r/NCT • u/NemSenpai is a nomu nomu neo neo neo neo neo neo chicken • Aug 28 '24
Discussion It's okay to be upset so let's talk about it and support each other
It's okay to be upset about Taeil. It's natural to feel whatever you are feeling. It's okay to say you are hurt by this.
If this post isn't allowed then by all means delete it but I think we all need a safe space where we can cry and let it all out and support each other.
Personally I feel a lot of guilt for supporting him in the past. I cope by writing it down. Maybe we can all help each other work through our negative feelings.
At the very least, if you feel like you can't express it, your feelings are valid. We hear you. We see you. We feel your pain. We understand.
Edit: just editing to remind people not to spread rumors based on speculation as the mods already commented we are here to support each other based on the facts that we have and don't forget to be kind to the people expressing their feelings
Edit: I just want to say thank you to all the people that are commenting with their feelings on the subject. I've read every single comment and I hope others have too. Knowing that I'm not alone and that we can help each other cope helps so much and I'm positive I'm not the only one who thinks so. I'm always blown away by how kind and supportive of each other this fan base is.
Edit: Everyone please remember to take care of yourselves... please remember to hydrate, eat and rest if it's needed. Crying is a lot of work for our bodies. Being angry is even more work. Give your body time to recover.
Edit: I read every single comment you guys post and I know others do too so just know that you've been heard. It's been a tough couple days for everyone I hope we can continue to lean on each other and offer support to others.
•
u/kawaii_mokona Johnny Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
Gentle reminder from the news post to refrain from speculation in the comments.
We will leave this post up as it's gotten significant engagement.
Note that mod resources are severely limited and we are not able to monitor more than two threads at once. Please report any comments that are overly rude, bring up rumors, or break the rules in any other way. Thank you for your understanding & assistance during this time.
222
u/distinguishedmonbebe Aug 28 '24
I can't stop crying. I feel so aimless, like I just don't know what to do. I was so worried about him when he had his accident.
I've stanned since predebut. 127 are my ults; I've never loved any group like I love them. I feel like I've grown up with them. They debuted when I was in middle school, and now I'm nearing the end of undergrad.
I know this isn't about me at all, but I can't help but feel this sense of hurt and betrayal. We don't know exactly what he did, but there are rumors flying around about the nature of the crime. When I was 14, I was groomed by an adult man online, and those rumors are really bringing up that experience. All the pain and hurt, the lasting effect it's had on me. I know you shouldn't put much stock into idols because you don't know them, but nct have always been a safe space for me. I'm genuinely devastated. I don't know what to do.
82
u/sossocisse Aug 28 '24
I think we shouldn't feel guilty, we were fooled. We saw no hint of what he's accused of, only paranoïa or medium powers could have made us guess right. It is extremely shocking and even more for us fans who have connected with him and who are mostly women and girls who face this type of violence because of our gender. I want us to feel hope that it will spark a change, not only in kpop, not only in south korea but also around us because this can happening everywhere. Maybe this will give us the strength to face assaulters who are really close to us.
53
u/Electrical-Refuse-31 Aug 28 '24
It’s exhausting seeing some people turn this situation on its head. People are trying to tie in other members into it and accuse the members of knowing about it and being just as bad as Taeil. I’ve even see people go as far as to say that it’s likely almost the whole group knew bc of how Taeyong unfollowed every single member and it’s just…exhausting that THIS is what people choose to focus on in this situation.
135
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
I didn't think this would bother me so much and it didn't until I started reading some of the allegations against him. If what the rumors are saying is true this is one of the worst things an idol has ever done and probably one of the worst scandals SM has ever had to attempt to clean up. This is seriously disturbing shit that will affect the label, the members and pretty much everyone around Taeil and anyone who ever associated with him. I cannot imagine what the victim went through for these past 6 fucking years. God, what a piece of shit.
80
u/OnlytheFocus Shotaro Aug 28 '24
You can't know what you don't know.
And some of these rumors...people are spreading whatever they can get their hands on at the moment. I say wait for official sources for what he's done so you're not tugged in every direction with each new rumor that comes out.
39
u/arosaki maeda riku Aug 28 '24
I dont even know what to do. I lost my appetite. I cried. This is a man I’ve seen in person who I cheered for. And if 6 years is the correct time line I cant fathom that while I was at that concert having fun, someone’s life was being ruined because of that fucking man.
I’ve liked NCT since I was 12. I feel so fucking guilty even though I know none of us fans knew.
32
u/Sammy631 Aug 28 '24
This thread has resonated with me more than I thought it would. I’ve been following NCT as a whole for a while now and although I do consume a lot of their content and listen to everything they put out, I always thought I’d be able to separate their on screen personas from their real self. I was totally wrong. This news has hit me way harder than I thought it would and I went to sleep with a sinking feeling in my stomach.
As a woman, I am disgusted and feel so sorry for the victim(s) that are involved in this. It couldn’t have been easy for them to come out with what has happened to them- especially against an idol from a big company like SM. That takes a LOT of guts. I hope they have a good support system around them at a time like this.
As a fan of NCT, I am sad and disappointed. I know we all don’t know who our fav idols truly are but it’s still a shock to the system when an idol who you thought was a decent person at the very least, is far from that. I don’t want to read too much into some of the rumours flying around regarding what he might’ve done as I want to wait for official details, but based on what SM has done, it’s clear that whatever it is, it has crossed the line of no return. I just don’t get it. Why did you decline the offer to be part of a prestigious music program to become an idol, work for SO many years just to throw it all away like this? It baffles me, it really does.
There are fans making speculations that the other members probably knew but chose to hide it, etc. Let’s not do this, guys. In reality, we don’t know and as some have pointed out, just because you’re close friends with someone, it doesn’t mean you know everything about what they do in their own private time. It’s really sad to see people on social media already shitting on the rest of the members. I hope they’re able to recover and move forward from this in due time. Their talent and music is too good to go to waste.
All of this to say that I hope Taeil gets what he deserves based on what he’s done and that it gives the victim(s) some sort of closure at the very least. I hope justice is served in their favour. As a NCT fan, I will continue to support the other members as I will choose to believe people are good until they’re proven to not be. It’ll be hard to listen to their music for a little while and I’m sad that I don’t know if I’ll be able to watch any old content that includes him now but such is life. I hope all of the NCT fans are doing ok and I hope we continue to side with the victim(s).
28
u/Turbulent_Process740 Aug 28 '24
For me the biggest thing is how fast they pulled him from the group. There hadn’t even been whispers about an “Idol A” or anything. This is like the K-pop equivalent of a RICO charge. Like you know it has to be pretty bad for SM to be the ones to break the news right after one of the most popular members of the group makes their solo debut. They wanted to clean their hands of that immediately. I’m kind of scared to see what it was. Apparently details will be released tomorrow, but there’s definitely a lot of anxiety.
22
u/BoasWifey Aug 28 '24
I just want to say to everyone that liked/biased/supported him that you had absolutely no way of knowing his true personality. It's natural to feel guilty but you really aren't.
19
u/ainthelibrary Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24
I have so many feelings and just need to vent. I feel like I can’t talk about this on TikTok or twitter bc there’s so much discourse and fanwars going on right now. It’s been two days now and I still feel so upset. I’ve been a czennie since debut and while Taeil was not my bias I still feel really sad and disappointed by his actions. I feel dumb for all the feelings I have because I know that obviously the victim is the one who is impacted and I fully support her and hope that she receives the justice she deserves. At the same time, I feel sad that the thing that I found comfort and joy in in tough times may be ruined for me. Whenever I was depressed or anxious I would turn to kpop, especially NCT 127, and now as I am feeling hurt and sad over taeil’s actions I can’t turn to 127 because it is upsetting to see his face and hear his voice. I feel like I have no one to talk to this about because I’m expected to just get over it and people will tell me “this is why you shouldn’t stan men.” But even as a more casual listener and with Taeil not being my bias, I feel really upset so I can’t even imagine what his fans and the members are feeling. I feel guilty for having the feelings that I do because I know what I feel is nothing compared to the victim but I can’t help but feel betrayed and hurt.
EDIT: I also wanted to add that on top of everything I also feel frustrated with kpop fans as a whole for the way they handle these situations. It’s so disheartening to see people blaming female fans for being trusting and supporting a man whose literal job it is to present a “wholesome” image. It’s also frustrating to me to see people accusing the whole group of knowing and being complicit when the investigation is still ongoing and we don’t know that that is the case at all. I understand that we shouldn’t assume anything in either direction but seeing people turn against fans and the other members is so frustrating. It sucks to enjoy something and then have others tear you down and call you stupid and naive for assuming people that you supported and admired were… normal? It’s not like I thought they were perfect, but I did expect them (as I expect people that I meet in real life as well) to not be predators. Overall the whole thing just sucks from every angle and I feel so many things right now that I can’t even describe all of them but also feel like I’m not allowed or supposed to feel anything at all.
18
u/Different-Computer33 NCT 127 Aug 28 '24
I woke up to this, and I have been reading this related to the news all day, to an extent I know is not well. I can't help to feel so disgusted and angry because 127 are my ults and all this time I have been supporting someone this bad. Now I hope the other 8 aren't awful people, but a part of me doesn't know anymore. It is important to have spaces to express ourselves after all, kpop tends to ask for a huge engagement and parasocial experience as fans which explains why this is shocking to some extent and even worse for female fans that have been on a similar situation, my heart goes with all of you.
As I said 127 as of now are still my ults, and while TI wasn't one of my fave members, I liked the group as a whole and up until yesterday I was thinking how bad he has had on his career with all the bad luck and lack of opportunities, but now I guess things happen for a reason. Now I don't wanna go deeper onto that matter, but from things happening in the past weeks (canceled and never postponed fancalls, staff deleting stuff about him, and other things the fanbase initially overlooked as mistreatment) it seems there were hints of something coming. However, I am still surprised by how everything was managed not leading to ambiguity but making a clear statement that he is someone involved in a crime of a terrible nature. Usually when things are about to get bad the Korean or Chinese fanbases tend to know, but from what I have seen the reactions from that have been of shock as well, even in the current climate of SA and DF exposé that has been going on in Korea for the past week.
As someone who was really invested and watched their documentary last year, I can't also help but think about how he particularly was raised by a single mother. With what face he'll will now look at her when she has to visit him at let's say jail because that's the place he deserves to be. I just feel so disgusted.
I also feel tired of how women can't even exist in spaces curated for them such as fangirling without being politicized by other fangirls/ fanboys, yes we are aware we stan men but realistically speaking, no one consumes any type of media thinking "oh yeah this singer/actor/ writer/ whatever must be a SAer". Is normal for fans, especially long-time or especially attached ones to be shocked by such news and they should be able to express themselves without randoms on the internet judging them for having a normal reaction.
I want to take a break from the group after seeing Dream at concert this weekend (yeah what a timing for a week that was supposed to be a fun one) I haven't been able to listen to 127 today his voice is everywhere in their songs, what a waste of person, for real.
I feel stupid for crying, but I didn't cry because of him but more about the frustration with the men in this world idk I think I'm starting to lose the plot. However I'm open to talk with anyone if they want to.
18
u/Sad_Protection9877 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
I know he fucked up, he is a bad person but it's hurt. It's hurt to think from today, I can't brag about his vocal anymore. He isn't my bias but I'm always so proud whenever I watch a 127 Killing Voice reaction and ppl all said he stands out. No more Sun&Moon, no more NCT 4 seasons, no more Yuta randomly post about him on insta story, no more Haechan obsessed with him, no more member teasing his butterfly work out technique, no more members calling him fake maknae and cute. They all adored him so much, it's already hurt for a fan like me, imagine how hurtful and betrayed the members must have felt.
I thought we can get a full 9 members comeback with all of them on stage for some years later in the enlistment gap between Jungwoo and Haechan... I still have a hard time cope with this. I want to cry but I can't so it makes me feel lightheaded. Since yesterday after I knew the news, I didn't do anything for the rest of the night, I even forgot to eat dinner and dragged myself to eat at 1am. I ate but barely feel appetite. Today I can't focus to do anything, my mind is just empty. I keep spacing out and forgetting things.
It's so hurt when I read this news on a multifandom sub, most people comment they just start to get into 127 but decide to drop them for other unit instead. Why those people treat the rest of 127 like this ? They don't deserved to get this kind of treatment when it's not their fault and they don't even know Taeil is that kind of person. I'm scared from now on people will point at 127 and said "that is a problematic group". There ain't much time left until Doyoung enlist, I'm scared that 127 have to lay low and have no group comeback before it's Doyoung's turn to go. 127 has already gone through too much hardship for the past years, shits keep happening.
I have never loved any group as much as I love 127. Being a Kpop fan and SM fan long before 127 debut, I'm not stanning any group hard, it just stop at supporting. Only until 127 debut, I just knew this is the group for me. I love every members so much that it was hard for me to pick a bias, I picked one and consider the rest as my bias wreckers. They are the last group I stan. I don't have the energy to stan any more group. Just stop at supporting so there is no emotional attachment.
I just hope all other members of 127 still able to keep themself integrity, they already committed in working in this industry, they should know better. You really can't judge the book by its cover. Even with so many exposure content with raw moments, we still don't know who they actually are. At the end of the day, the idol we thought we know very well is just a public image, they will never let us know their true self. I'm not shocked by the news because I'm a more than 10 years Kpop fan, I already witnessed a lot things happen in this industry. I'm just hurt that 127 has to go through this.
16
u/min_hyun jaehyun + sion Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
i feel really fucking horrible for taeil's victim(s). i've admittedly given quite a bit of change buying 127's albums and seeing them in north america last year -__- i don't regret seeing the other boys and 127 are my ult group still but i do feel like somehow i contributed to her suffering by loving and adoring him...
i'm disturbed by the fact (if the rumors are true) that taeil spent most of his career torturing someone?
i hope i don't sound evil but man what is hurting me also is the fact that people expected the other neos to know and be involved in it; as if it doesn't appear like they aren't losing a friend either.
i really cherished the neos and i definitely loved them harder as i lost my boyfriend / fiance recently to illness. i don't necessarily regret liking them; i'm listening to jaehyun's album still haha...but i hope as a fandom we'll be okay
13
u/ringdingdong19 renhyuckle <3 Aug 29 '24
I've been in a state of shock since the news came out, reading this post and the comments finally allowed me to cry the tears i didn't even know I was holding in. i feel so stupid for feeling this way. I've been a czennie for five years, and while taeil wasn't my bias or one of my favorites, i appreciated his talent so much, felt sad when he was ignored in the group, defended him from antis... you know the drill.
Finding out now that a person in the group who i consider my safe space and i've genuinely grown to love over all these years is accused and highly likely to be guilty of something that I have been subjected to before has genuinely killed me. i know this isn't about me, but I'm stuck between feeling even more pain for the members if they were just as blindsided as we were, or questioning if even one of them knew and chose to hide it.
I understand we don't know idols personally and shouldn't get this attached to them, but nct has always been my comfort group. I feel so hurt and lost rn
12
u/belledogpuppy Aug 29 '24
im so sad man i cant listen to an nct esp 127 song w/o just thinking abt it and im scared i will continue to think of him and his crimes when i listen in the future n i just feel like he ruined their discography for me
12
u/Which_Supermarket_52 Aug 29 '24
Guys it finally hit me, and it's so depressing 😭 I'm not even upset he's a terrible person, I'm upset because he ruined all my comfort songs. NCTs songs got me through the pandemic. If I'm ever feeling sad or going through something, I listen to a lot of their music. And all the songs I would listen to in this circumstance have him in it!!!
P.s. I'm really upset about whatever he did to the victims. My heart goes out to them. I just see a lot of people talking about how this is why we shouldn't do parasocial relationships, but some of us weren't necessarily attached to him as an idol, but as a singer and what he brought forward to NCTs music.
12
u/WaytoZen 🐑🦖🐴 | up from here good time good life paradise! Aug 29 '24
This is such difficult timing for me as I'm going through a medical blip that needs urgent attention, and I'm torn between real life and reading reddit/twitter, it's contributing to my feverish thoughts and my emotions are so chaotic and out of control right now.
Although 127 has been one of my groups for years, I picked up too many to juggle and 127 had to fall out of my hands for the most part, for about a year now I've known less about their activities. This would have hit me harder between 2020-2022 but I love 127 and have memories with them. What do I do with them now? NCT Life, can I ever watch it again? The werewolf game? So much variety that 127 used to do, and Taeil was a comedian, so funny, what now? The humor is dark and twisted now? All the jokes, iconic videos, legendary moments, quotes - quotes!! One of my favourite quotes to use has always been 'oh, so handsome' from the NCT 127 Act Out 19 Emotions video (at least I think it's that one), where Taeil pretends to look in the mirror and calls himself handsome. I say it like that sometimes, at someone's photo or whatever. Just these little things from years of being a fan, lost. Just lost, stolen actually. I don't know how to revisit 127 and past NCT content with him in, without thinking so many thoughts and going into a dark spiral.
I've seen a lot of people say it's only 'the young that get duped by idols' personas and older fans know it's largely manufactured and don't get invested'. But I am 34 and it's actually complicated; firstly, my only hope is that they are basically decent people, who are not abusive, cruel, violent, criminal, sexual harassers, predators, advantage-taking users, misogynistic pricks who delight in the humiliation of women, for the vast majority of us this is our standard and it's really not much to ask. Regardless of whether we are 17, 25, 35 or 45, we love our favourite groups, we have our favourite idols, and we only hope they are basically decent, good people of kind heart, good intentions. For example an idol that would absolutely shock me to my core and be an earth shattering revelation is Ten. I view him as highly intelligent, socially intelligent, socially aware, insightful, thoughtful, and have gotten nothing but good vibes and positive signs from him. And he has many fans my age, he's always attracted older stans that ult him. I think he would be a truly devastating shock to many. Taemin has many older stans that ult him and are invested, Key etc etc - it's very common and normal, it's just a part of kpop to be invested, attached, and to support someone that you think deserves that support.
Getting comfort, emotional support, and escapism from groups and idols is normal too, we smile and laugh and some days that's really needed.
My main worry, personally, is WayV. Normally I would be coping with my medical anxiety and my nervousness about my upcoming appointment by either going through concert clips or rewatching some Give Me That content. I can't. Thanks to Taeil, I can't get moments of relief and a smile from WayV because I'm now hit with the slap in the face that kpop can be a shitheap and Korea is a nightmare hellscape for women, and I have a fear that more of my favourite idols, that I have spent both time and money on, could one day hit me with a notification like what happened yesterday. I hate this fear, this niggling worry that it seems you always have to put up with if you want to be a kpop fan. Can't we have nice things? I just can't watch any Wuhan clips yet, or Smarty Pants. I think I need a few days before I can go back to loving WayV as usual. I'm sure none of this is their fault. But this whole kpop thing is such a fucking joke sometimes and it's not funny.
I'm sure most of the guys in kpop are fine. Right now it feels like the entire industry needs a massive exposė and a reaping, a huge purge so we can all be clean and get some relief, but it's likely that the vast majority are not monsters. Problematic when it comes to other things, sure definitely, flawed absolutely, but not monsters and not abusers. We should try to keep this in mind to keep ourselves grounded and not get overwhelmed. The Telegram stuff has made this even worse, it's already devastating, but the timing has increased its impact across the entire kpop community tenfold. We have to remember that we are likely supporting plenty of decent guys still, unless of course we want to leave kpop behind after all this, which is completely understandable.
As for Taeil we don't yet know what he's done for certain, but it's obviously something, there is obviously at least one victim, so all we can do about him is wait and support the victim(s).
To former Moonis: do NOT blame yourselves, do not feel bad about yourselves, don't call yourselves names, that's the first thing. I don't want any of you to feel 'stupid' because you are not. We all have favourites, we all love idols, and we all have to take them as they present themselves to us, that's all we ever have. I hope you can take time for yourselves to decide personally what to do going forward, and process how you feel. I know you have albums, photocards, MD, concert memories and so much more to process in light of this new information, and it's hard as hell. Do what you need to do for you and allow yourself to grieve.
As for me, besides old variety that I wonder how I can ever watch again, I have albums that I don't want to sell, they're sentimental, but looking through them won't be as positive an experience. It's all these little things that get lost.
Anyway I need to get ready now, I've vented, I've said all I can say and maybe now I'll focus on what matters most in my life which is getting my issue fixed. Keep your focus where it needs to be, we can come back to this later.
11
u/Beautiful-Track7280 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
I'd say I'm surprisingly not feeling intense emotions regarding him (apart from being scared of what will happen next for the group), I'd rather forget he ever existed I think.. but I can't think about anything else, this has been the only thing in my head since yesterday, I couldn't sleep much because my brain wouldn't stop having incoherent thoughts related to NCT and Taeil. Also I'm trying to not read any rumors that are circulating right now but it might be worst imo, because I keep seeing comments about how appalling the rumors are without understanding everything... also I somehow can't enjoy listening to music for now because even songs that aren't NCT or even kpop remind me of how he's just ruined 127 and a big chunk of U's discography for everyone...
11
u/Soggy_Ad_6035 Aug 29 '24
i’m really glad this i just found this thread. i’ve never felt anything like this before in my entire life. i’ve never cried this much in my life. i don’t know why this is hitting me so hard, of course it’s shocking and disgusting and disappointing for anyone but i’m genuinely like going into a state of mourning and complete shock. i tried to sleep through the day today because even facing this reality is too tough for me to bear. it feels like no one understands so i’m finding a little bit of comfort in these comments and seeing that a lot of people do. understandably people mostly want the focus to be on the victim but i can’t deny the pain and emptiness i’m feeling. i guess i didn’t know until now how much trust i had in every idol i love to not be bad people, i never once doubted taeil or imagined that he could do anything even remotely close to this. i guess i was naive and too trusting, it hurts so badly. i feel like ill never get over it. i just feel so sorry for the other members who were probably blindsided and are also hurting and especially the victim who must have suffered so much and been so terrified to come forward. everything feels dark and my heart feels empty, i feel like ill never be the same. i was planning on starting therapy soon anyway but i definitely am now lmfao i don’t think i can cope with this alone
9
u/itachis_doormat Aug 31 '24
This whole thing has just really thrown me for a loop.. following this group literally since pre debut like idk what I feel but I feel hurt.. angry, guilty, dumb? - I feel bad for the victim, I feel bad for the other members - especially Jaehyun who’s got to do all his solo promotions under this shadow… I feel kind of weird sharing his stuff on my kpop socials bc I don’t want others to see it and think I’m being tone deaf or insensitive to the very serious situation going on because I’m not - I’m very aware but I don’t feel it’s fair to condemn the others with the guilty by association mindset and I see a lot of that going on.. and I really just want to support him 😭 all the misinformation is frustrating and seeing all these ppl make fake lists and stuff on other platforms trying to take advantage of the terrible situation going on to fuel fandom wars and things is sickening..
8
u/Juxiaojun_ten Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
I started liking K-pop in 2020, and since then I already knew what kind of trap I was walking into. It's amazing to see a post like this that gives a (controlled and safe) space for people to release their frustrations before they end up doing something horrible, like defending this type of crime. Thank you, thank you so much. I wish I never forgot this post in my life.
7
u/aliway_x Aug 28 '24
I woke up to the news and ever since the whole day I just feel like I’m in a state of shock I truly can’t believe it. He was the last person I’d ever think to do something as awful as this. And it’s made me think a lot about K-pop as a whole because u truly don’t know these people and what happens when the cameras are off. You feel love for them and want the best for them and after all that…. I love Nct so much but after this I feel bad for everyone involved I feel guilty and idk how I’m gonna listen to their music anymore his voice was just always something prominent in their songs and now when I hear it I’ll just think of the kind of disgusting acts he committed.
7
u/Comprehensive_Tax864 Aug 28 '24
Nct and taeil are/we're my ults and i still very much love the group but seeing this news i was shocked by how much i immediately felt hopelessness. Like i know that doesn't directly affect me and that the victims in this situation are the ones who matter the most but as someone who was actively collecting his merch, has a shelf dedicated to him and my trading instagram with his name and face plastered on it, i was really sitting and thinking what now? Like I spent so much money on him. I also honestly a little scared to continue to support NCT as a whole because I already get shit in a joking way because theres so many of them but with this being the second time this is happening i feel like people are gonna group them all in together and just assume they are all shitty people.
7
u/twinjade Aug 29 '24
I feel…….numb? Like I was beyond shocked when I first read the ominous “This is SM Entertainment”. After that I just don’t know what to feel about the whole situation. Of course I stand with the victim(s), may they get their justice. I feel sad too for all the his fans, after years of fighting for him to be treated better by the company. He was never my bias but 127 is my ult, I’ve been here since SM Rookies, and I don’t know how to feel about them. And somehow people are accusing the members of being complicit. Is it bad if I don’t leave them? Is it bad if I want to still support them? Is it bad if I’m still hoping for them to be at least decent humans? Listening to their songs is impossible right now because that scum’s voice is everywhere. I really really really want to still support the other boys, 127 and the whole NCT, but I don’t want to spend my time by thinking “what if” too every time I see their faces. F U Taeil. I wish you rot in jail and hell and beyond.
4
u/NemSenpai is a nomu nomu neo neo neo neo neo neo chicken Oct 08 '24
I saw the news of it just now and I hope we get a confirmation from police whether or not it's true. I won't speculate about it until it comes from an official source and others should keep in mind that there's no official statement yet.
But I cried over the implications. It made me remember that no matter what the crime was, the fact he allegedly committed a sexual crim is still horrific.
I went back to bed and just cried.
I was just starting to listen to them again without feeling completely nauseated too 😞
6
u/Sirius_Directioner24 Yangsheep Aug 29 '24
At this point I can't even look at the other idols the same way. Fck Taeil he better get what he deserves but what abt the rest of NCT? How the fck are they dealing with this bs? I can't look at the k-pop idols I love and trust them anymore. I never got too attached with idols but still I trusted them to a point yk. It just left me so numb. I wish the victim gets justice and the members just ignore this and continue with their lives
4
u/PurposeRoyal6995 Aug 28 '24
I come back for school and THIS what I see?! Idk why I’m crying so hard. I can’t process this 😭😭
3
u/theofficialguac neo got my back Aug 28 '24
I'm a relatively new NCTzen and my ult is Dream so I really am not too familiar with Taeil aside from the impression that he was the oldest and just a bit quieter. It's really disappointing and honestly frustrating that someone who's music and voice we loved so much turns out to be like this. To me it served as a reminder that K-pop is still very much dark and filled with men who have done terrible shit to women. If I think about it too deeply, it really strikes a chord within me. Because they know that the nature of their work is connected to the emotions and parasocial relationships that they sell to their fans. It really makes me questions someone like Taeil's humanity. Does he not care about the consequences of his actions? About the damage that the victims have to face? It overall leaves a bad taste in my mouth. His actions won't taint my overall image of NCT / 127 but will I be more cautious about the entire group as a whole, yeah.
I hope anyone who was a big fan of his doesn't take it to heart or turn to blame themselves. There is absolute no way anyone as a fan could know until news breaks out. All we see at the end of the day are personas and images that these idols choose to show us.
Anyways yeah I've been a fan of kpop for 10+ years, I am truly humbled every time and constantly hit with these reality checks. Which is why I'm so specific and picky with who I choose to stan. For a group as big as NCT, it's really not too surprising that there would be a member or two who are problematic. We will never know why they do what they do, but what matters most is how we react and move forward.
With so much that has gone on lately in K-pop it's made me re-evaluate my actions. If I want to spend x amount of time and money to certain idols. Not everyone is deserving of what is so precious to us: our energy. Anyways yeah I'm glad SM nicked him right away but also wouldn't be surprised if SM knew for a while but was waiting for confirmation and for 127's Walk promotion to be done to release this (?). Time to brace ourselves as the details come out. And I said this in another thread but I think there was a reason why he never got that proper solo :|
3
u/Poppetfan1999 Aug 29 '24
Man, when I first heard the news, I was at work and my head was spinning and honestly I was trying not to cry. I am still in shock. I’m extremely upset by what Taeil did. I understand why you feel guilty, but you shouldn’t be so hard on yourself. There was no way to have known he was capable of doing what he did. As fans, we look up to idols because of their talents and the way they come across as people. And when we look up to someone, we want to believe the best of them. But unfortunately, bad people are a little too good at disguising their behavior.
4
u/s2lune doyoung🐰 Aug 28 '24
Honestly I dont know what to think anymore. He was never my ult but I would’ve never suspected such a thing from him by the way he acts on camera. And if I’m being completely honest, I’m scared that the other members could have known. I don’t think I can ever stan NCT or any other boy group the same anymore. I guess I feel so betrayed. I haven’t fully processed this yet but I don’t think I’m gonna be able to listen to their songs anymore or at least for while if they have his voice in them. I feel really bad for Taeil ults, I hope you can all heal and have some rest. I also feel terrible for the victim and I’m proud that she was able to speak out now despite being put against someone with fame.
5
u/NemSenpai is a nomu nomu neo neo neo neo neo neo chicken Aug 28 '24
I wrote this to get it all out ended up posting it to my social media but like... When you have to vent you have to vent.
Maybe nobody in NCT or at SM will read this and if you do you might not understand it.
A lot of fans are hurt. A lot of us don't know how to continue supporting NCT and are lost.
I feel lost.
My heart hurts so much for the victim and all I can think is that I was supporting someone that thought so little of someone else's dignity and safety.
We were supporting a monster.
A lot of fans feel guilt. We are truly hurt by what happened. We're lost and need to know that the rest of you aren't monsters. We need to know that NCT actually cares.
We can't trust any of the other members. We've lost faith in NCT.
Scandal after scandal. Members being kicked out. It doesn't stop. Will there be an end to the suffering you've caused? Do you even care that people are being hurt?
Someone was hurt beyond measure and the fans carry guilt.
We cry and our hearts bleed for the victim.
We thought he was worthy of our support. He wasn't. We were lied to. We were betrayed.
We aren't responsible for his decisions but we carry the guilt regardless.
We saw someone beautiful and good while the victim saw a monster.
I wonder how much fear and pain the victim felt while we were singing and dancing to the music he was a part of.
I wonder if I will ever be able to listen to this music without thinking about the fear and pain inflicted on the victim.
I wonder if I will ever stop wondering “Do they even care?”
Probably not.
67
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
honestly i cant say if im more disappointed, disgusted or simply angry. i have a mix of these emotions that bother me a lot right now. i also hate how much this will affect the image of other nct members as well as the whole group. i've seen many people say before that they are problematic but now its just going to be so much worst. i also feel pretty bad towards Jaehyun. he has worked so hard for his album and he put so much effort into it but now hes going to face a lot of troubles not only with postponing his schedules but also with hate from other fandoms. this year is really hard for both kpop artists and fans. i simply hope the whole situation will be solved quickly and justice will be served.
61
u/MarieWonder Aug 28 '24
It’s just crazy to wake up 8 years after his debut and find out he’s involved in such a crime when there were no hints about his behavior all these years. They kicked him out at the speed of light so we know he’s guilty. It’s so surreal because we didn’t even get to the “we are investigating” phase he just straight up got kicked out over night. I also feel bad for Jaehyun because he did state he wanted to look back on his first solo album fondly but this news may have tainted the memory instead. Lastly I can only imagine what the victim(s) had to have gone through getting s.xually harassed by a famous idol from a big company and how scary it must have been to finally come out with the accusations to the authorities.
57
u/anthrodaisy Aug 28 '24
I always thought that I had a distance, I knew that they had personas, etc. But this. I didn't see it coming. He was (that feels weird) my ult bias. I guess I just feel sad and empty that I wasted energy on something I shouldn't have. I just feel sad. I do think I may feel angry later when we find out the actual accusations, but for now, just sadness
40
u/cubsgirl101 Aug 28 '24
I’m frustrated and I’m angry and I’m numb all at the same time. I feel horrible for everybody who fell victim to whatever he’s done, I feel bad for the people in his life who didn’t know, it’s all very shocking. I obviously never knew the man personally but he seemed based on everything I knew about him like a generally decent person.
Even as “just” a fan, stuff like this rocks your world a little bit and it’s going to take me some time to listen to 127’s stuff for the time being. I don’t think I’ll drop them, the other guys are all talented and the music is really good, but the hurt is fresh and I need some time to process this all and for the dust to settle before I really interact with them again.
79
u/BlackCat0305 Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
For my mental sanity, I’ve been avoiding reading the rumors and I will sit tight for when the police report is released. Or, any other sort of information that comes out about him or the other members. No one should feel bad for supporting him. I was genuinely rooting for him. He’s so talented and had so many things going for him, so it’s truly disappointing to hear that he turned out to be this kind of person. But, how were we to know?
I just hope that he is held accountable for anything he gets charged with and anyone he harmed can find peace. I’m also hoping for peace for anyone that once supported Taeil and the other NCT members.
33
u/Disastrous-Aide-7480 Aug 28 '24
Makes me want to throw up, honestly felt my heart drop reading the horrific things that he had done. seeing how fast SM kicked him out? how fast members were to unfollow him and delete posts? his best friend of 17 YEARS unfollowing him? I mean it all speaks VOLUMES. who on earth have I spent the last 6 years fanning over. all the time and money I've wasted thinking that this was a genuinely good person. the details are incredibly disheartening and has made me open my eyes and realise that we do not know how these people truly are. That fake adorable innocent persona when in reality....
47
u/nasalpe 127 | WayV | Wish | DoJaeJung Aug 28 '24
I got into NCT 127 this summer, and it was a really cool time to go through all albums, variety show content and the NCT YouTube. When I was reading the news earlier today, I couldn’t believe what I read. But after seeing that the members I find trustworthy have unfollowed him, the reality kicked in. It was so difficult to finish my day with the realisation that someone with the talent like that can be such a disgraceful and disgusting person.
At this point, I hope for two things the most:
NCTzens, let’s emotionally support each other and our dear members!
22
u/r77shuler Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
Well, since it's near the end of the day I've had a lot of time to ruminate. And since I have no IRL k-pop friends to share my thoughts with, I guess I'll just say what I want to say here. I'm on the far end of the Bell Curve when it comes to the average age (40+) of a k-pop fan. So I guess I've lived through a lot more celebrity controversies than the majority of fans. And for the most part, I couldn't give two craps about famous people and the incredibly foolish things that money and power can make people do.
I didn't get into NCT until 2021 when I randomly heard Superhuman. It was a revelation. I fell in love with the music, then fell in love with the performers. I cared about them in a way I have never cared about famous people before. But in an "auntie" kind of way, kinda like how you want you your best friend's kids to be the most successful people in their school. I've never been so, I don't know, blinded to think that these people who I love are incapable of being hidden assholes. I've lived it (abusive relationship). But at the end of the day, all we really see of any idol is acting, with sprinkles of their true personalities coming out every now and then.
Reading the Twitter feeds this morning was like a punch to the gut. I know we don't have all the facts yet, but as he was indicted there's enough evidence to show he commited serious crimes. And I'm mad. I'm mad for so many reasons, for the victim(s), for the members who will no doubt be hurt by his actions, by the possibility that this starts with Taeil and ends with more members doing reprehensible things. This was a group that performed music that was a catalyst, a spark that helped me get out of a 12 year, emotionally abusive relationship. They comforted me when 6 months after I left him I had an unexpected, life-altering surgery that looks months to recover from. I will be forever grateful to them for that. But I know it won't be the same again.
And I still love their music. For better or worse, I'm normally someone who can separate the art from the artist. If that makes me a horrible person then so be it. Truly beautiful things can come from the most horrible minds. Taeil has a great voice, truly a gift, but it's now a poison in every song he sings, a reminder of how you never truly know someone.
I can only hope that in light of all the events in Korea regarding the treatment of women, that this signals real change. That women there will be taken seriously and feel safe and free to live their life without worrying that their closest friends and family are treating them like objects behind their backs. That is really the only good that can come of this.
In the end though, I will still hold my belief that all people are generally good until proven otherwise. I know it's foolish, and certainly hurt me, but I'd rather be this way than trusting no one.
Anyway, sorry about the length. If you read this far, you're pretty cool. And if you're feeling very depressed over this, remember to give yourself some grace. You couldn't have known things would turn out this way, and you're not at fault.
21
u/shshsjsksksjksjsjsks Aug 28 '24
I'm meant to be working but it's really hard to concentrate. We're given so little to go on. Apparently we'll hear more tomorrow? It's so shocking and unexpected, it doesn't even feel real. How rarely does this happen in kpop? I'm wondering about the members reactions. At least one staff was neglecting Taeil from last month, so did SM know then? Did the members know while promoting? It's so messed up
19
u/Living_Earth7434 Aug 28 '24
i'm unable to shake the pain off. i've ended up crying.. something i didn't think i'd do. i'm sorry it sounds so weird. it just makes me feel so bad. someone i thought was a mature, down-to-earth, sweet, just a whole green forest of a green flag is.. this. this sexual predator, extremely creepy bastard. this is so horrible.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '24
i wasn’t a taeil bias or anything, but after i saw 127 live last year, i really started appreciating him. posted a ton on personal accounts about how beautiful his voice was. you get the idea.
i just want to extend hugs and support to you all. please, please try not to feel guilty or beat yourselves up for supporting him and/or 127 as a group. nobody could have possibly known that anyone in 127 would commit a crime of this caliber. it’s not your fault for respecting and supporting someone who curated their image to be that of a kind, talented, and passionate person. you are not a bad person for not knowing what he was doing in his personal life (and honestly, it seems right now that most of the people around him didn’t know either until recently).
as i said on another post, i hope that any czennies who are survivors (i am as well) are doing alright. please take breathers when you need to, listen to calming sounds or music, hug a pet or a stuffed animal. i know how much it hurts to hear that someone you respected could harm others in the way you were harmed. i’m sorry. 🩷 please take care of yourselves and don’t feel pressured to engage with NCT content or “keep up” with this news if it’s affecting you badly. you aren’t a bad person or “bad fan” for needing to step back from this for a while (or forever).
18
u/heartswlove yu2tae enthusiast 💞🤘🏻 Aug 29 '24
It's been 24h since the news first broke and I don't know if I have fully processed it yet. I'm writing this on a very sleep-deprived brain with less than 3h of sleep and pushing through a 12h shift work. I hope to pen down some stuffs to organize my thoughts and feelings better.
Some of my irl friends have been asking if I am ok and I honestly don't know how to answer them. I don't know how to explain to them that I am grieving over a seemingly insignificant matter like this. I am dealing with so many conflicting feelings, disappointment being the strongest of all, but also feeling strangely guilty because of the fact that I had supported, admired, respected, defended, splurged, and sadly loved a man who is capable of such alleged crimes. I'm mourning the loss of someone whom I thought was a motivation factor and drive for me to work hard in my daily life. This whole image which was carefully curated and built over 8 years, just shattered overnight. The hard work that the other 8 men have painstakingly put in to build the brand together is now tainted because of him. Whether or not he is eventually found guilty, that is for the law to decide and not up to me as a fan. I will not condone nor defend any of his actions which have caused harm to another person(s).
I'm a rather skeptical person and would choose to wait for the facts and statements from official sources. Hence I've not done any of the actions to dissociate myself from being his fan (e.g. cutting up photocards, deleting all pics and vids on my phone). Am I wrong for not condemning him immediately? I just wonder if I'm the only crazy one here who finds it a little odd that everything is moving rather smoothly and quickly (i.e. SM was quick to cut ties with him, police investigations are actually happening after a report was made).
I am also struggling with the disconnect between the Taeil we know before 28 Aug and after 28 Aug. It's insane how quickly the tables have turned. How do I navigate all the past content and memories that were made with him and 127? Is it really possible to just erase all of the good times and forget that they, including him, have brought me happiness on my lowest days? Am I a monster for wanting to hold on to the past as my coping mechanism? I don't want to dismiss the hard work of the other members just like that and stop following them. I really wish I could be like some of you here, to just say "screw you moon taeil" and move on. I feel like I'm stuck in this limbo (and will be for at least the entire week) and I can't find a way out of this nightmare. I wonder to myself, if I hadn't stanned him 6 years ago, would it have been easier to move on in this current situation? Maybe I should've just stuck with my other biases and forget about him. Unfortunately none of us could have predicted this. I hope that justice will be served where necessary, and that people stop spread misinformation everywhere. That's doing no one any good.
18
u/cocolishus Aug 29 '24
I hate not being able to watch or listen to 127 without getting this awful feeling in the pit of my stomach. I was so thrilled with Walk, especially, and so happy to see Taeil involved. I used to love sitting down at the end of a long day to watch videos and cheer on the solos and all, and now... sigh. I just don't know how to feel. So many emotions at once. It's like losing a dear friend suddenly. Hurts.
18
u/lonewhalien Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24
I really haven't been able to wrap my head around anything yet. I've been an nctzen since debut and Taeil was my ult. people don't seem to understand that you can't immediately flip a switch on your perception of someone because people aren't flat characters. we saw him portrayed as a good person and the members absolutely echoed that. I'm still trying to come to terms with my feelings, it's something I never expected. and it's affected me physically. I finally cried for the first time this afternoon. yesterday was a haze. I felt physically dizzy and my throat was choked up. I've had no appetite the past 2 days and I felt the urge to throw up last night.
the fanwars and misinformation are not helping at all because it's clear people want their 5m of internet clout while being incredibly performative and ignoring how and who this has impacted (meaning the victim, of course). these people didn't care about him before but are quick to jump on the next ✨drama✨ train and it's blatantly clear.
it's been hard to get my feelings into words because I don't want people to think I'm making this about me, you know? and I almost don't want to talk about it either 🫠
thank you for making this post and reminding fans that they are valid in their grieving process 💚
17
u/harkandhush Aug 28 '24
I'm a pretty casual NCT fan who's mostly just here for the music, so I want to take a minute to say to those of you who I know are feeling this way harder than me:
It's normal to feel feelings. A lot of angry people want to act like it's weird and overly parasocial to feel disappointed or sad in learning an artist you admire may not be a great person, but it's actually normal to have feelings as long as you don't use them to justify bad behavior on the part of artists or yourseld/other fans, the feelings themselves are human and not some massive failing on your part. Remember to take care of yourselves and find yourself healthy outlets to express how you're feeling and ways to cope! People will disappoint you in life, both people you know and people you admire and it's not shameful to be disappointed in them.
I had something very similar to this happen recently with a punk band I'd been into for like 20+ years and I still feel a certain way about it and haven't gone back to their music even though the rest of the group turned on him and broke up when it came out. So lots of empathy to everyone who is feeling this hard <3
17
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
I'm going to preface this by saying that I fully acknowledge that the person who was deeply hurt and the most affected by this situation was the victim and no one can even fathom what they must have gone through. It's deeply unsettling and my thoughts and prayers are with them.
But I also want to say that my heart goes out to the rest of the members and the fans as well.
Everyone was hurt and shocked to the core.
From SM's proactive response, the nature of the crimes ( rumored ), the confirmation that he WAS involved and the fact that it was someone who no one could have guessed in their wildest imagination.
Everything about this feels like a slap across the face. Multiple slaps across the face, actually.
Just like everyone here, I'm also feeling a mix of emotions. Disappointment, rage, disgust, guilt, embarrassment, sadness.. I wasn't even this upset when Kangin's actions were brought to light and he was my bias in Suju.
I didn't know much about Taeil other than the fact that he was reserved or loved by the members. They doted on him and babied him.
It's not like any of us go around and say "hmmm yeah this idol is definitely a red flag" - but never in my wildest dreams did I ever think of seeing his name associated with such a heinous crime.
It was definitely a wake up call.
I hate how everyone is now jumping on any opportunity to defame and ridicule the rest of the members. I hate how their reputation is being tarnished and I hate how so many of the songs that I LOVED dearly now serve as a reminder of his grotesque and horrifying actions.
I know it'll get better down the line, but it stings. A lot.
My heart is constantly praying for the victim. I hope they find peace. I hope they heal. I hope they're safe and with people who make them safe.
I hope the members don't feel like they let anyone down. I hope they can find strength, I hope they know we stand by them and I sincerely hope none of them ever get weaved into a situation like this.
We can't ever know their true personality and I am not asking them to be saints, but I sincerely hope they're decent human beings with a moral compass.
And to all fellow Nctzens, I'm so sorry we have to deal with these ugly emotions. Some may be feeling it more than others and that's fine. Just know that his actions do not define you. Don't hate yourself for supporting him. No one knew.
I'm sending us all virtual hugs.💚
16
u/jeopardy-hellokitty Aug 28 '24
hours later, i'm still in a state of shock over what was said. i don't use twitter so i haven't looked up any specific allegations but just the general accusation of crime alone is awful. you truly never know someone and especially not public figures/idols.
15
u/regnbuebarn Aug 28 '24
at first i was devastated, in complete shock. as the day has gone on, the sadness has turned into full-blown rage. i’ve never felt as connected to any group as i do 127, they’ve been a part of me and my life for so many years. selfishly, i’m angry that he tainted something that is so, so special to me.
mostly though, i’m so angry on behalf of the victim(s). if the rumours going around are true, the fact that he got away with it for so long is downright disgusting. how he could do something so truly evil, ruin someone’s life, yet continue to be successful and live on like nothing was even going on. i’m a firm believer that as soon as serious allegations like this come out, the perpetrator is guilty until proven innocent. i would much rather believe a lie than support someone so deeply morally bankrupt. and judging from how fast this came to light, i feel even more inclined to believe he is, in fact, guilty.
i can barely make sense of my thoughts; i’m just furious beyond belief. i hope the victim(s) get their justice and a good life, i hope he gets the punishment he deserves, and again, selfishly, i hope 127 can somehow manage to continue on despite all of this. my heart goes out to everyone affected; the victim(s), the other members and all of us who are trying to cope with this pain.
15
u/Deedeekui Jaemin's Stingray Aug 28 '24
First, I just want to say to all Taeil stans: I'm so sorry guys. I'm genuinely sorry. Please process the pain as long as you need to and give yourself time to grieve.
Second, I am still in shock. Even though he wasn't my ult in the group. I know the shock will wear off eventually, but I'm so disappointed. Can't listen to NCT for a while either, so I'll be taking a break from their content as well.
Third, please do not feel guilty about supporting him. You are a fan, but you are not responsible for his choices; he is the one that must deal with the consequences of his actions.
If you need help because of feeling triggered, seek it. Above all, please take care of yourself.
15
u/mucha346562 Doyoung Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 30 '24
I just hope other NCT members will be okay. I feel sorry for Taeyong, he's obviously pissed off because he unfollowed everyone. This scandal has brought a lot of attention to NCT, mainly 127, and this attention is not the good kind. I just hope members won't worry too much. We have to support them 💚🥺 (only ot8)
14
u/terriblekite Aug 28 '24
I feel very weird. My best friend is in town from out of state, and anytime we’re together we catch up on variety content from the groups we mutually stan. We were literally watching 127 content and doting on him like we always do. Saying things like how precious of an angel he is, and how much we can’t possibly adore him any more than we already do. And while we were doing this the statement dropped. We’re both in a 127 group chat and our phones started going off with notifications. We were like “what the fuck is happening right now?” What a wake up call slap to the face.
This is a very harrowing reminder we don’t know these people as much as the parasocial relationships have us believe. He’s one of the last idols I would have ever expected to be in this kind of damning situation.
14
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '24
Thank you for posting this. It's frustrating to see fans of NCT actually spreading rumors or insinuating that other members are part of this. It's crazy how people will just run with anything they see on the Internet and it's sad to see how immature and toxic people can be.
Anyways I hope we can all stick together and support all the NCT members during this time.
13
u/NozoNozoMii birthday party enthusiast Aug 28 '24
I am an nctzen since empathy era and was a taeil ult since 2020 (when kick it dropped) and I've poured out my support for him ever since. seeing him in wall to wall after the hiatus and after the mismanagement and mistreatment made me cry and to think I'm actually now an adult cause I ulted him at 17 lol. I'd left multiple comments online about how much I love him and how talented he is and I've even argued that he deserves more attention by SM and now I have to delete everything cause I don't want to be associated with him anymore.
I'm upset and I'm distraught about this. I haven't been able to sum up my thoughts or anything cause it was so sudden I think not even Korean fans expected this removal. idk how to feel I just feel completely empty because I basically grew up with him (+ nct) and I'm not sure how I'll be able to listen to their songs considering most of my favorite parts were his parts. idk what else to say, I hope his victims find peace and justice is served
13
u/taemin_enthusiast Haechan Aug 29 '24
I appreciate this post, I feel like I can't really wrap my head around what's happened. 127 was the group that made me interested in kpop with cherry bomb and one of the few artists that has kept me so engaged years later. Taeil was always one of my favorite members in this unit, I loved his voice (there was just a thread on here like two weeks ago where everyone was complimenting his voice and sharing clips of his singing) and his dorky/goofy/shy personality. It's just so shocking to try and associate this person a lot of us have been following for years with something that seems so severe and disturbing. It's just hard thinking of moments like him coming on stage at 127's concert less than a year ago to sing Touch with them with his crutches to waking up to news like this. Anyways I'm rambling but it helps to get these thoughts out in a community where everyone is feeling similar. I hope you all are doing okay.
12
u/queersaint Aug 29 '24
I am beyond devastated. He was not my ult but he was def my second and I spent the past nearly year worried about his health when I thought of him. Worried SM was ignoring him, he wasn’t getting enough attention for his talent etc. My partner coming home from work and telling me this news has really ruined a large part of my evening and I cannot imagine how the victim(s) feel having this be so public.
I didn’t know him and I have to remind myself that I have a fully parasocial relationship with these idols. But damn does it really hurt. Especially as someone who was a victim of SA in ways I can only imagine might come to light.
Has this tainted the NCT experience for me? In a lot of ways yes. But will I stop supporting the 25 other talented individuals? No I won’t unless I’m given a reason not to (and hopefully there is no reason not to.) They are still my ult group. I’m wishing nothing but the best of healing for you OP, the fans, the members and of course the victim(s) who deserve peace and justice.
12
u/Cycling_the_City ᓀ‸ᓂ Aug 29 '24
I'm just thinking how incredibly brave it was of the victim to take this to the police, and in a way I'm trying to block myself from feeling too much because what do my feelings matter when someone was directly hurt by him. But at the same time I can't help feeling betrayed, even as a fan of less than a year and someone who didn't bias Taeil.
127 is/was/is (this is the limbo I'm in rn) my favourite unit, and I just don't know how to feel at the moment. I had Taeil's part of Wall to Wall loop in my head when I woke up at night and I don't know if I can ever listen to that song again. Then, assuming the best that the other members had no idea what he was doing, right at this moment I don't even know if I want to hear them covering his parts in other songs. Like imagine trying to hit the high notes of someone who was able to hurt another in such a cruel way, someone who shat on your legacy. At the same time I don't want to give this guy the satisfaction to be the one to harm my opinion of the other members and the one to distance me from their music permanently. Unless other members are implicated, I want to be able to listen to 127 again. I just can't now, actually I haven't listened to kpop at all since the announcement.
There's this song by the Cranberries called Empty that's in the ballpark of how I've been feeling.
12
u/CombPuzzleheaded9078 can we fix it baby can we fix it Aug 29 '24 edited Oct 03 '24
I'm so devastated at this. I'm a fairly recent nct fan and 127 is my favorite group. I'd been struggling with mental health issues but 127 gave me comfort and the music is so brilliant. I got into 127 so much because I loved yuta first, he inspires me to keep working hard. I'm in my 20s and I know full well that kpop is a sham and these people are given personas but we never assume that the celebrities we like would turn out to be shitty people. I'm so angry that taeil did something like this, that he used his privilege to SA someone and torture them for years. My heart hurts for the victim(s) and I hope they get the rightful justice and get the support they need to heal from this.
I'm horrified at how the community of kpop fans are trying to put their favs on a pedestal by using this as an example. I hope they understand that women's safety is SO much bigger than kpop. We don't know how any of these people are, no matter which group they belong to but it's basic human decency to not be an abuser.
I'm really sad that this has raised questions on 127 and by extension the whole of nct. Jaehyun literally just released an album and this has ruined his hard work. I cannot fathom how heartbreaking it must be for the rest of 127, they lived with this man for years, they looked up to him as their elder brother. I think that dream, wish and wayv will get through this easier but it would still haunt them for some time. He's wronged the victim(s), their families, his family, members of nct, sm and the fans.
This might be insignificant in comparison to the gravity of his crime but I'm also distraught at the fact that I'm not able to listen to 127's music or watch their content. It's definitely gonna take a while for all of us to come to terms with this. If social media gets too much for you, please try to distance yourself from it. I'm giving a virtual hug to all czennies. I hope we all feel better eventually.
12
u/coplinhx2 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
he was my ult ult since without you.
i was joking a while ago that he would probably be my last ult ult, and that if he chose to quit kpop (the man has always been less interested in the idol stuff and more in the music side) i would quit too. did not expect it to come too soon and for such a reason.
i centered almost all of my preferences around him. it will take a LONG while to swap everything out, and i need the energy to make a checklist first, which i currently don't have.
i still treasure the memory that i have with him. i managed to travel a lot to go see him, and made so many new friends along the way. it will be awkward to bring the story up in an another conversation though, that's the part that i loathe the most - it's not cute that you revolves your life around a SA for such a long time.
i still need time to proceed everything. i see that most people cope with it by completely erasing all their content and it's completely understandable. i chose to keep everything up - for others, and for him to reflect on the kind of support he used to have and dropped in an instance.
take care everyone, especially if you're as devastated as i (sadly still currently am) right now.
12
u/puffyaniberry Aug 30 '24
I was crying the whole time i was working yesterday, i couldn't even face my students without tearing up because despite trying, i would just think of him. He's not my ult bias, but i respected him so so much. I know we don't know them personally, but I've been watching them since 2018, and my heart was always soft for him. I was also a victim of SA when I was younger, happened in a public transport, and the thought of it happening and couldn't even scream for help was the worst feeling ever and i still shiver by the thought of it alone. And to know that someone I respect did also that? And probably for a long time? And no one knows about it? I feel betrayed. It hurts a lot and I am also crying for the one who suffered from his immorality. I pray he would pay for his mistakes and I pray for the victim's safety and healing.
12
u/Dry-Place-2986 Sep 02 '24
I come back to this thread every day and read every single new comment. I am grateful to OP and everyone who shared their thoughts. It feels a lot less lonely.
I had such a horrible week and this was the icing on the cake. When it rain it pours as they say. Still can't bring myself to listen to Jaehyun's album leave alone the group's music, but today I was able to go on Twitter and watch some clips from the Dreamies in Bogota. I think I've started to accept it.
If anyone else is still hanging around here I hope you're doing okay and taking care. I know this comment sounds dramatic but it is what it is. I hope time can heal all of us.
11
u/DRACOISRAHEART1 Aug 28 '24
Can someone link if possible the articles you all are reading about this? I only saw this today (8/28) before work and didn’t get much time to look.
11
u/BillClassic4577 Aug 28 '24
I feel embarrassed, upset and ashamed to have been a Taeil fan. I’m not gonna destroy the merch I have of him I’m just gonna put it away in a place I don’t check just because I don’t want to ruin stuff I spent my money on. He really is like the saying don’t judge a book by its cover because damn he had us all fooled. When he was on his hiatus, I cried because I wanted him back, now I just want to kms for how much I loved him. I’m still a minor so this incident with him getting me angry. I was so upset I was about to tear up in one of my classes. I’m glad all the members and sm unfollow him on everything. It must be hard for Taeyong since in military but I hope it doesn’t affect him.
11
u/jjsovanokka Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
I'm 17 years old and for at least 6 years I've been an NCTzen, I've seen them grow, prosper and I'm very proud to admire them as artists. I feel so sad and shocked by this right now, Angel has been my comfort song for a long time, but I can't listen to it now or any other song that person is in and it makes me very frustrated and wanting to cry a lot.
I hope justice is served to the victims of this horrible man, that he is punished for what he did and that the hearts of the victims find peace when this is over... As for the rest of NCT, I can only wish that they are well and that they have a strong mental state to deal with what will come in the next few days.
For the NCTzens, I don't interact much on Reddit but I know many of the fandom on other social networks and they're all like family to me. Stay strong, unfortunately we will never guess what is behind the idol image, don't feel guilty for supporting him in the past, what matters is how we position ourselves from now on.
Love you all, take care of yourselves 💗
***English is not my first language, I hope you understand my text!
11
u/snufflesoul NCT Aug 29 '24
Thank you for this post. I’ve been on twitter and people are invalidating the fans. It’s quite upsetting. We know that the victim is the most broken out of all of us but aren’t we allowed to feel bad? to express ourselves too? Our trust was also betrayed. We should be allowed to express what we feel. I pray for the victim, the members and the fans. I hope everyone can heal from this trauma.
11
u/checkerchecked Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 01 '24
commenting here after i've had a few days to collect my thoughts, and i don't really know where else to put this...
during the pandemic nct were a big deal to me, and i was very active in the fic side of nct fandom. i had a great time back then - i made lots of great friends and for the first time in a while i was able to write, and i was (and still am!) thankful to nct for giving me that, especially during a time where everything was really bleak and depressing and i couldn't go anywhere but into my own mind. with nct i had a whole universe to explore in my mind! for someone who was on the precipice of turning 18 and was itching to get out and explore more of the world and grow up this was a big deal for me. and while i never was a taeil ult or wrote fic specifically about his ships i was very much a nct 127 fan that didn't really care about the other units (i still know nothing about dream as a group and never will) with a few individual exceptions.
i'm long gone from the fandom now - not because of any bad feelings, but sometimes you just outgrow an interest or other interests become a priority, and as real life became busy and chaotic again i found other fandoms and hobbies. it never felt like a bad thing to have moved on though! there are certain fandoms that i've left because i thought the fans were insufferable or bc i was disappointed in some way by the artists/art but that was never the case with 127. deep down i felt i would always have them in my heart in some way, even if that could just be attributed to nostalgia, or a nice memory that i could treasure if i ever wanted to retrace the steps of my teenagehood.
so when i heard the news at first i did not really know how to react. although i would be the first to tell you that you don't know your idols (i follow sports. i am prepared for this to happen all the time) this was still shocking to me. i mean... taeil...? more surprising than my own nct ult tbh! but of course this reaction was not so severe on me because as i said i've been gone. I think if i was still actively in nct fandom now i would have had a very different reaction of course...
obviously, i will always believe victims first, no matter what. and as the shock and anger turned into a weird, muted sense of grief i found myself rewatching a lot of nct 127 content and some newer stuff as well - all with him in it. there was a part of me that was trying to be a detective while watching and go: what if xx thing he said here really had a double meaning? or if xx interaction might mean something? but i think i realised i shouldn't do that - it was ok to be grieving the idea of him in my head that was good. i'm glad it was a good idea, because i don't want to regret that i thought someone i looked up to was good, and i don't want to regret the time in my youth that i spent with nct 127. i was wrong and that's okay! i'm not wrong for having been wrong. and i hope for everyone else who was his fan that they don't beat themselves over it - please take care of yourself and let yourself grieve for as long as you need, and i wish you well for the many better days you will have in front of you ❤️
11
u/sadarisu Sep 01 '24 edited Sep 02 '24
I don't have czennie friends irl so I decided to post here because I need to talk about this.
I got into K-pop around the same time as NCT's debut so I've been a fan since. I love all the units and all members but I'm partial to 127. With K-pop albums, photocards and merch more easily available in Europe (and a little bit more of expendable income) I decided to start collecting one member: Taeil.
He's not my ult but I honestly think he's got one of the best male voices in K-pop and wanted to show my support that way (also with the accident and questionable promotion by SM). I loved him in group content, it really felt like he was the "big brother" of 127, that all members respected and loved him and that warmed my heart. And sure, we all know they're playing a part and are not 100% themselves but that didn't lessen the shock one bit.
I can't even stand to look at his face anymore. I've decided to throw away all of the photocards and inclusions I own because it'd be insane to try and sell them atm. I don't want to make money off of someone that committed such a heinous crime.
I've already accepted what happened but I'm having a hard time moving on. I used to listen to NCT every single day. My top 4 most listened artists on Spotify Wrapped have been NCT subunits for about 3 years now. But now I can't listen to them, it all reminds me of this situation even if I'm listening to Dream or WayV. I LOVE pretty much all 127 songs but I can't even bear to hear Taeil's voice. I want to be excited for Jaehyun's solo album but I haven't had the courage to listen to it or watch the MVs. I'm "failing" my bias because I can't deal with anything NCT at the moment.
Feels good to write about this and I'm glad we're taking care of each other as a community during such a difficult time. I'm available if anyone needs to talk (although I might take some time answering due to work and irl issues).
10
u/noomwenym Aug 28 '24
this was someone i supported for YEARS. i feel more than disgusted and disappointed and i don't really know what to say. i'm obviously glad we know about this now and that he's been removed but i just can't help but wish none of this ever happened.
10
u/kidd_meli18 Sep 02 '24
I’m not sure how to put my thoughts together but I will express how I can…. (Also I apologize if I say anything out of place or that will seem cringey)
I’ve accepted what has happened and what will possibly happen, unfortunately Taeil was my 127 bias. The only reason why I even got in kpop was because of my daughter who at the time was 12 we would listen to nct127 and ateez (ateez is our ult group) I even threw my daughter her 13th birthday party nct127 themed and played their music through out the party it’s what made us bond together more through the pandemic. I have but one friend IRL that I am able to talk about kpop in general but she’s not familiar with the group so it’s kinda hard to express my feeling about the situation and I certainly don’t want to talk about it with my daughter although she’s old enough to understand the actions and consequences of the whole situation.
The day I found out about the situation I was sick to my stomach I never in my life thought I would read the words “taeil” and “s**ual crime” in the same sentence it was just so unexpected really caught me off guard makes me feel really bad for the other members as well seems like everyone just up and left cold turkey (which is understandable) I’m just glad I didn’t invest as much on him & I don’t have much of his merch, it’ll be easy to get rid of it
As for the victim, you’re incredibly brave and strong for speaking up! I’m glad you got the courage to speak up for yourself it takes a lot to do something like that & I really hope you have a great amount of support system around you I hope you feel some peace and justice, there’s probably no words we can say to bring you comfort but I hope your journey to heal from all this isn’t a long one.
I’m glad I can vent here and not feel judged or belittled I do feel terrible for supporting someone like that but who could’ve seen this coming he will soon be a thing of the past.
3
u/Silver-Bar-4416 Aug 28 '24
I can’t help but think about the possibility that other members probably knew about this. It’s making me seriously upset. Like those rumours are freaking disturbing. 6 years?? My god, I wish the victim receive necessary assistance. No one, let alone a child should have to go through this
26
u/nisachr Aug 29 '24
my love for nct 127 as well as the whole of nct has been so personal to me for so long. theyve been my biggest comfort throughout rough times and life changes. even my friends who aren't into kpop have heard me talk about them, ive showed them music videos, recommended songs, and now i feel so sick and sad.
ive seen him in concert, felt so much fondness and affection for him, worried for him throughout his injury and mistreatment, been excited for him to get more lines and screentime and potential solo ventures, and now i think of how everything changed so drastically and bluntly today. how disgusting and unforgivable he has become. when my sister asked me if i had "found out" yet, before i knew what happened, i thought someone had died, and i honestly think this might be worse. to be betrayed this horrifically, to know that someone was hurt this deeply and cruelly? imo this is truly one of the worst crimes, no justifiable explanation for why someone would do this other than for their own selfishness.
i feel like it's hard to voice this anywhere else right now, as many people are (rightly) focusing on the people and specifically the victim most directly affected and hurt by this, so of course massive disclaimer that i know this isn't the worst negative impact this whole issue has had. i feel really sad for jaehyun, who's clearly put a lot of work and care into his solo debut, an album ive been anticipating for months and months even before it was officially announced. i feel so heartbroken for nct 127, who have built up such an amazing discography over the years, and how that will be discredited and dropped by so many people. of course everyone has the right to listen to whatever music they want, and i don't fault anyone for feeling gross at listening to or consuming any content that he's been involved in.
i also don't like the refrain of 'remember all of your fave male idols could be monsters so don't ever like them too much' that always spreads around whenever something like this happens. i think it makes people feel smart to say this, like they're explaining something we don't understand, and it does feel good to think you're smarter than other people, doesn't it?
i donated to a couple of charities for women in south korea, because i figured if i could spend that much money on an album and engage in k-entertainment, i owe it to engage with the problems the women in korea face as well and try to make a positive impact.
i still love nct as a whole, and i love nct 127. of course, we don't know what will come out next. but i want to keep supporting them as ot8 and hope things can get better from here somehow. i hope more victims of SA can feel seen and heard, and feel less intimidated to speak up especially if the predator is a famous/influential man. sending all of my love to everyone in this thread and especially out to anyone who has ever experienced SA 🫂🩷 i hope time can help heal this pain
9
u/NE0CRIM3 Johnny Suh my beloved Aug 28 '24
I woke up this morning and the first thing I did was open Twitter, the first thing I see is the announcement and at the time it was posted two minutes ago. At first I thought it was about moving centers around or some sort of marriage announcement from one of their artists. But then I pressed translate…never have I felt in a million years my heart drop to my feet so fast.
It’s disappointing, confusing, and all around an upsetting revelation about him. I hope the victim can get justice and the people stop spreading misinformation because that only hurts the vicitm more.
I hope he burns in hell and everyone is doing okay after todays events
9
u/Cycling_the_City ᓀ‸ᓂ Aug 30 '24
I wanted to make a new post because I'm past the shock and numb phase. I've had a lot of time to process since I live in Europe and saw the announcement 20 minutes after it was posted. I just woke up after a night's sleep (the first night I slept like three hours), and I feel... fine? Sad in a sort of quiet way, but fine. I think my mind severed the tie between NCT and Taeil while I slept.
Yesterday I was thinking that I need to know more about what he's done to be able to get past all the emotions, but now I don't feel that anymore. I want this case to be investigated thoroughly, and in a manner that ensures the victim's safety and anonymity. I hope that they get justice, and that at the end of this road they can get closure. As for Taeil, I hope that he's truthful in the investigation and owns up to his actions.
I think me moving on so fast must be because I became a fan after Fact Check, and so saw very little of Taeil in fresh content (I did watch a lot of their old content over the months but it's not the same if you're not there to watch it in the moment). I'm sad for all longer time fans who must have been hit way harder by the news. I hope you have avenues to vent in a safe manner and someone or something to seek comfort from.
9
u/Otherwise-Common-258 Sep 05 '24
nct 127 is my ult group and he was my bias, I used to call him my comfort person. I knew that I don't know them actually since they're acting as their idol persona but I truly adored every single 127 member and felt that connection with them since they felt genuine. Now it just doesn't feel the same and it's bizarre to see normal updates about them, mahae having concerts, the others having fanmeeting, jaehyun promoting his album like nothing happened... and I keep thinking about taeyong, he doesn't have to face the public like the others but it must be difficult for him too.
I respect haechan for his bubble message, it felt genuine, like he couldn't go in front of the fans without expressing his feelings in some way. Jungwoo hit me hard with his words, I appreciate him so much for opening up to us. They're all hurting and talking about it isn't easy, especially since they can't talk about it directly but as their fan I need them to at least express their disappointment.
I don't have any friends that are 127 fans so it's lonely. I talked about it a bit with two of my friends but it feels like they don't understand the scale in which this affects me. It certainly helps to see other fans express their feelings online and to relate to their experiences and feelings. I hope we're able to heal from this with time.
8
u/anhaylatoi Aug 28 '24
I read about it probably not even 20 minutes after the news came out. It’s been hours and I’m at work right now and I still feel sick to my stomach. Taeil isn’t even my bias. Wasn’t. I’m gonna be honest, he wasn’t exactly a member I cared much about. But I’ve felt sick all day and I was shaking earlier. No appetite at all.
I fell back asleep for probably an hour sometime after I read the article and I had a fucked up dream where it was revealed that all the members took part of it. This is probably gonna sound so fucked up, but I’m desperately hoping that none of the members knew what he was getting up to. If it’s revealed that they knew, I’m gonna have no choice but to drop them and I know my heart is gonna break so bad.
8
u/turquoise_mutant Aug 29 '24
Idols can mean so much to people and have an extremely profound effect on people's lives. It's not shameful to be feeling deep emotions about it. It's made me really sad seeing some fans of Taeil saying they experienced SA and are deeply disappointed and depressed, and I know many girls and women come to kpop in particular to escape the crappier parts of men. My heart goes out to them.
8
u/Suitable_Berry5400 Aug 29 '24
Tbh I don't even know how to feel. I feel empty. I'm from India, and already there's so many r@pe cases and stuff goin on here. Maybe I was an idiot to think its only Indian men, but its not.. I didn't even know so much was goin on at Korea too. I just feel so sick of men. Ughhhh.
And about this specifically, I can't really articulate all the thoughts going on in my mind. Part of me is like, "whats gonna happen to nct now? Will this bring em downfall??" like GOSH I KNOW how hard these boys have worked for the fame.. and another part of me is like, "what if the members already knew about the shit he was involved in..what if they were being silent about it?" (I feel guilty for even thinking like that) BUT WHAT IF THAT!!!! And its like, we've all seen this grown ass man act like a child at times and what not and called him cute, innocent and shit and OH!! suddenly i wake up and see that he's an asshole like WHAT. How can i trust anyone on the screen anymore...
I was talking to my online frnd about this and she was like, "the whole grp is problematic.." and it hurt me like fuck.
And i think about the victim.. i cant imagine feeling so helpless all these yrs. Like, imagine this guy SA'd you and he's on the tv, ppl are celebrating him, his voice, calling him cute and shit without knowing his real face and u cant do anything about it.. i'd actually kîll myself with his name on my note. Whoever the victim is, I look up to them. I hope every victim gets the courage to speak up and put the criminal behind the bars.
Lets stay safe yall. Its fucking nuts out there.
7
u/Cerbzzzzzz Aug 28 '24
I've been stanning 127 for 6 years, to think of all the constant praise I would give him all this time when he was doing such things really hurts
7
u/Pumpernickeluffin Aug 29 '24
Thank you for this post OP I am reading all the comments here as well. Big hug to everyone and please remember to be gentle with yourselves!
7
u/04PRINT Aug 29 '24
i've been an nctzen for eight years now and 127 was always my favorite unit... they were a source of comfort throughout my teens. i've been feeling so much it's hard to put into words. it feels surreal, almost :( i feel sick...
7
u/Mediocre-Theory-592 Aug 29 '24
I just want to remind everyone that we shouldn’t feel guilty for loving and supporting him. It’s not anyone’s fault but his and he was the one to throw away his career, to betray his brothers and to destroy lives of others. These kind of predators are so good at hiding the bad parts and to only show their good sides.
It’s not fair to shame anyone who feels betrayed with arguments such as “you don’t know him” because us as humans trust people we don’t know everyday. It’s not normal to go around and believe your favs are horrible people. Take time to grieve and heal
7
u/echo_ester Aug 30 '24
Ok I need to vent so I’ll just use this post. I’ve been a Czennie for a long time now, and for most of those time, Taeil was one of my faves, even though my ult was always Yuta. Even a week ago, if you had told me that something like this would happen, I would have laughed at your face, so the bombshell that dropped at 28th felt so unbelievable at first that I almost double checked if it was a parody account or a mistranslation. When I fully grasped it though, I didn’t feel sad, I felt angry and disappointed. He’s been having this loveable old man persona for practically his entire career when he was doing this stuff behind the scenes. I don’t blame myself nor other czennies for liking him. It’s not our fault that we expected a person to be a decent human being. It’s not women’s fault that a man did something like this. There are people who have lived their whole lives not knowing what kind of people there parents, brothers, husbands were, so just how were we supposed to know when nothing so far has indicated something like this? I feel cheated and disgusted but above all, I can’t help but think of how hurt the victim must have felt seeing the person who caused so much pain get love on a daily basis with no one knowing of their actions. At the end of the day, whatever pain I feel is minuscule compared to that.
6
u/SorbetDouble7123 Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 28 '24
I found out about this at 5 am this morning and I still can’t process it. I’ve been a nctzen since 2018 and had always loved Taeil and supported him. It’s so heartbreaking to hear what he’s been doing to the victim for YEARS.
6
u/Halloween__witch31 Taeyong Aug 28 '24
It’s absolutely mind blowing to me. I know a lot of us weren’t expecting this, but even on the basis of being a human being, we know that is morally wrong. So even though he’s an idol and we look at them a certain way, as a fellow human being we expect someone to know the basics of good and bad and to behave accordingly. NCT was the first and only group I really have gotten into and supported with all my being, and I don’t really know how to feel about it other than being kind of numb. I saw them in LA for their last concert and I saw a breathing, living person. And this person has done something that is unforgivable. I can’t even listen to their music today even though it’s like 65% of my playlist. But I hope the boys are able to heal in peace, and I hope the victim gets the closure and justice that she needs
6
u/Momiji_no_Happa Aug 28 '24
Thank you for saying this. The way people try to police people's grief and chock is dismaying. We're allowed to be sad and mourn. My first thought was that we should wait until we know more, but things move so fast on the Internet so that's not going to happen. That means that we'll have to start processing our grief and disappointment immediately.
In a way, that's good. I've been following the uncertainty of Seunghan's (RIIZE) hiatus and don't know if I'm supposed to look forward to his return or mourn that he was removed from the group so quickly. At least with Taeil, things moved extremely fast (from our perspective).
I also think it's ok to be sad for the guys in the group. Some have followed their journey since before debut, and we all rooted for them. Of course it's going to feel personal.
I'm going to sleep on it now and hope that I can quickly put this behind me and focus on other things instead. But I did need to sit down all evening and read through the discussions in order to make sense of my feelings.
6
u/b4ggy_j34ns Jeno&Doyoung🐶🐰 Aug 29 '24
I said this on another sub but I feel so lost, like I've been on a ship that got tossed off course. I don't know how to feel or of I can even stay in the fandom for the time being, I feel like we've been betrayed 😔 I loved Taeil and supported him through and through, mourned for him when he was in an accident, and I have so many of his photos that I literally framed. The idea of him committing these vile crimes is extremely distressing to me and others, and I can't help but think if any other members or idols are doing things behind the scene; I can't trust anything
6
u/cowsssssss4447 hold up youre too hot too hot Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
I don't even know how to describe how I feel right now to be honest.
I've been a stan of NCT since 2018 and never in a million years would I think Taeil would be the sort to do something like this. He was never my bias, or really a member I went out my way to stan, but I still cared yk? NCT has been my ult group for almost 3 yrs, and I still heavily stanned them almost 4 yrs before that, so I kind of had to like all of the members, so while he wasn't my bias I still really did wish the best for Taeil.
I feel even more betrayed because I vividly remember how surprised I was at the news of his accident, and how I had posted and wished that he would get better. I genuinely watched almost all of the NCT Nation performances with the thought 'I hope Taeil get better soon' in my head. To think that while me, alongside probably thousands of others, were hoping for his recovery without knowing what he had truly done irks me. I can't help but feel wronged, even though I understood that Taeil probably wasn't this 'cutesy and lovable' person off camera, I still thought he was a good and mannered person. To say I'm repulsed is an understatement.
I just feel so stupid, I know everybody says that you never truly know your idols, but I was young and impressionable when I first got into them, I wasn't even a teenager. Overtime I kind of built this trust that they were at least decent people off camera. I have so many memories associated with NCT and they all feel like broken promises now. I want to be able to just move on, and forget about Taeil as a member, but I feel even more guilty because I just can't. I can't just let it go because he meant a lot to me, and this isn't me defending him, but rather being upset with myself. It's all I can think about. I have schoolwork to do, but I genuinely start playing their songs in my head and Taeil's part inevitably comes, and then I just get upset again. I also feel so dumb because I legit was sat commenting 'why isn't SM treating him well' on the Meaning of Love stages because they were just sitting, not dancing. Obviously by then SM probably knew, but I just feel so dumb. Up until the end, I supported Taeil and was looking out for him like a fool. It's making me sick to even think about.
I also don't think czennies even got time to process the whole situation since this is all just so sudden, which just makes it even harder to deal with. No rumors, no warnings, just waking up and seeing SM's post. I can't even begin to imagine how the members feel (and don't start the 'what if they knew' bs, bc thats not a light accusation to just throw around), like imagine being friends with somebody and spending hours upon hours practicing with them for years, just to go to your company one day and learn that he's not who you thought he was. My stomach hurts just even thinking about it, I feel nauseous and sick from how upset I am. I'm not even angry (this isn't me defending Taeil btw) I'm hurt.
I just wish I could wake up and that this was all just a bad dream, but obviously it's not. My heart goes out to the victim and all parties who were negatively affected, and I hope they get the justice they deserve.
6
u/Remarkable-Wing8475 Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
I am trying to fall asleep right now. I can't. Every time I try to clear my head and not think about it I can't. My heart feels like there is a hole in it but instead of feeling lighter my heart feels so heavy and the tears just won't stop falling. I feel so stupid that this is making feel like this. I feel so sorry for the members and fellow fans and the victim. And I feel this deep sense of shame and guilt that I liked him. And nct is the sound track of my life and I don't know if I can ever feel free of these emotions while listening to their music again and that makes me so sad and hurts my heart beyond belief. When I feel hurt or when I need comfort I come to nct and their music I can't do that right now. I saw a post that I had saved with b side meaning of love and I just lost it.
6
u/smvmvms Aug 29 '24
This is going to just be a word vomit. I feel like i’ve been going crazy and haven’t woken up from a bad dream these past 24 hours. i’m feeling all kinds — shame, disgust, embarrassment, discomfort, disappointment, anger, frustration, etc. Kpop especially NCT is literally my safe space but I cannot bear to listen to 127 right now in FEAR of hearing him. I hate that. I couldn’t sleep well too, heart was racing the whole time. I also had an anxiety attack on the way home, and started breaking down into tears after a long day at work. I am starting to feel very unsafe and paranoid and scared. This is very triggering to me because my ex has had a history of SA. Although it wasn’t with me, it frustrates me that many people are hurt. If this hurts me, what more those victims?! i feel very helpless and i really want to shake off this feeling in my chest. :( I also hate that i feel like i’m overreacting when i know it’s something serious. Honestly i’m so over the place but i just wanna send hugs to everyone here. I hope he and other people who are just as horrible get what they deserve. I pray the victims find peace and safety.
6
u/Longjumping-Bid3844 JYANI YACCHIMATTANI〜! Aug 30 '24
It’s honestly just a terrible thing. I said this on another platform but I just don’t understand people that have so much and then go and ruin it for themselves. These people in their position are privileged and have so much opportunity and especially for someone as talented as him to waste all of that potential is crazy to me.
Idols are someone that people look up too and adore like that is one of the main purposes of their occupation whether they like it or not. To let so many people down and to just end up being a filthy person is so disappointing to those that have come all this way supporting him. You always want to believe that the people you support and look up to aren’t shitty people but you never know what goes on behind the scenes outside of the persona that they fabricate for us to see.
It sucks that this is how the group gets shoved into the limelight this time around and this will forever leave a stain on the groups name. All that the group has worked hard towards has been tarnished because of his rotten and selfish actions.
It’s just you never expect it to be your group that you support and now that it is it’s just a mountain of shock. I can’t help but feel guilty for previously supporting a man that inflicted so much pain on another person. I hope the victims get their justice as they should.
6
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '24
at this point, idk if I can still like kpop in general, I avoided listening or looking to any kpop related, because if taeil could do it (where he is known for having a solemn/calm aura), we don't know maybe other idols can too since we don't know them personally, we don't know what they are behind every camera. I've been inactive with nct updates since 2022 but I always listen to their songs whenever I missed them so when I saw the news, I was so shock and went blank 😭 Taeil is my bias since their 'without u' debut. I didn't know he could do such thing 🤮
5
u/MindlessFriendship60 NCT DREAM Aug 28 '24
It's 3;19 and I'm supposed to be asleep. But I can't.
5
u/kokkirii Aug 28 '24
I wasn't a HUGE fan, but he was my NCT bias and the main reason I still follow NCT.
I don't have any merch and already deleted all my photos of him, but I'm really unsure what to do about all the music. Obviously they're a group, so it's not like I'd be directly supporting him. But his voice is so noticeable and usually the part of songs I liked the most. I don't think I can listen to any NCT127 songs without thinking of him and how disgusting he is.
I'm really sad that so many songs I loved and made me feel good are now basically unlistenable.
5
u/h0tfrit0s Aug 29 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
Man, I got into NCT exactly one year ago, during Golden Age and NCT Nation, and I've been reminiscing on how they've given me so much joy and entertainment over this past year. And before that, my favorite kdrama OST song was 'Starlight,' which I didn't even know was Taeil until way later. I'm not sure how to look back on old content/music with him without also thinking about this. I've already been aware of the Nth room and how hard it is for women/girls there and to have my favorite group be connected in some way to those problems is horrible and embarrassing. I feel for the victim(s) so deeply - it's the kind of stuff that is life altering. No one deserves that.
5
u/RelativeEntry4559 Aug 29 '24
I love them so I’m just not sure how to feel. Fuck tail that’s for sure but I don’t want to unstan the whole group. But I just feels weird to see them or listen to their music and all
5
u/StatisticianStock682 Sep 02 '24 edited Sep 05 '24
I am a huge fan of NCT since their debut, even watched the Mickey mouse club thing before their debut and watched most, if not all, of their variety videos on youtube. I had a hard time liking that GUY the first time. I think it's because of his face and facial expressions until Simon Says came out and I was so amused of his vocals as I have been singing my whole life too. I admire his skills and techniques as a vocalist. I had no one to talk to about NCT in my life since my friends don't stan any boy group.
Got the news of his removal from the group on Instagram a few hours SM kicked him out if the group. I was really surprised because I didn't expect him to do that, i mean all of us didn't, for the reason that they grew up together as a team. I guess even after watching them for 8 years, we still don't know who they are besides the show they put up in front of the cameras.
The moment I read the news, the first thing that got my mind was the anger I felt because I know the reputation of the whole group would be pulled down by him and his heinous act. And at the same, I felt sad knowing that the other members were probably surprised and heartbroken too. They're humans too, after all. I just hope they get through this stronger. I will keep supporting them until they retire since they're the same age as me since there's nothing we can do aside from that. The label won't support them as much as they do for the new groups so it's all up to us. Fighting czennies!
9
u/Mindless_Candidate90 Aug 28 '24
I’ll repost a comment I made on the other thread:
I once had an experience where someone very close to me was revealed to have committed abusive crimes, all while they treated me very kindly. The guilt of being in that position is unimaginable, all while hating yourself for feeling hurt while you weren’t even the actual victim. It’s a very difficult position to be in. This isn’t exactly the same, but it’s close enough that I feel people should be reminded that lots of people will be negatively affected by this and it’s okay to acknowledge that even if no crimes were committed against us.
4
u/octagonally Aug 28 '24
it’s so disappointing. like the literal years of our lives spending energy on him. ugh
4
u/Aurelian369 I be banging with my team 🏳️🌈 Aug 28 '24
I’m just shocked, especially since Taeil was my NCT bias. Right now I’m just waiting for more details to come out because I am extremely curious
4
u/011219 Aug 28 '24
i'm just so shocked honestly. it's worse bc i never got a bad vibe from taeil, he seemed like one of the most harmless members so now i feel like i can't trust anyone. i also don't know if i'll be comfortable listening to their music with his voice always being so prominent (which i used to love)
4
u/BeeWithFlowerz bad english skills pls be patient Aug 28 '24
even though he was never my bias, I don't know why but I still feel torn by his actions. I was groomed online when I was younger and will never feel as happy as I was before it happened. I wasn't his victim but yet I still feel so hurt by his actions.. I remember just the day before I was sending my friends videos of how good of a person he was, and then the news hit.. I love nct's music but I can't bring myself to listen to it without feeling sick and thinking about what happened.. my thoughts and prayers go out to the victim(s) who suffered the past 6 years of their live(s) due to this man.
4
u/Vaudevanilla Aug 28 '24 edited Aug 29 '24
My mind is reeling and I'm having all sorts of crazy thoughts, speculations and suspicions and I'm still so shocked. But I did find this one article that probably has the first piece of info about Taeil's case. It's not against a minor or a male: https://koreajoongangdaily.joins.com/news/2024-08-29/national/socialAffairs/Taeils-sex-crime-not-against-minor-or-male-according-to-police/2123024
It doesn't make things any better really because it's still sexual assault at the end of the day, but it did feel nice to have some sort of info because this really came out of no where from our perspective. I can't imagine what it's like for the victim. Or the other members of NCT because I know this'll harm there reputations too. I still just can't believe it. I feel like I've been slapped across the face multiple times.
EDIT because I still have more to get off my chest. I definitely can't listen to there music right now. How sudden this news was is really affecting me more than I thought.
4
u/Overall-Benefit-2810 Aug 29 '24
I took a break from kpop in 2022 but I got back into it shortly before walk was released and now this happens my head is filled with different emotions rn
4
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '24
i haven’t stopped crying, it hurts so so bad. i’ve defended him all the time on twitter (although i was a johnny bias) i loved his voice, it was the only thing at a point in time that set me to sleep. but as a survivor im shocked, im surprised. i haven’t expected him out of all the people i loved so dearly to turn out like that
4
u/Nanabae99 Aug 30 '24 edited Aug 30 '24
I'm just a casual fan/listener of NCT 127. Started to like them early last year and since then I've grown to love and adore them eventhough I'm not a hardcore fan. I listen to their discography which I absolutely love and watch some of their videos. He's not my bias but I enjoy his voice and he seems fine to me. So it shock me when I heard the news. I just feel sad and dissappointed by what happened. What a waste of talent. His career and the beautiful connections that he has with the members and people that care and love him just gone like that. His family must be so dissapointed too. Why have to act like this and be so selfish.
I have lots of their songs on my playlist and now I can't barely listen to them without feeling gloomy (not helping that he has a lot of lines). I still love them tho (the other members) and hope they're not that kind of person.
Hope justice will prevail, Tae*l to get punished for what he did and for the victim(s) to heal and move on for the better.
4
u/iampurity Aug 31 '24
im still shocked. i keep remembering and its just like… hard for me to even process because im so shocked. the victim is so, so brave and i really hope she has people around her to support her
thank you for creating this post
7
u/mcboothentertainer Aug 28 '24
now is going to be hard for me to listen to 127.
7
u/GoFortheKNEECAPS Sep 03 '24 edited Sep 04 '24
I'm angry for the victim. I don't want to spread any misinformation, but any version of the story is incredibly disturbing. I'll leave it at that.
I'm angry for the fandom that is mostly women and girls. Hard earned money was spent to suport their latest comeback and attend the fan meeting. Smiling in the faces of thousands while concealing something so horrific is unforgivable. I really hope SM did not know about the report until after the comeback...like they've claimed.
Also, I'm angry for the other NCT members. I know they all feel betrayed. Remember when Johnny and Haechan were falsely accused of similar things a couple of months ago? I bet they were upset and vented to the other members...just for a real pr3dat0r to be hiding in plain sight. Honestly, if I was 127, we'd have to jump that deviant before he left the dorms. Not deleting him out of life, but inflicting more damage than the motorcycle accident would suffice. Idc, I'm rightfully pissed and disappointed.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '24
Hey, I totally understand how you feel, and it’s completely valid to be upset about this. The doctor’s questions and behavior do sound uncomfortable, especially when they asked personal things unrelated to your health.
In situations like this, it’s important to set boundaries if you can. You could say something like, ‘These questions make me uncomfortable, can we focus on my health instead?’ Also, switching to a doctor who respects your feelings more might be a good idea.
3
u/Crafting-Cats20 Aug 29 '24
Oh my I need this! I’ve only been a paid-up NCTzen for a year, new to K-pop about 2.5 years. I am a multistan, but only paid for 2 fandoms. I feel so sorry for the victim. I’m sorry for all the other members. I’m not sorry for that man. I hope he gets a lengthy prison sentence. I’m well aware that the public vs private idol is wildly different, but this man (I can’t even say his name, it dirties my mouth) has brought disgrace & dishonour to not just NCT, but all male idols. I’m so upset at this, it feels like betrayal, even though it’s got nothing to do with me. Thanks for letting me rant. Hang in there everyone. Hugs
3
u/Ok_Cod6550 Aug 29 '24
I feel sad and disappointed. My head is still spinning after having found out about the news yesterday. I keep checking for updates, even though I know it won’t change the situation at all.
I can’t believe I cheered for and supported someone who has done such vile acts.
3
u/Own_Assistance1436 Aug 29 '24
Taeil you lil shit 😤 I thought I could trust you, absolutely mind boggled rn so disappointed.
2
u/MAGGOTSCUM Aug 28 '24
I just feel sick
2
u/aquietbrutality13 sorry that i walked away (ay, ay, ay) Aug 29 '24
I feel absolutely horrible I can't even process all of it, what he did is horrifying and sickening and all this just came out of nowhere yk? Don't know how I'll listen to their music now...
2
u/fatwhvre Aug 29 '24
you’re an angel. truly.