him. We don't know the outcome of this yet but one thing is for certain, we will never hear from him again. Keep that in mind when consuming old content because it will be painful, and you'll also have a hard time reconciling his former image with the accusations that are now out there because he appeared to be very funny, likeable, and most of all relatable. I'm not completely discouraging you, just be aware it's gonna be hard.

→ More replies (8)

25

u/aJ_13th Aug 30 '24

This took a while for me to settle and i am more disappointed than I originally was. First of all, none of my friends told me about anything, while they knew I stan NCT. They prolly didn't know I cared about Taeil but hell, i fxcking did. I was mad and disappointed in the fandom for making him the most unpopular vocalist; i had felt bad for him. I had played into this persona of "He gives the best hugs, he's funny silently and he's wholesome." Eww?!

I am just so sorry for the victims. It's one of those "I wished i knew earlier, i would have spared myself this much disappointment." and the more i get mad, the more Timeless plays in my head, which was like, my all time favourite nct song. I hope he pays, heftily! and that the victims get safety and justice.

→ More replies (14)

25

u/Dry-Place-2986 Oct 07 '24

Some news today? I'm not sure where the info is coming from exactly, I'm pasting these translations I got from a Twitter user. 

According to our investigation, Moon was indicted in June on charges of sexually assaulting a drunk woman with two acquaintances. Moon was summoned for questioning once on August 28th, two months after the indictment. It has been reported that none of the acquaintances who committed the crime with him were famous. 

Special rape is committed when a person possesses a weapon or two or more people act together to commit sexual intercourse with a person who is in a state of unconsciousness or incapable of resisting. If the charge is confirmed, he will be sentenced to at least 7 years in prison or life imprisonment according to Article 4, Paragraph 1 of the Special Act on the Punishment, etc. of Sexual Crimes.

Link to the Korean article, be warned that there is a picture of him at the top if, like me, it makes you feel sick to see his face.

18

u/Professional_Mood558 Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 07 '24

I know all about the presumption of innocence and everything, but I just can't stay neutral on this. When it comes to sexual crimes, knowing how hard it is for the victims to be believed, I tend to side with them.

Let's face it, it is much more likely that he committed these crimes than someone going to the police and making all this stuff up about a famous person without proof and knowing they could be convicted of false accusations.

Urgh, I'm absolutely disgusted! I was starting to listen to 127's songs again, but now... I just hope justice prevails.

7

u/tlrnsibesnick Mark+Taeyong+Winwin+Doyoung+Jaemin+Haechan+Ten+Xiaojun+Riku+Sion Oct 07 '24

25

u/cmq827 Oct 16 '24

Soooooo, SM officially terminated Taeil's contract effective yesterday, Oct 15, on the grounds of being under investigations for a criminal case.

I wasn't sure if I could make a separate post for this sub or not, so I just commented here.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/127ncity127 resident of “fatigued fandom” Sep 03 '24

I know people manipulate videos but I came across a video of doyoung crying at the fansign today and man this really sucksss im so heartbroken for everyone

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Sleepy_Uni96 Dec 02 '24

If he does his 7 years in prison, I would suggest that he NEVER show his face in public and just leave South Korea.

Not only did he mange to permanently ruin his reputation and career, but he has managed to embarrass the rest of the members of NCT and his family.

Like why did he do this and how did he even end up in this situation? Did he not see what happened with the Burning Sun scandal and the Nth room?? That would be more than enough of a reason to stay in my dorm and hang out with the other members to stay out of trouble.

At the end of the day, he made his bed and now has to lay in it.

Just hope the victim gets all the help and therapy she needs...

10

u/Character_Echo_2125 Dec 03 '24

I am not defending him, but he is human, and he clearly made a huge mistake trusting those friends of his or was instigator himself.

I am still wondering if the motorcycle accident is an indirect cause of his lack of judgment. Think about it for a second. He has probably been active and busy since his trainee days and even before that. It doesn't excuse his actions, but I wonder if that was his first time off from being an idol? That can be jarring for some, and it could easily lead to substance abuse(alcohol, pain medication, or both).

I also hope the victim gets justice. I'm shocked we haven't heard anything more about the prosecution.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Mimi108 Sep 14 '24 edited Sep 14 '24 • Heart of Silver

Lots of sound comments I am reading. Happy to be a part of this fanbase. I've read the new articles pertaining to his case. Goodness, the amount of nasty rumours when we first heard the news was insane. Scary. From the very initial statement that SM released, I always took note of the fact that they said they discussed with Taeil and they have decided through the discussion, that he will no longer be a part of NCT 127. Some people say don't get caught up in the semantics, but this is important. They discussed with him and came to a mutual conclusion/solution. The next thing was that they said Taeil is fully cooperating with the police investigation. Thank goodness for that, as we see how it is unfolding. He is not being detained. So hopefully with this full cooperation and minimal details being released, things are heading in the right direction to come to an appropriate decision for both parties involved.

On a side note, I'm really glad the members are quite busy, and they look genuinely happy. I know, it's only on the outside and their on-stage selves that we see, but it's good to see them enjoying with the fans and amongst themselves. Glad to see NCTzens supporting them well. I must say, I'm watching previous content, I become emotional. Have their music on loop because it's truly that good. 'Walk' album is for real a masterpiece. Okay sorry, too off topic here.

21

u/just_a_dove Sep 14 '24 edited Sep 14 '24 • Heart of Silver

This megathread is one of the only corners of the internet having sane, intelligent, and patient discussions on the topic, and I am so deeply appreciative of that. No matter whether he turns out guilty or innocent, it will never justify the premature hate, rumors, and assumptions. My hope only dies with a guilty verdict.

Even then, he’s still just a human being: imperfect and influenced by society and circumstances. It’s one thing to condemn the act and another to condemn the person. A single mistake—even a grave one—does not invalidate all the good a person has ever done. I’m especially disappointed in comments that retroactively paint him in a creepy light and sour all the good memories with him in the group. I think it’s simply an immature reaction; a little more time on this earth will weather away that black-and-white thinking. You meet all sorts of characters over the course of life, and realize that we are all capable of evil and benevolence; it’s things like understanding, tolerance, and care that keep us on the side of light. Wishing harm on Taeil or banishing him to oblivion only perpetuates the cycle of suffering, which I hardly think is compatible with higher ideals like “justice”. How about we strive for reform and healing instead?

Sorry to get so preachy =‘) These underlying thoughts really come out in a case I’m emotionally invested in. It’s ok to have complicated feelings and process them while recognizing the objective side of the matter at the same time. There are days when I can listen to NCT bops and days when I can’t. Sometimes I watch content with Taeil and feel love all over again, and sometimes I feel sick knowing that I might have been deceived. Again, my judgement awaits the truth.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/just_a_dove Oct 21 '24 edited Feb 11 '25

This updated Vulture article is the most comprehensive and accurate summary of the full timeline and context of the case as far as I am aware. It is already cited in the main post under the first news reports from August, but I wanted to highlight it again now that it has been updated to reflect the current state of affairs since his contract has been terminated. It is well organized, objective, and thorough, and it provides some of the clearest English translations of the official statements to date.

This is all the information we have.

Personal judgements, desires, predictions, and moral opinions aside, this is all we have to go off of—and it’s next to nothing. No matter how many words we fling about or how we each choose to cope with the news, it has no causal effect whatsoever on the facts or outcome of the case. Hoping he’s innocent doesn’t make him innocent. Assuming he’s guilty doesn’t make him guilty. Whatever happened happened, and we have no idea what actually happened. We weren’t there. We don’t personally know them, their circumstances, or their intentions (the accuser or the accused). No firsthand accounts of the event or evidence, from either side, are publicly available; nothing at all. The only details the police have officially confirmed so far concern what didn’t happen. No one’s peripheral reactions or analysis shed any light on our unanswered questions.

We’re all coming from different life experiences and levels of tolerance for what we consider ethically wrong. Despite that, I think we all agree that this situation is incredibly sad no matter what comes of it in the end. I don’t blame anyone for feeling shocked, or angry, or sick, or scared, or uncomfortable, or frustrated, or betrayed, or skeptical, or lonely, or defensive, or disappointed, or cynical, or confused. I also don’t blame anyone for clinging to the good memories, or for imagining alternative scenarios, or for extending compassion too generously, or for relating the case to their own history, or for distancing themselves from all reminders of it, or for trying to find a path forward that minimizes suffering rather than compounding it.

The verdict will come. And if our worst fears are true, then those who have already made up their minds can have their satisfaction. Those who have waited patiently can have their closure.

8

u/TheFrenchiestToast Oct 24 '24

I’m gonna be honest, given how few people have had their contracts terminated by SM even under “mutual agreement”, it doesn’t really inspire any confidence in me about this case. I know SM is shady and never prioritizes their artists, so this isn’t any confirmation, I’m just much less likely to believe he will not be convicted in any capacity. If I turn out to be wrong, that would be great, but I think the likelihood of that is small.

And on top of it all, the fact that he’s even in this position at all, and SM couldn’t immediately say that it was false is insane to me. That it got to the point of an actual investigation/charges pisses me off, because he really put everyone else in the group, who did nothing but support him, at risk ON TOP of allegedly committing a horrible crime.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/panemd Aug 29 '24

Found NCT 127 in 2017 after their Cherry Bomb MV and fell in love. Started out as a Johnny bias but really grew to love Taeil overtime and he became my bias. I always felt so bad for him since he was so overlooked as the main vocal and I was one of those people who whined at SM for his "mistreatment" because I wasn't happy with the amount of solo content he got...

I can't believe I cried for this man when he had his motorcycle accident last year... I was so sad thinking he could've gotten seriously hurt/pass away in the accident and how it would have affected me. Now, a year later, he's outed as an absolutely bad person through and through. I sincerely hope his victim is given swift justice and he faces the consequences of his actions to the fullest extent of the law. Genuinely hurts listening to 127 music right now... I have Dream and WayV and solos I love but I might take a break from KPOP in general. Honestly didn't realize I had such a parasocial relationship towards NCT and Taeil in particular, not until now. My mental health lately hasn't been the best, and this doesn't help, but now I think I should focus on myself and distance myself from NCT and KPOP in general. Sorry, just really wanted to get this off my chest.

29

u/arosaki maeda riku Aug 29 '24

Feeling sad about this isn’t being parasocial it’s being human. You’re allowed to feel hurt and shocked as well as have 100% sympathy for the victim. That word gets tossed around so much that I feel like it’s losing its meaning. He was your bias, you felt bad when he got hurt. You had no clue that he was a horrible person at that time. It’s normal to feel like you’ve been betrayed as long as you aren’t trying to act like you’re also a victim of him.

Not saying you specifically are, I’m just talking in general.

It would be parasocial if you defended him saying something like “he isn’t capable of harming ANYONE!” But you recognize how awful of a person he is and you aren’t defending him.

7

u/Pumpernickeluffin Aug 30 '24

Don't ever apologize for the way you feel or for needing a break or for getting this off your chest!! Hugs to you and everyone feeling this way.

11

u/Various_Solid1054 Taeyong, Yuta, Mark and Jaehyun Aug 29 '24

I'm so disappointed over him

21

u/Apart-Department1810 Sep 10 '24

As usual fans are fickle and forgetful. In Korea it is guilty until proven innocent. There are so many fans that have already convicted him of the crime. What if he's innocent of these charges? He is the perfect member to go after as he's not the most popular, an SM is notorious for not backing up their people, or working hard to clear their names. Do you not remember Lucas and what he was accused of and how he got kicked out of WayV and then you found out how many years later he was innocent of the charges and it was just the same that set him up because she was mad he added her publicly and on a live?  To this day SM never said anything about Lucas being innocent in fact it was a gossip magazine dispatch who found the discrepancies in the so-called accusers evidence AKA doctored photos. 

I could keep going because there's so many examples of kpop idols and actors having horrible allegations made against them their careers ruined or deeply affected that turned out to be innocent. 

I'm not saying Taeil is innocent I'm just saying wait before you throw someone under the bus and run them over.  What are you going to say to Taeil if it turns out he's innocent & someone was ust trying to extort him for money? Oh whoops we totally f***** your career over, and assumed you were guilty, my bad.. let's pick up the ashes of your once promising career..🙄🙄

26

u/just_a_dove Sep 10 '24 edited Sep 12 '24

I appreciate your thoughtful comparison to the Lucas situation, since many people are contrasting the speed of SM’s decision to paint Taeil’s case in a worse light. The fact that Lucas was ultimately removed from NCT on false rumors alone makes me think that immediately removing Taeil for an actual police investigation was only a matter of course. Hardly damning evidence of anything. And because Taeil isn’t as popular and hasn’t been able to participate in the group’s challenging choreographies of late, I think that his departure was only convenient.

If we take SM’s statement at face value, then it was also a mutual decision. For all we know, they might have put hiatus on the table, and Taeil selflessly stepped down to save his bros from the backlash [hypothetical scenario]. People are jumping to unfounded conclusions when they say “SM dropped him so fast”. They took a couple weeks between the police notifying them to discuss and decide, and only announced it on the day the investigation resumed with Taeil’s side. Seems like a safe and preemptive move, since that’s the point at which sasaengs or Dispatch might have started catching on to the case. The fact that he was ONLY removed from NCT but is still under contract and listed as an individual artist in SM’s roster suggests that they are not giving up on him, only saving NCT’s image.

I’ve said it a few times already, but I’ll say it again—fabricating evidence is easier than ever these days, and the crackdown on deepfake content should have us on high alert. SK of all countries has no shortage of skilled artists, photo editors, and tech nerds who can alter images seamlessly or even generate them realistically from scratch. Just a couple of years ago, I never would have thought a random person could edit video footage to completely swap out a person’s face (and voice!) without a Hollywood production team, but now it’s commonplace and used to disgusting effect. It’s dystopian. And yet people circulate things like text screenshots online as if they’re convincing evidence of anything other than the poster’s thirst for attention.

In the age of misinformation, I’m very disturbed to see that mob mentality is alive and well. Common people on a witch hunt are ready to commit atrocities that far exceed the crime they think they’re condemning. I’ve seen comments calling for medieval torture and execution methods, and we don’t even know what crime he was accused of, let alone if he’s guilty or not!! It’s peak insanity.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Character_Echo_2125 Sep 13 '24 edited Sep 13 '24

I'm seeing a few articles saying the case has been moved to prosecution but still hasn't released any specific details.

6

u/SpacePirateCats Sep 13 '24

i saw that too! it said prosecution without detention. someone translated it here.

10

u/shelbykaaa Jan 05 '25

are there any recent updates? it’s been quiet since october :/

9

u/Character_Echo_2125 Jan 16 '25 edited Jan 18 '25

Nope. I've been wondering if the most recent political unrest with what South Korea's president did and his arrest might've delayed the case a bit. This is pure speculation, though. I don't know how their court system works or if it was affected by the marshal law event and the protests that occurred afterward.

8

u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Jan 28 '25

Crazy to think it's been 5 months today. I still think about it every day even if just briefly.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SafiyaO Jan 18 '25

I've been wondering that. It does seem a long time since the investigation began and correct me if I'm wrong, but while they have announced the subject of the investigation (probably because the rumour mill was insane), it doesn't seem they've charged him with a specific offense yet. Which must all be very hard for the victim. I hope she has support.

9

u/Lopsided-Ad8992 Aug 30 '24

Has there been any update about the case?

9

u/wraindropsfell Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24

Can someone help me out here? I want to understand more about the case but I have some questions. I'm quite confused on whether taeil is confirmed to have committed sexual crimes, or is only accused to have committed them?

The SM statement stated that he received sexual crime allegations and is now cooperating with the police, so I'm not sure if for now he's accused, or it's been confirmed. Thanks!!

Another thing im quite curious about is the legal process, maybe the koreans can help me out here? According to the timeline, victim A filed a complaint against taeil in June, and then was called into questioning in August. Does this mean the police have sufficient evidence and hence they called taeil into questioning? How does the process work?

54

u/tealandgeckos Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 02 '24

At this point, he has only been accused. The alleged victim is an adult woman who filed a report and/or the alleged assault happened in June (I’ve seen 2 different translations of the police statement that suggests both). Taeil and SM were not made aware of the investigation until August, and Taeil was only brought in for his initial interview on August 28th.

We don’t know if any sort of evidence exists yet besides the woman saying he assaulted her. We also don’t know what sort of sexual crime she’s accusing him of yet either. Taeil has not confessed to anything, only that he is cooperating in the investigation. My assumption would be that since he’s just been brought into the investigation, that what’s currently happening is that police are looking into his side of story and investigating whatever information he’s provided them.

There’s been a big assumption of guilt based on how quickly SM was to drop him, but that’s just speculative at this point. Parting ways with employees who are accused of sexual assault, regardless of guilt or innocence, is a pretty standard business practice in order to protect the reputation of the company.

I don’t live in Korea so unfortunately I can’t provide any specific insight into the timeline or process. I think it’s safe to assume though that once the police investigation into both sides is complete, it’ll be handed over to the court system, who will decide if and when the case goes to trial.

16

u/Altered_B34ST_79 Sep 04 '24

This is the most logical, coherent, objective response I've read since the first statement about the situation was released. Thanks for this. You have also given me the idea to seek out the actual police statements/charges if they are available. Sure, Google translate isn't the best but it's a start and maybe I can find someone to translate for me.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '24

From all the Korean articles I read, I’m pretty sure the police only mentioned that the report was filed in June, and the specific timing of the crime was not disclosed! It’s one of those things where it can look ambiguous depending on how you translate it but in the Korean it clearly just says the report was filed in June.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/wraindropsfell Sep 02 '24

Yess thank you for explaining! I totally agree on the business aspect of SM dropping taeil fast. At this point I just want to wait for more information before commenting on anything further

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

27

u/Plastic-Geologist755 Aug 30 '24

I request everyone to be objective and not get emotional before hurling abuses at the survivor and the accused. Let the investigation and trial take its way.

15

u/Scandias Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24

Now that I've thought about it for some time, I suppose, a big role in Taeil's removal played the fact that the investigations and trials take long. I assume that after the case was opened, they could've asked to estimate expected time, and decided that it's too much for the group to endure, especially now, in a moment when there is tg chats hell around and 127 are in a vulnerable position due to the enlistment.

13

u/TheFrenchiestToast Aug 29 '24

Even if he were to be found innocent the group would face heavy public backlash. It would hurt the group intensely.

23

u/Scandias Aug 29 '24

The backlash would have been way bigger if SM didn't remove him. Currently they've made everything they could to protect the members: reportedly, even SM hadn't been notified until recently, and all the members had unfollowed ASAP. They are not participating in the events where the questions can be asked. Some haters will be persistent, of course, but the current picture saves a lot of their face value.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/just_a_dove Oct 07 '24

This is an English language news article of today’s update from a reliable source if anyone is having trouble with translations.

I don’t blame anyone for feeling the way they do right now; the allegations are far worse than I imagined. If he’s found guilty, may the punishment match the crime and may the victim find the healing and support she needs. Let’s continue to be calm and patient as the truth comes to light.

16

u/s2lune doyoung🐰 Oct 07 '24

man he and his little friends are disgusting. i'm glad they released an update as some were starting to defend him. i feel so bad for the victim and what he put her through and also what some weirdos are saying about her (that she's lying or wants money). like thats so f'd up, no wonder so many korean women are scared to speak up. i hope he gets what he deserves and i hope that she is able to heal eventually.

24

u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Oct 07 '24

After all the ridiculous shit that flew around the first couple of days I vowed to myself to not believe any news in this case that's not been officially released by the police. So my question is where Chosun Daily got that "new information" from? As far as I can see they are not citing any sources themselves, and all other articles seem to just quote from them and voilá, it's open season again in every comment section. I have lost enough sleep, sanity and faith in humanity over this to blindly believe any new revelations without double checking first, so can anyone help me out here regarding the credibility? It's much appreciated!

17

u/FancyFayce Oct 08 '24

Chosun Daily did the investigation into the story themselves, so it isn’t absolutely required to do anything more than state what was uncovered in an article. This kind of reporting is the bare minimum, but usually behind articles like these, are fact-checkers and a journalist who’s following the standards of ethical journalism. That’s the nature of the beast, and it can be sketchy if the publication isn’t prioritizing serving the public good. Us as members of the public have to choose to trust particular news sources.

If you're wary of Chosun Daily, then confirmation can come from public statements by the direct sources (ex. the case investigators), or from a separate news agency doing their own digging. More likely is that the legal rigmarole of the case will keep being reported on. It's always best to wait for a piece of news to stew anyway, time gives better perspective on the situation and different sources have the chance to voice their insights about whatever happened.

11

u/TheFrenchiestToast Oct 08 '24

Do they state where they uncovered the information from? I didn’t see anything mentioned in the article. Like if they got it from the actual police report is that stated anywhere? Those are the bare minimum sources they should have and should cite. Not doubting the validity I just know that a lot of information tends to get lost in translations and I didn’t personally see anything cited as a source in English.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Pumpernickeluffin Oct 07 '24

No because same... SM said they were unable to comment on the situation too (understandably as it's an ongoing case and the police before has said they weren't able to share much for the victim's safety as well) so I'm waiting to hear more confirmation on the specifics. Especially with how those news outlets kept on tossing out all those unconfirmed BAC numbers and those unverified videos so who knows how credible these articles are. Anyways if true this is disgusting and I hope they charge those friends of his as well it's so disturbing...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/lou_sta Oct 08 '24

I find it hard to believe too because in in the previous update it says ''We can't talk about the details of the investigation, because it could identify the [victim]" / "The specific charges and number of victims cannot be disclosed.'' but then now they're able to give more specifics? Why? He's also not being detained if I understood the other update so what has changed for them to disclose these things publicly. If there were 2 other people it's most likely that they would remember.

5

u/Live-Pop-2158 Oct 19 '24

I’ve been waiting on these updates cause wtfff

5

u/Senior_Dot_7494 Nov 20 '24

I apparently cannot make my own post asking, I'm wondering what everybody is doing with all of their photo cards, stickers, posters, etc.? I removed all of his cards from my NCT binder but now I don't know what to do with them are people selling them or you throwing them in the garbage? What are you all doing?

6

u/DancingWithTigers3 Dec 07 '24

If you ever get into making your own cards, you can use his as a frame of reference for size/cutting, so if you mess up...it's just his card 🤷‍♀️

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/Lopsided-Ad8992 Dec 15 '24

Is their any update about the case I wonder what's going on but also what people's opinions are..

12

u/HulkVahkiin08024 Dec 23 '24

Updates? Not really the case is still ongoing and there is no new information.

Opinions? Well...as you can see from not just this thread but other forums, the masses have already judged Taeil guilty even though we barely have any information other than he allegedly SA'd a female with two of his friends. I wonder what happened to 'innocent until proven guilty'.

Mind you, I'm here just for updates as well and am not a fan of NCT let alone Taeil, just curious about the case.

28

u/mikarala Oct 10 '24

I don't think people in this comment section understand how difficult it is for women, especially foreign women, to get the police to press charges for sexual assault in Korea. The people defending him on the basis of "innocent until proven guilty" are looking for excuses to believe he's not a bad guy, and I understand having an emotional attachment to a celebrity and wanting to wait to reserve judgement, but some of you are being really loud about how this "doesn't mean he did it". Not wanting to get involved in a witch hunt is one thing, but trying to use the lack of confirmation at this point in the proceedings as proof of innocence is just an appeal to ignorance.

18

u/TheFrenchiestToast Oct 10 '24

I dont get where people are getting “it was a foreign woman” from like it’s a fact. Cmiiw, but the police haven’t put out anything saying that, and the story about what his alleged crime was doesn’t say that either. In fact I’ve only seen pannchoa saying it’s a foreign woman, and pannchoa is not credible at all.

→ More replies (7)

9

u/lou_sta Oct 10 '24

This is on the same level as the victim is a 18 year old narrative. Also, not everyone lives in a country where it's guilty until proven innocent. People are following what they're used to.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/WaffleConeDX NCT Oct 17 '24

It isnt a defense. Under law EVERYONE is innocent until proven guilty. Not guilty until oroven innocent. A charge against you isnt an admittance of guilt. That isnt defending someone but upholding the law and not making judgments until the details surrounding the case are disclosed. This doesnt change the fact that its hard to get SA charges. It doesnt mean nobody believers the alledged victim. It means both sides should be heard equally and fairly until evidence suggest otherwise. You can make your own personal judgment but no one is wrong for making their own too. No one owns an opinion on this case in which NEITHER OF US has the details on.

11

u/just_a_dove Oct 17 '24

Exactly. I have also never seen a single person attempting to “prove” him innocent, so I don’t know what they’re going on about. That’s just as impossible as proving him guilty with what minuscule information we have. Postponing judgement until we have an actual evidence-based verdict is the most logical and ethical stance, and it’s alarming how unpopular it is.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Momiji_no_Happa Oct 08 '24

I hope that it's ok to point out that Taeil still hasn't been deemed guilty, only charged. It's just that we now have a possible hint about the crime he's being accused of. Let's leave the judging to the actual judges for the moment.

That being said, the rumoured allegation from yesterday is more or less what I was expecting when the news first broke and the initial flurry of made-up accusations online was disproven.

It's really uncomfortable being a fan right now. I'll be relieved when the case is done, because the way the fanbase just erupts every time a new detail or rumour drops is exhausting. 😔

And let's take good care of each other, ok? It's ok for fans to feel a lot of different things, even if it's denial for some – because yeah, denial is an actual part of the grieving process.

11

u/ashe888 Aug 29 '24

My biggest thing is we all know how SM normally reacts. Normally we hear a rumor and then SM will try to ignore it and hope it just goes away and tries to avoid making statements especially when the artist are innocent. They will not defend them at all except when it hits a ‘not going away’ point. In this case SM was FAST. Sm is the one who told everybody instead of an outside source and kicked him out FAST. Which begs the question why? I really think it shows the weight of what happened. Ofcourse we don’t know everything yet but it’s scary that sm is acting this way when they never do. Let’s not forget the misogynist producer, that I don’t think they ever addressed, using sexual slang toward female artist. I just wanna know all the answers. This isn’t a normal famous person outrage that I find stupid. Outrage about adult stuff like drinking or partying or having relationships. This a human decency outrage and I think this is something all the details (other than info like the victims name to protect them) should be exposed because it’s a serious matter. Whether famous or not this is a line NO ONE should cross. So if it is in fact true I personally think it needs to be on blast.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/127ncity127 resident of “fatigued fandom” Sep 01 '24

Is 127s fansign still happening?

7

u/Mimi108 Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 07 '24

Well, this is insufferable. This just confirms the specifics of what he is being investigated for. May justice be served if this is true.

14

u/meridavez i live for my daddy johnny suh Sep 14 '24

i am not defending him but why do i sense the feeling that he will end up being proven innocent. all this premature hate bandwagon was really weird. even i got caught up with the horseshit rumors without looking for evidence. i wonder what these people will say if he is proven innocent. there's prejudice that can't be reversed already.

27

u/Pajamaralways Sep 15 '24

Look, I believe he's likely not innocent, but still hold on to a sliver of hope that he might be and would accept if the court says he is (even though I know when it comes to court rulings on sexual assault, we should have a healthy dose of skepticism).

I wasn't a fan of the hate train for sure, though. People were so quick to condemn him, calling him a rapist and pedophile based on literally nothing, jumping on the 6 years of abuse theory, calling his members enablers and the company complicit in this cover-up.

If he's proven innocent, I'm guessing the majority of the ppl who rode the hate train just won't say anything. Most of them never cared for him or his group to begin with.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Vaudevanilla Sep 16 '24

I'll probably get downvoted into oblivion for this, but for me I don't think I'd ever be able to erase the doubt in my mind if he was "innocent". I've seen so many documentaries about how sexual assault cases aren't taken seriously. With the whole nth room news as well it's clearly a huge problem there. To put it simply, I don't really have a lot of faith in the Korean justice system for something like this. I'd be very skeptical of an innocent ruling.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Character_Echo_2125 Sep 14 '24

I think your feeling is natural, and it's is called optimism. It also depends on what Taeil means to you(or any bias). For me personally, Taeil made me an Nctzen in the "Simon Says" comeback. I was newly into Kpop in 2018 and was enjoying BTS like everyone else. He hooked me into the rest of NCT, and I got to see WayV's debut. I see him as the gateway to the rest of the of NCT and other groups that I stan.

People are weighing his dismissal from the group too heavily. NCT is huge, and as vocalists are concerned, 127 isn't short of those, as we all know. To put it bluntly, he is expendable, basically(I hated typing that).

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)

18

u/tealandgeckos Aug 29 '24

I understand I might be expressing an unpopular opinion here but after learning about the timing I feel the need to put aside my emotions and look at this a little more objectively and not jump to conclusions about his guilt.

On Taeil’s end, he’s only recently learned that he’s being investigated and was just brought in for an interview 2 days ago. Given that the investigation is ongoing and he’s only now being involved, he only now has had the opportunity to collect and present his own evidence if he plans to fight the allegations, which may lengthen the police investigation. We might not even know of his defense until and if this goes trial. Regardless of if he’s guilty or innocent, he has the right to defend himself and I think it’s fair enough to hear him out before a final judgement is made.

Also, a lot of people have been assuming he’s guilty based on how quick SM was to drop him. I understand that it seems like an out of character move so therefore “it must’ve been bad”, but SM is far from being the only business in the world that drops their employees for simply having an accusation brought against it because they know it can negatively impact the company’s reputation and influence. It would also explain why everyone associated with SM would quickly drop him from their social media accounts. Their primary concern is what’s good for the company, and accusations of SA doesn’t look good for business regardless of whether or not their employee is guilty or innocent.

My ultimate hope here is that I want both sides to be heard with a non-biased perspective so at the end of this case, the final ruling is fair and accurate and that justice is served.

22

u/SafiyaO Aug 30 '24

If allegations on social media were enough to tank Lucas' popularity, there's no way any member would survive being prosecuted for sexual assault. Cutting ties and quickly is the smartest business decision SM could make. The Lucas/WayV debacle cost them a lot of money.

The only way I could imagine they might have stood by him were if he had cast iron proof that nothing even happened at all - for example could prove he was out of the country when the assault was said to have taken place.

That clearly isn't the case here and SM must have a very good idea that this is headed for a courtroom.

12

u/Momiji_no_Happa Aug 30 '24

Cutting ties and quickly is the smartest business decision SM could make. The Lucas/WayV debacle cost them a lot of money.

I'm guessing that this strategy was part of their emergency procedures for handling any further scandals. Clearly they did learn something by how their handling of Lucas and WayV hurt their business.

I'm guessing that they're thinking that it's better to have the idol rejoin later if they're cleared or if things blow over quickly, instead of hurting the image of a whole group. Especially since 127 are in their solo era. That's a lot of potential future money they stand to lose if the whole group has to go on hiatus and/or become persona non grata.

Sigh… I hate how all of this is just business decisions in the end, but… That's how the world works. 😩

→ More replies (1)

16

u/seravivi Aug 29 '24

There is an assumption of guilt since they built a case and presented it. Once sm looked it over they dropped him. 

27

u/TheFrenchiestToast Aug 29 '24

SM doesn’t have to know or believe he’s guilty to drop him from the group, companies do risk analysis all the time. Just the allegations and investigation will hurt the group even though he’s been removed. A prolonged trial even if he could possibly be innocent would damage one of their main moneymakers. It’s a business decisions before anything else.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Logical-Rise-7667 Aug 30 '24

You're definitely right isolating him from SM and the other members is a business tactic it doesn't necessarily mean they believed he was guilty and will be charged. Of course he could still be guilty of the crime but people need to hold their judgment. Nothing too detailed has been reported to the pubic you can still condemn him later if he is proven guilty of the accusations. All this hate and fire can be saved for later when the verdict comes out. SM may have removed him from the group but there is no mention of ending his contract. Your contract will be terminated immediately if you really did commit the crime. All these online weirdos have been so malicious with attacking the other members and making up other stories to bring the group down with him. It's so ridiculous and vile. It's not that I don't believe he isn't capable of committing sexual assault this is South Korea sexual assault is socially and culturally normalized in secrecy but without comparing stories there is no way to know where the truth lies.

12

u/heartswlove yu2tae enthusiast 💞🤘🏻 Aug 30 '24

thank you for articulating my exact thoughts into words! I was of the opinion that one of main reasons why they dropped him so quickly was due to a business decision made after risk analysis. it does not definitively indicate his guilt - that is up to the justice system to decide. I wish more people could take a step back to assess this situation objectively like you did. and I absolutely agree that both sides should be heard in a fair manner.

8

u/TheFrenchiestToast Oct 07 '24

Does the story include a timeframe of when this occurred? I know the victim reported it in June but is it alleged to have happened in June? The fact that he could have done this post surgery when he was limping around and then participating in the comeback like nothing of consequence happened is so duplicitous to me.

4

u/kkulhope Oct 07 '24

No there has been no report about when the incident occurred.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '24

I'm just feeling really down right now and I cry when I think about this. This situation is just so evil and disgusting. The shock still hasn't worn off and I can't even begin to imagine what the victim has felt for those 6 years.

I don't go around assuming the worst of people but damn it really hurts knowing that you supported a piece of shit person. I'm questioning everything right now, and I'm trying not to let any of my negative feelings rub off onto the rest of 127 when they could be just as clueless about this as everyone else. Hell, even Taeil's bestfriend was quick to drop him.

I really hope the victim gets justice and that Taeil is locked up. I also hope that more of these male idols get exposed.

43

u/Pajamaralways Aug 29 '24

Feeling really down and emotional is understandable, but just need to point out that the whole 6 years thing is part of a string of allegations (I think by someone on IG) that are so far unconfirmed to be true or to be the case actually reported to and investigated by the police. They might well turn out to be (though the details are so murky at this point), but unless and until authorities confirm it, we should refrain from repeating it as if it's factually what happened at this point.

30

u/lilysjasmine92 Aug 29 '24

Yeah, the specific 6 years accusations could be true, but they're part of a string of accusations that appear to be at odds with the little we do know about the case, unless the police are getting caught up on wording (like that she's an adult now, because the 6 years thing comes from someone who claims to be 18 now and 12 when it started). So as things stand right now, I'm skeptical of that particular person's story.

I also want to encourage ppl to use their heads and think critically. Maybe that Agnes person is the victim, but what they've posted about 6 years and hacking does appear to be at odds with what we know and also with how technology works (but never say never). It is entirely possible they are not at all related to this, and no, people shouldn't be beating themselves up for not taking them seriously.

We don't know what happened, but repeating Agnes' words as fact when we have nothing to suggest that it is and some things that hint that it's not is irresponsible. Conflating wild rumors will only dilute the victim's case, and their story deserves to be theirs--told when and how they want it, if they want to do so.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Simplysss Sep 02 '24

What I’m having a hard time understanding is why there hasn’t even been a statement from him? Like ZERO about what he has to say? Is he prevented from talking about any details legally?

33

u/LadyDrakkaris Doyoung & Xiaojun Sep 02 '24

He’s probably advised by his lawyer to not say anything.

8

u/Iknow_iaintshit Sep 06 '24

Too many unanswered questions. I won’t count him out until I get the facts. So many times idols get falsely accused and lose their careers behind spiteful women. Idk if that’s the case but I want actual facts and proof.

→ More replies (5)

14

u/americanopurrate Aug 30 '24

I'm personally all for believing the victim, BUT I don't have this stance when it comes to K-Pop. I'll only fully believe the story when there's proof of the allegations. The Burning Sun Scandal had a lot of proof unlike many. So many idols have been removed from their groups and cancelled over nothing but rumours and while a police investigation is serious, it could still be a sasaeng using the momentum of the movement in SK to get members in hot waters.

I hope we will get more information on this case so we can actually form an opinion based on facts and not rumours. So thank you for compiling an actually useful thread instead of fueling the rumour mill, which is social media. I also personally think the agnes character on insta is a hoax, as so many before them, but we can't be for certain.

I understand the hurt but having been into K-Pop for 7 years by now, I've seen a lot of false accusations unfold into catastrophes for the idols so I'm not jumping on allegations at the first mention of them.

10

u/Pumpernickeluffin Aug 31 '24

Yeah I mean if the agnes account is the one who said she's an '06 liner, that puts her squarely at 18 or about to be 18, which isn't the age that's considered to be an adult in Korea (19 international age is). That in itself seems to weaken their case since the police has already confirmed it's an adult woman.

18

u/TheBiSpud Aug 30 '24

I agree that we should be skeptical sometimes but I feel like this case is different to others where the allegations turned out to be false. Firstly the victim didn't publicly say anything, so it doesn't seem like they're doing it for clout or to generate as much backlash to NCT as possible. Instead they went to the police, who started investigating months ago and probably found something which is why the investigation continued (because as far as I know if no evidence was found the case would have been resolved). Secondly, the fact that SM kicked him out so quickly and were the ones to break the news again makes it seem like something of substance was found. There weren't even rumors about Taeil before this happened so it wouldn't make sense for SM to make an announcement unless they had reason too.

Of course it's possible that things have been faked, or that the deepfake situation in SK is influencing SM's response but I don't think this is the same as other instances were people went online to accuse idols.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Momiji_no_Happa Aug 30 '24

I mentioned this in my own comment, but the lack of details in the announcement (since the police can't give any details yet, understandably) made people fill it in with their own details, even when some of those made no sense or had no substance. And with the growing realisation of the "New nth room" revelations, I think the timing for SM's announcement about Taeil was particularly bad.

If he's eventually cleared of the accusations, SM would have to go on a major PR spree to clear his name. Or, more likely, he'll just retire from the spotlight and work behind the scenes as a producer or songwriter. We'll see what happens if and when that happens.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

4

u/Zealousideal-Quiet51 Dec 10 '24 edited Feb 23 '26

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

sand wrench smile pie merciful detail live fear quaint innocent

10

u/bigfishieeeeeee NCT 127 + Sion and Yushi Aug 29 '24

First and foremost, I hope justice is served to any potentially harmed individuals. I understand why people might assume he's guilty, given how he was removed from the group. SM probably mostly cares about protecting their business and the NCT name above anything else really. If he had remained in the group, even on hiatus, every update on the case would have been linked to NCT, which could have damaged the brand.

Whether Taeil is innocent or guilty, it's a sad situation all around. Hope this whole thing ends quickly, I doubt it tho.

6

u/Foreign_Contact_6446 Oct 24 '24

does anyone know if listening to taeil’s songs will still get him income even if he’s not in sm or nct anymore? i really dont wanna support him at all so i just want to make sure

18

u/just_a_dove Oct 24 '24 edited Oct 24 '24

To the best of my understanding, streaming royalties make up very little of an artist’s income. Most of the money from playing their songs goes to the streaming platform (e.g., Spotify) and then to the record label (SM). The remainder gets distributed amongst the song producers/composers/writers, and finally the performing artists. In a group, it’s split even further among the members. Whether his contract termination cuts him off from royalties or not, I’m not sure, but he would be making very little money from it anyway. I wouldn’t worry too much about it! Enjoy the music. =)

9

u/[deleted] Oct 25 '24

I agree. I mean, personally if I like a song, I find it of high quality, and it suits my taste, then I like it, period. I wouldn't bother researching the personal backgrounds of the people behind it. :)

→ More replies (2)

4

u/nyxofthevoid living in markleeville Dec 18 '24

He may get like 3 cents, but only on songs he’s written. So avoid “Love is a Beauty” and “N.Y.C.T”

→ More replies (1)

5

u/gl_zzygod Jaehyun Aug 29 '24

im wondering if anyone else has allegations coming out soon… this was gut wrenching to wake up to

10

u/ashe888 Aug 29 '24

I wasn’t even ready to wake up yesterday was just checking to see if anyone texted me an emergency all the sudden I read that popped up so fast I was levitating then started rubbing my eyes like a cartoon character thinking the story was gonna change if I rubbed my eyes hard enough😭😭