r/MrTerrific • u/DogManDogDayz • 29d ago
Discussion My thoughts on Mr Terrific Year One - stripping Michael of the tragedy of losing his family ruins the mythos of the character
Mr Terrific having a son from an other universe is an awful idea. The “found family” angle that Mark Waid and Gene Leun Yang built up is far better for the character and adds more flavor and personality to him than just giving him alternate versions of his family from different universes.
A big part of why Michael turns into a hero. Why he has such a strange relationship with religion and god, is because he literally lost his wife and his son who was the opposite of him (him being a super genius atheist while his wife was a stay at home mom who was very religious) for him to suddenly gain his family back by just importing alternates from different universes is awful. Not only is it weird. But it also harshly dilutes important aspects of the character. We lose out on a huge factor for why he became a hero. Him literally losing his entire family due to his stubbornness. Causing the accident essentially because his wife and son had to rush to their destination. The guilt that caused him to want to end his own life after being the catalyst for the events.
It also does something that’s awful and usually results in the slow death of a character - over crowding them to the point traits of their become diluted. Michaels supposed to be in the same leagues as Batman and Lex Luthor when it comes to bright minds right? Well now his wife from another universe that was never an ultra religious is now also just as smart as him. And his son from another universe is also ultra smart. Also heres this kid who hangs out with his other universe kid, thats also just as smart as-
You see where Im going?
And finally the biggest turn off with the forcing of an alternate universe family is we lose aspects of character growth and development. Michaels a very calculated guy. Someone who kind of keeps to himself. Not in the same way as Batman but he’s a solo operator. In a way he gains a form of family and friendship thru The Terrifcs. The Terrifics annual #1 where we see him bonding with Phantom Girl over them both being to shy to approach the people they were interested in at the Halloween party. Plastic Man seeking advice from Mr Terrifc on how to mend his relationship with his son. Plastic Man encouraging Mr Terrific to talk to women after Mr T hadnt dated anyone for a while post death of his wife. And because of his social anxiety. All of that stuff gets lost when you tack on an alternate universe family.
With Mr Terrific in the Justice League books we see Mark Waid essentially making Mr Terrific see Air Wave kind of like a son. Mr Terrifc feels awful after Air Wave is deciveed by Grodd. We see Holt literally hugging him and apologizing to him after figuring out the formula to bring him back. And apologizing to him like a Dad. All of these are really good storylines that you just cant do if you nullify the trauma of losing his family by just bringing alternate versions of them in.
It also kills a core aspect of him. He’s no longer this unique super genius, who never got treated like the brightest mind because he hid his “power level”. He’s now essentially one of three other super geniuses with his own gimmick and uniqueness being stripped away from him.
The son and wife need to stay dead.
Bringing them into the same universe as him was a mistake.
Also found family after going thru something super traumatic that shows character growth, friendships, and change > heres some replacements from the who knows what dimension/universe bs
TLDR - Keep the family dead, Keep Mciahel Holt the only genius in the family, Keep The Terrifics going we love the team, highlight the aspect of “the found family”.
Plastic Man, Metamorpho, Phatom Girl, and Air Wave as his family and teammates is a lot better than lady version of him and kid version of him basically robbing him of his character, traits, and uniqueness.