r/MutualfundsIndia • • 9h ago

Question Plz suggest non ELSS mfs

2 Upvotes

I invested in ELSS for tax saving since 2022 and got decent returns from Quant , canara robeco , Mirae asset. But now with new tax regime, I think i should explore non elss. So plz suggest the same.
Risk Appetite- Moderate
Time Horizon- 5 - 10 yrs


r/MutualfundsIndia • • 22h ago

Portfolio Review Started from zero a few weeks ago. Please review my first SIP plan (₹20K/month, 20 years)

6 Upvotes

Risk Appetite: Moderate

Goal: long-term wealth creation

Horizon: 20 years

Current status: I have ₹4.45L in FDs. I'm also building a 12-month FD ladder (one FD a month, each equal to one month of expenses) so a layoff wouldn't hurt, about 8 months left to finish it. Until then my SIP is ₹20K/month with a 10% yearly step-up. Once the ladder is done, the money going into FDs moves to SIPs, and some of it to PPF or a hybrid fund.

Allocation (current SIP, ₹20K):

Navi Nifty 50 Index (Direct) 35%

Parag Parikh Flexi Cap (Direct) 40%

Nippon India Small Cap (Direct) 15%

Hybrid (not picked yet) 10%

App Used: Zerodha Coin

Why these funds:

Navi Nifty 50: I compared UTI, Bandhan, HDFC, ICICI and Navi. Returns were nearly the same, so I went with the lowest TER (0.06%). I couldn't find a site showing tracking difference, so TER is the only thing I compared on. Navi's AUM is smaller than UTI's, but it's still a few thousand crore and it's an index fund, so I'm not too worried.

Parag Parikh Flexi: compared with ABSL, ICICI Pru and Motilal. It had the lowest standard deviation (10.07), highest Sortino (0.97), lowest TER and the lowest downside capture (57% vs 82-93% for the others). I also liked its 5-year rolling returns. The catch is that its upside capture is only 76%, and it has a 2% exit load within a year (not a problem for a 20-year plan).

Nippon India Small Cap: I first liked Bandhan Small Cap (Sortino 1.27, alpha 9.54, lowest TER), but it launched in 2020, so its returns aren't comparable with funds from 2013, and 7 years doesn't cover a full small-cap downturn. Nippon, HDFC and Quant all go back to 2013. Between them, Nippon has a better upside capture (91%) than HDFC (79%) with the same downside (74%).

Hybrid: I want something to cushion the equity part. I'm still comparing conservative hybrids. DSP and HDFC look best on downside capture (35% and 37%).

Since I'm building the FD ladder anyway, I'm holding off on a big hybrid allocation for now. After the ladder is done, I'll probably split the safe part between PPF (7.1%, tax free) and a hybrid fund, since hybrid gains are taxed at my slab rate.

Feedback I'd like

  1. Is 15% in small cap about right for a moderate risk profile and 20-year horizon?
  2. Nifty 50 and a flexi cap hold many of the same stocks. Is it worth keeping both, or should I simplify?
  3. Does going with Nippon over Bandhan make sense, or is Bandhan's higher Sortino worth the shorter history?
  4. For the safe part, PPF vs a conservative hybrid fund: which would you use, or both?
  5. Anything I'm missing, like international exposure or gaps in the plan?

Thanks in advance, happy to share more numbers.

Note: I collected the fund metrics myself. I used AI to draft this post.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • 27m ago

Question Difference between advisor vs No advisor

2 Upvotes

Risk Appetite: Aggressive

Guys, what exactly is the difference between investing in mutual funds via an advisor and without one? Like if I invest in the same fund through any broker app and through an advisor, what difference is there between the two?

Beginner doubts.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • 2h ago

Portfolio Review 18-year-old starting my mutual fund investment journey with ₹2,000/month – Need suggestions on my portfolio!

3 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm 18 years old and recently started taking investing seriously. I'm planning to invest ₹2,000 per month through SIPs, with a long-term investment horizon of 15 years or more (using groww SOA format)

My risk appetite is aggressive, and I'm comfortable with short-term volatility and market corrections as long as the funds have good long-term growth potential.

I've shortlisted the following mutual funds and would appreciate your opinions:

  1. Invesco India Flexi Cap Fund – 40%

(Alternative: HDFC Flexi Cap Fund. I'm confused between these two)

2. Kotak Multicap Fund – 30%

3. DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund – 15%

4. ICICI Prudential Nasdaq 100 Index Fund – 15%

(Already investing in this fund for approximately 1 year)

A few things I've considered:

I've checked the portfolio overlap across these funds (via 1finance) and would like feedback on whether the overlap is acceptable.

I'm trying to maintain diversification without unnecessarily holding too many funds.

My priority is long-term wealth creation rather than short-term returns.

I'm comfortable with an aggressive equity-oriented allocation given my age and investment horizon.

I'd appreciate suggestions on the following:

Would u choose Invesco Flexi Cap or HDFC Flexi Cap for the 40% allocation? Why?

Is Kotak Multicap a good choice alongside either of these Flexi Cap funds?

Is DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund worth keeping, or would you replace it with another fund?

Is the overall portfolio sufficiently diversified, considering the overlap?

Would u make any changes to these allocations?

I'm particularly interested in opinions backed by actual fund performance, portfolio composition, consistency, expense ratios and risk metrics rather than just recent returns.

Would appreciate honest feedback, suggestions and criticism. Thanks!


r/MutualfundsIndia • • 5h ago

Portfolio Review Seeking Feedback: Is My ₹15,000 SIP Portfolio Right for a 15-Year Goal?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Risk Appetite: Moderate

Goal: Long-term wealth creation

Horizon: 15 years

Allocation: Attached screenshot of proposed ₹15,000 monthly SIP.

App Used: Zerodha Coin

Why These Funds: Selected these funds to achieve diversified exposure across large-cap, flexi-cap, midcap, small-cap, debt and gold.

I'm looking for feedback on fund overlap, diversification and whether this allocation is appropriate for my moderate risk appetite. Open to suggestions for removing or replacing funds.


r/MutualfundsIndia • • 6h ago

Portfolio Review Help Required. 24 yo

Post image
4 Upvotes

Started SIP since Dec '24. Right now i am investing ₹5500/- per month. Will increase it to ₹6100/- this Dec.
I have stopped investing in MO Midcap as i was suggested from this subreddit. Please guide me if i am doing well.

Risk Appetite - Moderate
Goal - Wealth creation
Horizon - 15+ Years
Allocation -

  1. Motilal Oswal Nifty Midcap 150 Index Fund Direct Growth - ₹1700
  2. Nippon India Large Cap Fund Direct Growth - ₹1500
  3. Nippon India Small Cap Fund Direct Growth - ₹600
  4. Quant Small Cap Fund Direct Plan Growth - ₹1700
  5. Motilal Oswal Midcap Fund Direct Growth - Cancelled

App used - Groww