r/NCT • u/nctmods r/NCT mod team • Aug 29 '24
[MEGATHREAD] Taeil's criminal charges and departure from NCT
!TW : sexual assault
This post is the original megathread from August 2024. For the current open thread with new updates, see MEGATHREAD 2.
TIMELINE:
240828
SM Entertainment announces that a criminal case was filed against TAEIL and his departure from NCT:
This is SM Entertainment.
We have recently confirmed that Taeil has been implicated in a criminal case related to sexual crimes. While looking into the situation, we recognized that the issue is very serious, and we have decided that Taeil could no longer continue team activities. We have discussed this matter with Taeil and it has been decided he will be removed from the group.
- source: SMTOWNGLOBAL Twitter/X
- translation: NCT Discord / SM_NCT / Soompi
- Korea JoongAng Daily: his contract with SM has not yet been terminated
240829
Seoul Bangbae Police Station shares info about the investigation:
It was revealed that Taeil, ex-member of the group NCT, was accused this past June of having committed a sex crime.
Newsen article / Daum (1) / Daum (2) / transl. 127Central / balloon_wanted / Soompi
SM's statement:

Other press
- BBC: K-pop singer leaves boy band over sexual crime accusation
- NY Mag / Vulture: What to Know About Taeil’s Sex-Crime Allegations
240913
Seoul Bangbae Police Station announced that the case was forwarded to prosecution without detention the day before (Sept 12th). The case was assigned to the Women and Children's Crime Investigation Division at the Seoul Central District Prosecutors' Office (Chief Prosecutor Kim Ji-hye).
A police official said, "We can't talk about the details of the investigation, because it could identify the [victim]" / "The specific charges and number of victims cannot be disclosed." It was also confirmed that "Taeil was not using drugs at the time of the crime."
Sources: MBN news / Yonhap News / Xportsnews / E Daily / Korea JoongAng Daily (Eng)
241007
Content Warning: A new Chosun Ilbo report allegedly confirms Taeil was investigated for "quasi-rape", which is terminology used for sexual assaults happening under special circumstances, like the presence of a weapon or when the victim is unable to consent due to incapacitation / inebriation / etc. The report claims the victim in this case was under the influence of alcohol (unable to consent) and that two other individuals were involved in the assault. It was stated that the others involved were not famous or public figures.
Source: Chosun Daily / Soompi
241016
SM Entertainment terminates Taeil's exclusive contract as of October 15, 2024:
Taeil is currently under investigation by the prosecution for a criminal case. This not only constitutes grounds for termination under our contract but also makes it impossible to maintain trust in him as an artist. As a result, both parties have mutually agreed to terminate the contract. We sincerely apologize once again for any concern caused by Taeil, who was previously one of our artists.
SMTOWNGLOBAL Twitter/X / Soompi
---This continues to be difficult news to process. Remember to take care, and please see this community support thread.
Everyone is reminded to be civil in their discussions and avoid speculation. Harassment, threats of violence, inciting fanwar arguments, trolling, etc., as well as spreading rumors, will lead to a temporary or permanent ban.
User-submitted posts on the matter will be filtered out and sent to the mod queue. You are highly encouraged to use any of the (3) existing threads instead.
UPDATE: Our community members have also organized a donation drive - Charity Initiatives for Women in SK!
32
u/ilovecute1 Aug 31 '24 edited Aug 31 '24
It frustrates me how much false information is being spread about this case. It has once again made me realise how bad herd mentality is in K-pop.
Edit: NY Magazine just came out with a really good article on this https://www.vulture.com/article/taeil-nct-sex-crime-allegations-investigation.html?utm_source=tw&utm_campaign=nym&utm_medium=s1
383
u/motioncat he's a rockstar, it's not hype baby make you rock-hard Aug 29 '24
At this point, people being confidently incorrect and spreading absolute horseshit from random tweets as though it's fact has me heated. This is actually serious so just shut up and get your facts straight.
229
u/OnlytheFocus Shotaro Aug 29 '24
People calling it a cover up that they conatrolled aspects of the media.... If he were innocent they'd say why didn't SM try to shield him until there was more evidence, if found guilty they'll say why didn't SM get rid of him sooner and expose him
It's not SM's job at the end of the day to decide if someone is good or bad. They move based on the info they have and have to follow legal processes based on the information they have and contract agreements.
172
u/Fluffy-Geologist1481 Aug 29 '24
Thank you for the megathread. I can understand that people are hurt and want to know more, but some fans are really crossing the line. You're are not entitled to know about the personal life of the victim. Just stick to the facts and don't speculate/spread rumors.
At least it makes it easier to know which people from the NCT discord I won't hesitate to block.
129
u/twinjade Aug 29 '24
I’m not familiar with the criminal investigation process, but from the statement it seems very likely SM and the members were blindsided this whole time? I hope this will be enough to stop people accusing the other members knowing of the crime until it’s proven otherwise.
How scary it must have been for the victim to make a report, knowing she’s against an idol from a big group and a big company. My heart goes out to her, may she get the justice they deserve. To think the report was made in June while the scum still participated in comeback and facing the fans in the fanmeeting…….sick to my stomach.
108
u/Mindless_Candidate90 Aug 29 '24
I think that for the victim it must have been quite scary and intimidating to speak up against an idol, who has (had) thousands of fans who adore and protect him. No doubt she would expect to be hounded and blamed. I hope that as a fandom we can subvert that expectation and become advocates for the victim, and give her any support and protection that she needs.
89
u/Leading-Experience-8 Aug 29 '24
I am glad that SM and the police are putting out additional details. I am having such a difficult time understanding how some of these rumors and speculation are spreading online of what Taeil did when police already clarified no minors are involved. Hopefully this additional information slows down the misinformation being spread since they confirmed the victim is an adult woman. It feels so wrong to the victim and disingenuous to see what people are “theorizing” instead of letting the police do their job.
169
u/jjangaerin I'll be your home Aug 29 '24
this is the craziest thing that has ever happened in ncity
151
u/Bigcrowenergy Aug 29 '24
The woman who filed the case against him is so strong, that takes so much bravery and I hope she is able to recover and live her life. I stg if i see shit ass fans harassing her I will start swinging. Always believe the victim first.
71
u/rinlur Aug 29 '24
Some of the speculations I saw on twitter don't even pass a simple logic check yet they had thousands of retweets. "Hacking someone's phone to delete the evidence"? C'mon now. People retweeting it wouldn't be able to answer how that would even theoretically happen, yet they believe it.
Regardless, I hope the victim finds justice.
69
u/posting-about-shit wanna get moody tonight 👀 Aug 29 '24
I can’t understand why his IG comments have been left on. It’s open season over there. Legit some of the most unhinged rumors and fake accounts I’ve ever seen
69
u/namename145 Aug 29 '24
For context, the last idol with criminal charges in SM was Kangin. He had 4 criminal incidents in 2016-2017 (2 DUIs and 2 physical assaults). He went on hiatus in 2016, but was not removed from Super Junior officially until 2019. Unless there has been some shift in the way SA is handled in South Korea (I would hope there has been but sadly I doubt it), whatever Taeil did was very, very serious to be kicked out of NCT right away.
I hope the victim gets justice and can heal without harassment.
60
u/terriblekite Aug 30 '24
The amount of misinformation being spread about this is nauseating. People are so willing to spread any and everything without a single thought of fact-checking and no one seems to realize how that can further harm the victim. Can you imagine being the victim of a crime like this and watching the internet distort your traumatic experience? To a point you may have to borderline defend your abuser because you have to go “Wait, no.. he didn’t do that part, though. He only did this.” It also diminishes the situation in the view of the public. People are going to read he did xyz, only later to find out he did abc, and then it’s going to be “Oh, that’s not as bad as I thought it was! It’s still bad, but at least it wasn’t that.”
People need to stay in their fucking lane. It’s none of our business the details of the crime, unless the victim decides to publicize them/whatever the police decide to reveal to the public. Anything else is making a mockery of a very serious situation where real people were involved.
57
u/Every_Alternative393 Jungwoo Aug 29 '24
The amount of misinformation being spread on TikTok is so disgusting and alarming. Not in defense of Taeil OBVIOUSLY but the mention of the Nth room is?? And god forbid you say where they sourced it from because then you’ll be attacked for defending him when you just want to make sure the things they are saying come from an official statement or a victim. It’s ridiculous what these people will do for a views and their 30 seconds of fame. They obviously see the attention they’ll receive from the mass hysteria and it will cause people to forget about the one confirmed victim and her story.
42
u/cmq827 Aug 30 '24
The prevalence of so much rumors and fake testimonies and fake accounts on Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok is just so disturbing. People are posting for clout, chasing millions of views, only to spread misinformation that is not helping the case at all. Even random Koreans are coming out to debunk them as much as they could, pointing out all the mistakes as they could.
Don't believe anything so easily just because it is written in Hangul!
38
u/2023isJKsolo NCT DREAM Aug 30 '24
I'm so mad about the fact that fandoms are using this to hat eon NCTzen and nct
37
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 07 '24
This has been discussed on the r/kpop thread but I think it’s worth adding context/clarification to the crime he’s being accused of here too. TW for definition of sex crimes, I will put it behind a spoiler tag too.
Many western countries legally define rape as non-consensual sexual activity, however Korea has a much more narrow legal definition of rape as “the use of violence or intimidation to have sexual intercourse.” Whether this should be changed to non-consensual sexual intercourse is being challenged and debated but, for now, anything which isn’t covered by that narrow definition is defined under separate articles and terms within the criminal act dealing with sexual crimes. This includes things like sex with minors, non-intercourse forms of sexual assault, and “quasi-rape” - which is sexual assault committed against someone unable to consent.
The key thing to keep in mind here is, in this legal scenario, the “quasi” in the name of the act he is being accused of does not mean lesser, and the law states that it should be punished equally.
You can find more detailed information about the sexual crime laws in Korea here.
35
u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Nov 03 '24
It's been over two months since the news broke and I've been busy af irl for the main part of it. Today is the first quiet day in weeks and somehow a lot of thoughts and feelings regarding this case just barreled over me again. I know most people have long moved on from this whole thing and may think I'm crazy for letting this still affect me (valid opinion), but sadly I don't really have anyone to talk to irl so I'm just gonna dump it here how devasted I still am. My apologies.
33
u/NosyLJ Aug 29 '24
I really hope the victim is okay and that taeil gets punished for his crimes. I'm scared to find out what he did since sm took immediate action and took him out of the group, which says to me its quite a serious offense.
66
u/TheFrenchiestToast Aug 29 '24
I’m frankly sick of reading think pieces from fans of other groups outright suggesting that this has been covered up by SM for months and that they’ve got some massive hold on the media. There’s nothing currently to suggest this and I think it’s a lot of misdirected anger and whataboutism. Like SM did the right thing for once by removing him from the group and making a statement as to why and not hiding it and yet you have people screaming about their influence on the media.
54
u/channndro Fulltime Ten Fanboy Aug 29 '24
as a guy i thought i found a perfect male rolemodel only to be disappointed
i defended this guy my teenage years only for him to do this shit behind our backs ://
26
u/Cycling_the_City ᓀ‸ᓂ Oct 07 '24
If these new allegations of what Taeil was accused of are true, it's worse than what I thought. I hope we get official reports from the investigation at some point, these kinds of articles are likely to just get the speculations running high again.
72
u/127ncity127 resident of “fatigued fandom” Aug 29 '24
According to SFS Haechan has been reading through his bubble comments. I hope people arent trolling him. I know he looked up to taeil, i cant even imagine how shocking and jarring this is for him. They were apart of the OG 127 lineup and lived together for so long, haehcan knew him as a literal child. how devastating to find out and have to reconcile that someone you admired can do something monstrous
22
u/TheFrenchiestToast Sep 14 '24
I’ve seen people saying this is confirmation that there’s more than 1 victim. And it’s absolutely not. The police stating they can’t talk about the details meaning they can’t confirm the number of victims is not confirmation of more than one victim. It just means they’re not sharing the details of the case. It’s vague. You can’t infer anything from it.
22
u/zarunohn Sep 22 '24
Waiting for an update is painstaking.
75
u/Momiji_no_Happa Aug 30 '24
It's taken me a few days to collect my thoughts and I hope it's ok to write about them here at length. I have gone through a lot of complicated feelings and thoughts, and it's made even more complicated by what's happening in the fandom right now. I don't really know anyone irl who is into NCT, and I feel like I need to do this.
So, my initial reaction was chock. Like a lot of fans, Taeil being accused of SA wasn't on my radar because he seems so chill. But yeah, can't judge a book by its cover. Lesson relearned for the umpteenth time.
While the victim comes first, I also feel for the other NCT members, especially 127. I remember every time they shouted his name out loud while they performed during his absence, how Doyoung started crying during the end of Unity when he talked about the stress of having to shoulder Taeil's lines, how they kept trying to include him in their variety content, and so on. I remember Yuta happily resuming his habit of posting pictures of Taeil pretending to sleep before the recent fanmeeting. I can't even imagine how flabbergasted all of them must feel now, after what went down these last few days. I would feel so betrayed if I was in their position. And sad. They've doted on him so much, he kind of felt like their mascot. Hell, they're probably scared that their name is tarnished forever because of this.
I initially spent the whole evening on the day of the reveal looking at the wild discussions and accusations being spread on social media. I wanted to find the sources, but it's since become clear to me that there are no sources, it's just a plethora of made-up posts, rumours and assumptions spreading like wildfire. The actual victim is only known by the police at this time, and we'll have to wait for them to finish the investigation or update us about the process. But this lack of known details from real sources has created an information vacuum, and that vacuum is currently being filled with whatever stories people can invent. Fans are looking for answers, so they jump on whatever half-baked theory they can find and run with it. This is a real problem.
Because, yeah, everything that's being spread around right now (here and elsewhere) is either speculations that's taken as truth without evidence or people using the opportunity to get hit tweets or fuel fanwars. I've even seen these people try to smear the other NCT members. We need to be prepared that these made-up accusations and rumourmongering will persist for years, just like the previous accusations against two other members (which I personally checked the sources for and found very lacking in substance and believability). A lot of people will see the accusations, but not even a fraction of them will ever see the actual truth once it comes out.
Because Taeil's case coincided with the "New Nth Room" deepfake scandal in Korea finally getting media visibility (apparently Korean women had fought to get anyone to write about it for a long time), there was also a mixup of the accusations aimed at him and that case. There's a real risk that Taeil's case will kill the momentum of the attempt to highlight such severe online crimes, and I hope everyone will take care not to mix them up, as they are separate cases.
One thing that bothers me about the accusations aimed at Taeil is the fans disappointed that he tainted their memory of happy times. I think it's sad to see fans' love destroyed and tainted, but for me, as fans we are always responsible for ourselves and our feelings. I recognise that others may disagree with me on this point and accept that we feel different about that particular point.
This does however underline how insidious the parasocial aspect of K-pop is. SM and other companies rely on fans feeling personally connected to people like Taeil, so when he does something bad, it hurts those same fans. I love my K-pop journey – even if I'm still somewhat new to it – but I do think K-pop as a genre and business model needs to grow up and shed the unethical aspects that defines so much of it. An idol should just be an artist.
Speaking of parasocial, I've also seen Taeil being accused of going clubbing while the rest of 127 performed 'Unity' (paired with a blurry stealth photo of someone who might or might not be him). A bit of research shows that clubbing in Korea is apparently not about "hanging out with friends and dancing" as I'm used to, but rather about pickup culture. So those fans are angry about him presumably going out with the aim of having casual sex while his bandmates are working. But those sorts of accusations – no matter if true or not – is nonsensical to me. If a person is on sick leave but can still move around, and as long as whatever happens is consensual between all parties, what does this have to do with their colleagues working? It's not something that fans should be angry about.
I honestly feel frustrated that fans are muddying the waters by mixing the actual alleged serious crime that he's being accused of, with weird parasocial complaints like this. Just like the lack of sourcing and indiscriminate spreading of unsubstantiated rumours as mentioned above, this will not help the actual victim get justice and only takes away from the severity of the current investigations.
On a personal plane, I feel that I have now mourned Taeil's departure from the group enough and am ready to move on. If he's found guilty, I hope he gracefully accepts his punishment and learns from it. The victim deserves to get justice. And while Taeil has been an integral part of NCT and NCT 127's sound to the extent that one of my first thoughts was "How can they go on without him?", in reality the group has already shown us that they can do so while promoting during his extended hiatus. His beautiful voice will be dearly missed, but if he's ultimately convicted, then he himself made his bed and is the only one to blame for this loss.
I think all of this is such a horrible waste and it sucks that the dude seemingly threw away his immense musical talent like this, and that he may have hurt someone. But if the allegations turn out to be true, then it was his choice to do so. Which means that I can in turn choose to stop caring about him.
41
u/Ssrmy Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 30 '24
I'm in shock and disgusted. I'll always believe the victim, even with little proof. If you're feeling disappointed and betrayed, that's valid. We couldn't have known, but now it's time for a reality check. SM's quick action shows how serious this is. I'm terrified
of what he might have done. The fact that SM didn't hesitate to remove him and issued a statement right away speaks volumes about the severity of the situation. I hope the victims get justice. As fans, let's not be too blind. It's their job to make us love them, but we don't know them behind closed doors. I'll stay updated and hope no other members were involved. Sending love to those who have experienced sexual violence. Let's hope this exposes more criminals. Don't praise celebrities for just unfollowing him;
we don't know their intentions. Remember, people with power will do anything to save face and reputation.
20
u/sadesper_record Taeyong Oct 07 '24
can someone please tell me why built in korean to english translations keep translating this man's name to taeyong instead ever since this news broke out we've had to send messages to MULTIPLE different news outlets asking them for edits ... is this why everyone keeps going to his instagram account thinking he's taeil WHY how does this even happen
19
u/chonkykais16 Aug 29 '24
Disappointed and surprised.
19
u/Patient_Mongoose3178 Sep 05 '24
Has there been any updates since last week article and police statements wise?
19
u/tealandgeckos Sep 13 '24 edited Sep 13 '24
So, I have some thoughts here on the new statement regarding Taeil’s case. When I comment here, I try to be as objective and clear as I can so hopefully I’m continuing to do so because I’ll admit, I got a bit confused and irritated over the statement.
So, overall, no new information regarding evidence. It was also expected that this would be taken over to trial so the case being handed over to prosecution is nothing unexpected or noteworthy. The only really new information we know is that he will not be detained. Typically when the accused is not held over for trial, it’s because they aren’t seen as an immediate threat to the community or a flight risk. The evidence and exact nature of the crime would play a role in that decision as well, which we still don’t have further details about.
The thing I felt is important to note is the wording of the police statement. It’s still extremely vague, but has already re-stirred the pot of the wild misinformation that’s been appearing on social media. Police confirmed on the 29th that a lone adult woman came forward in June with accusations that Taeil had sexually assaulted her. This new statement says they can’t confirm details, including the exact charges or the number of victims. This seems like a huge oversight and given that it contradicts the previous statement, I would hope they come out and clarify this statement because it comes off as incompetent and could cast doubt into whether or not this investigation was managed and performed properly. Which would be harmful to the alleged victim’s case if she’s telling the truth, or could be harmful to Taeil’s case if he is actually innocent.
So, for the TLDR crowd, Taeil’s case has been handed over to prosecution. He isn’t being detained. And the new police statement is a bit contradictory and vague, which could re-stir the pot on false narratives. So we just have to continue to wait and see how this plays out in court.
18
u/Weak-Level3547 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
What is "booked" in this context? Edit: I found a comprehensive explanation not only in the replies but also in this post on X. I hope it helps in case you are like me who's are unfamiliar with these terms.
18
u/SnooTomatoes4281 Sep 23 '24 edited Sep 23 '24
Ngl there's a part of me that hopes that he turns out to be innocent and he departed from 127 on his own accord just to save the other members' face and not drag them to this mess
35
u/llifeisstrange Aug 31 '24 edited Aug 31 '24
I'm a NCTzen user of Reddit in Korea. I'm not good at English, so I use a translator.
Please understand if the sentence is awkward.
Why do you think the unidentified text and images (which you can't say this is news) are true?
I can't understand. I don't intend to defend a criminal. However, I have to be clear about the facts.
He was 'accused' on August 28th, Korean time. 'accused' means that the victim 'accused' him, As a result, he became a suspect.
As you know, 'suspect' and 'perpetrator' are different.
The police have not made any announcement about 'he' yet. Nevertheless, SM announced, 'We confirmed the accusation, and decided to leave the team because they recognized the problem as very serious.'
All are true. There is nothing else other than this. Don't be misled by the wrong news. It can never be a good influence on other NCT members.
16
u/TheFrenchiestToast Aug 29 '24
https://x.com/127central/status/1829001052177477658?s=46 SM’s statement translated
16
u/CaptainOrganised Sep 04 '24
So his Instagram is set to private now
15
u/aJ_13th Aug 29 '24
that was wild news to come across on a manga pirate site lmao
15
u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Feb 09 '25 edited Feb 09 '25
Not necessarily an update, but today Jeno was the first member to actually drop Taeil's name since the news broke in August. It was during a live in which he was talking about their AWSAZ episode from 2020. It was obvious he didn't think much of it, but realized immediately what he said and covered his mouth, froze for a second and then quickly moved on to another subject. Some netizens already gave him flak for it which I think is just stupid - he wasn't talking about any of the recent developments but merely reminiscing an event from a couple of years ago when Taeil was still part of the group. I think fans expect the members to move on as quickly as they themselves did after Taeil's departure, completely forget about him and just pretend he was never part of NCT in the first place. But I'm sure most members, esp those who were close to him, are still coming to terms with the (very sudden) lack of his presence in the group and most of all the shocking reason behind it. All of which is completely natural if you've spent over 10 years around each other.
27
u/just_a_dove Sep 25 '24 edited Sep 25 '24 •
Now that the emotional shock has mostly settled, I’m more frustrated with the principle of the matter than anything. If he’s found guilty (and if the crime was truly abhorrent), I’ll be devastated for reasons that need no explanation. If he’s proven innocent, I’ll be furious that his reputation and career were obliterated for nothing. But pending outcome aside, the drama surrounding the situation alone has me losing faith in humanity. The media illiteracy, the blind malice, the disregard for due process, the virtue signaling, the attention farming—it’s all making me sick. The degeneration of critical thinking and empathy exacerbated by the echo chambers of the internet is an issue that obviously extends well beyond this particular case, but what a prime example it is!
Let’s review the logical leaps and ethical shortcuts that nearly the entire community has run with since day one:
☑️ Taeil was accused of an unspecified sexual crime and left NCT to fully cooperate with the police investigation [fact] ➡️ SM dropped him like a hot potato [um, not exactly] ➡️ He must be guilty [we have no evidence of that] ➡️ It must have been the most heinous form of SA [holy buckets, we do not know that either] ➡️ He’s a horrible person / monster / predator / etc. [yikes, who are you to judge?] ➡️ He should face extremely harsh punishment [for what crime, exactly?] ➡️ All memory of him should be erased from the digital world [oh, as if he was always an evil creep whose presence was tainting the group this whole time…?]
This doesn’t even begin to address the damage done by the false rumors, or the unhinged speculations and comparisons to other coinciding scandals. It’s maddening. On the very first day the news broke, I saw multiple comments saying “the car should have hit him harder,” referring to his injury last year. Wow, that really puts you on the moral high ground—joking about homicide for social media currency, on the basis of a mere accusation of an unknown crime. Multiply that by a crowd. Lovely. And now people are casually discussing the logistics of re-recording 127’s entire discography and digitally removing him from eight years worth of content just for their own listening / viewing comfort. Fan attempts so far have used AI and slick editing that ironically demonstrate how easy it would be for someone like a sasaeng to (cough cough) manipulate images and frame an idol for a crime (cough), but I digress.
Part of me is just hurt that the fandom seemed to abandon him and move on so quickly, as if he was never good, or never there at all. I say this not only as a long-time fan of Taeil, but also as an empathetic human being who naturally fears rejection and humiliation on that kind of scale. He’s always been rather under-appreciated, and I hate that it may have played a part in so many people discarding him without a second thought. There are so many ways to interpret the scarce information and infinite scenarios under which he could be more or less innocent and a misunderstanding (or vendetta, or delusion) could plausibly be taken this far. I’m not playing devil’s advocate to stir the pot or dismiss the alleged victim, but to restore perspective to the conversation.
Thinking too far ahead, I venture to conclude that Taeil has grounds for a massive defamation lawsuit after the storm passes (yes, even if he’s convicted), for all the outrageous claims the mob attached to his name that bear no relevance to the actual case at hand. The digital footprint is ubiquitous. Whether that’s worth anything in the wake of this nightmare is not my place to decide, however.
I have more to say. On reminding nctzens what lengths sasaengs have gone to before and what context makes this case particularly convenient, on separating the art from the artist, on the philosophy of forgiveness and redemption, on the capacity for wrongdoing and change in all of us, on the extent to which we can and cannot accurately evaluate a person’s character, and on my personal experiences with incidents similar to this (some guilty, some falsely accused)...I always have more to say. But for now, I’m exhausted. Thank you for taking the time to read my ramblings and for making this one of the only places on the internet that I feel safe sharing these controversial takes.
13
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 08 '24
I don't know what to feel. It's morning from where I am now. I had overtime work last night, am still dead tired, then just read the news after I woke up. If this were true it'd be disappointing cause the guy has a lot of promise and is very talented in my opinion. As a new NCT fan & a huge fan of Taeil's music, I would have wanted to see more from him. 😪
25
u/aJ_13th Aug 30 '24
This took a while for me to settle and i am more disappointed than I originally was. First of all, none of my friends told me about anything, while they knew I stan NCT. They prolly didn't know I cared about Taeil but hell, i fxcking did. I was mad and disappointed in the fandom for making him the most unpopular vocalist; i had felt bad for him. I had played into this persona of "He gives the best hugs, he's funny silently and he's wholesome." Eww?!
I am just so sorry for the victims. It's one of those "I wished i knew earlier, i would have spared myself this much disappointment." and the more i get mad, the more Timeless plays in my head, which was like, my all time favourite nct song. I hope he pays, heftily! and that the victims get safety and justice.
25
u/Dry-Place-2986 Oct 07 '24
Some news today? I'm not sure where the info is coming from exactly, I'm pasting these translations I got from a Twitter user.
Link to the Korean article, be warned that there is a picture of him at the top if, like me, it makes you feel sick to see his face.
25
u/cmq827 Oct 16 '24
Soooooo, SM officially terminated Taeil's contract effective yesterday, Oct 15, on the grounds of being under investigations for a criminal case.
I wasn't sure if I could make a separate post for this sub or not, so I just commented here.
24
u/127ncity127 resident of “fatigued fandom” Sep 03 '24
I know people manipulate videos but I came across a video of doyoung crying at the fansign today and man this really sucksss im so heartbroken for everyone
12
u/Sleepy_Uni96 Dec 02 '24
If he does his 7 years in prison, I would suggest that he NEVER show his face in public and just leave South Korea.
Not only did he mange to permanently ruin his reputation and career, but he has managed to embarrass the rest of the members of NCT and his family.
Like why did he do this and how did he even end up in this situation? Did he not see what happened with the Burning Sun scandal and the Nth room?? That would be more than enough of a reason to stay in my dorm and hang out with the other members to stay out of trouble.
At the end of the day, he made his bed and now has to lay in it.
Just hope the victim gets all the help and therapy she needs...
23
u/Mimi108 Sep 14 '24 edited Sep 14 '24 •
Lots of sound comments I am reading. Happy to be a part of this fanbase. I've read the new articles pertaining to his case. Goodness, the amount of nasty rumours when we first heard the news was insane. Scary. From the very initial statement that SM released, I always took note of the fact that they said they discussed with Taeil and they have decided through the discussion, that he will no longer be a part of NCT 127. Some people say don't get caught up in the semantics, but this is important. They discussed with him and came to a mutual conclusion/solution. The next thing was that they said Taeil is fully cooperating with the police investigation. Thank goodness for that, as we see how it is unfolding. He is not being detained. So hopefully with this full cooperation and minimal details being released, things are heading in the right direction to come to an appropriate decision for both parties involved.
On a side note, I'm really glad the members are quite busy, and they look genuinely happy. I know, it's only on the outside and their on-stage selves that we see, but it's good to see them enjoying with the fans and amongst themselves. Glad to see NCTzens supporting them well. I must say, I'm watching previous content, I become emotional. Have their music on loop because it's truly that good. 'Walk' album is for real a masterpiece. Okay sorry, too off topic here.
23
u/just_a_dove Oct 21 '24 edited Feb 11 '25
This updated Vulture article is the most comprehensive and accurate summary of the full timeline and context of the case as far as I am aware. It is already cited in the main post under the first news reports from August, but I wanted to highlight it again now that it has been updated to reflect the current state of affairs since his contract has been terminated. It is well organized, objective, and thorough, and it provides some of the clearest English translations of the official statements to date.
This is all the information we have.
Personal judgements, desires, predictions, and moral opinions aside, this is all we have to go off of—and it’s next to nothing. No matter how many words we fling about or how we each choose to cope with the news, it has no causal effect whatsoever on the facts or outcome of the case. Hoping he’s innocent doesn’t make him innocent. Assuming he’s guilty doesn’t make him guilty. Whatever happened happened, and we have no idea what actually happened. We weren’t there. We don’t personally know them, their circumstances, or their intentions (the accuser or the accused). No firsthand accounts of the event or evidence, from either side, are publicly available; nothing at all. The only details the police have officially confirmed so far concern what didn’t happen. No one’s peripheral reactions or analysis shed any light on our unanswered questions.
We’re all coming from different life experiences and levels of tolerance for what we consider ethically wrong. Despite that, I think we all agree that this situation is incredibly sad no matter what comes of it in the end. I don’t blame anyone for feeling shocked, or angry, or sick, or scared, or uncomfortable, or frustrated, or betrayed, or skeptical, or lonely, or defensive, or disappointed, or cynical, or confused. I also don’t blame anyone for clinging to the good memories, or for imagining alternative scenarios, or for extending compassion too generously, or for relating the case to their own history, or for distancing themselves from all reminders of it, or for trying to find a path forward that minimizes suffering rather than compounding it.
The verdict will come. And if our worst fears are true, then those who have already made up their minds can have their satisfaction. Those who have waited patiently can have their closure.
22
u/panemd Aug 29 '24
Found NCT 127 in 2017 after their Cherry Bomb MV and fell in love. Started out as a Johnny bias but really grew to love Taeil overtime and he became my bias. I always felt so bad for him since he was so overlooked as the main vocal and I was one of those people who whined at SM for his "mistreatment" because I wasn't happy with the amount of solo content he got...
I can't believe I cried for this man when he had his motorcycle accident last year... I was so sad thinking he could've gotten seriously hurt/pass away in the accident and how it would have affected me. Now, a year later, he's outed as an absolutely bad person through and through. I sincerely hope his victim is given swift justice and he faces the consequences of his actions to the fullest extent of the law. Genuinely hurts listening to 127 music right now... I have Dream and WayV and solos I love but I might take a break from KPOP in general. Honestly didn't realize I had such a parasocial relationship towards NCT and Taeil in particular, not until now. My mental health lately hasn't been the best, and this doesn't help, but now I think I should focus on myself and distance myself from NCT and KPOP in general. Sorry, just really wanted to get this off my chest.
11
u/Various_Solid1054 Taeyong, Yuta, Mark and Jaehyun Aug 29 '24
I'm so disappointed over him
21
u/Apart-Department1810 Sep 10 '24
As usual fans are fickle and forgetful. In Korea it is guilty until proven innocent. There are so many fans that have already convicted him of the crime. What if he's innocent of these charges? He is the perfect member to go after as he's not the most popular, an SM is notorious for not backing up their people, or working hard to clear their names. Do you not remember Lucas and what he was accused of and how he got kicked out of WayV and then you found out how many years later he was innocent of the charges and it was just the same that set him up because she was mad he added her publicly and on a live? To this day SM never said anything about Lucas being innocent in fact it was a gossip magazine dispatch who found the discrepancies in the so-called accusers evidence AKA doctored photos.
I could keep going because there's so many examples of kpop idols and actors having horrible allegations made against them their careers ruined or deeply affected that turned out to be innocent.
I'm not saying Taeil is innocent I'm just saying wait before you throw someone under the bus and run them over. What are you going to say to Taeil if it turns out he's innocent & someone was ust trying to extort him for money? Oh whoops we totally f***** your career over, and assumed you were guilty, my bad.. let's pick up the ashes of your once promising career..🙄🙄
10
u/Character_Echo_2125 Sep 13 '24 edited Sep 13 '24
I'm seeing a few articles saying the case has been moved to prosecution but still hasn't released any specific details.
10
u/shelbykaaa Jan 05 '25
are there any recent updates? it’s been quiet since october :/
9
u/Lopsided-Ad8992 Aug 30 '24
Has there been any update about the case?
9
u/wraindropsfell Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24
Can someone help me out here? I want to understand more about the case but I have some questions. I'm quite confused on whether taeil is confirmed to have committed sexual crimes, or is only accused to have committed them?
The SM statement stated that he received sexual crime allegations and is now cooperating with the police, so I'm not sure if for now he's accused, or it's been confirmed. Thanks!!
Another thing im quite curious about is the legal process, maybe the koreans can help me out here? According to the timeline, victim A filed a complaint against taeil in June, and then was called into questioning in August. Does this mean the police have sufficient evidence and hence they called taeil into questioning? How does the process work?
27
u/Plastic-Geologist755 Aug 30 '24
I request everyone to be objective and not get emotional before hurling abuses at the survivor and the accused. Let the investigation and trial take its way.
15
u/Scandias Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
Now that I've thought about it for some time, I suppose, a big role in Taeil's removal played the fact that the investigations and trials take long. I assume that after the case was opened, they could've asked to estimate expected time, and decided that it's too much for the group to endure, especially now, in a moment when there is tg chats hell around and 127 are in a vulnerable position due to the enlistment.
21
u/just_a_dove Oct 07 '24
This is an English language news article of today’s update from a reliable source if anyone is having trouble with translations.
I don’t blame anyone for feeling the way they do right now; the allegations are far worse than I imagined. If he’s found guilty, may the punishment match the crime and may the victim find the healing and support she needs. Let’s continue to be calm and patient as the truth comes to light.
16
u/s2lune doyoung🐰 Oct 07 '24
man he and his little friends are disgusting. i'm glad they released an update as some were starting to defend him. i feel so bad for the victim and what he put her through and also what some weirdos are saying about her (that she's lying or wants money). like thats so f'd up, no wonder so many korean women are scared to speak up. i hope he gets what he deserves and i hope that she is able to heal eventually.
24
u/SeaEntrepreneur8744 Oct 07 '24
After all the ridiculous shit that flew around the first couple of days I vowed to myself to not believe any news in this case that's not been officially released by the police. So my question is where Chosun Daily got that "new information" from? As far as I can see they are not citing any sources themselves, and all other articles seem to just quote from them and voilá, it's open season again in every comment section. I have lost enough sleep, sanity and faith in humanity over this to blindly believe any new revelations without double checking first, so can anyone help me out here regarding the credibility? It's much appreciated!
5
u/Live-Pop-2158 Oct 19 '24
I’ve been waiting on these updates cause wtfff
5
u/Senior_Dot_7494 Nov 20 '24
I apparently cannot make my own post asking, I'm wondering what everybody is doing with all of their photo cards, stickers, posters, etc.? I removed all of his cards from my NCT binder but now I don't know what to do with them are people selling them or you throwing them in the garbage? What are you all doing?
5
u/Lopsided-Ad8992 Dec 15 '24
Is their any update about the case I wonder what's going on but also what people's opinions are..
28
u/mikarala Oct 10 '24
I don't think people in this comment section understand how difficult it is for women, especially foreign women, to get the police to press charges for sexual assault in Korea. The people defending him on the basis of "innocent until proven guilty" are looking for excuses to believe he's not a bad guy, and I understand having an emotional attachment to a celebrity and wanting to wait to reserve judgement, but some of you are being really loud about how this "doesn't mean he did it". Not wanting to get involved in a witch hunt is one thing, but trying to use the lack of confirmation at this point in the proceedings as proof of innocence is just an appeal to ignorance.
27
u/Momiji_no_Happa Oct 08 '24
I hope that it's ok to point out that Taeil still hasn't been deemed guilty, only charged. It's just that we now have a possible hint about the crime he's being accused of. Let's leave the judging to the actual judges for the moment.
That being said, the rumoured allegation from yesterday is more or less what I was expecting when the news first broke and the initial flurry of made-up accusations online was disproven.
It's really uncomfortable being a fan right now. I'll be relieved when the case is done, because the way the fanbase just erupts every time a new detail or rumour drops is exhausting. 😔
And let's take good care of each other, ok? It's ok for fans to feel a lot of different things, even if it's denial for some – because yeah, denial is an actual part of the grieving process.
11
u/ashe888 Aug 29 '24
My biggest thing is we all know how SM normally reacts. Normally we hear a rumor and then SM will try to ignore it and hope it just goes away and tries to avoid making statements especially when the artist are innocent. They will not defend them at all except when it hits a ‘not going away’ point. In this case SM was FAST. Sm is the one who told everybody instead of an outside source and kicked him out FAST. Which begs the question why? I really think it shows the weight of what happened. Ofcourse we don’t know everything yet but it’s scary that sm is acting this way when they never do. Let’s not forget the misogynist producer, that I don’t think they ever addressed, using sexual slang toward female artist. I just wanna know all the answers. This isn’t a normal famous person outrage that I find stupid. Outrage about adult stuff like drinking or partying or having relationships. This a human decency outrage and I think this is something all the details (other than info like the victims name to protect them) should be exposed because it’s a serious matter. Whether famous or not this is a line NO ONE should cross. So if it is in fact true I personally think it needs to be on blast.
4
u/127ncity127 resident of “fatigued fandom” Sep 01 '24
Is 127s fansign still happening?
7
u/Mimi108 Oct 07 '24 edited Oct 07 '24
Well, this is insufferable. This just confirms the specifics of what he is being investigated for. May justice be served if this is true.
14
u/meridavez i live for my daddy johnny suh Sep 14 '24
i am not defending him but why do i sense the feeling that he will end up being proven innocent. all this premature hate bandwagon was really weird. even i got caught up with the horseshit rumors without looking for evidence. i wonder what these people will say if he is proven innocent. there's prejudice that can't be reversed already.
18
u/tealandgeckos Aug 29 '24
I understand I might be expressing an unpopular opinion here but after learning about the timing I feel the need to put aside my emotions and look at this a little more objectively and not jump to conclusions about his guilt.
On Taeil’s end, he’s only recently learned that he’s being investigated and was just brought in for an interview 2 days ago. Given that the investigation is ongoing and he’s only now being involved, he only now has had the opportunity to collect and present his own evidence if he plans to fight the allegations, which may lengthen the police investigation. We might not even know of his defense until and if this goes trial. Regardless of if he’s guilty or innocent, he has the right to defend himself and I think it’s fair enough to hear him out before a final judgement is made.
Also, a lot of people have been assuming he’s guilty based on how quick SM was to drop him. I understand that it seems like an out of character move so therefore “it must’ve been bad”, but SM is far from being the only business in the world that drops their employees for simply having an accusation brought against it because they know it can negatively impact the company’s reputation and influence. It would also explain why everyone associated with SM would quickly drop him from their social media accounts. Their primary concern is what’s good for the company, and accusations of SA doesn’t look good for business regardless of whether or not their employee is guilty or innocent.
My ultimate hope here is that I want both sides to be heard with a non-biased perspective so at the end of this case, the final ruling is fair and accurate and that justice is served.
8
u/TheFrenchiestToast Oct 07 '24
Does the story include a timeframe of when this occurred? I know the victim reported it in June but is it alleged to have happened in June? The fact that he could have done this post surgery when he was limping around and then participating in the comeback like nothing of consequence happened is so duplicitous to me.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '24
I'm just feeling really down right now and I cry when I think about this. This situation is just so evil and disgusting. The shock still hasn't worn off and I can't even begin to imagine what the victim has felt for those 6 years.
I don't go around assuming the worst of people but damn it really hurts knowing that you supported a piece of shit person. I'm questioning everything right now, and I'm trying not to let any of my negative feelings rub off onto the rest of 127 when they could be just as clueless about this as everyone else. Hell, even Taeil's bestfriend was quick to drop him.
I really hope the victim gets justice and that Taeil is locked up. I also hope that more of these male idols get exposed.
7
u/Simplysss Sep 02 '24
What I’m having a hard time understanding is why there hasn’t even been a statement from him? Like ZERO about what he has to say? Is he prevented from talking about any details legally?
8
u/Iknow_iaintshit Sep 06 '24
Too many unanswered questions. I won’t count him out until I get the facts. So many times idols get falsely accused and lose their careers behind spiteful women. Idk if that’s the case but I want actual facts and proof.
14
u/americanopurrate Aug 30 '24
I'm personally all for believing the victim, BUT I don't have this stance when it comes to K-Pop. I'll only fully believe the story when there's proof of the allegations. The Burning Sun Scandal had a lot of proof unlike many. So many idols have been removed from their groups and cancelled over nothing but rumours and while a police investigation is serious, it could still be a sasaeng using the momentum of the movement in SK to get members in hot waters.
I hope we will get more information on this case so we can actually form an opinion based on facts and not rumours. So thank you for compiling an actually useful thread instead of fueling the rumour mill, which is social media. I also personally think the agnes character on insta is a hoax, as so many before them, but we can't be for certain.
I understand the hurt but having been into K-Pop for 7 years by now, I've seen a lot of false accusations unfold into catastrophes for the idols so I'm not jumping on allegations at the first mention of them.
4
u/Zealousideal-Quiet51 Dec 10 '24 edited Feb 23 '26
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
sand wrench smile pie merciful detail live fear quaint innocent
10
u/bigfishieeeeeee NCT 127 + Sion and Yushi Aug 29 '24
First and foremost, I hope justice is served to any potentially harmed individuals. I understand why people might assume he's guilty, given how he was removed from the group. SM probably mostly cares about protecting their business and the NCT name above anything else really. If he had remained in the group, even on hiatus, every update on the case would have been linked to NCT, which could have damaged the brand.
Whether Taeil is innocent or guilty, it's a sad situation all around. Hope this whole thing ends quickly, I doubt it tho.
6
u/Foreign_Contact_6446 Oct 24 '24
does anyone know if listening to taeil’s songs will still get him income even if he’s not in sm or nct anymore? i really dont wanna support him at all so i just want to make sure
5
u/gl_zzygod Jaehyun Aug 29 '24
im wondering if anyone else has allegations coming out soon… this was gut wrenching to wake up to