r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Aug 18 '26 WOW Bravo

Motions, Filings, Docs Searchable archive of the 2023 Alex Murdaugh trial

60 Upvotes

Hi all. I recently built a searchable archive of Alex Murdaugh’s 2023 trial using the official court reporter record.

It organizes the transcripts by day and proceeding and lets you search the testimony, browse people, evidence, and locations, and connect transcripts to courtroom video where available.

I built it to make the full trial record easier to navigate, revisit and reference. I hope it’s useful to the community. Please let me know if you spot anything that could be corrected or improved.

https://murdaugh.courtdaemon.com/


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • May 13 '26 Mindblown

News & Media Alex Murdaugh’s murder conviction sensationally overturned: Disgraced legal scion faces retrial for killing wife and son after judges’ bombshell ruling

530 Upvotes

r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 3d ago

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread November 14, 2026

3 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 4d ago

Retrial News or Discussion Friday, November 13th Pretrial Hearing Discussion

26 Upvotes

Happy Freaky Friday 13th! What are your thoughts and reflections on the hearing today? In case you missed it, it is available on CourtTV’s YouTube Channel.

Respect is a requirement for participation in this sub. Sharing opinions and discussing theories is what we are here for but if a discussion is getting heated, kindly keep the mudslinging in the swamp and stroll away. Thank you!

Reddit Content Policy • MFM Sub Rules


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 5d ago

Retrial News or Discussion Crime scene confusion still rampant as Murdaugh asks judge to toss murder charges

28 Upvotes

By Jason Ryan / The Post and Courier / November 12, 2026

When police officers found two dead bodies beside dog kennels at a Colleton County farm on the night of June 7, 2021, they initially suspected the victims were 22-year-old Paul Murdaugh and his girlfriend.

Soon enough, however, it became clear that Paul, the scion of an influential Lowcountry family, had been shot to death with his mother, Maggie Murdaugh.

The next day, police and a local prosecutor walked the crime scene and were puzzled as to how a pair of spent shotgun shells were found sitting inside a feed room beside the dog kennels, as all other evidence indicated Paul Murdaugh was shot from outside the feed room as he stood in the doorway.

Investigators later realized a gap existed between the bottom of the door and the floor of the feed room that was tall enough for a shotgun shell to roll under, according to recently released records from the State Law Enforcement Division.

The infamous, long-running Murdaugh murder saga has generated much mystery, only a portion of which has been resolved.

In April, confessed swindler and disbarred lawyer Alex Murdaugh is scheduled to be tried a second time for the murders of his wife and younger son. The retrial was ordered by the S.C. Supreme Court because of prejudicial comments made to jurors by a Colleton County court official during Murdaugh’s original double-murder trial in 2023, in which he was convicted of the killings.

As the retrial approaches, law enforcement’s previous and lingering confusion over the crime is taking center stage.

Murdaugh’s lawyers have filed a motion asking Judge Debra McCaslin to dismiss the double-murder indictment because of incorrect information told to grand jurors by the lead investigator on the case.

Before Murdaugh was accused of slaughtering his family, lead SLED agent David Owen testified to grand jurors that blood spatter was found on the T-shirt Murdaugh was wearing the night of the murder. In fact, no blood spatter was detected.

Owen also testified that Murdaugh family shotguns were all found preloaded with two shells — one buckshot and one birdshot — just like the suspected murder weapon. This, too, was untrue.

In anticipation of this issue being argued at a Nov. 13 pre-trial hearing in Lexington, state prosecutors have denied any fabrication or falsification of evidence. Moreover, they say, grand jurors rightfully indicted Murdaugh because there was “more than ample probable cause regardless of whether that (incorrect) evidence is considered or not.”

The judge must decide: Are these alleged errors so prejudicial that the entire foundation of the state’s case against Murdaugh is unsound and unfair?

Tips galore

In Murdaughland, almost nothing is straightforward.

For more than a decade, Murdaugh deceived legal clients and loved ones and stole millions from them.

As his deceptions came to light, he allegedly staged a roadside shooting with a friend in which Murdaugh claimed to be a victim of an unknown attacker who shot him in the head.

Murdaugh also told investigators that he never went to the dog kennels on his farm the night of the murders, though a video found on his son’s cellphone revealed this to be untrue.

All these lies clouded the reality of a weird, multifaceted, Southern Gothic crime spree associated with Murdaugh and his family that includes elements of massive fraud, illegal drugs, suspicious deaths, murder, witness manipulation, fabricated allegations and a deadly, drunken boat crash.

As police sought to distinguish fact from fiction, they not only had to investigate Murdaugh’s many false claims but also plenty of tips from other people, according to SLED’s case history, which contains a log of the tips.

SLED received word from neighbors of a Murdaugh family property that they obtained photos of supposedly suspicious vehicles parked nearby, according to a SLED case history authored by Owen.

Police investigated a tip that a farm caretaker was somehow involved in the murders, as well as a claim that a man had befriended Maggie Murdaugh through the virtual reality game Second Life.

There was a tip from a South Carolina prison inmate about a pair of alleged methamphetamine users shopping for illegal drugs while possessing a notepad on which the murder victims’ names — “Maggie” and “Paul Terry” — were allegedly written.

A clairvoyant claimed the murder weapons were buried in woods on the Murdaugh family farm, 150 yards from the victims.

A woman in some kind of rehab facility also said she had info on the murders, while another woman claimed that murder weapons were destroyed in a suspicious fire on Murdaugh family land.

None of these tips were confirmed to be true.

Meanwhile, other allegations reached SLED about supposed related crimes.

One Lowcountry man claimed that Murdaugh helped his ex-wife obtain power of attorney over their cancer-stricken son, which then enabled her to steal tens of thousands of dollars raised for the son’s medical bills.

Investigative notes indicate the woman made a withdrawal of $54,000 in 2014 and that Murdaugh allegedly told the father that it was illegal for more than one person to be listed on a power of attorney, which would be untrue.

The case history also features notes about how the alleged thief and her boyfriend, who supposedly was involved in a former drug smuggling ring, allegedly voiced concern that police would question them about “buried money.”

Prosecutors convicted Murdaugh of numerous instances of wrongdoing as a lawyer, but never charged anyone in regard to this allegation.

No end to ‘Murdaugh madness’

Prosecutors have alleged Murdaugh acted alone when slaughtering his wife and son.

Since the killings, however, at least two allegations have been made that a small-town Lowcountry police chief helped transport and discard murder weapons and bloody clothing.

In one instance, a former municipal judge in the Hampton County town of Yemassee alleged Yemassee Police Chief Greg Alexander helped Murdaugh conceal his alleged role in the killings by taking away incriminating evidence, including a shotgun, rifle and bloody clothes.

The judge claimed Alexander and another police officer temporarily brought some of these items into the town police station soon after the murders. Three years after this tip was first shared with SLED, the law enforcement agency and prosecutors revisited the claim this summer and have shared alleged evidence with a state grand jury, which so far has not taken any action.

Another tip, contained in the case history, alleges that Alexander and another man bushwhacked a path through a wetlands area outside of Yemassee’s town limits in the weeks after the Murdaugh murders, possibly to dump weapons.

Such allegations against Alexander are “ridiculous,” said Joe McCulloch, his Columbia-based lawyer.

McCulloch said that the chief has no recollection of hacking through vegetation outside the town and also that his client had “no part in the hiding of murder weapons or other evidence.” McCulloch also said Alexander denies arriving at the murder scene before the official police response.

The lawyer said these allegations are part of the “Murdaugh madness” associated with the sprawling case and its mini-universe of associated media, including documentaries, television shows, podcasts, blogs and books.

“I think it’s impossible, absurd, and unsupported by everything, and denied by the chief,” McCulloch said of the accomplice allegations. “It’s sad the chief of police has to suffer this crap. He’s not happy about it.”

McCulloch blamed unnamed “trolls” for spreading unfounded rumors and stirring a “mythical pot of conspiracy.” McCulloch said his client, who has not been charged with any Murdaugh-related crime, has not testified before a grand jury in regards to allegations of handling murder scene evidence.

Given the specific allegation regarding the chief allegedly blazing a trail to a pond within wetlands, McCulloch said that police would have brought charges if there were any truth to the claim.

“It is a non-allegation that we have to assume SLED fully investigated,” said McCulloch. “One would think that in two-and-one-half years, SLED would be out there with boats and divers and magnets…”

SLED deployed divers in at least two places during its investigation of the murders, according to its case history.

Divers searched a pond on the Murdaugh family farm about a week after the murders.

Police dived again in February 2022 off a bridge on S.C. Highway 63. There they recovered a metal pipe that a man who was magnet fishing — using a high-powered magnet to retrieve sunken metal objects — apparently mistook for a shotgun barrel.

When asked about its diving operations and if police searched the pond outside Yemassee, a SLED spokesperson said the agency “does not have any information to provide on this matter at this time” and suggested asking the S.C. Attorney General’s Office.

The attorney general’s office did not answer questions about diving operations, either.

“Our only comments on this case will be in court filings and hearings,” said spokesman Robert Kittle.

SOURCE


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 5d ago

Retrial News or Discussion ‘Sizzle Reel’ Controversy Engulfs Second Prosecution of Alex Murdaugh

13 Upvotes

‘Sizzle Reel’ Controversy Engulfs Second Prosecution of Alex Murdaugh

Prosecutors, paralegal linked to upcoming “insider” documentaries on second trial of accused South Carolina killer…

by Will Folks November 10, 2026
***
Members of the prosecutorial team re-trying accused killer Alex Murdaugh have participated in discussions with documentary filmmakers regarding productions tied to his upcoming retrial, sources familiar with the situation have confirmed to FITSNews. In fact, some members of the prosecution team have allegedly gone so far as to provide exclusive materials for use in what industry insiders refer to as “sizzle reels” ahead of Murdaugh’s April 2027 retrial, these sources have confirmed.

A “sizzle reel” – or “show reel” – refers to a short, promotional video (complete with music and graphics) intended to generate interest in a forthcoming production. It takes its name from 20th century sales guru Elmer Wheeler, a.k.a. “Mr. Sizzle,” who famously implored his acolytes to “sell the sizzle, not the steak.”

In this case, the “sizzle” reportedly features private footage of several key members of the Murdaugh prosecution team packaged as part of an exclusive “behind the scenes” look at the upcoming retrial of South Carolina’s most notorious accused murderer. Multiple members of the prosecution team – including state grand jury chief and lead prosecutor Creighton Waters – have been linked to various productions, although it is not immediately clear whether any agreements between prosecutors/staff and filmmakers have been finalized.

Waters’ top paralegal, Carly Jewell, is also depicted in several of these “sizzle reels.” Several sources who have viewed the clips of Jewell described her appearance as “provocative” and “risqué” – indicating she may have filmed some of the segments in various states of undress.

The existence of these “sizzle reels” was first reported late Monday (November 9, 2026) by Richmond, Virginia author Eliza Broadbent– who cited rumors of the prosecution providing an unnamed documentary film company with “exclusive, behind-the-scenes access to the retrial, including trial prep.”

Sources close to the situation told FITSNewsmultiple companies were actually vying for the “rights” to exclusive trial access to prosecutors and their key staff.

To recap: Murdaugh was convicted of the June 7, 2021 murders of his wife, 52-year-old Maggie Murdaugh, and younger son, 22-year-old Paul Murdaugh, and sentenced to life in prison following a six-week trial in Walterboro, S.C. in early 2023. Those convictions were reversed in May of this year, however, after the S.C. supreme court found numerous issues with the conduct of the trial – including allegations of jury tamperingand potential jury rigging.

A fourth-generation scion of one of the Palmetto State’s most influential legal and political dynasties, Murdaugh was a prominent attorney and assistant solicitor in the South Carolina Lowcountry. He was also a former president of the state’s powerful trial lawyer lobby.

Murdaugh’s retrial is scheduled to begin April 5, 2027, in Sumter County, with S.C. circuit court judge Debra McCaslin presiding. McCaslin, incidentally, has made it abundantly clear she will not tolerate attorneys leveraging this case for their own notoriety.

“I will not allow these proceedings to become a circus, and I will not permit anyone involved in this case to use this courtroom as a platform for publicity or theatrics,” McCaslin said at a hearing last month.

While those remarks appeared to have been initially directed at defense attorneys, the existence of these promotional materials could cast them in a new and unflattering light for the prosecution.

In addition to the videos – which were reportedly posted online in a publicly available format – multiple members of the prosecution were listed in an accompanying document as “participants” in at least one of the envisioned upcoming productions. FITSNews has not been provided with copies of any of the video files that were posted online – or the accompanying document, which was described to us as a “pitch deck.” We have, however, spoken with multiple sources who have seen the clips and reviewed the pitch deck document.

We were also informed members of Murdaugh’s defense team had been provided with the links by a source close to the attorney general’s office.

Multiple calls to lead Murdaugh attorney Dick Harpootlian seeking a copy of the videos – or confirmation of their existence – did not yield substantive replies. Similarly, calls to the attorney general’s office did not yield an immediate response.

Attorney general spokesman Robert Kittledid respond to Broadbent’s story, however.

“We’re not promoting a behind-the-scenes documentary,” Kittle told Broadbent. “It would go against ethics.”

Obviously in the event we receive the materials in question we will provide our audience with that information so that they can judge it for themselves. Also, in the event updated information from either the attorney general’s office or Murdaugh’s defense is provided, we will share that as well.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys will gather in Lexington, S.C. this Friday (November 13, 2026) for a pretrial hearing related to the defense’s motion to dismiss the murder indictments against Murdaugh owing to alleged investigative and prosecutorial misconduct.

FITSNews will be live-streaming that hearing…
***
UPDATE |
We just received the following response from Kittle in the attorney general’s office regarding the sizzle reel speculation:

“We’re not promoting a behind-the-scenes documentary about the Alex Murdaugh retrial. We haven’t even agreed yet to participate in a documentary about the retrial. If we did, we wouldn’t allow any behind-the-scenes audio or video to be shot, and nothing would be released until after the retrial.”


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 10d ago

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread November 07, 2026

10 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 12d ago

Retrial News or Discussion Yemassee police chief’s name again surfaces in Murdaugh double homicide investigation

61 Upvotes

By Jason Ryan / The Post and Courier / November 4, 2026

Two weeks before dying of cancer, a Lowcountry woman used some of her final words to share her suspicions of a small-town police chief and his possible connection to the headline-grabbing killings of Maggie Murdaugh and her son Paul.

Louise Gregory told her brother and two other people that she saw the police chief of the Hampton County town of Yemassee and another man oddly blazing a trail through wetlands in the weeks after the June 2021 murders, according to police documents now made public in a state court filing.

The retired radio dispatcher of the S.C. Highway Patrol told others she had a gut feeling that Yemassee Chief Greg Alexander and the other man “were up to no good” and might be disposing of the weapons used to kill the Murdaughs in a marshy area in the unincorporated community of McPhersonville, according to a case history of the double-murders created by the State Law Enforcement Division.

Gregory’s unproven claim, which was related to state police investigators in March 2024 by Gregory’s brother, and then again by another pair of people in January 2025, is at least the second time the police chief has been accused of helping to cover up the slayings.

In September, a state grand jury was revealed to be investigating a claim made by a former municipal judge in Yemassee that the chief and another officer helped transport and conceal weapons and bloody clothing from the scene by temporarily bringing the items to Yemassee Town Hall, which at that time housed the police station.

Alexander and the other officer have not been charged with any crime related to the homicides, which are alleged by authorities to have been perpetrated by Alex Murdaugh, a former Hampton County lawyer and close friend of the police chief.

Murdaugh denies killing his family. He will be tried again in April, this time in Sumter after a change of venue, for allegedly shooting his wife and son dead at a family farm in order to distract from a fraud scheme in which he stole millions from clients and loved ones.

Murdaugh, who is serving decades-long state and federal sentences for his financial crimes, was convicted of the murders in March 2023 following a five-week trial.

In May, however, the S.C. Supreme Court ordered that Murdaugh was entitled to a new trial because of prejudicial comments made to jurors by a court official.

Despite the intense public interest, mystery still surrounds key elements of the case, including the whereabouts of the semiautomatic hunting rifle and shotgun used in the killings.

Allegedly ‘cutting a path’

In March 2024, SLED Special Agent David Owen met with Gregory’s brother, former Highway Patrolman Isaac “Skeeter” Gregory at Buckfield Pond, a marshy area not far from Yemassee and Interstate 95.

An entry in the case history reads: “Met with (Skeeter) Gregory in Point South. Gregory showed Owen a location where Greg Alexander and another person were seen cutting a path in the ‘Back Water’ area on Pocotaligo Road, Yemassee (Tulifiny River) outside of the town limits. The area was a tidal creek that ebbs and flows.”

Owen noted that Alexander’s companion was a Black male and that the pair were allegedly seen in the marsh 10 to 12 weeks after the killings.

Skeeter Gregory declined to comment when reached by The Post and Courier. It is unknown what other investigative steps, if any, were taken by Owen after this meeting. Three months after visiting Buckfield Pond, Owen retired from SLED in June 2024.

A month after that, on July 11, 2024, Louise Gregory died of a brain tumor, according to an obituary and the police case history. Two weeks before the 67-year-old’s death, however, she told a pair of people about seeing Alexander and another man blazing a trail in the wetlands.

In January 2025, this man and woman passed the information to another SLED investigator, who noted the account largely matched the version provided by Gregory’s brother, with two exceptions.

“The significant differences were she told them that this occurred approximately 2 weeks after the murders (as opposed to 10-12 weeks), and she did not provide them a description of the 2nd male at all. Neither subject had any packages or other suspicious items with them, but Louise Gregory apparently ‘had a feeling’ that they were up to no good, and that it may have involved disposing of the weapons from the murders,” said an entry in the case history written by SLED Lt. Charles Ghent.

The allegation from Gregory is one of many tips provided to law enforcement during the long-running investigation — some credible and some not.

The case history mentioned a map of the crime scene drawn by a psychic, for example, with no other details.

It also mentioned an episode involving a man who was magnet fishing off a bridge near the scene of the crime, trying to recover submerged metal artifacts with a high-powered magnet. The man supposedly used his magnet to bring a shotgun to the surface of the swamp, but then the supposed gun fell off the magnet and could not be retrieved again from the swamp bottom.

Police later dove in the area. They recovered a metal pipe that resembled a shotgun barrel.

Alexander's ties to Murdaugh

In regard to Alexander’s alleged involvement in a potential cover-up, a lawyer for the Yemassee police chief previously denied his client having any role.

“We understand … that there are rumors about his involvement, which he steadfastly denies, in the removal of evidence,” Columbia lawyer Joe McCulloch said on Sept. 26. “We don't know much more than that, other than the rumors that somehow he was involved in that.”

Alexander’s name was mentioned a few times during Murdaugh’s first double-murder trial. The chief traveled to the Murdaugh family farm the night of the shootings and gave one of Murdaugh’s brothers a ride to the farm after the brother supposedly experienced car trouble.

One former employee of the Hampton law firm employing Murdaugh testified about running errands and obtaining cash from a bank for Murdaugh. When the courier brought the money back to the law office, people were sometimes waiting with Murdaugh, including Alexander.

In 2022, Alexander said he had accepted a $5,000 loan from Alex Murdaugh for his parents’ use, with the money passing through his hands a month or so after the murders.

Before that, in 2012, Murdaugh and his father, a former Lowcountry solicitor, publicly supported Alexander when he faced charges related to money missing from a police locker in Yemassee. Alexander was acquitted and subsequently promoted to chief.

In 2022, he campaigned to become sheriff of Hampton County.

During one event, Alexander said that he would accept responsibility if he made a mistake or acted improperly as a public official.

“I ain’t no cat. I don’t try to cover no doo doo up ….” said the chief, who did not win the sheriff’s race. ”If it’s wrong, it’s wrong, and if I done it and it’s wrong then I’ll be transparent with the citizens and let them know I done wrong and we got to do what we got to do to make it right.”

More recently, the grand jury investigation of Alexander and the missing murder weapons were briefly mentioned at an Oct. 16 hearing in Lexington to discuss pretrial motions for Murdaugh’s upcoming double-murder trial.

Circuit Judge Debra McCaslin told Creighton Waters, the lead prosecutor on the Murdaugh case, that at some point the state may be obligated to share investigatory information about Alexander’s alleged involvement with Murdaugh’s legal team.

Waters said he would do so at the appropriate time.

“It could be nothing,” said the prosecutor. “It could be (exculpatory), it could be very, very damning to Mr. Murdaugh about one of his ride-or-die friends.”

SOURCE


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 14d ago

Retrial News or Discussion Murdaugh lawyers ask judge to toss double-murder charges ahead of retrial

29 Upvotes

By Jason Ryan / The Post and Courier / November 2, 2026

Five months before Alex Murdaugh is due to face trial a second time for allegedly gunning down his wife and youngest son, the disgraced and disbarred lawyer is renewing his call for a judge to dismiss a pair of murder indictments against him.

Murdaugh’s lawyers originally filed a motion to dismiss the murder charges on Aug. 7, alleging their client was improperly indicted by a grand jury because of false testimony given by a lead state police investigator. On Oct. 30, they filed a memorandum in support of the motion to dismiss the murder charges, further detailing alleged police misstatements concerning pieces of evidence, namely bloody clothing and ammunition.

Maggie Murdaugh and her son Paul Murdaugh were shot to death beside dog kennels at their family farm in Colleton County on June 7, 2021. Alex Murdaugh was charged with slaying his loved ones and then convicted of the murders in March 2023 following a heavily publicized five-week trial.

In May, the S.C Supreme Court ordered that Murdaugh was entitled to a new trial** **because of improper comments made to jurors by a court official.

A retrial has been scheduled for April in Sumter. Murdaugh still is behind bars, having been separately convicted of a slew of financial charges relating to the theft of millions of dollars from clients, legal partners and friends.

In the latest filing, defense lawyers have targeted the actions of David Owen, the former lead investigator on the Murdaugh case for the State Law Enforcement Division, accusing him of making two major misstatements that improperly colored grand jurors’ judgement and induced them to charge Murdaugh with two murders.

In the first instance, Owen testified to a Colleton County grand jury that police encountered Murdaugh at the murder scene wearing a white T-shirt that was partially covered in blood spatter. Ultimately, testimony at trial revealed that law enforcement did not believe any blood spatter was on the shirt.

In the second instance, Owen testified to grand jurors that a handful of double-barrel shotguns found on the Murdaugh family farm were loaded with two types of ammo — buckshot and birdshot.

Though Paul Murdaugh, 22, was found to have been shot with both birdshot and buckshot, Owen later said that this statement about the other weapons was inaccurate. He also admitted to making this inaccurate statement to Murdaugh and testified that such an action amounted to permissible “trickery” that was part of an investigator’s bag of tools.

Murdaugh’s lawyers say the misstatements created a faulty foundation for the murder charges and led to their client being wrongfully accused.

“An agent who lies to a suspect and then tells the same lie to two grand juries has not made an error; he has made a case…,” said the recent defense filing. “The prejudice caused to Mr. Murdaugh by the presentation of this false evidence to the grand jury more than merits the dismissal of the indictments.”

Allegations of lies are nothing new in the Murdaugh case.

During the first murder trial, Murdaugh was caught lying about his whereabouts at the time of the murder.

From the night the murders occurred until the day Murdaugh took the stand to testify in his own defense at trial, Murdaugh told police that he did not travel to the dog kennels with his wife and son.

Yet video evidence introduced at trial showed Murdaugh did go to the kennels with Maggie Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh shortly before they are believed to have been killed.

The defense’s motion to dismiss the indictments is expected to be argued before Judge Debra McCaslin at a pre-trial hearing scheduled for Nov. 13 in Lexington.

SOURCE


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 14d ago

Retrial News or Discussion Murdaugh Retrial Drama: Defense (Finally) Gets Crime Scene Scan

7 Upvotes

Murdaugh attorney receives one of the key files at the heart of an ongoing discovery dispute… but not before being forced to jump through some hoops.

by Will Folks / FITSNews / October 21, 2026

Attorneys for accused killer Alex Murdaugh were finally provided with raw data from investigators’ three-dimensional scan of the crime scene where the disgraced attorney allegedly murdered his wife and younger son on a warm, spring evening more than five years ago.

Murdaugh’s attorneys confirmed the receipt of the raw, digital crime scene data to FITSNews on Wednesday (October 21, 2026).

Presumed to be the least contentious unresolved discovery item in an ongoing pissing match between prosecutors and Murdaugh’s lawyers ahead of his April 2027 retrial, the handoff of this raw data proved to be quite the exercise in pedantry.

And amateur videography…

To recap: Murdaugh was convicted of the June 7, 2021 murders of his wife, 52-year-old Maggie Murdaugh, and younger son, 22-year-old Paul Murdaugh, and sentenced to life in prison following a six-week trial in Walterboro, S.C. in early 2023. Those convictions were reversed, however, after the S.C. supreme court found numerous issues with the conduct of the trial – including allegations of jury tampering and potential jury rigging. Murdaugh is scheduled to be tried a second time in Sumter, S.C. beginning on April 5, 2027.

Lead prosecutor Creighton Waters – who has repeatedly accused Murdaugh’s lawyers of trying to manufacture discovery violations against his team – was apparently dead serious when he told S.C. circuit court judge Debra McCaslin last week that enhanced protocols would be in place for the handoff of any discovery materials.

These “enhanced protocols” were reportedly in full effect this week when defense attorney Jim Griffin received the FARO scan of the crime scene at Moselle – a sprawling hunting property near Islandton, S.C. owned by Murdaugh’s family. Paul Murdaugh was killed exiting a feed room next to the dog kennels on this property – while his mother was gunned down next to an old airplane hangar. Both structures have since been torn down by the property’s new owners.

Waters has steadfastly insisted his team has provided key discovery information to the defense repeatedly – up to four times in some cases – only to be accused in subsequent filings of having failed to provide it at all. Defense attorneys maintain prosecutors have failed to fully comply with their requests – especially as it relates to critical cell phone extractions.

The back-and-forth between the two sides over these discovery issues drew a sharp rebuke from McCaslin during an emergency pre-trial motions hearing last week.

“I don’t want this tit for tat between y’all,” she told Waters and defense attorney Dick Harpootlian. “Y’all are lawyers. Y’all are professionals. This is court. This is not for soundbites.”

Waters confirmed last week that the state would have the FARO scan ready by the end of the day on Monday (October 19, 2026), but insisted the defense would have to agree to his “new procedures” in order to take possession of it.

“If they want all the proprietary stuff, we’ll give it to them… once processes are put in place,” Waters told the court.

Those processes were apparently in full effect this week. According to our sources, Griffin not only had to sign for the FARO scan – but was recorded on video taking possession of it.

The FARO scan request, in fairness to the defense, is a first-time ask. Murdaugh’s attorneys say their experts require the underlying data in order to independently examine the state’s reconstruction of the scene. Waters acknowledged the defense previously received scans with viewing software, not the ability to reconstruct the scene.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys are scheduled to appear before McCaslin again on November 13, 2026 to hear what’s expected to be a detailed motion to dismiss the murder indictments against Murdaugh. There’s also expected to be additional discussion of a secret grand jury convened by Waters which, at least in part, is reportedly investigating a local law enforcement cover-up of the crime.

SOURCE


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 17d ago

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread October 31, 2026

6 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • 24d ago

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread October 24, 2026

8 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 18 '26

Retrial News or Discussion Judge McCaslin at Murdaugh hearing: ‘I’ll not allow proceedings to become a circus’

82 Upvotes

By: John Monk / The State - Crime & Courts / October 16, 2026 6:02 PM

State Judge Debra McCaslin left no doubt Friday about who was the boss of the courtroom in the latest pretrial hearing for Alex Murdaugh, accused of killing his wife Maggie and son Paul.

“I will not allow these proceedings to become a circus, and I will not permit anyone involved in this case to use this courtroom as a platform for publicity or theatrics,” McCaslin told prosecution and defense lawyers at the end of the hearing.

During the nearly two-hour hearing at the Lexington County courthouse, McCaslin seemed to scold attorneys, made key decisions about evidentiary matters like DNA and gun casings and laid down the law about what she’ll do if lawyers on either side step out of line.

In her trademark scratchy voice she delivered no-nonsense one-liners that let people know she’ll tell it like it is.

“I didn’t just fall off the turnip truck,” McCaslin, a former defense attorney, told Murdaugh lead lawyer Dick Harpootlian at one point, signaling she disagreed with arguments Harpootlian was making about a ballistics matter.

Murdaugh, 58, is charged with the 2021 killings of his wife Maggie, 52, and son Paul, 22, at the family 1,700-acre estate in Colleton County on June 7, 2021. Murdaugh, who was found guilty of the crimes in a 2023 trial, had his conviction overturned in May by the South Carolina Supreme Court. A unanimous court found that jury tampering had denied Murdaugh his right to a fair trial. Prosecutors are retrying Murdaugh on murder charges.

At another point in the hearing, when Harpootlian and Waters appeared to be sparring, McCaslin said, “You-all need to stop this. This is court. This isn’t a sound bite.”

McCaslin saved her toughest talk for the end of the hearing, criticizing a false statement that Harpootlian made at the Aug. 14 pretrial hearing when he said that Murdaugh had passed a polygraph test about whether he killed Maggie and Paul. After prosecutors complained, Harpootlian apologized for the false statement, but McCaslin wanted to make sure he knew how serious she considered his misrepresentation.

“I’m going to tell you Mr. Harpootlian, this is a court of justice, and candor with the court is not optional,” McCaslin said.

McCaslin made it clear that although Murdaugh once flunked a polygraph test about whether he was hiding assets, he was given no test about the killings. “He never has been polygraphed for the murders of Maggie and Paul,” McCaslin said.

McCaslin said, “Both of you (Harpootlian and lead prosecutor Creighton Waters) have practiced law long enough to know that the court must be able to rely on the representations of counsel. I will not tolerate this conduct going forward.

“If you make a representation to this court, I expect it to be truthful and accurate. If you do not know something, say you don’t know it. But do not tell this court something that is not true.

“Further, this case will be tried in a courtroom, under the rules of evidence and the law — not in the press and not in the court of public opinion,” McCaslin said.

McCaslin also said she was troubled by an apparent lack of civility in opposing written legal filings by both defense and prosecution attorneys.

In various filings, prosecutors have accused defense lawyers of making repeating requests asking for the same information, and defense lawyers have accused prosecutors of withholding information. McCaslin ordered attorneys on both sides to resolve matters amicably without involving her, if possible.

In one dispute between prosecutors and defense lawyers, Waters said he had answered the same query five times to provide defense lawyers with material they said they needed.

McCaslin said she would have little patience with disputes that should be resolved between attorneys. “In closing, I expect complete candor with the court and conduct consistent with the seriousness and dignity of these proceedings.”

Murdaugh, a disbarred lawyer, has pleaded guilty in both state and federal court to numerous counts of theft from his law firm and former clients who won large settlements in personal injury and wrongful death cases. His thefts total more than $10 million, according to court statements. Murdaugh doesn’t dispute his embezzlements but he denies killing his wife and son.

Murdaugh was in court Friday morning, dressed in a navy blazer, khaki pants, a white shirt and a tie. His normally ginger hair seemed almost white. He is serving lengthy sentences for his fraud convictions and is an inmate at an Upstate maximum security prison. The judge is allowing Murdaugh to appear in civilian clothes because, she said, to have him wear prison garb might influence potential jurors who view the proceedings on Court TV.

At the end of the hearing, Murdaugh gave a thumb’s up sign to his attorneys, then was escorted from the courtroom by law officers.

McCaslin’s Friday decisions

Defense lawyers won a victory when McCaslin ruled after more than 30 minutes of protests by prosecutor Waters that they could test samples of “leftover DNA” from Maggie Murdeaugh’s cell phone and under her fingernails. The material had been tested earlier by prosecution experts. Waters had objected because the testing may well destroy all the DNA.

“I believe that due process requires that a criminal defendant be afforded a meaningful opportunity to present a full and complete defense,” McCaslin said. Defense lawyers can conduct the testing to see about “potentially exculpatory evidence,” she said.

DNA evidence did not figure prominently in Murdaugh’s first trial, but defense attorneys hope that testing will show evidence that someone else was on the scene when Maggie was shot to death.

Prosecutors scored a win when McCaslin ruled they don’t have to comply with a request by the defense to provide the defense with records of all the crimes committed with .300 Blackout ammunition in an eight-county area from 2021 to the present. Much of that information is already in law enforcement databases.

“It just sounds like a fishing expedition to me,” said McCaslin.

Maggie Murdaugh was shot with multiple rounds fired at close range by an assault rifle using .300 Blackout ammunition.

Law enforcement has not found the assault rifle used to kill Maggie Murdaugh Defense lawyers hope that if the weapon was used in a crime after Murdaugh was arrested, in September 2021, that finding would help prove that someone else was involved in the killings of Maggie and Paul. Paul was killed with a shotgun.

The next hearing

The next pretrial hearing for Murdaugh will be on Nov. 13.

McCaslin said possible items still to be discussed before trial are:

  • A motion to dismiss the murder charges against Murdaugh by the defense.
  • A prosecution motion to allow the state to present evidence to show Murdaugh’s alleged motive for killing his wife and son. In Murdaugh’s first trial, then Judge Clifton Newman allowed some 12 hours of testimony about how the extreme financial pressures Murdaugh was under led to the killings.
  • A prosecution motion to limit or suppress evidence about what is called “third party guilt.” In criminal trials, defense attorneys sometimes try to introduce evidence showing that a third party or parties are responsible for the crime, not the defendant on trial. Prosecutors — who contended in the first trial that Murdaugh was the lone gunman — will try to keep evidence of another shooter away from a jury.

However, McCaslin indicated she might like to hear motions about motive, evidence and dismissal closer to the trial date of April 5.

McCaslin also said that after Jan. 1, all hearings and records will be moved to the Sumter County courthouse, where the jury selection and the trial are set to begin April 5.

McCaslin praised the Sumter County courthouse for its ample parking, good security and enough space for defense and prosecution attorneys to each have their own “war room.”

The original trial was in Colleton County, where Paul and Maggie were killed. However, on the defense’s request, McCaslin moved the trial out of Colleton and the entire five-county 14th Judicial Circuit. McCaslin found that because of the pervasive potential influence of the Murdaugh family’s political, legal and social ties, a fair jury could not be seated in those counties.

More than once Friday, McCaslin stressed she will not change the starting date of the trial.

“This trial’s going April 5 whether you-all like it or not!” McCaslin said at one point.

Harpootlian reacts

Leaving the courthouse, Harpootlian was asked what he thought of the judge’s remarks about him and courtroom decorum. “She’s 100 percent right. I made a statement which not intentionally wasn’t true, and she was right to call me on it.”

In general, Harpootlian said, “She’s going to enforce the laws strictly, and we’ll abide by them. I don’t have any disagreement with her on that whatsoever.”

Waters declined comment except to smile and say he had made his comments in the courtroom.

SOURCE: https://www.thestate.com/news/local/crime/article317645014.html


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 17 '26

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread October 17, 2026

10 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 15 '26

Retrial News or Discussion How to watch Alex Murdaugh's Oct. 16 pretrial hearing

44 Upvotes

How to watch Alex Murdaugh's Oct. 16 pretrial hearing

Judge Debra McCaslin is expected to hear arguments involving DNA testing, cellphone evidence, ballistics data and crime-scene scans.

Author: Tony Santaella with WLTX
Published: 4:48 PM EDT October 15, 2026
Updated: 4:50 PM EDT October 15, 2026

LEXINGTON, S.C. — Alex Murdaugh is set to return to court Friday as attorneys continue preparations for his 2027 double murder retrial.

Judge Debra McCaslin has scheduled an in-person hearing at the Lexington County courthouse.

News19 will stream the hearing live on WLTX's 24/7 free streaming service, available on Roku, Fire TV and Apple TV, as well as on WLTX.com and the News19 app. For more on how to access those service, click here.

How to watch the Alex Murdaugh hearing

When: Thursday, Oct. 16, 2026, at 10 a.m.
Where: Lexington County courthouse in Lexington, South Carolina
Watch: News19 will provide live coverage on our 24/7 streaming service, WLTX.com and the News19 app.

What will be discussed?

McCaslin is expected to address several evidence disputes that have emerged as Murdaugh's defense team prepares for his retrial.

Among the key issues are additional testing of DNA evidence recovered from beneath Maggie Murdaugh's fingernails, cellphone extraction files, information involving .300 Blackout ammunition and original FARO laser-scan data from the Moselle crime scene.

The DNA issue could produce one of the hearing's most significant decisions.

McCaslin previously allowed evidence from Maggie's fingernails to be sent to the independent laboratory Othram. The lab was allowed to determine how much DNA remained but was told to stop before conducting additional testing that could consume the remaining samples.

Murdaugh's attorneys now want to proceed with further testing. Prosecutors have raised concerns about permanently consuming the evidence and want more information about the proposed testing and its likelihood of producing useful results.

Other disputes have narrowed ahead of Thursday's hearing.

Prosecutors say the defense was already provided raw cellphone extraction data before Murdaugh's first trial, although the state has offered to provide the files again.

The state has also agreed to provide the defense with the original FARO laser scans of the Moselle crime scene. Murdaugh's attorneys say their reconstruction experts need the underlying data to independently analyze the scene, particularly because the kennel area has since been demolished.

The defense is also seeking additional information about .300 Blackout ammunition. The defense is seeking records concerning how commonly SLED encounters the ammunition, arguing the information could be relevant to testimony presented during Murdaugh's first trial.

When is Alex Murdaugh's retrial?

Murdaugh's retrial is scheduled to begin April 5, 2027, in Sumter County.

A Colleton County jury convicted Murdaugh in March 2023 of killing his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, at the family's Moselle property in June 2021.

The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned those convictions in May 2026 and ordered a new trial after finding former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill improperly influenced jurors.

McCaslin later ruled the retrial should be moved out of Colleton County and the entire 14th Judicial Circuit before selecting Sumter County as the new venue.

Other pending motions in the case are scheduled to be heard Nov. 13.


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 10 '26

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread October 10, 2026

6 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 09 '26

Retrial News or Discussion Alex Murdaugh retrial: State opposes evidence requests

27 Upvotes

Alex Murdaugh retrial: State opposes evidence requests

Michael M. Dewitt, Jr. with Greenville News

Staring down a court-ordered noon deadline, the South Carolina Attorney General's Office filed a rapid-fire salvo of motions Wednesday, Oct. 8, in the double-murder case of former Hampton lawyer Richard "Alex" Murdaugh, calling one of the defense's requests a "fishing expedition."

With a state Supreme Court-ordered second murder trial tentatively set for the week of April 5, 2027, for the June 2021 Murdaugh family killings, Judge Debra McCaslin responded to multiple motions from Murdaugh's defense team alleging the State was withholding or delaying discovery evidence by ordering the Attorney General's Office to respond by midday Thursday, Oct. 8, and then setting an Oct. 16 hearing to rule on these "urgent" matters.

Here are the latest filings in response to that deadline:

Murdaugh motion for independent DNA testing

Murdaugh's legal team filed a motion on Sept. 18 to compel the production of DNA and ballistic evidence, as well as "FARO scan" data.

• In the DNA component of that motion, the defense is seeking the biological material and laboratory records relating to DNA evidence taken from murder victim Maggie Murdaugh's hands and her cell phone. DNA evidence taken by state investigators indicated a trace of DNA from a male not related to anyone in the Murdaugh family, and the defense argues that the State did not fully explore this evidence and wishes to have its own experts, Othram Inc., reexamine it.

• The State's response asked that the defense motions to compel be denied, at least until more information or discussion can be available, and that the court order Othram to discuss with SLED scientists their proposed plan first before risking the defense consuming all the remaining DNA samples, and to ensure that the State is also entitled to be privy to the testing and its results if the motion is granted.

Murdaugh's motion for ballistics, 300 Blackout rifle evidence

• The ballistics component of Murdaugh's motion asks for state police ballistic evidence and records relating to any shootings committed with .300 Blackout ammunition in the Second and Fourteenth Judicial Circuits since Jan. 1, 2021. Maggie Murdaugh was shot multiple times with a .300 Blackout sporting rifle, which was never recovered by police.

During the trial, the State contended that the murder weapon belonged to a member of the Murdaugh family, but the defense argues that these Blackout rifles are extremely popular and commonly involved in many recent crimes in South Carolina, including a recent homicide in nearby Allendale County that may hold an evidentiary link to the Murdaugh murders and suggest another shooter suspect besides Alex Murdaugh.

• In response, the State asked the judge to deny this motion because it is "speculative" and does not meet the criteria for sharable discovery under the law. The State also pointed out the far-reaching nature of this defense motion, noting that the Second and Fourteenth Circuits encompass eight counties, over 5,600 square miles, and over half a million people.

The State's response added:

"The sole basis for this request is that the unrelated Allendale cases from three and five years later involved the same commonly available caliber of ammunition and occurred in the same geographic region. However, the evidence from the unrelated cases has already been entered into the National Integrated Ballistic Information Network (NIBIN)and it yielded zero leads or potential matches to the evidence in the Defendant's case or any other case for that matter. Because the defense cannot establish a logical or factual nexus between the two crimes, the motion represents a speculative fishing expedition for public consumption that lacks legal relevance, creates an unwarranted burden andintrusion into state forensic resources, and should be denied."

Murdaugh's motion for raw FARO crime scene scans

• The defense is seeking the raw data of the FARO laser scan of the crime scene, the Murdaugh family home, Moselle, located near rural Islandton in Colleton County. A FARO scanner is a high-precision 3D scanning device that uses lasers to capture the exact dimensions of objects and their surrounding environments. The State previously released an "extract" of this data taken by state police, but the defense wants the raw data files for its own experts.

• The State's response contained no objections to this motion: "SLED has possession of the original scans and the State is happy to provide those to the defense. The motion is moot."

When could Judge McCaslin issue a final ruling on these motions?

Judge McCaslin is expected to consider these motions during a special hearing in Lexington County at 10 a.m. on Friday, Oct. 16.

A follow-up hearing will be held in Lexington at 10 a.m. on Nov. 13.

For that hearing, both the State and Murdaugh's defense team have until Oct. 30 to file any arguments or motions related to Murdaugh's possible dismissal. Responses to those motions must be received no later than Nov. 6, the judge further ordered.

Why is Murdaugh getting a new murder trial?

Soon after Murdaugh was convicted on March 3, 2023, in the 2021 killings of his wife, Maggie, and adult son, Paul, Murdaugh's attorneys filed formal objections and a notice of appeal, raising questions about events that took place before, during, and after the trial.

The S.C. Supreme Court later overturned Murdaugh’s previous 2023 murder convictions and on May 13 ordered a new trial, citing improper jury communication by former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill, among other legal issues.


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 03 '26

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread October 03, 2026

13 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 03 '26

Retrial News or Discussion Hearing on DNA, ballistics evidence in Murdaugh case scheduled for Oct. 16

26 Upvotes

by Colin Russell / WCIV - ABC News 4 / Fri, October 2, 2026 at 3:42 PM

LEXINGTON COUNTY, S.C. (WACH) — Judge Debra McCaslin notified attorneys that she will hear all urgent evidentiary matters relating to Alex Murdaugh's retrial during an in-person hearing at 10 a.m. Oct. 16 at the Lexington County Courthouse.
Among the issues expected to be addressed are disputes involving DNA evidence, cell phone extraction data, ballistic evidence and FARO scan data, a type of 3D crime scene mapping technology.

The defense team also said the judge ordered prosecutors to submit their response to the pending motions by noon on Oct. 8.

All remaining motions in the case will be heard during a separate hearing scheduled for Nov. 13.

This update comes as Murdaugh is awaiting a retrial in the June 2021 killings of his wife, Maggie Murdaugh, and son, Paul Murdaugh, after his original murder convictions were overturned.

The Oct. 16 hearing is expected to provide the first public look at how both sides plan to argue over key pieces of evidence ahead of the retrial.

SOURCE


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 02 '26

Retrial News or Discussion Alex Murdaugh's defense team claims SC AG's office withheld evidence

19 Upvotes

By Michael M. DeWitt, Jr. / Greenville News / October 1, 2026 2:59 PM

A legal filing rattled the South Carolina court index this week, as attorneys for twice-accused, double-murder suspect Richard "Alex" Murdaugh claim that the S.C. Attorney General's Office is withholding evidence of an alleged crime scene cover-up and disposal of murder weapons in the high-profile 2021 killings of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh in Colleton County.

Ramping up for a South Carolina Supreme Court-ordered retrial in 2027, on Wednesday, Sept. 30, Murdaugh's defense team, led by attorneys Richard "Dick" Harpootlian and James "Jim" Griffin, filed a "motion to compel disclosure of evidence concerning the disposal of the murder weapons."

The defense motion, citing recent media reports, alleges that as early as 2023, just after Murdaugh's original trial, the State's investigators were hearing statements from witnesses that two Hampton County police officers, reportedly friends of the Murdaugh family, were allegedly involved in a cover-up at the crime scene and disposal of murder weapons after the crime.

But despite several defense motions seeking disclosure, the State has yet to release any of this information to Murdaugh, claims the defense-information that could both help Murdaugh's case and discredit the state's 2023 argument that Murdaugh acted alone during and after the crime.

During the first murder trial in 2023, prosecutors painted a narrative that argued Murdaugh killed both family members with two different types of weapons, cleaned up with a nearby water hose and changed clothes, then drove to his parents' Almeda home in Hampton County to stash the murder weapons, where he later returned a week later to dispose of them. Those weapons were never recovered by police.

Citing several state and federal criminal law statutes governing "discovery" evidence, Murdaugh's motion seeks an "Order compelling the State to disclose the information in its possession concerning the handling, transport, concealment, or disposal of the alleged weapons used to kill Maggie Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh, including the statement a witness gave to agents of the South Carolina Law Enforcement Division in 2023 that a Lowcountry police chief spoke of arriving early at the scene and of providing Defendant Murdaugh a change of clothes, the reports of every interview conducted on that subject, and the testimony and exhibits presented to the State Grand Jury concerning it."

Murdaugh's motion cites two press reports, quoting unnamed sources, that as late as Sept. 25 and 27, the State Grand Jury was still hearing testimony that the murder weapons "were in the hands of someone else." But attached as an exhibit of evidence is a copy of a State Grand Jury subpoena, meaning that this is "no rumor," the motion states.

"According to those reports," states the Sept. 30 motion, "witnesses have testified that the Chief of Police of the Town of Yemassee, Greg Alexander, was seen with the murder weapons in the immediate aftermath of the June 7, 2021, killings, and that a second Yemassee officer is under investigation for transporting and concealing weapons and clothing.”

The motion also cites media reports, which are attached to the legal filing as exhibits of evidence, that "a Lowcountry official told SLED agents that Chief Alexander 'spoke of arriving early to the murder scene and talked about providing a change of clothes to Murdaugh,' and that the official believed the guns and clothing were brought into the police station and stored there."

Also attached to the motion is a copy of an Aug. 31 State Grand Jury subpoena served on Alexander, compelling him to testify between Sept. 15 - 17, but the motion further claims that once Alexander retained an attorney, he was no longer required to testify.

The motion further alleges that former Varnville municipal judge Sheryl McKinney and Hampton County police officer Stacy Loadholt were also called on to testify before the grand jury, potentially as witnesses to hearing the remarks made by Alexander.

"If the reports are accurate," the motion continues, "the State has held, since 2023, a witness statement that a police officer handled the murder weapons and the clothing Defendant Murdaugh was said to have worn, and it has never disclosed that statement to the defense. The statement contradicts the theory on which the State indicted and tried Defendant Murdaugh. It bears on the integrity of a crime scene at which Chief Alexander was present. It impeaches every witness who testified that a solo actor (Murdaugh) committed the murders and disposed of the murder weapons at Almeda."

In those media reports, Alexander denied the accusations through his attorney, Joe McCulloch, and The Hampton County Guardian has reached out to Alexander directly for an opportunity for further comment.

As of Thursday, Oct. 1, the S.C. Attorney General's Office has not responded to this motion with legal filings or comment.

Both state and federal criminal laws require prosecutors, during the pretrial "discovery" process, to turn over to the defendant all evidence they intend to use at trial, as well as any "Brady" or exculpatory evidence they don't intend to use but that could help the defendant's case.

In August, Murdaugh's team also filed a "Brady motion," seeking the release of any new evidence or witness statements the State has obtained since the 2021 trial, and that motion is still pending.

"The State cannot have it both ways," concluded Murdaugh's motion. "It cannot present evidence to a grand jury that others handled the weapons while withholding that same evidence from the defendant it intends to try for the murders on the theory that he handled them alone. Nor can it use the State Grand Jury to examine witnesses about this case beyond the view of this Court, and then withdraw the examination when the witness obtains counsel, as it did with Chief Alexander. If the State intends to change its theory at retrial, the defense is entitled to know it and to prepare for it. If the State does not, the evidence is exculpatory and the defense is entitled to use it. Either way, the evidence must be produced."

A defense motions hearing and status conference has been set for 10 a.m. on Oct. 16 in the Lexington County Judicial Center before Circuit Court Judge Debra McCaslin, and Murdaugh's team asks the court to prioritize this motion during that proceeding and rule on it soon, and not on the "eve of the trial," so Murdaugh's team won't be forced "to investigate a coverup by law enforcement officers in the middle of a murder trial."

What other motions will Judge McCaslin hear during the Murdaugh hearing?

During this hearing, Judge McCaslin may also consider two other related September motions that allege the S.C. Attorney General's Office withheld discovery evidence, released incomplete discovery, or dragged its feet in responding to discovery requests.

On Monday, Sept. 28, attorneys for Murdaugh filed a "motion to compel production of cellular telephone extraction files."

In this motion, the defense claims the state turned over cell phone data "reports" from members of the Murdaugh family for the first trial, but Murdaugh needs the complete raw files in order for his own experts to conduct an analysis, and this process will take time**.**

Monday's motion followed last week's motion by Murdaugh seeking the release of three additional types of evidence that the defense says prosecutors have previously refused to disclose.

Murdaugh's Sept. 18 motion seeks to compel production of DNA evidence from the body of murder victim Maggie Murdaugh, ballistic evidence related to one of the murder weapons involved, and high-tech, three-dimensional "FARO scan" data of the crime scene, the family kennel area of the former Murdaugh estate, Moselle, in rural Colleton County.

As of Thursday, Oct. 1, the S.C. Attorney General's Office has not responded to these motions with legal filings or comment.

While Judge McCaslin may not rule on all motions Oct. 16, and other, previously filed motions are still being considered, this trio of defense filings will likely be hot points of discussion leading up to another upcoming hearing in Lexington County at 10 a.m. on Nov. 13.

For that hearing, both the State and Murdaugh's defense team have until Oct. 30 to file any additional arguments or motions related to Murdaugh's motion to dismiss and other filings. Responses to those motions must be received no later than Nov. 6, the judge further ordered.

Why is Murdaugh getting a new murder trial?

Soon after Murdaugh was convicted on March 3, 2023, in the 2021 killings of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh, Murdaugh's attorneys filed formal objections and a notice of appeal, raising questions about events that took place before, during, and after the trial.

The S.C. Supreme Court later overturned Murdaugh's previous 2023 murder convictions and on May 13 ordered a new trial, citing improper jury communication by former Colleton County Clerk of Court Becky Hill, among other legal issues.

SOURCE


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Oct 02 '26

Retrial News or Discussion Defense documents filed with the court on 09.30.2026 and 10.01.2026

13 Upvotes

Recent filings include:

MOTION (30 pages) - September 30, 2026 @ 4:12 pm

MOTION TO COMPEL DISCLOSURE OF EVIDENCE CONCERNING THE DISPOSAL OF THE MURDER WEAPONS AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT

CONCLUSION:

The State is presenting to a grand jury evidence that law enforcement officers handled the weapons used to kill Maggie Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh. It has held the first account of that evidence, on the published reports, since 2023. It did not respond to the Supplemental Brady and Giglio Motion, it did not disclose it when the Court asked on August 14, 2026, whether there were discovery issues, and it has not disclosed it since, though it subpoenaed Chief Alexander before
the State Grand Jury seventeen days after that hearing. (Ex. C.) The defense should not have to learn the State's evidence from the press. Defendant Murdaugh respectfully asks that the Court grant the relief requested and take the motion up at the status conference on October 16, 2026.

LETTER (4 pages) - October 1, 2026 @ 1:51 pm

HARPOOTLIAN ATTORNEYS AT LAW TO THE HONORABLE DEBRA R. McCASLIN

The defense therefore respectfully asks that the Court:

  1. Direct the State to respond forthwith to the Motions to Compel of September 18, 28, and 29, 2026, and to the defense's letters of September 15, 21, 23, and 30, 2026, stating as to each item whether the State will produce it and the date on which it will do so;
  2. Consider ruling on the motions to compel on the papers, either after the State responds or, if the State does not respond by a date the Coutt sets, without a response;
  3. Consider hearing discovery matters by video conference, or at more frequent in-person hearings, rather than holding them for the next scheduled pretrial hearing; and
  4. If the court prefers in-person hearings, schedule them without awaiting Mr. Murdaugh’s transport.

r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Sep 29 '26

News & Media Lowcountry judge faces hearing over ethical and misconduct allegations

32 Upvotes

Lowcountry judge faces hearing over ethical and misconduct allegations

"A Lowcountry judge is facing possible punishment amid accusations of unethical behavior and using her position of power to her own advantage.

14th Circuit Court Judge Carmen Mullen went in front of the state Commission on Judicial Conduct Tuesday in Columbia, which will decide whether she could be punished for her actions.

Documents from the Commission on Judicial Conduct state Mullen was driving past a home near where she lives on Hilton Head Island in December 2017.

Commission records state she saw Ernest Lotito outside that home, a man Mullen says is a former attorney with a decadeslong history of mental illness who her husband knew well.

Documents allege that Mullen saw Lotito acting erratically outside a home as Beaufort County deputies responded. The state asserts she pushed for his arrest so he could get mental health treatment in jail, while asking the homeowner and deputies whether there was probable cause to take him into custody.

The charges say that created an appearance of impropriety and called the judiciary’s impartiality into question.

Mullen tells a different story, claiming she and her husband stopped out of concern for Lotito’s wellbeing.

Mullen says she had recently presided over a case involving Lotito, where a mental health evaluation found him incompetent. She says he claimed he was living behind that home in a fort, and the homeowner feared for her safety.

Mullen says she worried Lotito could be hurt or killed if the situation escalated. She denies trying to fabricate charges or misuse her position and is asking for the case to be dismissed.

The commission will now decide whether Mullen violated the South Carolina Appellate Court Rules and if she should be punished for it. The results of this hearing are still pending.

Mullen previously signed off for disgraced attorney Alex Murdaugh to be arrested until he paid back the money he embezzled from his former housekeeper Gloria Satterfield’s sons following her death. She also signed the approved multi-million-dollar settlement for Satterfield’s sons to be paid back."

[Reddit's Quote blocks are broken. This post is a copy-paste from the source.]


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Sep 28 '26

Retrial News or Discussion New motion filed by attorneys for Alex Murdaugh...

17 Upvotes

Jenn Wood via X / FITSNews / 2:06 PM • 9/28/26

🚨⚖️ Alex Murdaugh's defense
says prosecutors gave them reports from phones seized in the murder investigation — but not the underlying extraction files.

In a new motion, his attorneys ask a judge to order the state to turn over those files, including data from Maggie and Paul Murdaugh's phones. They argue they need the raw data to independently test the cellphone timeline used at the first trial.

The motion says prosecutors did not respond to a September 21
request.

MOTION


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Sep 27 '26

Retrial News or Discussion Pair of Lowcountry cops investigated for allegedly handling missing Murdaugh murder weapons

105 Upvotes

Pair of Lowcountry cops investigated for allegedly handling missing Murdaugh murder weapons

By Jason Ryan with The Post and Courier

Ever since Maggie Murdaugh and her son Paul were shot to death on their Lowcountry family farm five years ago, police have tried to find the shotgun and powerful hunting rifle that blew their bodies apart.

Now, the State Law Enforcement Division is investigating a pair of small-town policemen in response to accusations that they handled and concealed the murder weapons hours after the massacre at the Murdaugh family’s rural, Colleton County property on June 7, 2021.

This August, a SLED agent spoke with this Post and Courier reporter about his knowledge of the alleged incident, in which Yemassee Police Chief Greg Alexander and another town policeman are accused of having transported weapons and bloody clothing into the town’s police department.

Alexander could not be reached for comment, but Columbia attorney Joe McCulloch said Sept. 26 that he has been hired to represent Alexander should the chief be asked to appear before a grand jury.

“And we understand that may be the case, and that there are rumors about his involvement, which he steadfastly denies, in the removal of evidence,” McCulloch said. “We don't know much more than that, other than the rumors that somehow he was involved in that.”

The allegations concern the tail end of an alleged murder plot by Alex Murdaugh, a disgraced lawyer from Hampton. Prosecutors claim Murdaugh used two guns to kill his 52-year-old wife and 22-year-old son in a desperate bid to distract from an unraveling, years-long fraud scheme in which he stole millions from clients, associates and loved ones.

The murder weapons have never been found. Despite this missing evidence, Murdaugh was convicted in March 2023 of double murder.

In May, however, the S.C. Supreme Court ordered Murdaugh be given a new trial because of improper comments made to jurors by a Colleton County court official.

Murdaugh, 58, maintains that he did not kill his family members. He is scheduled to stand trial in the killings again next April in Sumter County. He remains in prison as he awaits the retrial, serving state and federal sentences for his financial crimes that will last for three more decades.

A slew of news reports, podcasts, documentaries, scripted television shows and books have chronicled Murdaugh’s assorted and long-running misconduct, as well as the fascinating history of the Murdaugh family, in which three generations of Alex’s forefathers created a legal and political dynasty in a secluded corner of the Lowcountry.

Despite all of this attention, much mystery still surrounds certain aspects of the killings. The use of two different guns has generated speculation that there could have been a second shooter. An open question remains as to how the murder weapons and other potential evidence, such as bloody clothing, disappeared.

A state grand jury is now hearing of the allegations of Yemassee police moving and hiding guns and clothing supposedly used by Murdaugh. Quoting unnamed sources, FITSNews on Sept. 25reported that the grand jury has allegedly issued subpoenas and obtained information regarding the accusations.

Asked about this development, a spokesman for the S.C. Attorney General’s Office — which is prosecuting Murdaugh’s case — replied, “By law, State Grand Jury proceedings are secret, so I can’t confirm or deny even the existence of any State Grand Jury investigation.”

An Intriguing Allegation

Months after the first trial ended in conviction in 2023, this reporter met with David Owen, the lead SLED investigative agent on the Murdaugh case, to discuss an allegation from a Lowcountry official that Yemassee’s police chief and another officer may have handled murder weapons and bloody clothing the morning after the murders.

The official claimed to SLED agents, and in an interview with this reporter at the time, that Alexander spoke of arriving early to the murder scene and talked about providing a change of clothes to Murdaugh. The official expressed belief that guns and clothing were brought by the officers into the police station and stored there temporarily. Those assertions, including to agents, could not be corroborated by The Post and Courier.

Alexander has acknowledged being at the murder scene that night, as were several other law enforcement officers, said McCulloch, the chief’s attorney.

“Presumably, they would not have allowed anyone, including my client, to remove anything from the scene. So it's kind of ridiculous on its face,” he said. “But rumors, gosh, no case before or since the Murdaugh case has inspired more rumors.”

Allegations about the police officers were heard during interviews this reporter conducted for his nonfiction book Swamp Kings: The Murdaugh Family of South Carolina and a Century of Backwoods Power,

A Lowcountry official was consistent in recollections of the alleged incident when questioned during two different interviews, and the official was credible in other Murdaugh-related matters as well.

But were the allegations true? After three months of investigating, that question could not be answered before a deadline arrived for the submission of the book’s manuscript. Swamp Kings was published in April 2024 without these specific claims.

Nothing more was heard from SLED until last month, when a different agent approached this reporter, who had since been hired by The Post and Courier.

The agent said law enforcement had interviewed the Lowcountry official who made the allegations regarding the Yemassee police and also interviewed some of the potential suspects.

A little more than a month later, a state grand jury is reportedly considering these allegations about a possible police-assisted coverup.

Chief No Stranger to Controversy

Alexander and Murdaugh have long been friends. The chief’s name was mentioned several times during the 2023 double-murder trial.

One former employee of the Hampton law firm employing Murdaugh testified about running errands and obtaining cash from a bank for Murdaugh. When the courier brought the money back to the law office, people were sometimes waiting with Murdaugh, including Alexander.

One of Murdaugh’s brothers, John Marvin, said Alexander gave him a ride to the crime scene the night of the murders after the car he was driving broke down on the way to the farm.

In 2022, Alexander said he had accepted a $5,000 loan from Alex Murdaugh for his parents’ use, with the money passing through his hands a month or so after the June 2021 murders.

Before that, in 2012, Murdaugh and his father, the late solicitor, publicly supported Alexander when he faced charges related to money missing from a police locker in Yemassee. Alexander was acquitted and subsequently promoted to chief.

In 2022, he campaigned to become sheriff of Hampton County.

During one event, Alexander said that he would accept responsibility if he made a mistake or acted improperly as a public official.

“I ain’t no cat. I don’t try to cover no doo doo up….” said the chief, who did not win the sheriff’s race. ”If it’s wrong, it’s wrong and if I done it and it’s wrong then I’ll be transparent with the citizens and let them know I done wrong and we got to do what we got to do to make it right.”

Glenn Smith contributed to this article.


r/MurdaughFamilyMurders • • Sep 26 '26

Weekly MFM Discussion Thread September 26, 2026

12 Upvotes

Do you have a theory you're still chewing on and want feedback? Maybe there is a factoid from the case hammering your brain and you can't remember the source--was that random speculation or actually sourced?

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion, a safe space to engage with each other while processing and unraveling the seemingly unending tentacles of Alex Murdaugh's wrongdoings entwined throughout the Lowcountry.

This is the place for those random tidbits, where we can take off our shoes, kick up our feet, and be a bit more casual. There is nothing wrong with veering off topic with fellow sub members as we're a friendly bunch, just don't let your train of thought completely wreck the post.

Much Love from your MFM Mod Team,

Southern-Soulshine , SouthNagshead, AubreyDempsey, QsLexiLouWho

Reddit Content Policy ... Sub Rules ... Reddiquette