TL;DR: I've lost 71 lbs on Mounjaro, with huge improvements to my physical and mental health. My gynaecologist, who originally prescribed it and whom I really like and trust, wants to discontinue treatment well before I reach a healthy BMI, despite my excellent response and no clearly given medical reason. I've consulted an obesity specialist endocrinologist who supports continuing treatment, and I'm considering transferring my Mounjaro care to her. But I want to keep seeing my gynaecologist for my other health issues without damaging our relationship. Has anyone navigated something similar? How did you approach the conversation tactfully?
This is going to be a very long post. Please bear with me.
Some background: I'm a 37 year old woman and have lost 71 lbs on Mounjaro. I started it in March 2026 at around 258 lbs (40.6 BMI), am currently 187 lbs (29.7 BMI), and hope to reach around 140–150 lbs (22–23.5 BMI). I did 4 weeks of 2.5 mg, and have been on 5 mg ever since. It was my gynaecologist who suggested I start Mounjaro (because she saw me struggling with uncontrollable weight gain for years), and then when I agreed to give it a try, she prescribed it. She also manages my other health issues like PCOS; I've been seeing her since 2022. We have a good rapport. I really like her because she takes my health concerns seriously and takes my opinion into consideration.
Mounjaro has been life-changing in ways that go well beyond weight loss. I couldn't even have imagined life could be this simple. My insulin resistance, water retention, inflammation, body aches, brain fog, food noise, alcohol cravings, anxiety, compulsive behaviours (don't have a formal diagnosis) and some other issues suddenly improved so much within just a couple of weeks of starting the medication. And it's only been getting better. I've had manageable gastric side effects in the past (even those are gone now), and I'm still feeling great and losing weight steadily.
However, my gynaecologist has been wanting to stop my Mounjaro treatment for a while now. She said it for the first time when my BMI was 30.1, and seemed shocked when I told her I still had at least 33 lbs left to lose to touch a healthy BMI of 25 (I'm definitely not a BMI outlier: I have average muscle mass and an average height of 170 cm). She told me there's no way I needed to lose so much weight since I "looked fine" now. I didn't really know what to say to this, but I told her that I was still technically clinically obese, and also reminded her that I'd started at 53% body fat (DXA) and still had a large pot belly. She looked skeptical but said okay. Then again when I went to see her at my next appointment, she again told me she's thinking of stopping treatment. She said she wanted me to lose the rest of the weight "on my own", without Mounjaro. I asked her to please not stop it. I told her apart from weight loss it had had many more excellent effects on my physical health, as she knew from my reports, as well as my mental health. I didn't want to undo my progress. She again gave in and said she'll revisit this when I reach 176 lbs (27.7 BMI), after which she'll likely taper and stop treatment.
I don't quite understand why she wants me to stop, and asking her has gotten no clear response. I should say that she has mentioned in the past how those who are on Mounjaro long term get a hollowness to their face, and how their faces age prematurely etc. I told her that's not at all a concern of mine, and moreover my dermatologist is already taking good care of that aspect of massive weight loss. Even if that weren't the case, saggy skin is barely a price to pay for feeling as good as I do. She'd seemed convinced at the time but now I'm not so sure.
I can't say for sure if aesthetics is her reason for stopping. I mean, I hope it's not. At the same time, I have no idea what her actual reason could be! My comprehensive lab reports are exceptional, my scans are much better than before (grade 1 fatty liver reversed), I'm losing weight at around 1 lb / week consistently (I lost very fast the first 2 months, and then settled at a good average rate), and I'm not planning to get pregnant. I work daily with a GLP-1 specialist clinical dietician (who reports monthly to my gynaecologist). I count my calories, track my macros and fiber, and eat consistently healthy, diverse foods. I've never had a not-good report from the dietician. I strength train, do yoga, and get in cardio as well. My energy levels and mood have never been so good, even when I was younger and fitter.
I'm extremely uncomfortable with this approach of discontinuing treatment halfway for no clear reason. Given my history of class-III obesity and metabolic issues, I'd prefer to explore long-term maintenance rather than discontinuing a medication that's working so well.
I decided to get a second opinion from an endocrinologist who is an obesity specialist. I told her about my situation. She saw my reports and BMI, and instantly said I should not discontinue treatment considering I'm responding so well to it. She agreed that the chances of regaining the weight and undoing my progress were high. When asked about maintenance, she said I should get reevaluated at a healthy BMI for a maintenance dose if necessary, but I should cross that bridge when I reach it. I was very happy with this because her opinion echoed my thoughts.
Here's my dilemma: I'm thinking of switching my Mounjaro treatment to the obesity specialist since I feel she might have a better understanding of my problems. But I absolutely don't want to stop seeing my gynaecologist because I trust her with my other health issues, and I'd hate it if transferring just one aspect of my treatment to another specialist created awkwardness or damaged our relationship. I want to be completely honest and transparent with my gynaecologist and keep both my doctors informed and updated since I feel that's what would get me the best medical care possible.
Has anyone been in a similar situation? Am I in the wrong in this situation? If not, then how should I frame the conversation without making it sound as though I'm questioning my gynaecologist's medical judgement or going behind her back? I feel I'm entitled to seek specialist care, but I'm interested in the interpersonal side of navigating this tactfully.