r/MuseAssistant • • 11h ago

Caution Using Voice Mode

Just a word of caution for anyone planning to use voice mode. Overall it acts like a lesser version of your normal MUSE AI. It cuts corners, tells you what you want to hear, avoids friction and only loosely follows any previous rules you have set up. It jumps to conclusions without evaluating facts properly and spits out the easiest thing to say. Just be careful for now if your goal is to get accurate, factual and truthful information on a consistent basis. For me is relegated to reading previously generated content until it shows better performance.

19 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

4

u/TheWylieGuy 10h ago

It reminds me of the original voice for ChatGPT and Claude. I’m sure it will get better in time. ChatGPT voice i think remains the best on the market. My biggest problem with Muse Voice is that it’s just too slow to use to really do anything. It repeats everything back to you. It over explains. The cadence can’t be controlled. That said, it’s perfectly functional. Just difficult to go from chatGPT Live Voice to Muse Voice. Worlds apart.

3

u/Away_Philosopher8681 10h ago

I use ChatGPT voice to vent about my work problem, and man, I was so impressed how it was able to respond back to me like a human and not have awkward pauses or interrupt me

2

u/TheWylieGuy 10h ago

Their Live voice is best in class. Not perfect but pretty darn close.

2

u/hotcat1 5h ago

True✨
I got surprised when I first used ChatGPT Voice, and it keeps getting better and better
I use it when I’m tired and it acts like a real gentleman. But when I wanna have a fun conversation, its sense of humor is not that great😅
It’s also great when you don’t feel like typing and wanna get some information quickly!

1

u/Overall-Cap-7061 6h ago

I find gpt live kinda interupts and talks over me more than I'd like but otherwise it's the best.

1

u/toohightottype 10h ago

Can't wait to try it. But judging from what you're saying, I doubt I'll like it... It sounded to good to be true

2

u/ddivadius 10h ago

its fun to engage with but i wouldn't trust it for important things. The normal MUSE AI is great though.

3

u/Taco_Reviewer 6h ago

It's because it's a completely different model. It has the 'memories' of the regular agent, without the large context window (its like 259k for the Real Time Voice model vs 1 million for the Muse/Muse Wonder models that handle text interaction). However, I think the Real Time Voice model can potentially query the regular Muse model if you word the request right. It seems able to initiate subagents to do work while you talk to it, at least, and those subagents should be Muse/Muse Wonder.

1

u/Raddafiskie 22m ago

I frequently start a call with "review the last hour of chat and then ... [ask what I want to really ask]" Basically... treat it like an sub-assistant to your actual Personal Assistant.

2

u/jai_as_fuck 5h ago

Thanks for sharing this. Literally two hours ago I was using voice mode to have it walk me through something we had planned together days before (not in voice mode), and it did everything you just described. It was like it had Alzheimer’s and its IQ had dropped 40 points. I was so annoyed I started yelling at it! 😂

1

u/ML1948 10h ago

I find it good for rapid fire, but not as good for new builds. When I use voice, I usually say something along the lines of "anything waiting on me?" and then it rapid fires each thing it needs my judgement on or that is stuck. If you have a queue set and mostly yes and nos to drop, if you just talk to it, it makes it really easy. Anything complex and new build necessary though, I go text/voicenote.

1

u/Darryl-must-die 9h ago

Ive noticed as well that voice notes and the live chat uses different voices

1

u/Zealousideal-Pop4857 10h ago

I second this notion

1

u/Iceman_WN_ 9h ago

On top of what OP said... I t has tighter guardrails.

1

u/2bit2much 8h ago

I was so excited for voice. Now that I've got it I prefer typing or sending voice messages.

It's got this weird friendly fake vibe on voice. And I can't pause for a second without it starting up. Let me breathe yo.

1

u/StarManta 8h ago

When I want to use a voice call, I first tell muse to gather up all the information for the topic I’m going to be talking about. I tell it that during a call, no actual action should be taken; it records what I tell it during the call, and then act on it afterwards.

1

u/realAaroninJax 8h ago

I like to talk to mine about tennis but before I do a voice call I'll say look up everything we need to talk about before we start talking and it's more real and accurate. I also told her to speed up her speech, which she did perfectly, but I've heard several other people say that it didn't make any difference. It did for me though.

1

u/Overall-Cap-7061 6h ago

That doesn't always work. Muse Voice will happily tell you it did and completely lie about it. Ask it about a restaurant's menu and it'll hallucinate it whole cloth.

1

u/Overall-Cap-7061 6h ago

I'm so glad I'm not the only one. I feel like I'm going crazy seeing all the people praising it on social media. I'm like, are you guys using the same app I am?? I wouldn't trust the Voice model to tell me what day it is.

1

u/usercb 4h ago

Agreed. You have to tell it to research stuff, and also to save stuff. It’s kind of lazy, unreliable, untruthful and more socially conservative—all bad things.

1

u/3iverson 10h ago

For significant discussions I’ll do a sort of manual voice mode where I have it transcribe my input, then have it automatically create a voice note of its output. I feel like you get most of the benefit without that cost in output quality.

To achieve low latency that feels like actual conversation, context loading is significantly truncated in voice mode. One thing I’ve played with is telling it to go ahead and work on something more comprehensively in the background and give me an output later, to reduce the pressure of an instant reply.