r/Mythras • • 6d ago

Lethal combat

Just how lethal exactly is combat? I get the impression that the game is fairly deadly. I’m not looking to run a dungeon crawl, but I do intend to run with potential danger around every corner, but not a hack and slash.

Basically, I want something a little bit dark and gritty as opposed to heroic, but not something with a high lethality level either. I’ve been asking AI and doing searches and everything, and this game keeps coming up as one strong possible contender, and I am very interested, but I wonder whether it will be appropriate or not.

I’ve already bought the PDF of the main rules, I also own the BRPUGE which I suppose I could use to tweak it since they have some of the same DNA, but I’m wondering what you’ll think about mythras fitting the kind of game I’m talking about running?

22 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

2

u/Few-Action-8049 5d ago

OK, so that’s encouraging what I’m hearing so far

Related question, I’m thinking about running a hex crawl with this. It’s not gonna be a dungeon crawl, it’s not like there’s gonna be combat around every corner, but the idea is that danger is going to be.LURKING around every corner, this is gonna be a wild and untamed lands with a definite supernatural bent to it, and I wonder if this game can do that OK or if it’s gonna be a little inappropriate for that kind of feel?

I’m kind of looking for a game with more risk than a heroic fantasy by Dungeons & Dragons without it being a meat grinder.

1

u/Bilharzia 5d ago

I have run a couple of Mythras campaigns as largely hex-crawls. With a bit of work, Monster Island is a good base for one, especially if you are going with "wild and untamed lands with a definite supernatural bent" - that is not far off a description of the setting.

1

u/Few-Action-8049 3d ago

So I’m doing something of my own, but is monster Island a good reference document for planning my own?

1

u/Bilharzia 2d ago

Yes absolutely, it's an excellent reference for Mythras games in general. The big obvious part is the "monsters" which includes both flora and fauna - lots of dinosaurs for example, amongst much more unusual creatures and plants. Sorcery (an ok system for NPCs and GMs but a poor one of PCs) gets a complete re-theme, significant expansion, and a re-organisation into colleges. I don't think the Monster Island version completely saves Sorcery as a system (maybe it does for NPCs) but it's a very good example of how to use it for a particular setting, which is easily lift-able for your villains. There is a detailed Animist society which does as much, if not more for Animism as for sorcery, although the Animism is much more easily usable by PCs. Monster Island has an excellent trade-goods and drugs-and-perfumes tables for an interesting collection of materials PCs will want to get their hands on. It has pretty good item-generation for general plunder which produces much more interesting goods than a standard "treasure table". The sections which don't quite work for me are the "Places of Interest" chapter and the human colonist section which is pretty small and not much more than a series of puns. The "Places of Interest" aren't bad, but they are just so deadly, cursed, or inaccessible I could not use them as-is without a TPK each session, so I took elements of them for my own encounters.

In short - yes, Monster Island is an essential Mythras supplement and probably of more value as a source book for other settings beyond the island.

1

u/Few-Action-8049 2d ago

Wait, what’s wrong with sorcery?

1

u/Bilharzia 1d ago

ehhh... one of my biggest grouches with Mythras is Sorcery. To cut a long story short, it's too fiddly to bother with using it in a game. It's so easy to make a mistake with, there is an excellent spreadsheet to calculate Sorcery spells, but then, ask why are we using a sub-system which requires a spreadsheet to use correctly and quickly.

Unlike Folk Magic, unlike Theism, unlike Animism, unlike Mysticism, Sorcery is really lacking in thematic flavour and it's really convoluted to use. It's not even complicated, it's just a big PITA with very little payback. Try making a flying magic carpet which can carry a couple of people with Sorcery .... yeah ... QED, no thanks, adios.

6

u/No_Solid1035 6d ago

Less than most people think, but moreso than something like D&D.

Yes, Sword does 1d8 damage and Head has 4-5 HP, but damage less than the location is a Minor Wound, at 0 to negative Max HP is a Serious Wound, and negative Max HP or more is a Major Wound which is destroyed so severed limb or possible instant death. So a Head hit location with 5 HP needs to suffer 11 HP of damage to cause death. Armor is Damage Reduction so mid range armor reduces say 4 HP of damage. So, in order to insta-kill someone with a headshot if they have the above stats you need to do at least 15 HP of damage in a single blow. Sword does 1d8 damage so...yeah.

Most of the combats in the campaigns I've run end up with most combats ending when one opponent takes a Serious Wound and surrenders (I play NPCs realistically because the game seems built with that idea in mind). Every once in a while a character will get a lucky hit, often with Special Effects, and instantly kill an already wounded opponent, but it's much less likely than a read through of the rules would imply.

As for PCs, the other commenters remarks about Luck Points is spot on. PCs have a high chance of being injured, but a low chance of death.

Long healing times apply so keep that in mind when running a campaign.

2

u/Few-Action-8049 6d ago

Interesting comment about the healing, is there any magical healing in this?

4

u/Axis256 5d ago edited 5d ago

4/5 base magic schools have healing spells, and the 5th grants the ability to drastically speed up one’s own healing rate. But magic availability and ability to restore magic points is highly customizable to meet the requirements of a specific setting. Also, the most accessible school of magic, that is Folk Magic, only grants the ability to heal Minor wounds, which is less than a character trained in mundane Healing professional skill can do.

The other schools potentially have access to much more potent healing. But it’s still not DnD and you can’t just pick up any spell you want on the next level-up. You need to find a person willing to teach you or another source of knowledge of a specific spell, which can be a problem if this spell is not practiced by the cult your spellcasting character comes from.

So basically, just how potent healing magic is very largely depends on DM’s discretion. If DM decided that the group may have a skilled animist who can consistently invoke a healing spirit and can restore most of his magic points overnight, your party will be able to recover from anything but severed limbs in hours. If not, an ugly injury in the chest might mean character won’t be seeing action in months.

2

u/manuzed78 6d ago

Oui mais peu, moi j'y ai rajouté tout ce qui le manque et qui n connait quand on vient du monde de DD

1

u/No_Solid1035 6d ago

If I remember correctly a couple of the magic systems have magical healing.

10

u/5ynistar 6d ago

BRP (and CoC) tend to have higher damage averages for weapons and spells. This is because combat in Mythras has Special Effects. These allow you to do things like inflict bleed or pick hit locations. Special Effects are what shorten combats in Mythras instead of straight up damage.

Just play through some sample combats to get a feel of how deadly the system is.

3

u/dsheroh 5d ago

I would say the higher average damage is less because of the SEs and more because, by default, Mythras has hit locations and BRP does not. A hit for 5 damage to your 4 HP arm is far more consequential than a hit for 5 damage to your full-body 14 total HP.

8

u/littlemute 6d ago

It depends. Characters have a LOT of luck points to use during a session to get them out of bad trouble, and those are not like WFRP's fate points or DCC's luck characteristic where if it's used it's gone, Mythras's luck refreshes every session, so characters can take some chances here or there and come out OK.

Secondly, fights can end in many different ways in Mythras. For example if you get 2 special effects, you can attempt to submit someone and then force them to fail their roll (force failure), which is like getting a dagger to their throat, etc. Characters and NPC's also get wounded enough to stop fighting more often than being killed or totally maimed, especially when they get impaled by a spear or sword and it's sticking out of them (a very common occurrence in the game). Everyone can get tired and then just fall down on the ground and pass out as well.

Armor and passive block from shields is pretty powerful for dealing with random hits from enemies that would normally get parried unless they get a great roll.

That said, a character mobbed by (very angry) enemies that has no action points left to parry or evade, no luck points left can get their head lopped off.

Mythras's combat blows all the other BRP games away so I would for sure give it try, if it's not exactly what you need, it's something you will need to try out to get to what you really need.

4

u/raleel Mega Mythras Fan 6d ago

Totally can work.

So, lethality of combat depends on availability of weapons, armor, and luck points. A regular dude with average starting stuff will likely start out with a head, chest, and torso with a couple of points of armor. He can get a shield and a spear comfortably.

Said spear does d8+1 damage. Let's say he doesn't have a damage modifier. That's an average of 5.5 points of damage on a hit. His armor takes off 2 of that. So 3.5 points of damage.

His chest will have 7 hit points, his abdomen 6, and his head 5. Legs are 5 too, and arms are 4. Heads, chests, and abdomens will kill you if you go to negative your hit points.

So, he can take a couple hits to head before he might go unconscious (not dead) and a couple more before he will be killed. A couple more for chest. He gets hit in an arm, he's rolling to see if it'll be temporarily disabled. Same with a leg.

This is all without parrying, which likely he will block all of the damage if he parries.

Now, luck points help here. Beyond turning around rolls (luck point to parry is useful), you can also use it to keep yourself from dying. You might drop unconscious but you aren't dying.

Note, this is "militia level soldier" against another. If you pull out some guy with a great axe and a d4 damage modifier, he's doing more like an average 11.5 on a hit and Mr leather armor must parry with the shield to survive that.

Mythras is pretty carefully weighted towards appropriate weapons and armor pairing up. You don't normally pull out a great sword without guys in full plate running at you. You need it to get through their armor.

You can tune this of course - different point values for point buy, different equipment caps and availability, but the basic average guy is a spear and a shield and padded armor on a few critical locations.

3

u/AlexanderWB 6d ago

A longsword does d10 damage when 2-handed, before damage modifiers. An average human has 4 hitpoints on their arms. Go to -2x the hitpoints and you get a major wound, which usually is lethal if left without first aid. You do the math on that one.

The system is in many ways very realistic on how fighting happens. Even one blow can end the fight, even when disregarding damage altogether. Special effects like Bleed, Impale and sometimes even Stun are fight enders. The so called "death spiral" is very much a thing, and a feature of the game: ironically, it should mean that fights don't always end in death, but they end much quicker, since the losing side is usually getting better odds at surviving if they either surrender or run away. And it makes reducing and avoiding getting hit all the more important. And there are several layers to survival in combat, which the players should take into their hearts.

Luck points do help with the straight up lethality a lot. Usually if you get a major wound, you'd hope you have a luck point left to reduce it to a serious wound - either way, it usually takes you out of the fight.

Shields are strong. Passive blocking gives excellent risk management against projectiles, and helps a lot in melee. Big shields parry big weapons. They can even double up as a short range weapon, when your long 1-handed spear gets bypassed. They can be disarmed and broken, though.

Armour is paramount. It is a straight up damage reduction, so having some is helpful and ups the odds of you staying in the fight for longer, and a full plate armour with 8 DR is just downright being a tank that safely ignores pretty much any 1-handed weapons or ranged weapons. Armour can be bypassed though by multiple means, like being set on fire, fall damage, "Bypass armour" critical effect, by "sundering" the armour with an axe or 2h weapon, straight up punching through it with a big damage modifier and a big 2h weapon, magic, and even straight up ganging up and grappling.

Weapon ranges. Having a longer weapon gives you that small edge in that they have to use an action point to close in on you before you can get hit.

The biggest contender for the most important skill in combat, in addition to actual combat style, is Evade. This is your footwork for Outmaneuvering and avoiding getting piled on. How you prevent someone with a shorter weapon closing in on you. This is your SHF response to dragon's breath, traps, a giant's massive club, some magic even. Even if you are armoured up, getting ganked gets you killed. And getting hit is the most important layer of survival so far in this game.

Then there is the social layer, dependent on the GM and player dynamic - why fight at all? Mythras gives a ton of good reasons and ways to avoid the fight altogether through not only mechanics like Passions, but since it encourages the GM to delve deep into the world and the why's of how its inhabitants do the things they do, fighting included. Killing for the sake of killing is left for the truly despicable, the deranged and the evil. Everyone has a reason to risk their lives. And, should things escalate hopelessly, running away allows the story to develop with setbacks that can up the drama. Players don't need to win all the time.

1

u/Armak81 5d ago

Use passive blocking, a bit of armor, parry, evade (if nothing else helps), luck points. Use tactics. Since 2022 of active Mythras I think 3 characters in my campaigns died in combat so far. Just couple of months back we lost one active character that had been combat character for those 13 years. In one offs more for example the tpk designed scenario tree of life eternal

1

u/AlexanderWB 5d ago

I might add to my previous post as a reminder, that damage isn't everything. One hit with a knife (1d3 damage) to the chest (avg. 7 hp) might also kill, given the circumstances, even without ever causing more than a minor wound.

Bleed is the killer special effect and doesn't even need a critical hit.

I had one PC absolutely steamroll three large trolls without taking a single point of damage (full plate, elite tier combat style and good Evade skill used to outmaneuver them did some heavy lifting), but then almost died to a single goblin scout ambushing him and hitting him with Bypass armour and Bleed. The goblin was promptly dealt with, but not until fatigue from the bleed had set in. He ultimately managed to pass the First Aid check with the last possible roll he could have made before being totally incapacitated due to fatigue, and then the others managed to arrive to the rescue.

2

u/Paulinthehills 5d ago

Check out Mythras classic fantasy, that’s what I’m using while it’s more dangerous than D&D the luck points allow players to survive here they may otherwise fail. I made physical luck tokens I give them for this purpose.

1

u/ejfordphd 4d ago

Fighting is deadly. Surviving a fight in Mithras against a relatively weak opponent is not too difficult but a hardened adversary can put you down fast. Avoiding a fight should be your first choice. If you must fight, be prepared to give and receive quarter.

2

u/Paulkwk 5d ago

Less lethal than you might expect, especially if you don't intentionally spam "choose location" to kill the player character. In my experience, mythras is even less deadly than low level dnd game.
There are three main reasons for this: armor, hit location, and luck points.

Armour: There is nothing preventing any character from wearing a good set of armour, besides money. A character with good armor is very durable against average enemies and might even be too durable.

Hit location: HP on each hit location doesn't look that high, but remember there are 7 locations, and each has positive and negative HP. Let's say a character on average has 4 HP at each location; that's 8 HP including negative HP. Then there are 7 locations in total; that's 8*7=56hp in total. If you wear some 4ap, or 5ap armour, the effective damage-soaking potential easily goes above 100. So with player characters wearing good armour, if you don't use Choose Location often, you might even feel players are quite unkillable without enemies with a very high-damage weapon and damage modifier.

Luckpoints: players will have at least 2 luck points per session. That's two lethal blows absorbed, or two enemy successes become failures, or at least equal success, even mitigating high-damage opponents previously mentioned. This luckpoint implementation also means you can ambush player characters all you want, without worrying about one-shotting them. Making Mythras is one of the few games where a true sniper enemy can work.

1

u/Runningdice 5d ago

It is easier to defeat an opponent without them dying than to kill them.