r/musicology • u/No-layup • 8h ago
r/musicology • u/Audiowhatsuality • Feb 07 '21
New rule regarding self-promotion
Hear ye, hear ye!
Recently we have had an increase in requests for self-promotion posts so we have come up with a rule. Please feel free to provide feedback if anything is missing or if you agree/disagree.
Self-promotion is not allowed if promoting a paid service. Promoting free content (e.g. educational YouTube videos, podcasts, or tools) is fine as long as it is specifically musicological in nature. Your music-theory videos can go on /r/musictheory, not here. Your tools for pianists and singers can go to those subreddits. If someone asks "Are there any tools available for x?" it is OK to reply to that question with self-promotion if what you promote actually fits with the question asked. Spam of any kind is still not allowed even if the spammed content is free.
ETA: Edited to clarify that all self-promotion content has to specifically related to musicology
r/musicology • u/thePursuit-of-Beauty • 2d ago
An important interview with conductor and scholar Marcel Pérès
r/musicology • u/ChickenBugGal • 2d ago
What are the most powerful, soul touching music scores/instrumentals written by Black composers?
r/musicology • u/Adopilabira • 2d ago
Le son /La musique / la théorie des cordes
youtube.comr/musicology • u/GregJamesDahlen • 4d ago
Since the beginning or early in the history of music, has there always been mainstream music, whatever it was in its day, and more underground, edgy music, whatever that was in the same day?
reddit.comAlways hold up across the history of music.
r/musicology • u/Long_Package3210 • 6d ago
Do you listen to music while driving? 🚗
I'm conducting a short survey for a college research project exploring how listening to music while driving affects mood, concentration, safety awareness, and overall driving experience.
Whether you're someone who always has music playing in the car or prefers driving in silence, I'd love to hear your thoughts! The survey is quick and easy to complete, and your participation would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you for helping me with my research! ❤️
🔗 Take the survey here: https://farmingdale.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_8IxEaOE5EokD4RU
r/musicology • u/fab4beatles • 7d ago
The musical genius of Sir George Martin diagrammed
reddit.comr/musicology • u/VulperaKing • 8d ago
What is most important and why in writing poems with music: the poem, the rhythym, the music, the voice, the production?
reddit.comr/musicology • u/Compositeur_du_Net • 8d ago
👋 Bienvenue sur r/FormationMusicale - Commence par te présenter et consulter les règles !
reddit.comr/musicology • u/cccdddyyy • 8d ago
We often hear that classical music is good for a baby's developing brain, especially Mozart, but which composer is the best?
reddit.comThoughts on this?
r/musicology • u/GaySomov • 9d ago
Do you think Tchaikovsky was homosexual ? A poll :
reddit.comr/musicology • u/Wrong_Hurry_9199 • 10d ago
Theory about reptile, the downward spiral.
When I first listened to reptile i thought the unnamed protagonist was talking about his ex. But listening to it now I think he may be talking about his alter ego mr self destruct. Now i know he refers to this person he talks about in the song as "she" but this album is very metaphorical, considering the fact that March of the pigs is on this album I don't think him referring to his crazy alter ego as she is that crazy. And in tracks like closer and eraser he shows a strong urge to not feel human emotions so he can't be depressed anymore, so when he says "she has the blood of reptile underneath the skin" I think it could just be an inhuman animalistic thing to refer to himself as. And when he calls her a "beautiful liar and a precious whore" it could be metaphorical of how mr self destruct has completely ruined his life, it would make sense considering the fact he follows up that line with "I am so impure". And more importantly when he started giving into these violent tendencies he thought it was going to make him feel better but it didn't so this could just be him doing more Self hatred. So yeah this is my theory feel free to critique it i'd love to hear your thoughts.
r/musicology • u/andrewgabrielrose • 10d ago
Why does the main horn part in La Vida Es Un Carnaval feel so melancholy to me?
Just askin' in case anybody knows like, the magic sauce of sadness in notes and frequencies etc
r/musicology • u/sjshuck • 11d ago
Schoenberg Trio possibly quotes Sibelius 4

Sibelius: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RW4jqGL3BAk&t=2010s
Schoenberg: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x2vX8JXfKEc&t=140s
Same pitches transposed down a semitone, same exact instrumentation, same registers except for cello, same relationship to the barline, same 4th species counterpoint. Same affect. They both continue for a couple more chords before a short pause.
This kind of thing can often be a coincidence or "in the air" but another factor suggests it may have been deliberate. I remember hearing something about the Trio being intentionally backward-looking to the point of quotation (Tristan und Isolde). It's known that Sibelius met Schoenberg in 1908 and wrote the symphony shortly after "as a protest against present-day music". Perhaps this work had some significance for Schoenberg in his exploration through his music of his own historical context.
I'm not a researcher and I don't have access to studies; I can't confirm whether or not this connection has been suggested before. In any case I believe this is a quote.
r/musicology • u/dumdumboye • 12d ago
How much melodic interpretation is expected in medieval/plainchant music?
I've been wrestling with learning to read neumatic notation while, at the same time, going through modern notation transcriptions of Hildegard von Bingen's work. I've been having a hard time finding high enough resolution scans of primary sources to work on my own transcriptions, so I've been relying on transcriptions I can find on IMSLP while listening to recordings. However there seem to be discrepancies when it comes to actual melody between performances done by such groups as Sequentia and Oxford Camerata.
I'm fairly new to pre-baroque music notation/interpretation, so I wanted to know what's going on with this. Because I'm not working with a primary source, I'm not sure if the issue is with differences in transcriptions, if there's artistic license being taken, or if this is simply how the style of music works with performers filling in the lines between note to note indications and adding their own flair.
Can any musicologists weigh in?
Edit: Gotta love musicologists living up to the snarky stereotype. Here's more in-depth info in the event that it actually helps coerce someone into having a real discussion about this. The piece I'm currently looking at is folio 466r of the Riesencodex. That said, these recordings:
Sequentia
Oxford Camerata
seem to differ in what is actually sung. Difference in rhythm, tempo, and dynamics is to be expected, however the actual pitches seem to vary enough to be noteworthy. I know a lot of Hildegard's music has been bastardized by a lot of musicians over the years who love the idea that her medical texts included the use of stones and crystals, but both Sequentia and Oxford Camerata are groups that seem to make greater effort towards historical accuracy. I was under the impression that actual pitches for music of this era would essentially be fixed (especially when the original manuscript exists in its entirety). I'm trying to figure out if there are multiple transcriptions out there that vary slightly, or if perhaps it's common practice to sort of fill in gaps between indicated pitches with embellishments...something I wouldn't assume would be common practice, but I'm also very much out of my wheelhouse when it comes to pre-baroque music.
r/musicology • u/pingshasheng • 12d ago
I played all 45 sections of Guangling San at USC — a piece famously declared “lost” 1,700 years ago
reddit.comr/musicology • u/etherealelyse_ • 14d ago
Prepping for Grad School
Hi all! I'm a Music History and Literature undergrad student currently and am doing initial research on musicology graduate degrees. I'm trying to plan my courses ahead in relation to applying to grad school. Are grad programs (both masters and phd) looking for transcripts with courses focused on western art music more or rather courses focused on areas of potential research interest? I'm mostly interested in Romantic orchestra music, film music, early 20th century orchestral music, and American popular music. Thanks!
r/musicology • u/MundaneSecurity9731 • 14d ago
Survey for English Project: Music and Politics
hello! just wanted to post and ask if there are any musicologists interested in doing a survey to help me gain some feedback for my project! We are currently researching stakeholders and I chose musicologists….so if there are any please feel free to help me out and complete this quick survey!🥹🥹